Pourquoi certains hommes se sentent-ils émasculés dès que les femmes apparaissent en position de pouvoir ? En février 2022, la chanteuse Rihanna était en couverture du magazine Vogue UK. Fière, tête haute, marchant sur une plage, entraînant par la main son compagnon, le rappeur Asap Rocky. Celui-ci portait dans ses bras leur enfant, qu’il embrassait sur le front. Il n’en a pas fallu plus pour que les masculinistes crient à l’émasculation des hommes. Dans cet épisode, je m’appuie sur les analyses de l’écrivaine nigériane Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, mais aussi sur les discussions avec mes invités. Ndeye Fatou Kane, féministe, chercheuse sénégalaise sur le genre et auteure de Vous avez dit féministe ? Aux éditions Harmattan ; Zakaria Guingané de la Team féodale, un groupe au Burkina Faso pour qui l’idéologie féministe est une menace pour ce qu’il appelle “les valeurs africaines”; Sylvain Zagré, avocat.
You're listening to Ballet Pâtes, season 2, episode 4.
Is the contemporary man masculine?
A RFI podcast.
Sometimes, the headlines of women's fashion magazines
say something about our time,
and they are very widely shared and commented on online.
This is the case of the British version of the Vogue magazine
dated February 2022.
Rihanna appeared there, proud, with her head held high,
walking on a beach,
dragging her companion, the rapper Asap Rocky,
who was carrying their child in his arms, and kissing him on the forehead.
This cover was saluted as a small revolution by feminists,
because the photo symbolized an inversion of roles
between a woman and a man in a couple.
The masculinists criticized it, even hated it.
The Senegalese Ndeye Fatoukane, a feminist,
writer and researcher on the genre, is a fan of Rihanna.
She observed all this agitation on social media
about the cover of Vogue UK.
What struck me was a young woman, proud of herself,
of her power, who is in front, and behind her companion,
who is holding their child.
I found this picture extraordinarily beautiful.
I'm a big fan of Rihanna, not for her music,
but for the fact that she pushes the boundaries,
whether it's beauty, posture,
the way she leads her career, very freely.
I love that.
Men feel attacked,
and for them, it's a way to make them effeminate.
Whereas every day, we see powerful men
who lead flourishing careers,
and who rely on their companions
while they do their careers.
They manage the home space, they take care of the children,
and no one has ever asked themselves this question.
But for once, it's the other way around.
Men feel oppressed.
And that's what I like,
this movement of hegemonic masculinity.
I think it's a superb case of school.
And above all, a lot of comments from black men,
from African men, who criticized this cover,
denouncing the fact that we want to emasculate African men,
how Rihanna can be in front, and the man behind, who holds the baby.
A lot of African men have experienced this badly.
So, what can we say? I think it's a shame,
but it's the reality.
Black men, for them,
their model of functioning is the dominant model.
So, for those few we see,
even America and Africa are very, very far away,
but for them, they feel attached to their masculinity.
So, maybe they think that in a few years,
it will be the same.
And I pray that it will be the same.
I see a lot of young women who have careers,
but who still fall into the traditional model of life,
of the couple.
So, I would really like to witness a period
where we will reverse the codes.
For example, that we will have paternity leave,
that men will stay at home to take care of the children,
as women do,
and that they will do free work.
And there, I think that maybe they will understand.
But for now, it's clear that they feel threatened.
And I think it's extraordinary.
As soon as we shake this dominant model of hegemonic masculinity a little bit,
I'm happy because I think that we are witnessing
manifestations that will take root in a few years
in our African societies.
It's not won because when we look at our African popular culture,
it's full of patriarchal norms,
it's full of patriarchal discourses,
it's all in favor of men.
So, in fact, it's completely our popular culture,
everything that is used on screens, in our media,
in our musical culture,
it's all that that must be completely shaken up.
Yes, I think that in order for a society to evolve,
it is necessary to destroy everything.
It's like when you destroy something and then you rebuild it.
That's how I see it.
And I'm happy to see that there is a feminine, feminist, young impulse.
Whether we are feminists or whether we claim to be feminists or not,
for me, once women unite,
they do wonders, and that's what I'm witnessing.
There is the network of feminist women,
there are entrepreneurial women.
Young women are becoming aware of the power they have.
And I think that's great.
And on the other hand, I also find it a bit of a shame
that young men don't realize
that they are still trapped in their privileges.
They are draped in the mantle of intolerance,
but they should also understand that there should be an alliance.
Because I think that for societies to evolve,
men and women should be able to understand each other.
Women have understood what power is,
and men should follow it.
In a banal appearance,
the photo has highlighted the fragile ego of some men
who have seen a way to demasculinate the black man.
