Pierre-Henri Dumont: «C'est quelque chose de nouveau en France, d’avoir des coalitions» • RFI

RFI
101 abonnés
24 sept. 2024 #MardiPol
L'invité de Mardi politique est Pierre-Henri Dumont (@phdumont), secrétaire général adjoint du parti Les Républicains.
#MardiPol
En savoir plus avec notre article : https://rfi.my/AzDx.y
🔔 Abonnez-vous à notre chaîne : https://rfi.my/YTfr
🔴 Suivez RFI en DIRECT vidéo ici : https://rfi.my/YTliveFR
🌍 L’actualité du monde et de l’Afrique en direct : https://www.rfi.fr/fr/
Rejoignez-nous sur Facebook : https://rfi.my/FBfr
Suivez-nous sur X (Twitter) : https://rfi.my/Xfr
Découvrez l’actu en images sur Instagram : https://rfi.my/IGfr
Recevez les dernières infos sur Telegram : https://rfi.my/TGfr
It's time for Tuesday Politics on France 24 RFI.
Good evening Frédéric Rivière.
Good evening, good evening everyone.
And together we welcome Pierre-Henri Dumont.
Good evening.
You are Secretary General of the Republicans.
Thank you for accepting our invitation.
So after laborious negotiations,
Michel Barnier, the Prime Minister,
formed his government.
He picked up at the Macronists,
at the center, and at you, the Republicans.
Where is the rupture announced by Michel Barnier?
It seems to me that each new government
has been talking about rupture for decades.
What is this rupture?
The rupture is already with the seven years
of Emmanuel Macron's quinquennas that have passed.
It was said during the speech
of the passing of power between
Michel Barnier and Gabriel Attal.
It is to ensure more security for the French,
to reduce immigration in our country.
Probably also, we will see in this general
political speech on October 1,
to make it evolve.
To go from family immigration,
underqualified, undergone,
to work immigration, overqualified and chosen.
To ensure that we can put back
public services of proximity,
especially in rural areas.
To ensure that those who work
can finally earn their living,
live the fruit of their labor.
To ensure that we can grow in society.
But for example, the chosen immigration,
we heard that under Nicolas Sarkozy.
So it's not new.
Maybe, but it did not escape you
that when Nicolas Sarkozy left power in 2012,
there were about 150,000
residence permits that were delivered per year.
We are at double today.
We have an access route,
which is the access route of the asylum application
which is unsealed, which is used,
which is overturned, which means that we can no longer
unfortunately accompany the real asylum seekers,
those who use it as a gateway.
Knowing that they will not be able to be sent back
in their country if their asylum application
is rejected.
So that's all that will have to be put in place.
When we heard the various speeches
about the passing of power,
especially at the Ministry of the Interior,
we realize that yes, this is indeed a break
with what was the case previously
in the last seven years and the last 12 years.
I tend to think that
Emmanuel Macron's five-year term
was just a continuation of that of Mr. Hollande.
To stay for a moment
on this new government,
there are 39 ministers
with some surprising positions.
For example,
the Ministry of Governmental Coordination
is quite new.
But basically, is this government
anything other than a construction
only intended to
respond to political imbalances?
Any government is
intended to respond to political imbalances.
Well, we could imagine that a government
is first a project, a guideline,
and then we cooperate with the best
to try to counter this policy.
We are here on a TV channel
and on a radio
which is international.
In all European countries,
there are coalitions that are formed
with people who represent
political weights within the various assemblies.
This is something, I promise you,
new in France, to have coalitions
that are project coalitions.
To begin with, the project was presented
by Michel Barnier in the main lines
during his speech on passing power
with former Prime Minister Gabriel Attal
and will be detailed in more detail
during his speech on general politics
on October 1st.
So there is no shame in saying
that it represents the political
balances of the National Assembly
and the Senate.
So, as such, the Republicans
have their part to play.
Before entering this studio,
you talked about Michel Barnier
saying that he is a negotiator,
it is his quality.
Today, he receives social partners
and we know that we will have to
tackle the budget,
the expenses of the State,
and find solutions.
Is he discussing
the increase
of taxes?
Will we have to increase
taxes, knowing that
the right-wing is quite allergic
to this subject?
Michel Barnier was very clear.
The groups, the Republicans,
the National Assembly, were very clear
in the legislative pact they presented
at the end of the legislative elections
last July, that there is no increase
in taxes on the middle class,
on the vast majority of French people,
on those who work hard,
who get up early in the morning
and go to bed late.
This is the line clearly defined
by the LR group and by the government.
The middle class is a vague notion.
No, it is not a vague notion.
When we call for more social justice,
more fiscal justice,
it probably means a certain tax
on large companies,
on large groups,
certain fiscal niches
that are granted to large industrial groups
can be reviewed.
This means that we can imagine
a taxation, which is today
a taxation on heritage,
on transmission trails,
which could be imagined to be increased,
this taxation of heritage trails.
There are many solutions on the table,
but before we get to the issue
of tax increases for a few people
who, if we look at it comparatively,
pay much less taxes
than those who work.
