La gauche lui promet déjà une motion de censure, l'extrême droite affirme qu'il n'a aucun avenir. À peine nommé samedi soir, le gouvernement de Michel Barnier s'est retrouvé sous le feu des critiques avant même la déclaration de politique générale du Premier ministre. Pas d'état de grâce, donc, loin de là pour ce gouvernement qui fait la part belle au camp présidentiel d'une part, et d'autre part aux LR, sortis pourtant tous deux affaiblis des législatives. Pour en parler, notre invité, Martin Garagnon, porte-parole d’Ensemble pour la République. #france#michelbarnier#république
The left is already promising a motion of censorship. The far-right is assuring that it has no future.
Barely appointed on Saturday evening, the government of Michel Barnier found itself under the fire of criticism
even before the declaration of general policy of the Prime Minister.
No state of grace, so far from it, for this government,
which does the parbel to the presidential camp on the one hand, and on the other hand to the LR,
however out of weakening of the legislatives.
Hello Martin Garagnon.
Hello.
Thank you for being with us.
Spokesman of Ensemble pour la République, support of Emmanuel Macron.
It is a government that frankly puts the bar on the right.
Do you really recognize it?
And totally?
It was a necessary government.
It is a government of responsibility, because you reminded it very precisely.
The RN was very clear on the subject,
since before the election they had explained that they would only take Matignon with an absolute majority.
The left, on the other hand, positioned themselves in the evening of the second round,
explaining to us, and this is their original sin,
that finally they had won this election and that they were there to apply all their programs,
nothing but their programs.
I remind you that they have a third of the deputies, so we are very far from an absolute majority.
And so they remained, they remained what in fact to build a government?
They remained the forces of the central bloc and the Republicans on the right.
But do you regret, in the image of Gabriel Attal,
for example, the absence of personality from the left,
even if it is not she who is at the maneuver of this government?
You know, I generally look at dogmatism in politics,
because that's not how we move forward.
I am a fervent supporter of political overtaking,
which simply consists of acting that good ideals are not the apanage of a single and unique party.
They can be on the left, on the right, among all the sensitivities.
What matters is that they go in the right direction, in the service of the French.
So, indeed, I regret the postures a priori.
When I hear Mr. Hollande explain to us that we must censor this government
even before the general policy speech of October 1st
or even before the examinations of the first elements of the budget,
I do not find that very responsible.
Because voting for censorship, why not?
It is freedom, it is constitutional, there is no problem with that.
But it is also necessary that they explain to us, these officials,
what they propose behind.
Do they have an alternative majority with whom they will govern?
The presence within the sub-government of Bruno Retailleau,
who was one of the most fierce opponents of Emmanuel Macron within the DLR,
who inherits the portfolio of the interior.
What does it inspire you? Does it shock you?
On the issue of immigration, for example, what will it be able to give?
Michel Barnier said yesterday, we will not do ideology, we will do practical things.
However, Bruno Retailleau, when he speaks, for example,
about some French immigrants on paper,
he is precisely in ideology, isn't he?
I think that indeed, for it to work,
we must leave ideology aside, we must be in the practical-practical.
That is to say, very concretely,
here we will enter the phase of the budgetary examination.
What budget are we going to propose to the French?
And to do what?
We have the answer to who, with the announcement of the government,
the nomination of the government,
we know who will embody this policy.
Now the question remains of what?
And that will be the general political speech of October 1,
which will give us the first clues
on which the government will be able to move forward.
After, we will see what is the attitude of the Assembly.
But why have you given the keys to this file,
immigration and the interior,
in particular to Bruno Retailleau,
if not to satisfy the National Assembly,
which precisely, too, can trigger a motion of censorship,
if politics, in its sense, does not go far enough in this area?
So, you know, to have made some debates with deputies of the National Assembly,
they do not say the greatest good of Mr. Retailleau in general.
They tend to say that yes, it's just words,
but behind, when the LR are in power,
they do not follow the acts.
So they do not give him ...
Finally, it's not a gage vis-à-vis the National Assembly
to have named Mr. Retailleau.
On the other hand, let's be clear,
obviously the National Assembly holds a part of the solution of censorship.
But on the one hand, because it is the left that gives him this possibility,
the left, with this principle of voting censorship,
finally gives the LR the keys to the truck,
since they are free to vote censorship with the LR.
