Heroes and Villains of Medieval Iberia: An Introduction | Dr. Kyle C. Lincoln

ancient literature
168 followers
22 Video Views·Sep 25, 2024
The Study of Antiquity and the Middle Ages presents Karwan Sarai Publishers.
Subscribe to their four extraordinary magazines, bringing the ancient world to life.
Ancient History. Warfare in the Age of Myth and Heroes.
Ancient Warfare. Warfare in the Age of Kings and Castles.
Medieval Warfare. It's Time to Play with History.
War Games, Soldiers and Strategy.
Karwan Sarai offers print and online issues and subscriptions.
If you love history, subscribe today.
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Study of Antiquity and the Middle Ages.
As always, I am your host, Nick Barksdale.
And today we are bringing you an introduction to a long series that's going to be titled
Heroes or Villains of Medieval Iberia.
Dr. Lincoln is going to be guiding us through a series of complicated
subjects, eras and historical personalities.
And without further ado, Dr. Lincoln, firstly, thank you for coming on the show today.
And secondly, would you guide the audience
through an introductory course on what they can expect to see with our upcoming series?
Thanks for having me, Nick.
One of the things that we've talked about for a while with this series is to do
short biographical deep dives of about 30 minutes or so on a number of
sometimes controversial, sometimes heroic, sometimes inspiring,
sometimes contemptible figures from medieval Iberian history.
It goes sort of without saying that in a land that is often described as the land
of the three faiths, we've got a number of entries.
So here today, one of the things I thought we should do is first
give an outline of the nine figures we'll be covering, not necessarily in order.
And then to give a little bit of an overview of the kind of places and peoples we're dealing with
so that in future episodes, when we take a deep dive into any of those individual figures,
we have some context for what we're talking about.
So the nine that we'll cover, and these are obviously just short versions of their names.
Names are always complicated.
They sometimes have acronyms.
They sometimes have toponyms.
They sometimes have tribal names and affiliations.
But we've got quite a lot to go through in this set of nine.
The first is Alfonso I of Aragon and Nevada.
He's often called the battler, Alfonso el Batallador.
We've got Ibn Mardanesh, Muhammad Ibn Sa'ad Ibn Mardanesh, the Taifa king of Mursia.
We've also got Gerardo Sempavor, a Portuguese adventurer who got into more than a little
mischief in the southwestern frontiers.
We've got the twin counts of Barcelona, Ramon Berenguer and Berenguer Ramon,
an object lesson about family names, if ever there were one.
We've got Sancho Fernandez, a prince of León from the early 13th and late 12th century.
We've got Samuel Ibn Naqrila, a high official in one of the Taifa kingdoms in the south
during the first Taifa period.
We've got Guillem Ramon de Moncada, a Catalan count who may or may not have murdered an
archbishop.
We've got Abd al-Rahman, the first emir of a separate Umayyad state in Iberia.
And we'll finish up because the Mythbusters told us you're always supposed to end with
a bang.
You're always supposed to save the best for last with Rodrigo Díaz de Bivar, commonly
known by his arabicizing epithet Alcide.
So those nine give us a good idea of what's coming up.
But I think it's also important to talk about the land that we're really discussing.
Now, medieval Iberia is full of all kinds of historiographical controversies.
There's a lot of debate about where we draw the lines between, on the one hand,
tolerance and, on the other hand, intolerance, how we map the differences in the balance
of power between religious communities, between political communities, and how we talk about
those subjects based on the sources that we have.
Now, it's worth noting a couple of things.
First, there are lots of popular books out there.
Unfortunately, there are very few that are any good.
Probably the best, for my money, on the wider history of Iberia for English-speaking audiences
is the late Simon Barton's History of Spain.
Unfortunately, although he was an award-winning, prize-winning, enormously important medieval
Hispanist who was taken from us far too early, Simon's book does not give too much attention
to medieval Iberia.
So we're sort of left with, okay, well, if we don't have that sort of big, big survey,
can we at least get the two parts of what we're dealing with?
And the short version is we kind of can.
On the one hand, the best book, perhaps, for popular audiences interested in medieval
Iberia's Islamic populations is the great Brian Katlos's wonderful book Kingdoms of Faith,
which I actually happen to have on an arm's reach.
The cover looks like this, at least in hard covers.
It's a fantastic read.
And, of course, Katlos is responsible for a number of really important translations
of Arabic sources and is perhaps one of the best historians of Islamic Iberia in the world
today, certainly in the English-speaking world.
On the other side of the peninsula, we're sort of blessed with a surfeit.
The work of the eminent Joseph O'Callaghan comes to mind for histories of medieval Iberia
writ large.
He's venerable but now quite dated by even his own admission.
History of medieval Spain is quite useful, as was the late Peter Linehan's History and
Historians of Medieval Spain, a much more scholarly book but still very readable because
of Linehan's wonderful style, although it can be a little bit difficult in translations
just because there are certain English witticisms that don't translate very well.
Those three books give us a kind of framing for some of the subjects we're talking about.