Here, in this case, the rapper Asap Rocky,
appearing, according to the masculinists, in a position of submission,
and Rihanna in a position of virility.
Given the negative comments that this has caused among black men,
I asked myself several questions.
Why do they immediately feel threatened in their virility
as soon as women manage to gain a small portion of power?
Why does the simple fact that a woman is put first in front of a man
cause so much criticism?
Finally, in addition to domination,
and if this toxic masculinity,
this detestation of women by some men who do not want to see them assert themselves,
was only a matter of love,
of loving,
loving oneself or loving other people around you.
Listen to what the writer Elgaz told us.
He, whose novel, Mal Noir,
is born out of personal questioning about love as an African man,
and all that this feeling represents in the quest for oneself,
especially in the life of a black man.
Why did this subject interest me?
Why did I want to explore it through the novel?
I finished my thesis in 2018.
I am a sociologist by training.
I experienced this period of post-doctoral error
where the student is in front of a completely fragile horizon,
sometimes blocked, where he asks himself 10,000 questions.
These questions were completely existential for me.
That is, what are we running towards? Why are we travelling?
Why are we leaving our land? What is more important?
In this economic, sometimes financial quest,
don't we crush the essence of our affections?
What are these affections?
I asked myself this question.
Leaving your loved ones,
going so far away, enduring loneliness,
isn't crushing a feeling that is very noble,
which is called love.
Does this love hold a special place in our hearts?
What do we do with it?
I started from this question in this period.
But did we love each other?
Do we have all this affective grammar?
Are these the resources we can have in family, in meetings?
Do we learn it right away?
The answers I tried to find to these questions were completely
unsatisfactory, if I may say so.
That's why I said, I'm going to try to confess to a black man
to find out what he thinks of this feeling.
Is he an affective incompetent?
Is he fragile? Did he learn it?
It multiplies the fields.
We see that affection and love lead to family,
to meetings with women.
Because love is not only the love of others,
but also the love of oneself.
These angles are there.
In the Senegalese society in which I was born,
do we learn a man to love?
In the spontaneity of the affective gesture,
in the ultimate devotion to the other,
in the concern for the other, in the affective benevolence.
And not only to love a woman, but to love her friends.
And sometimes to break these barriers
of the order of culture or tradition.
It tells us that we, men, and this is not only African,
we must maintain a certain social rank
and that a certain hardness is a form of valued identity.
And that our emotions are sometimes too much.
And so the novel gives us this resource
to be able to look into the unspoken,
into the discomfort, and sometimes into the uneasiness
of our relationships with various people.
To finally assume that we are incomplete individuals,
sometimes weak,
and that this weakness, instead of being a flaw,
is part of the structure of our sentimental architecture.
In the photo I was talking about earlier,
Assap Roki kisses his child on the temple.
It is a mark of affection, of tenderness.
And Rihanna says it in the interview in the magazine.
There is a particular connection between Assap Roki and their baby.
We could say that the latter has a paternal instinct
and that, just like some women, some men love children
and are inclined to develop this feeling.
Be careful, this is not the case for all men.
It is often said that women have a maternal instinct.
So they would have a particular connection with their children.
However, not all women are made to love children.
By doing a search on Google,
the first definition I find is
a popular expression that defines a natural feeling
of unconditional love and a protective instinct towards children.
It is manifested by intense feelings of tenderness,
of compassion and of responsibility
towards our own children and towards children in general.
After reading this definition,
we can wonder why most of the time we consider that this instinct,
this fiber, is a trait typical of women,
of all women.
For me, it is nothing more than a way of deresponsibilizing men.
These stereotypical conceptions have contributed to making women
those who must take care of the household
and men those who must provide for the financial needs of the family.
This distinction of roles has become the norm
to become a rule in the couple,
especially in African countries where many men
seem to have completely abandoned their father role.
This reminds me of a tweet by a Burkinabe father
who was desperate to be the only man present at the parent-student meeting.
Here is what he had written.
Parents, please make an effort.
Attend your children's school year-end ceremonies.
No one said it was only for mothers.
These moments mark the children.
Here I am sitting like an intruder among thirty smiling mothers.
This tweet, even if it was made in a humorous tone,
touches upon a real problem,
the absence or, let's say, the resignation of fathers
in the education of their children.
I have noticed several times in the families around me
that men are the least involved in the education of their children.
When, for example, the child starts crying,
most of the time he turns to his mother and not to his father.
Why? Because we are used to the fact that it is the mother who has to take care of him.
A vision assumed by Zakaria Gengane, president of the FEODAL team.
For us, here, since the beginning of time,
it is the woman to whom we had left the education.
Leaving the education to the woman, if our ancestors had decided that,
it is a sign of the strength and weakness of the woman
and the strength and weakness of the man.
