Disaster! NASA SLS & Orion Heat Shield In Big New Problem, Can't Launch...

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
24 Video Views·Sep 25, 2024
in the early 2010s following the
retirement of the Space Shuttle NASA
embarked on the development of a new
rocket called the space launch system or
SLS for short for this ambitious project
NASA selected Boeing a long-standing
partner and a well-known company from
the earlier era of space exploration to
support the construction of the core
booster and EXP ation upper stage at the
time NASA's choice of Boeing was driven
by the need for reliability and
experience however it seems they may
have overlooked the potential drawbacks
of relying on a company with older Tech
to build a nextg rocket an approach in
hindsight appears contradictory after
more than a decade the consequences of
this decision are becoming increasingly
apparent so what are the current issues
with the SLS should NASA consider
replacing both in its future projects
and who might be capable of stepping in
to resolve these challenges we'll
explore these questions in today's
episode of great SpaceX as we know the
first SLS rocket launched during the
Artemis 1 mission in 2022 came at a
staggering cost of over $23 billion for
the entire system with more than 11
billion attributed to the SLS itself
despite these costs NASA plans to
continue using the system in future
feuture Artemis missions notably Artemis
4 which is slated for September of 2028
will feature a new version of the rocket
the SLS 1B still being constructed by
Boeing however recent developments have
cast a shadow over this decision on
August 8th NASA's office of Inspector
General or oig released a report
following an assessment of the current
project the report delivered a harsh
critique of Boeing's work on the SLS 1B
at the machine Ed assembly facility in
New Orleans focusing on two all too
familiar issues quality and cost let's
start with the concerns regarding
quality the oig report noted that
Boeing's work has not met International
standards or NASA's stringent
requirements one particularly alarming
example highlighted in the report
involved a liquid oxygen fuel tank Dome
a critical component of the SLS core
stage three
during an April of 2023 visit to mhud
inspectors found the Dome segregated and
awaiting a decision on whether it could
be safely used due to welds that failed
to meet NASA specifications according to
the report these quality control lapses
are largely due to a shortage of trained
and experienced Aerospace workers at
Boeing the oig criticized Boeing for
inadequate training and oversight
leading to safety and reliability
concerns additionally many experienced
workers have left Boeing for newer
aerospace companies offering better pay
these issues have resulted in numerous
corrective action requests or cars
issued by the defense contract
management agency or the dcma which
oversees Boeing's work on the SLS
between September of 2021 and of 2023
dcma issued 71 cars 24 of which were
rated level two indicating serious
issues that involve critical safety
hardware and cannot be corrected
immediately the dcma even considered
drafting a new level three for severe
non-conformities despite these warnings
Boeing has shown little progress in
addressing these issues the report
stated according to dcma officials
Boeing's process for addressing
contractual non-compliance has been
ineffective and the company has
generally been nonresponsive in taking
corrective actions when the same quality
control issues reoccur moreover Boeing
has been using the earned value
management system or EVMS software to
measure progress however the Department
of Defense disapproved of this system
back in 2020 citing Boeing's inability
to produce a realistic Baseline delivery
date for the exploration upper stage due
to ongoing deficiencies in its EVMS not
only are there quality concerns but
Boeing's work is also driving up the
cost of the new SLS version the report
estimates the cost at $5.7 billion which
is $700 million higher than NASA's 20123
ageny Baseline commitment the E alone is
expected to cost 2.8 billion over three
times the initial estimate of 962
million in 2017 these are staggering
numbers to put it into perspective the
cost of the E alone is nearly half of
the 11 billion spent on the entire first
SLS prototype used in Artemis 1 so why
does a rocket with such questionable
quality come with such a high price tag
it seems the answer lies in outdated and
inefficient technology because the
technology is not up to Modern standards
numerous fixes are required leading to
delays and soaring costs the report
indicates that the delivery of the E
from Boeing has been delayed from the
original estimate of February of 2021
set back in October of 2016 to April of