But on the other hand,
it is not because the LR agitates a motion of censorship
or the risk of a motion of censorship
that we are here to apply a policy of the LR.
This is absolutely not our subject.
So we will never be the hostage of the LR
and we will never put in place a policy ...
If there are subjects on which the LR finds itself
on our proposals and the proposals of the government,
they are free to vote them.
And if it goes in the direction of France, so much the better.
Among the texts left in the fridge by the dissolution,
in June, there is the bill on the end of life.
Do you trust precisely this government
to carry it in turn?
There was no question about it yesterday
in the first interview of Michel Barnier.
On the other hand, the Prime Minister responded to Gabriel Attal,
who wanted guarantees on the rights of LGBT,
marriage for all.
He said, that's it, these are achievements.
He did not talk about the end of life.
Is this project going to end?
I wish it, because it is indeed part,
as you said, of the great texts that were at work.
This is not the only one.
We have the question of the AME, which was mentioned
at the beginning of the year during the vote,
especially the law on immigration.
We have the question of housing too,
which is a very concrete and immediate concern
of millions of French people.
So we have several texts that were,
let's say, in the pipes of the parliamentary circuit,
on which we will have to look again
at the Assembly, at the Senate.
We'll see what comes out of it.
I trust the sense of responsibility of each.
Once again, this is not a LR government.
It is a government of a kind of coalition
quite new.
So it's hard to name it,
but it has to go in the right direction.
And for which everyone must actually
propose compromises
in relation to positions that may be theirs initially.
You said it very precisely,
Mr. Barnier has no intention,
and that's the least of it,
to return to topics such as abortion,
the right of LGBT, the PMA, etc.
Martin Garagnon, you know the reproach
that is made to Emmanuel Macron,
that of having ignored the result of the legislatives,
to finally give power to the losers
of this scrutiny, of these scrutiny
of June 30 and July 7.
What do you answer to this criticism?
Well, if it was the reproach
that some make to the president,
it would tell us.
Many reproaches have been made to him.
But it's a serious reproach.
It's the reproach of having, in a way,
abused his power, isn't it?
You know, this reproach,
in general, is accompanied by a little music
on a possible resignation
or a mandate that would not go to his term
for the President of the Republic.
At the risk of disappointing all those
who make this little calculation,
I would just remind your listeners
that the President is not responsible
in front of the National Assembly.
He is not responsible.
He has a mandate that runs until 2027.
So tomorrow you can have X governments,
the President is not accountable
in front of the National Assembly.
On the other hand, those who want his resignation
or who can hope for it,
but tomorrow you have a presidential election,
the newly elected president
could not dissolve.
So it would not solve at all
the issue of the composition of the current Assembly.
Without going to this issue of resignation
which is carried by a part of the left,
do you conceive that the left-wing voters,
I was going to say,
are disappointed, quite simply,
of this casting,
they who have put, in spite of everything,
in charge of the forces of the left
through the new Popular Front?
I invite the left-wing voters
to ask this question
to their deputies,
local political leaders,
their leaders of federations, departments, sections,
to ask them an explanation on this.
Because when you see the result of the Europeans
who initiated this sequence of dissolution,
it is the Europeans who resulted in the dissolution
the same evening.
When you see the list,
the score of Mr. Glucksmann's list,
and what you see after,
in what intransigence
the leaders of the PS found themselves
taken hostage by Mr. Mélenchon,
indeed there is an explanation
that they will have to find
and give to their voters.
Because if I had been Mr. Glucksmann's voter,
I can tell you that indeed
I would have been a little bad
to see the outcome of this scrutiny.
But it is the responsibility, once again,
to the intransigence of a certain part
of the left-wing officials.
When you make a third of the deputies in the assembly,
you cannot demand power for yourself.
It does not exist, it is not a cohabitation.
This government is taking its first steps today.
We did not have time to talk about the budget.
Now we have the opportunity to come back to it
when the text arrives.
What longevity do you lend it?
The Prime Minister spoke of fraternity,
of culture, of compromise,
but an assembly so fragmented,
how long will it last?
I wish him longevity as long as possible
because a government that lasts
is a government that works.
For the good of my country, once again,
when we are patriots,
we want our country to turn,
that it works for France,
that the French live better,
find solutions to their problems
and therefore that the government
can be effective and at work.
Martin Garanion, spokesman of Ensemble pour la République.
Thank you for being with us this morning.