And we had to balance the roles, understand?
The man left the education to the woman
because the child spends more time with the woman.
When the child is born, who takes care of him? It is the woman.
I think that it is practically at an adolescent age
that the man can get the child back for the paternal education and everything.
But the basic education is to the child.
You are not going to tell me that after two or three years,
the child has to spend more time with...
He has to spend more time with his two parents.
Just in a few days, feminists will even ask men to take care of the children.
Behind every great man is a woman.
The night brings advice.
I have always heard these quotes, these poetic sentences,
and I have taken them myself sometimes,
to say that it is the women who make the right decisions
at the ears of their spouses or companions during the night.
I naively thought that they were used to value women,
to recognize the role they play in the dynamics of the couple.
Wrong.
From my adolescence to my twenties,
I was preparing myself to become that kind of woman myself.
Erased, submissive, ready to do anything to satisfy her man.
Because in my opinion, I should never take advantage of a man.
Years have passed.
I have learned things in order to develop my critical mind,
especially on the issues of feminism.
I ended up understanding that in fact, no.
These misleading quotes are not at all used to elevate women.
These sentences insidiously convey the injunction
that a woman must always support her man
and allow him to succeed,
while she remains in the shadows,
even if she has sometimes sacrificed her own career.
For me, all this has only one purpose,
to disqualify the words of women.
Let's listen again to the Senegalese sociologist Elgas.
What I noticed, in fact, in the discourse,
particularly conservative masculinist,
is the finesse and the ability
through which we try to corrupt the feminist discourse.
In Senegal, the religious discourse incenses women.
They say they are wonderful mothers,
that they are of high quality, and so on.
It's a way of depoliticizing them.
It's a way of caressing them in the sense of the hair,
to make them hear.
And sometimes, there are some feminists who fall into the trap.
Because we consider that we are incensing them
and that we must, in a way, lower the guard.
Women educate the world, they are our mothers,
they are the mothers of humanity.
The horrible sentence,
behind every great man, there is a great woman, and so on.
No, I mean...
And then, to untie all this, little by little,
because behind every great man, behind every great woman,
there may be people who support him, people who love him.
It's as simple as that.
They are of all possible genders.
But to make such archetypes around women
are elegiac discourses on women,
who have a vocation to dominate them.
And so, sometimes, the discourse...
But by the way, feminist productions are quite strong,
quite robust,
to unmask all these dead angles.
There are many of these women who one day had to give up their careers,
their ambitions,
so as not to eclipse their poor little spouses,
who, unable to see them succeed
and be financially independent, threatened to leave them.
When I write these words,
I think of the Nigerian, Shimamanda Ngozi Adichie, whom I love.
To me, she is one of the writers
who analyses gender relations the best.
This is what she writes in the manifesto,
We Are All Feminists.
We teach girls to diminish, to underestimate themselves.
We tell them, you can be ambitious, but not too much.
You have to aim for success without it being too spectacular.
Otherwise, you will be a threat to men.
If you have family support in your relationship,
don't be afraid to be in public.
Otherwise, you will emasculate him.
And if we question this very principle,
why should the success of a woman be a threat to a man?
Since men feel threatened and scream at emasculation,
I wanted to know the exact definition of this word.
In the dictionary, Robert, we read,
Emasculation is castration,
deprivation of reproductive organs in the male individual.
So it has nothing to do with depriving a man of his patriarchal authority.
I wonder, how would letting a woman be ambitious
deprive a man of his genital organ?
Tell me, how would this remove his virility?
I don't know about you, but after thinking,
I come to a single conclusion.
These men who want to preserve their privileges
do everything to keep a minimum of control over women,
especially in the couple.
The subject regularly arouses discussion
when we sometimes meet among friends.
During my stay in Abidjan for this podcast,
we met with some friends in a restaurant
to have a good time and also to talk about feminism.
I took out my microphone to record all this.
Welcome to my home.
Good evening.
Nice to meet you.
Most men who say they support gender equality
always say the same thing.
What are they going to say?
They say men are illegal.
We don't give the floor to men.
I think it's men who...
Who don't care.
Because for us, it's a false debate.
So we have to provoke the debate.
We think it's men who don't care.
I'm Sylvain-Charles Zagré,
a professional lawyer in Abidjan.
As an African who has received an education,
I say we have certain African values
that we must be able to keep, that are not necessarily bad.
Especially when it comes to the life of a couple,
when it comes to the matrimonial aspect of the couple.
There is this equality that must be nuanced.
In the couple, we're talking about equality.
Equality of role-playing,
of responsibility, whether it's a man or a woman.
That everyone plays their role, that everyone assumes their responsibilities.