2027 as of October of last year and
given the current issues it's uncertain
whether Boeing can meet this deadline
with the required quality the final cost
remains unknown and it's unclear whether
it will surpass the cost of the emis 1
prototype the oig report made four
recommendations to NASA including
developing a quality management system
for Boeing applying penalties for
quality standard violations analyzing
cost overruns and coordinating with dcma
to bring EVMS into compliance NASA has
accepted three of these recommendations
but has rejected the one related to
penalties in conclusion the report
States given Boeing's quality management
and its related Workforce challenges we
are concerned these factors could
potentially impact the safety of the SLS
and Orion spacecraft including its crew
and cargo more than ever it seems that
boing should be removed from this
program immediately the SLS itself may
need to be reconsidered it is too
expensive carries potential risks and
lacks the longevity needed Beyond lunar
missions if you agree respond with kick
it in the comment section don't forget
to like share the video and subscribe to
our channel to stay updated on spacex's
development Journey NASA's challenges
with Boeing extend beyond the SLS they
are also grappling with significant
issues related to Boeing's Starliner
spacecraft on the International Space
Station when NASA launched the
commercial crew program back in 2014
they selected both SpaceX and Boeing to
build crew spacecraft notably Boeing was
awarded 4 A5 billion US dollar
significantly more than the 2.6 billion
given to SpaceX reflecting NASA's
confidence in Boeing's capabilities
however the Starliner spacecraft has
encountered numerous issues during
testing leading to repeated delays in
the crude test flight even before its
scheduled launch Starliner faced
persistent problems including fuel leaks
despite these setbacks the spacecraft
was sent to the ISS and now Boeing is
struggling with its return currently
Starliner is plagued by issues with
helium leaks reaction control system
thrusters and undocking software these
problems have forced NASA to consider
sending spacex's Dragon to rescue these
starlander astronauts with a final
decision expected soon it's clear that
Boeing's performance with Starliner does
not justify the substantial funding they
received it's important to remember that
star laner has yet to complete any
missions under its commercial crew
program contract meanwhile the clock is
ticking with only 6 years remaining
until the planned retirement of the ISS
in 2030 can Starliner meet NASA's
requirements within this time frame much
like the SLS Starliner reflects Boeing's
slow and outdated technology ology if
NASA were to conduct an assessment of
Starliner similar to the oig's review of
the SLS it's likely that many more
issues would come to light given these
ongoing problems it may be time to
reconsider Starliner role and explore
more efficient Alternatives if you agree
please reply with drop it in the comment
section down below NASA has been
fortunate to have the support of SpaceX
during some of its most challenging
times and if they decide to part ways
with Boeing SpaceX is poised to continue
continue as NASA's most reliable partner
or perhaps its only partner when it
comes to the ISS it's clear that
spacex's dragon is more than capable of
taking over the tasks initially assigned
to Boeing's Starliner the superior
performance of dragon underscores the
Stark differences between Boeing and
SpaceX as for NASA's lunar Ambitions I
believe that even if NASA were to cancel
the SLS program spacex's Starship would
be more than capable of completing the
remaining objectives remaining obje Ives
in fact eliminating the SLS could
simplify NASA's plans considerably
allowing them to cut other costly and
high-risk projects such as the mobile
launcher Orion spacecraft and lunar
Gateway some might argue that spacex's
Starship hasn't yet proven its ability
to replace SLS in the Artemis program
but let's take a closer look in just
over a year Starship has completed four
integrated test flights something that
the SLS has yet to achieve moreover
these flights have demonstrated
Milestones no other program has reached
including the landing of both rocket
stages which is the first step towards a
fully reusable rocket reusability is a
key advantage that makes Starship
superior to the SLS building on this
Foundation SpaceX is pushing forward in
all aspects to meet the Artemis schedule
looking at the broader road map SpaceX
has ambitious plans for thousands of
Starship launches per year in contrast
we've never seen similar projects for
the SLS which is primarily Limited two
moon missions this limitation further
reinforces the argument for cancelling
the SLS program now is the time for NASA
