John Singleton Copley, Watson and the Shark

Antique Masterpieces
23 followers
32 Video Views·Sep 24, 2024
John Singleton Copley, Watson and the Shark, 1778, oil on canvas, 182.1 x 229.7 cm (National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C.). A conversation between Dr. Bryan Zygmont and Dr. Beth Harris.
We're in the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C.
We walked through the hallway, made a right turn, and we could see
the very famous painting that we're standing in front of,
John Singleton Copley's Watson and the Shark. We passed for a room of portraits,
and the room that this is in is one of portraits, and I'm reminded of how
important portraiture was in early American
painting, but Watson and the Shark presents us
something entirely different. The one thing there was a market for
in the American colonies was portraiture, and while
in the American colonies, Copley painted portrait after portrait,
but Copley had higher aspirations, and one of those aspirations was to paint
kind of grand manner history compositions that were at the very
pinnacle of the art hierarchy in the 18th century.
In a history painting, the artist is not painting something in front of him.
He's drawing from his imagination. The other thing
that history paintings had was the opportunity to provide
a kind of moral and instructive lesson. So we're talking about paintings that
featured the deaths of great heroes and showed
exemplary virtues. But what Copley has done
is something different. He hasn't looked back to the classical past.
This isn't Greece or Rome. This is an event that happened in 1749.
And this is something that we're going to see more and more of,
where artists begin to paint more contemporary events
using the heroic language of history painting.
We can think, for example, of Delacroix's Liberty Leading the People.
The other thing that's interesting here, though, about the Copley is that
it's kind of a portrait. It's a really interesting mix of a variety of different
genres. So I'm really drawn to the giant
shark, who is fiercely going after what looks like a very helpless young man.
And it's only upon really a second look that you can understand
the enormity of this beast. Its head is in the lower part of the composition,
and you see its tail immediately above part of the boat, which means that the
size of this thing we can only begin to guess at.
The scene was dictated by the patron, Brooke Watson, who went on to a long and
successful mercantile and political career, but in 1749
was merely a young sailor on a vessel in the Caribbean.
He's discarded his heavy garments and gone for a swim.
This moment of leisure becomes dangerous very quickly, and
Watson wrote about this experience. And you can see the shark has
already come around once, because you can see that his right leg
is missing a foot. And what has happened is the shark has come back around for a
second pass. We know that Watson lives, but the
composition does not make that clear. If there's a sense of anything right now,
it's hopelessness for our floundering figure in the water.
There are so many art historical references here. We look at the figures
in the foreground, for example, their hands are almost joined together
reaching down to help grab Watson. This was taken from
a Raphael of the miraculous draft officious,
and the standing figure in the boat is a reference to Saint George
killing the dragon. Raphael painted a version of this. So he's
working through visual ideas that have been around for centuries
and doing it in a different novel way. But the burning question to me is
why would Brooke Watson commission this tragic moment of his life where he
must have thought he was a dead man? Well, this is a really interesting idea
because when people commission portraits, it was often to commemorate some kind of
achievement, a major life goal, getting married or
having children. And this is a portrait that's been commissioned on what is
likely one of the worst days of Brooke Watson's life.
And so why would this be the moment in a
long career that was filled with successes that Brooke Watson wants to
commemorate? Brooke Watson gave this painting to an
orphanage, and there I think in some ways it
served as a model to inspire. Here is Watson who as a teenager
loses that foot, and he could say justifiably,
I had a rough teenage life and still I became a successful business person.
I was elected to parliament. I became Lord Mayor of London.
His coat of arms had a leg on it. He embraced this idea.
And so even though Copley isn't drawing on ancient Greek and Roman history to
tell a moral, it still is a painting that inspires,
that has a moral underpinning. It does. It has
all of the trappings of a grand manor history painting
just without the history. And it's so carefully composed, and we can see this
pyramid of figures, Copley drawing ideas about compositions from the
Renaissance, and our eye does go up to that black
figure at the apex of the pyramid. If there is a kind of
salvation for Watson, it's the rope that he has
thrown overboard that is laced over Watson's outstretched right arm.
We know that Watson becomes a Tory member of parliament,
and that one of the issues that's dividing the Tories and the Whigs at
this time is the Revolutionary War. And one of
the questions that the Tories ask is, how can the Americans
occupy a moral high ground when they're enslaving Africans?
So this idea of believing one is near death
and this moment of salvation. And we can think about that salvation as being
social, or personal, or Christian. And it really
works with some of the elements that are taken from a Christian context.
The Miraculous Draft of Fishes, the Saint George Killing the Dragon, those
are all Christian paintings that Copley is pulling from. And so the
salvation that Watson is achieving might not be a spiritual salvation,
but he is being saved.