As Africans, that's the education we've received.
And that's why I'm fighting.
When you say that everyone assumes their responsibilities,
for you, in the couple, what are the responsibilities of the woman
and what are the responsibilities of the man?
For me, as an African in the couple,
the main responsibility of the man is to meet the needs of the couple.
If he has the means.
If, of course, these means don't allow it,
the woman can come and help him.
To the extent that now,
it is almost impossible in our societies
that a single man can meet the needs of the whole family.
The woman is also called to help.
But I'm just saying that in our African traditions,
this responsibility must not be left in the hands of the woman.
I don't see it that way as an African.
Especially as a man.
As an African man, I don't see it that way
that a woman takes on the entire responsibility of the household,
while the man, who calls himself an African man,
is just a spectator of what's going on in the household.
For me, that's unacceptable.
But in terms of rights,
as a lawyer, I totally agree that they have the same rights.
The man goes to school, the woman has the right to go to school.
She has the right to choose the job she wants to do.
She has the right to work.
She has the right to have children, to have as many children as she wants.
She has the right to... I don't know, there are many other rights.
As a lawyer, I can't deny her those rights.
But I'm just saying that we have to contextualise these rights
that have been imported into us.
They have to be contextualised, they have to be Africanised.
And what do you think,
and how do these rights that you say are imported
violate or trample on the African traditions you were talking about?
Basically, these rights do not violate African traditions.
It's the understanding that people have of these rights
that violates African traditions.
Otherwise, these rights do not violate African traditions.
When we say that a woman has the right to go to school,
even if it comes from the West,
it's beneficial for us, it's perfectly normal for a woman to go to school.
When we say that she has the right to do a job
different from that of her husband, to do it independently,
it's perfectly normal, it's her right.
But I say that when we say that often,
in our traditions, in our cultures, I would say,
in our society, where the majority of people
do not have a high enough intellectual level,
people understand it as a mathematical equality.
When we say that man is equal to woman,
we understand it as a mathematical equality,
although this equality cannot be mathematical.
It's more about equity.
It's more about treating each of them
according to their particular condition,
to treat women according to their condition as women
and to treat men according to their condition as men.
What we ask of a man, we will not necessarily ask of a woman.
What we ask of a woman, we will not necessarily ask of a man.
With all the goodwill I have, I am a man, I could never have a child.
I don't know where science has come from, but I couldn't do it.
I am for women to benefit from the same rights as men as human beings.
I would say that I am for the rights of men with a capital H.
Whether we are a woman or a man with a capital H,
we benefit from the same rights.
But I say, as an African, that we must influence.
Let's take the example of a state. When we have a head of state,
we say that the head of state is the President of the Republic.
But he doesn't do it alone. He doesn't decide alone.
That's why he has a council of ministers,
where he sits with people who tell him,
Mr. President, you can do this, you can't do that.
You can't do this, you have to do that.
But there is a corner called the President.
Do you understand what I'm trying to tell you?
Yes. So for you, even if there is a certain collegiality in the couple,
the man remains the head of the family, and he must always keep that.
Exactly. As an African, I would defend him with all my heart.
I would always defend him. I am a lawyer, that's true.
I always remain in the field of law,
but I say that I also affirm myself as an African.
The fact that I studied law, for me,
should not make me lose the reality
of my condition as an African and also Burkina Faso, Burkina Faso.
But I am well aware that this is also a manifestation of patriarchy.
Exactly. Patriarchy is not necessarily bad.
Because today we have the impression
that we are giving patriarchy a pejorative connotation.
That's not true.
If we go back to patriarchy, will it be positive?
I'm not sure.
But patriarchy must be nuanced.
There are practices of patriarchy that are of a certain age,
that we cannot continue.
We cannot ask a man...
A man cannot tell his wife, I don't want you to work,
or decide the type of clothes you must wear,
a lot of things. That's at a certain age.
But patriarchy means
that there is a certain leadership that a man must be able to have
in the context of the home.
What I'm saying is not about professional life, social life,
that's another debate where there is a perfect equality.
But in the context of the home, there is a certain leadership
that a man must be able to have.
Men are determined not to let their domination in the couple escape,
which constitutes one of the anchor points of patriarchy.
But feminists have also decided not to give up.
In the next episode,
it will be a question of social pressure on girls,
encouraging them to get married early,
while boys are free to do it when they want to,
or even never get married.
Do not hesitate to share this podcast on your social networks.
Talk about it around you, especially to the men around you,
because the question of masculinity is just as important as feminism.
Did you like this episode?
I invite you to share it on social networks
and to talk about it around you.
Don't hesitate to subscribe to the podcast
and give it five stars on the listening platform of your choice.
See you soon.