Today, I remind you,
taxation on work is the most important taxation
when we compare it to all other taxation
on income, on heritage,
on transmission via heritage,
on consumption.
Before increasing taxes,
even if they are targeted,
we must first reduce expenses
and make sure to spend less,
but much better on public policies
that suffer today, on health,
on education, on security,
on justice.
But would increasing taxes
for some people
not be the easy solution
given that this government
would be too fragile to consider
conducting real reforms?
It's not the easy solution,
it's one of the possibilities
given to a government to balance a budget
or at least limit deficits.
But this government can reform.
I think there are spaces.
That's why Michel Barnier told you
to meet social partners
to see what are the spaces for discussion.
You know, we have between
20 and 25 billion euros
closer to 25 than 20 billion,
to find a way to get
into the nits of what is tolerable,
acceptable in terms of deficits.
Targeted tax increases
as they have been mentioned,
can make 5 billion euros at most.
We can see that the priority
is not to increase taxes,
but to reduce expenses
because that's where we can
save as much as possible
and get into the nits of what is
still tolerable for our country.
This government is considered
the most right-wing since
the Fillon government.
During the right-wing primaries,
François Fillon proposed
to remove civil servants.
At the time, he said 500,000,
which was huge.
Is that a way to remove
positions in public service?
Let's wait for the Prime Minister's
general policy speech.
It's next Tuesday, so we'll know.
You're not safe from ideas.
Sorry, but it's the Prime Minister
who defines the government.
No, but a party can also bring
these ideas.
We have always estimated that
there were expenses that were
incomprehensible in state accounts
and that the first state expenses
were civil servants.
So if there are savings to be made
on certain positions,
not on those who are already suffering.
We won't start by removing
civil servants in health care,
but in other places.
In the local community
where I was mayor,
we removed civil servants
to create public service.
And if we want to create
new public service,
like municipal police,
video protection,
double the number of nurseries
to meet children's needs,
create holiday communities,
we do that by creating savings.
When we talk about public money,
it's mainly about the biggest expense.
The biggest expense is still civil servants.
Michel Barnier's government
has only been in place
for a few days,
and we can already see
the first tug-of-war
between the Minister of Justice,
Didier Migaud, from the left,
and the Minister of the Interior,
Bono Otayu, from the right.
He was the president of the LRO group.
In the Senate,
does this tug-of-war have
the slightest chance of working?
First of all, it's not a novelty
that there are sometimes
different interpretations
between the tenant of Place Beauvau,
the Minister of the Interior,
and the guard of the Sceaux,
which is Place Vendôme.
Even in a government
where there are absolute majorities
to support them at the National Assembly.
Today, what do we have?
We have a Minister of the Interior
who said what the Prime Minister
said when he took office.
We need to restore security,
restore authority,
his famous triptych
that he announced
when he took office
with his predecessor,
Gérald Darmanin,
that we need to control
immigration in our country.
This is the line
that was defined by the Prime Minister,
Michel Barnier.
Then, Didier Migaud recalls
facts that everyone accepts
and that are normal in a democracy
that is a liberal democracy,
namely that justice is independent,
that judges are able
to define what the sentence
against a person should be
if they are found guilty
after an independent investigation.
The reality is that
we need to have
a certainty of the sentence.
If it's not a sentence pronounced by a judge,
it can be an administrative sentence.
Let's take the example
that has shaken the news
in the last few weeks,
which is the refusal to obtain a permit.
Maybe we can imagine a system
where anyone found guilty
of refusal to obtain a permit
would be automatically banned
from obtaining a driving license
for 10 years,
which would allow,
in addition to a sentence
pronounced by a judge
after an investigation
and contradicting versions
of each other,
to have at the same time
the certainty of a sanction
against the person
who has endangered
not only his life
but the lives of other people,
whether they are passers-by,
young children or police officers
When Bruno Retailleau
during the transition
with Gérald Darmanin
said, I want to restore order,
he said it three times,
is it an accusation
of laxity towards Gérald Darmanin
and, secondly,
is Bruno Retailleau's nomination
a nod to the National Assembly?
He said it himself.
He said we need to look
at the first legislative round.
It was clearly the National Assembly.
What is absolutely certain
is that Bruno Retailleau's line
is different from that of Gérald Darmanin
and his predecessors
under Emmanuel Macron and François Hollande.
Why is it different?
Because he is very clear.
He has convictions that he has long expressed,
whether when he was president
of the LR group in the Senate
or when he was a candidate
for the presidency of the Republicans.
It is a much firmer line,
much more assertive,
on restoring authority,
on diminishing immigration.
We know this.
This is what he announced
during his term in office.
I repeat, this is the line
presented by Michel Barnier
during his term in office
and during his various speeches.
Bruno Retailleau is not someone
who changes his mind.
If he is here, it is because
he wants to apply the policy
he has always taken.
You said that this is not the first time
that there are differences
between the Minister of Justice
and the Minister of the Interior.
In this case, Didier Migaud has said
for two days now
that the laxity of justice does not exist,
that it is a fantasy.
At the beginning of the afternoon,
I need to be able to contribute
to the information of my colleague,
the Minister of the Interior,
so that we can have exchanges
on this subject.