to enact a comprehensive change slow and
inefficient Boeing's approach no longer
aligns with the current direction of
space exploration to maintain its
leadership in the Space Race the US
should focus on removing barriers and
investing in modern fast and efficient
companies like SpaceX we all know that
next September NASA is set to launch
Artemis 2 marking the second phase of
its ambitious Artemis program this
Mission will see the SLS rocket and
Orion spacecraft take astronauts on a
journey around the Moon unlike Artemis 1
which was an uncrewed test flight
Artemis 2 will be a significant
milestone in human space exploration
carrying astronauts to the moon for the
first time since Apollo 17 in 1972 a gap
of over half a century for this mission
to succeed the vehicles used particular
L the Orion spacecraft must perform
flawlessly Orion will serve as the
crew's home for the duration of the
mission carrying them from launch to
lunar orbit and then back to Earth for
re-entry and splash down however Orion
has been plagued by several issues that
NASA must address before Artemis 2 can
safely fly in May NASA's office of
Inspector General or oig published a
report titled NASA's Readiness for the
Artemis 2 crew mission to lunar orbit
the report highlighted critical concerns
with Orion's heat shield separation
bolts and power distribution system all
of which could pose significant risks to
the safety of the crew these problems
are particularly alarming considering
that they pertain to some of the most
vital systems for a safe return from
space the heat shield has emerged as one
of the most concerning issues during the
re-entry of Artemis 1 NASA discovered
over a 100 spots where the heat shields
ablade of thermal material eroded
differently than expected this material
is designed to protect the spacecraft
from the intense heat generated during
re-entry but the uneven wear observed
raised serious concerns about the shield
reliability the oig report included
photographs showing the damage giving a
visual representation of the severity of
the problem NASA has stated that
Engineers are investigating possible
solutions which may involve redesigning
the heat shield or adjusting Orion's
re-entry trajectory however they have
yet to provide a clear timeline for when
these fixes will be implemented this
ongoing investig ation contributed to
NASA's decision to delay the launch of
emis 2 from its original schedule NASA
is now facing a tough choice regarding
Artemis 2 continue with the heat shield
used on Artemis 1 or design an entirely
new one both options come with serious
challenges sticking with the current
heat shield would keep the mission on
schedule but could risk the safety of
the crew given the issues encountered
during emis 1 while some suggest landing
at a steeper angle to reduce this risk
it's an untested approach on the other
hand creating a new heat shield would
reduce the risk but almost certainly
delay the mission with only a year left
before the planned 2025 launch the
timeline would be tight for NASA and its
contractors to develop test and install
a new system despite this NASA remains
publicly optimistic insisting that the
mission is still on track for September
of 2025 though this confidence may be
fragile a further delay could even lead
to aremis 2 Flying Without a crew
effectively repeating the uncrewed
aremis one Mission which would be a
major setback this dilemma highlights
NASA's ongoing struggle with
inefficiency and delays a byproduct of
its traditional Reliance on Legacy
contractors each system from the sls2
Orion has taken years to develop at the
cost of billions meanwhile private
companies like SpaceX are
revolutionizing the industry delivering
faster cheaper and more reliable
Solutions spacex's Dragon spacecraft and
Falcon Rockets are prime examples of how
modern Innovation can outpace NASA's
older systems as NASA grapples with
these challenges the widening gap
between traditional Aerospace methods
and the efficiency of private companies
becomes more apparent it's clear that
the future of space exploration may be
driven by the Bold strides of private
companies like SpaceX rather than
government agencies careful
considerations of the issues with Orion
becomes even more necessary when we look
at another recent disappointment the
Starliner once again Boeing NASA's
longtime partner has been at the center
of numerous delays and problems with an
investment of over4 billion US Boeing's
starlander has faced repeated issues
during development leading to years of
delays and when it finally launched new
problems surfaced creating anxiety
within the Aerospace Community even
after reaching the ISS technical
difficulties persisted causing chaos on
the station fortunately after over 3
months starlander returned to the
