Blaise Pascal (1623-1662) Pensées

Blaise Pascal
4 followers
This is Philosophy Bites with me David Edmonds and me Nigel Warburton.
Philosophy Bites is available at www.philosophybites.com.
Gamble on God. If he exists and you don't believe in him, you may end up in eternal damnation.
If he doesn't exist, well you've lost very little. It's a fair bet that you've heard of
Pascal's Wager. It was set out in his posthumously published thoughts, The Pensées, but Ben Rogers,
author of a book on Pascal, says the French 17th century genius ought to be celebrated also for
his penetrating analysis of the human condition. Ben Rogers, welcome to Philosophy Bites.
Thank you, hello.
We're going to focus on Blaise Pascal's Pensées. I wonder if you could begin by
saying who Blaise Pascal was.
Pascal was born in 1623 and he was recognised even in his own life as a preeminent
scientist, mathematician. We now don't take so much notice of his scientific achievements. He's
really remembered, above all, for the Pensées, which he wrote a few years before his death in
1662. We shouldn't pass over his scientific achievement because he did make an amazing
calculating machine, didn't he? He did. He was both, I suppose unusual even in his own day,
in being both an extraordinary mathematician but also an experimenter and a great gift for
creating things and a very practical turn of mind. But he was also highly religious and that's a
force that comes through the Pensées, his thoughts. Let's begin by saying how they came to be written.
Pascal was, as you said, a very religious man. I think he was born to a religious family. He was
brought up to be fairly devout but underwent a series of conversions and became more and more
religious throughout his life. He had one particularly momentous conversion in 1654,
which really was a profound, ecstatic experience. In fact, he wrote down the experience on a sheet
of parchment which he carried sewn into his clothes for the rest of his life. Shortly after
that, he became embroiled in a polemic against the Jesuits, who he thought represented a basically
lax form of Catholicism and he defended a much more austere, almost puritanical version of
Catholicism. Having written the provincial letters in which he defended the Jansenists,
which was the movement he was associated with against the Jesuits, he then set out to write
an apology, a defense of the Christian religion. The Pensées, as we know them today, came out of
he would write down his thoughts on large pieces of paper. He would then cut them up and organize
them in bundles, which he then threaded together. He never had time to finish the apology or indeed
take it very far before he became really too ill to work. When he died, his family and his
followers published the Pensées, but in a way which was not at all sensitive to the order in
which Pascal had left them. It's only over the last 50 or 60 years that scholars have begun to
piece together the original order of the Pensées, and actually the Pensées as we know them today,
I mean almost a thousand fragments, are very close to the order in which Pascal left them.
Given the strange nature of this book, there's lots of fragments sewn together essentially by
different editors, how do we go about reading it? Yeah, good question and a difficult one. I think
there's two tendencies which must be resisted. One is just to read them as individual fragments.
There is a tendency to sometimes asceticize them and think of them as being sort of Nietzsche,
just an aphorist, and what we actually have here are notes towards the finished work. The other
extreme, what we must also resist, is actually viewing it as a finished apology because he never
did finish it, and who knows, maybe actually he did not finish it because he was ill, maybe he
didn't finish it because he just had given up on it, it was too hard a challenge. But what we can
do from the fragments that have been left behind, and some of the fragments refer to the structure
of the work, and then there's the actual ordering of the fragments as well, gives us quite a good
clue as to how Pascal was thinking about the plan of his work. We can understand it in that way,
as long as we don't go too far down that road. Okay, well let's try and get a sense of the main
themes of the book. How would you outline the main thrust of this work? This is an apology for the
Christian religion. It's addressed to a sort of sceptical, worldly, perhaps conventionally
Christian but not heartfelt Christian, and he wanted to bring these people to God, convince
them of the truth of Christianity, and he did not believe in the sort of Cartesian approach.
Remember he was born a generation after Descartes, his father had been a friend of Descartes,
but Descartes attempted to prove the existence of God through a series of deductions essentially,
and Pascal thought this was entirely misconceived and never actually really persuaded anyone,
and ultimately the God you ended up with wasn't even the Christian God essentially,
it was a sort of a deity. Pascal adhered to a very very Christocentric form of Christianity,
he thought that we weren't able to know God directly, we were only able to know him through
Jesus Christ, so the point of the apology is to convince people of the truths of the Christian
religion, and very roughly the Pensee fall into two parts. In the first part there's a portrait
of man, and the second part there's an argument as to the truth of the Christian religion.