We should be clear, though, about why we're talking about medieval Iberia and not just
medieval Spain or medieval Portugal or even medieval Andorra, medieval Gibraltar.
The short version of any explanation about the geography of the peninsula is that it
is inherently interconnected but also divided.
There are enormous mountain ranges that divide sections of Iberia from another.
There are large rivers that, when they flood, can be catastrophic, and smaller rivers that
denote particular boundaries that created border zones that were ripe places for intercultural
and cross-cultural connections, as well as military activities.
Now, because most of the figures in this series have a nominally militarized bent,
it's worth noting that they also engage with a lot of that geography.
They wouldn't have called it Spain, and they don't.
Even in the Latin sources where most of the Roman toponyms are preserved, they often refer
to it as Spain's in the plural, that is to say the several provinces of Roman Spain.
If we look at a map of Roman Spain with all of its individual demarcations, whether it's the
late Republican provinces, the Diocletian dioceses, or even the way that the Visigothic
kingdom organized some of its territories with its strong borders in Galicia, that region that's
for a while controlled by the Suevi in the northwest of the peninsula, we can really
kind of see that this is not all one place, nor was it all one people.
We know that there's an enormous amount of early Celtiberian peoples.
There are Basque populations that are deeply entrenched.
We know that Roman colonization over the course of about four centuries was enormously influential
in shaping and reshaping the topography.
There's strong evidence of Basque sites that date into previous millennia.
There's also evidence of Roman aqueducts that still stand and form the walls,
say, at Segovia, or that provide visitors to an archaeological park in Merida a wonderful afternoon,
and more than a little shade in the sun.
One of the challenges, then, that we have to think about are all of these layers,
not just working against one another or shaping one another, but working together.
It's often stated that in 711, for example, there's an Islamic invasion of Iberia.
This is an inaccuracy in a number of ways, but I think it proves just how messy and complicated
and muddled this history can often be.
In the first place, the warriors that arrived from the other side of the Straits of Gibraltar
were invited, and they were invited by Visigothic warlords who were themselves fighting a civil war.
Second, most of the troops, if they were Muslim,
were Muslim only in certain small and precursory fashions.
The leadership certainly was.
The leadership seems to have been thoroughly a part of the early Islamic movement,
but the varying degrees of Islamization, if we want to use that term,
of conversion that had taken place into the rank and file
is still something that eludes our ability to recover.
We don't have great records from every rank and file soldier,
nor do we have a poem the likes of Let Us All Go from the Field of Flanders,
where we get this evocative portrait of what the enlisted thought.
Moreover, the Visigoths themselves were not all one group.
There were warring factions, tribal affiliations, and subdivisions,
all of which suggest enormously plural populations.
Moreover, calling it an Islamic invasion rather than a civil war that went bad
and turned out into a whole bunch of other settlement patterns
may be a convenient shorthand,
but it's important to remember for both this introductory video
and also the variety of topics that we're going to be covering
that shorthands are often ways to cut corners
and that cutting corners can be perfectly fine,
except when we're trying to build something that's sturdy and durable.
Therein lies the real challenge.
Digging deep and getting into the nitty-gritty,
into what the primary source is saying,
into what scholarly conversations have shown,
really helps reveal the wide array of topics that are at our fingertips,
but sometimes can just elude them.
And so in taking this exploration of so many of these subjects,
it's important to remember that we've got so many layers.
We've got, yes, an invasion by forces allied with the Umayyad Caliphate
on the one hand in 711,
but we've also got counter-invasions by a number of forces,
back and forth, back and forth,
tribal invasions, tribal resettlements,
repopulations, counter-repopulations, devastations,
all of which suggest that at even the most macro level
between the Christian kingdoms nominally in the north
and the Islamic kingdoms in the south,
there's always a bit of a tension.
But even those large monoliths betray the kind of fragmented,
plural and overlapping networks of power
that scholars have shown are hard at work on the ground.
Moreover, it's worth remembering that these demographics are not static.
What happened in 711 may have had a strong influence
on what happened in 1212,
but the two could not be farther apart.
Those five centuries were enormously influential.
Demography changes, customs change,
languages change, cultures change, religions change.
And so all of these diversities and pluralities suggest that
while, for example, the most simplistic of popular stories
would give you a good guys versus bad guys approach,
or a Muslims versus Christians approach,
or a Jews caught in the middle approach,
the reality is far more complicated.
And so one of the things I think we should explore
in this series generally
is about how we deal with this complexity,
how we deal with heroes on the one side
being villains on the other,
and how the plurality of identities
that they're always manipulating,
that they're always wearing multiple hats,
might tell us about the head that wears the crown
in most of these instances at least.
So that's where I think we should start.
That's where I think we're going.
And hopefully over the course of the next nine episodes
and maybe a wrap-up where we can invite a few more people on,
we've got a pretty good idea
of how complicated the situation really is,
and how unique and how special the history of medieval Iberia
and its variety of important power brokers
can really be for understanding the medieval world
in a much more rich and complex fashion.