morning of September 7th but now NASA
and Boeing must work hard to address the
persistent issues plaguing this
spacecraft Orion tasked with an even
more complex and demanding Mission could
face similar risks the extr ex
conditions it will encounter combined
with its known technical issues raise
serious concerns and if problems arise
during the mission where will the
astronauts turn for help who will be
able to save them these are difficult
questions for NASA to Grapple with as
they push forward what do you think
should NASA scrap the spacecraft and
start fresh if you believe so respond
with cancel it in the comment section
down below be sure to also like share
the video and subscribe to our channel
to stay updated on spacex's Journey as
they continue to make history all in all
Orion is just one of the many problems
within the current Artemis program NASA
spent over 23 billion us on the systems
needed to complete emus 1 and now
they're struggling to prepare for
Artemis 2 as we speak the SLS parts are
still being transported to Florida
meaning they aren't yet fully stacked
until the step is completed crucial
tests like cryogenic trials static fire
tests and the wet dress rehearsal cannot
take place they might even argue that
they have a year left but a year can
pass in the blink of an eye if no
progress is made and if delays continue
the cost of Artemis 2 could easily
surpass that of Artemis 1 adding to the
growing concern the hardware for SLS is
under increasing scrutiny the NASA
office of Inspector General recently
released a report on SLS 1B components
including the core booster and
exploration upper stage both managed by
Boeing the report revealed that these
parts are not meeting NASA or
International standards raising concerns
about further delays Boeing might need
additional time to fix these issues
which could directly impact act the
Artemis timeline and as we've seen
Boeing's challenges tend to inflate
costs sometimes exponentially although
these specific hardware issues relate to
Artemis 4 there's a real possibility
that similar problems could affect
Artemis 2 even though no official
reports have confirmed it yet the
inefficiency doesn't stop there NASA's
lunar Gateway project is another area of
concern according to a government
accountability office report this
project could cost up to $5.3 billion by
December of 2027 but what's more
worrying it's already showing
significant delays the current timeline
may not allow the gateway to be ready
for arous 4 by its September 2028 Target
Additionally the gateways design has
been flagged as incompatible with the
Starship hls the spacecraft that will
eventually fery astronauts to the lunar
surface furthermore the processes
involved in building and operating the
system in tandem with emis missions are
incredibly complex adding more layers of
difficulty to NASA's overall lunar goals
of course the SLS and Orion are still
part of NASA's vision for lunar
exploration but with so many problems
it's difficult to imagine how NASA can
maintain a well organized and effective
system the same inefficiencies apply to
other expensive NASA projects like the
mobile launchers each costing around a
billion dollars after just one use for
Artemis 1 NASA now has to spend a
significant amount of time and resources
to fix it meanwhile the cost for the new
launch system has reportedly ballooned
to nearly $3 billion looking at the
Artemis program as a whole it's clear
that many of NASA's systems are plagued
with issues they still exist today
mainly because NASA has been operating
in the same way for decades but with an
urgent schedule to return to the moon
it's becoming increasingly hard to
justify these inefficiencies should NASA
consider canceling these systems Al
together imagine a simpler approach
launching on SpaceX a Starship Landing
directly on the moon with Starship and
returning aboard the same spacecraft the
only additional infrastructure we'd need
is a refueling system in Earth's orbit
Orit without the need for the SLS Orion
or the lunar Gateway the journey to the
moon seems a lot more straightforward
perhaps the time has come for NASA to
make a bold decision Orion along with
NASA's other aging systems are obstacles
to the overall mission ending them in
favor of a simpler more efficient path
to the Moon may be the solution many are
waiting for NASA's decision to use
spacex's Dragon to assist Starliner last
month May hint at a broader realization
perhaps they are beginning to understand
who they can truly rely on can NASA make
another bold gamechanging decision in
this case only time will tell but the
future of space exploration may depend
on it well folks that's about it for
today's episode thank you so much for
tuning in and as always this has been
Kevin from great SpaceX until next time
keep looking up