So let's look at the portrait of man. How does he paint humanity? Well the portrait of man is,
to most of us today, by far the most interesting half of the Pensee. I mean it's an extraordinarily
sort of rich and deliberately contradictory portrait, full of sort of clashing elements,
and the idea is actually to build up a picture of man which is so rich that it can't be accounted
for in human terms alone, it can only really be accounted for in using a Christian framework. So
that is the central argument, and the way that Pascal does this is that he does by playing off
different schools of thought, and that's why you get all these different sort of voices going on,
and it's very dangerous with the Pensee of taking any one thought as an expression of Pascal's
views. In fact he's playing off one philosophical sect against another. Could you give some
examples of that? Yes, I think one of the sort of central divisions within the Pensee is between
philosophical sceptics and philosophical sort of stoics and dogmatists. Philosophical sceptics
represented say by Montaigne take a very low view of human capacity and human nature,
they're sceptics about what we can know, but they're also sceptics about our powers to attain
us of invincible virtue, and then you've got another school represented by Descartes for
example, or by Epictetus, who Pascal calls sometimes dogmatists or sometimes rationalists,
who have a very high view of what we can attain. They believe that we have this extraordinary
capacity for knowledge, they advocate a very sort of high-minded strenuous virtue, and Pascal plays
these off against each other, showing that both are true and neither are true. Well how do we
account for this? We account for this with the fact that man has elements of greatness in him
which distinguishes him from the animals he can think, at the same time he is feeble, and the fall
ultimately would explain that, the fact that we were made in God's image and then descended
essentially to become sort of fallen corporal creatures. On my superficial reading, the parts
of the book where Pascal is describing the wretchedness of humanity, he relishes, he loves
describing how we're driven by lust and greed, he doesn't celebrate reasoning with the same degree
of relish I feel. Oh well I mean there are passages where he quite emphatically opposes someone like
Montaigne and saying, ah yes, but you ignore the fact that we might be feeble but we can think,
and that's very important. In fact Pascal, as a matter of biographical fact, had an enormous
respect of course for intellectual and scientific achievement, and here we come actually to a very
important sort of structuring scheme of all of Pascal's thought, which is this idea of the three
orders. Okay so what are the three orders? Well the three orders are body, mind and heart. These
sort of inform Pascal's thinking throughout in lots of different ways. I mean he thinks we are
in a sense as humans belong to all three orders at once, so animals just belong to the bodily order,
we have a mind, we also have a heart. There are three different ways of forms of knowledge that
these offer, so there's the senses, there's reason, and then there's intuition, and all
offer real knowledge for Pascal. And then there are also three forms of leadership or greatness
with respect to these orders, so an athlete is a prince of material world, but so is a king.
Then you have the princes of the intellectual world who are the scientists, the philosophers,
and then you have the princes of the world of the heart, who's the church,
the church fathers and ultimately Christ. That's interesting, so the heart is the organ with which
you relate to God, not the mind, because Descartes for instance would have wanted you to relate with
your mind. Absolutely right, you know God ultimately through your heart, it's an intuition,
but Pascal also says that there are other things that we know through our intuition.
His answer to the sceptics who cast doubt on everything is actually we can't rationally
prove that time exists, that we exist, that the external world exists, but we know it through
these intuitions. And similarly the other forms of knowledge also have their place in the religious
life. A devout person will know God through the heart, but will also read the scriptures and that
way use their mind to appraise themselves in the truth of Christianity. They'll also repeatedly
take part in the sacraments, which is a sort of bodily engagement. So you said earlier there are
lots of different opposing points of view being brought into play. Could you give a few more
examples of those? Yeah, another really important one is the distinction between the philosophers
and the people. On the one hand Pascal is dividing the philosophers into two groups,
sceptics and dogmatists, but he also recognizes a certain family resemblance among all the
philosophers and he contrasts that or juxtaposes that against the people. So there's a sort of
view amongst all philosophers at the time that the people were ignorant and they were vain
and that only philosophy could lead you to the truth. And Pascal endorses that and then he
undermines it. One example would be attaining happiness and a good life. So the philosophers
laughed at the common people who spent their time chasing after worldly goods, playing, gambling,
fox hunting and so forth, and they said what an absurd way to be happy. The way to be happy is
to fortify yourself against fortune, to be sort of meditative and reflective. Pascal sort of
endorses that in the early stages of the Pensée and he has particular fun of the common people
who spend their days chasing a hare, which they wouldn't want if they could get it. Then he turns
the tables on the philosophers and said well of course they do that because the alternative is
sitting in a room and contemplating your own wretched condition. And that's the sort of
dynamic that's being played out throughout the Pensées and it's really to show that there's
actually no point of view that we humans can sort of attain through secular philosophy,
which is really sort of strong and able to guarantee us happiness. In our predicament
and to embrace Christianity is one of both sort of ignorance and unhappiness and wretchedness.