Isn't this a way of saying
Mr. Retailleau, you don't know
what you are talking about.
I need to be able to contribute
to the information of my colleague.
Let them have this discussion.
We will see what comes out of it.
I am telling you,
it is not the Ministers who will apply
the line they want to apply.
It is first of all the Prime Minister,
Michel Barnier, who will present
his roadmap on October 1st
in front of the MPs
and in front of the Senators.
It is from this General Policy Statement
that the Ministers will have to put on music
not their own opinions,
but the line defined by Michel Barnier.
Let's wait for October 1st
and you will see that
it will probably not be very far away.
The new Minister of Economy,
Antoine Armand,
made a joke this morning.
He explained that he would not speak
with the MPs of the National Assembly
because they do not belong
to the Republican Arc.
He was immediately recalled by Michel Barnier
who had to call Marine Le Pen
What does this expression
of the Republican Arc mean?
I don't know who they put in
We all know who they put in it.
It's McDonald's, everyone puts
what he wants to put inside.
The reality is that
the Republican Arc does not exist.
As long as a political party
is allowed to run in an election,
we have to consider
that there is no anathema to launch.
It's been 40 years since we launched anathemas
against the National Assembly
and it's been 40 years since the National Assembly
increased its scores year after year.
The only time when the National Assembly
at the time lowered
the level of the elections
was when Nicolas Sarkozy assumed a firm policy
in terms of authority
and made sure
to give more purchasing power
to those who worked hard.
This is the line that is presented
by Michel Barnier during his first interventions.
So you are basically saying
that between Michel Barnier and the National Assembly
there is the thickness of a cigarette leaf?
No, I'm telling you
that when 11 million people vote for a political party
you can't put them aside
by saying you don't exist,
you don't belong to the Republican Arc
and it's obviously a joke
because Michel Barnier said
that we have to respect each other.
It doesn't mean we have to adhere to their ideas.
It just means that if there are 11 million people
who vote for a party
or 5 or 6 million who vote for La France Insoumise
on the other side,
that they are not sub-citizens
that we have to consider and listen to.
It doesn't mean that we are going to apply
the policy taken by La France Insoumise
or by the National Assembly
but that each of their deputies
has the right to express themselves
the right to represent the citizens
the right to defend their convictions
then it will be up to them
to vote in favour of what is presented
by the government or not.
I'm just telling you that when
11 million voters
turn to a party
that is a party with this past,
with this passive,
there is a real anxiety
that politicians have not been able to respond to
mainly in terms of purchasing power,
the disappearance of public service,
and security.
And why do you think
that the new Minister of Economy,
Antoine Armand,
was able to think that it is relevant
to say what he said this morning?
I mean, I don't discuss with the RN.
Because probably he hasn't had the time
to change his attire yet,
to go from the candidate's attire
who was able to benefit from retirement
during the Republican Front,
who then was the deputy's attire
of Gabriel Attal's group
who had taken very firm positions
on this subject,
to now Minister,
not of a government,
which is the government of Gabriel Attal,
but Minister of the Republic,
to speak to all French people.
Antoine Armand is not Minister of Economy
of the voters of Emmanuel Macron,
of La République En Marche,
or of Renaissance.
He is Minister of Economy of all French people.
And as such, he must obviously
find, he must obviously meet
all the requirements.
What government was it?
All the governments.
But there was a particular government
where the expression came up a lot.
It's the first one.
It's under Hollande.
It's the time of adaptation.
A new government has just been named.
And you see, you mentioned earlier
the relevance of having
a Secretary of State and Minister of Delegation
in charge of the governmental coordination.
You have today a very concrete example
on the interest of having a person
capable of aligning positions,
which are positions that are sometimes different.
This is the case between Didier Migaud
and the Minister of the Interior,
Bruno Retailleau. This is what Antoine Armand just said.
All this needs to put a little oil in the wheels.
This will be the goal of this government.
By following, I tell you, I repeat,
the line of conduct defined by Michel Barnier
in his speech of General Policy.
The ministers of the government today
are not Minister of Emmanuel Macron.
They are Minister of Michel Barnier
to apply the policy defined by Michel Barnier
and which will be discussed
during a government seminar in a few days.
A little word of international politics
since we see that the Middle East is burning,
that the war in Ukraine continues.
Does the political instability
in which France is
not hindering
its radiance,
its voice in the world on the international scene?
Probably.
The most concrete example is
what has just happened to the European Commission
with the resignation of Thierry Breton,
the President of the Commission.
We, the Republicans, are very comfortable.
We had voted against his reintroduction, Ursula von der Leyen.
We were the only ones.
She was pushed by the President of the Republic
who finally, as soon as he was weakened
from a national point of view,
took the consequences to evacuate
an internal opponent in his commission, Thierry Breton.
So obviously the position
from the dissolution,
which is a position
of weakness of France,
of French institutions,
has an impact on the international level.
On the Middle East, I am not sure
that it has any link,
even if France
maintains extremely close
links with Lebanon
because of its history,
because of its past,
because of all the religious
and philosophical aspects that we have
with this friendly country.
But there should not be too many consequences.
Thank you. It's over.