So this portrait of man is the first part of the book and it's quite a complex portrait because
it's pulling in different directions, but what takes us from that to the second part of the book?
Well we end up with it towards the end of that portrait is a depiction of a creature with this
extraordinarily rich collection of qualities. He's both great and wretched, he has extraordinarily
intellectual potential and yet he's very much a sort of corporal object. He is neither big nor
small, neither finite or infinite. This is meant to be a sort of very unsettling depiction, it's meant
to really disturb the reader. What Pascal is doing in a sense is sort of softening the reader up
for Christianity. So human beings are neither one thing nor the other. We still haven't got to God
yet. My inclination would be to say the argument of the wager is what gets us there, that's the
book that every philosophy student knows. That's right, so we are neither one thing nor the other.
What Pascal's done already by the end of the portrait is to establish we do have all these
very real attributes. How do we put them together? How do we make sense of them? Where do they come
from? And you're right, the wager probably is an important part of that argument. You'd better
remind us what the wager is. It's a bet basically. Pascal says we can't know whether God exists or
not and we can't even say whether it's more probable that God does exist or doesn't because
we know so little about his nature. He is infinite, he's absolutely beyond our understanding.
At the same time what we do know is that if God does exist and we have believed in him then the
rewards are infinitely great. If we believe in him and it turns out that he doesn't exist, well
all we've done is spent a good life, been devout, helped others, no harm done. And those circumstances
is absolutely rational to bet on God's existence. That's the wager. It is hugely controversial
amongst logicians. There's one common criticism that we can defend Pascal against and that is
it's sometimes said well all that Pascal's done is shown you that it's rational to believe in God.
That actually can't make you believe in God and Pascal understands that very clearly. And his
argument is well it's a first step to believing in God. You have to try to believe in God. You then
begin to examine in a much more sympathetic light the case for Christianity and you begin taking
all these bodily exercises. You start going to mass, you start praying and Pascal thought that
actually just bodily practice had an effect on belief. So basically this is a gambler's argument.
Gamble on the existence of God because if you win you get a huge prize, infinite happiness,
and if you lose you burn in hell possibly. And if you gamble on God existing and he doesn't exist
it's not such a huge loss. So a rational gambler is going to choose God but then if you have trouble
believing in God just go through the motions. It's kind of reverse method acting. You pretend
that you believe in God and then the belief comes afterwards. That's right and actually
there's a sort of dig there I suppose at the very high-minded sort of forms of religion
and perhaps Cartesian religion which sees religion all about the mind when in fact it's
Pascal saying it's actually just about the body as well. It seems to me from what you've been
saying that the whole structure of this book relies on us believing that humanity is fallen,
that the different elements within a human being arise both because we're made in the
shape of God and because we've fallen from grace in some way. Now if you don't believe that,
if you don't take the metaphysical underpinning that comes from Christianity, what's left?
What's left is an extraordinarily rich timeless portrait of human nature actually.
You know if we think about philosophical debates today Pascal has a contribution to make to most
thinking about the distinction between sort of mind and body. All of Pascal's reflections on
our nature as both spiritual beings or beings with sort of mental attributes and bodily. I mean
that's a sort of extraordinarily sort of rich territory and I think likewise his sort of
reflections on happiness or indeed his reflections on the role of intuition in knowledge. I mean
these are sort of deep perennial issues and Pascal makes this really profound contribution. I think
he's quite a profound political philosopher. I think above all he's a sort of critic of the
philosophical tradition itself and its sort of conceits. What did Pascal have against philosophy
then? Well Pascal was a skeptic about systems. He thought there was no sort of system,
no purely secular system that could capture the complexity of reality and wherever he detected
a sort of system maker. I think most philosophers are system makers. He wanted to have a go and
undermine them and that's really one of the great strengths of this book. It's a perpetual sort of
warring against some of the pretensions of system builders. The way you've presented Pascal, he's a
fascinating thinker. Why do you think he's been so neglected by philosophers? Well I think that's a
good question. I wish he was better known but I think it's true to say that while he's very well
known in France and has always been an important influencer of French philosophy, he's not much
studied by English-speaking philosophers. One reason is it's very very hard. It's also the
case that there's been a revolution in our understanding of Pascal over the last couple of
generations and I just think that Anglophone philosophy hasn't caught up with that and I
really wish it would because in my view he should be one of the central figures of the canon. Pascal
was a sort of supreme genius. You're in the hands of a Shakespeare or a Plato or one of these people
who just crosses so much and is absorbed so much and you really feel has a position on everything
and if you're like me and spend many years reading Pascal you do also walk around with a sort of
Pascalian frame and this ability to think what would Pascal make of that and there's almost always
an answer to that. Ben Rogers, thank you very much. Thank you.
