Why This Broker Stopped Paying Agent Commissions

Invest In Realty
2 followers
Today I sit down with Pete Voss. He's the founder and broker owner of 3% Listing Company. This guy,
last July of 2023, he went out and said, I'm going to start a brokerage and I'm going to
take listings that do not offer the buyer commission. So he's been doing this since
last year, over a year ago. So he has a very interesting perspective and he has interesting
data points because he's been doing this for a while. So I figured this would be a really good
interview for you to listen to because this guy's a really ahead of the curve, like what you're
experiencing moving into the new rules. He has already been experiencing them for over a year
now. Okay. So I figured you guys could learn something from Pete and I'll read here about
his company. We offer a unique financial advantage to our sellers by only paying for the representation
they receive, allowing buyers to negotiate their own agent's fees and keeping transparency,
honesty, and clarity at the forefront of each transaction. Our brokerage caters to a diverse
clientele, including first-time home buyers, high-end buyers and sellers, and cost-conscious
individuals looking for exceptional value when selling their home. So without further ado,
let's get into the interview. Enjoy. Pete, how are you doing? I'm doing great. It's a lot of fun
right now, man. There's a whole lot of changes going on. It's been great. It is interesting, bro.
It is interesting. So you actually started the company 3% listing a year ago, right? Yeah. Yep.
June 1st was our year. I'm literally asking you because I don't know, just for the viewers. This
isn't rehearsed. I don't know the stats. I'm literally figuring this thing out. Back a year
ago, when you started the company, you literally, you take listings and a year ago, you stopped
offering a buyer agent commission on MLS. You literally put zero on MLS, correct? Yep. Yeah.
That was our big thing is just trying to figure out a way that we can still provide a listing
service to our sellers, but really push that negotiating position for our sellers to be able
to negotiate how much they want to contribute to the buy side agency and if they wanted to at all,
or kind of what they wanted to do that way. So we just give them that flexibility to be
able to kind of negotiate that into their transaction. There's so many questions and
I want to get into like, has it reduced showings and stuff like that, right? And interest in the
properties. But you did this a year ago, obviously we were pretty deep into this,
you know, this, this massive like lawsuit and nobody really knew a year ago kind of how it
was going to play out. I want to say the Sitzer Burnett trial actually went on, I think, I want
to say October-ish is actually when it actually was in court. And so you actually created this
business model before the court case even happened. So my first question is, like,
how did you, why, how did you, why did you do this? How did you, you know, what, like,
what exactly brought you to say, and I'm just going to quit off from the buyer agent commission?
Yeah, so we kind of, I went back and forth, conversation. So I'm in business with my dad
and we had, man, I bet three years of conversations back and forth about this and
what it would look like and how, how is it going to change agency and how is it going to change,
you know, how people are getting paid. And I mean, all of these different facets and kind of
talking, talking through all of these things. And then it really wasn't until, you know,
seeing the trial and how things were progressing that I really realized, hey, there's going to
be some big changes that are coming this way because of this. It's, it really is going to
shake things up. And so we looked at it as an opportunity to do things a little bit differently.
And kind of jumping in to see what how, how can we make a difference? How can we build a
business model? That's a little bit different and force people a little bit out of their comfort
zone. You know, you're we're, we're in a model that says, Hey, you as a buyer's agent, we're
not offering that paycheck anymore on, on the listing. So you need to have a conversation with
your buyer to discuss what is your fee and how are you going to get paid? If you want to include
that into your offer, then you can bring it in. But now it's bringing those conversations to the
forefront and really making, I think really the, the thing that bothered me most was for years and
years and years, we had so many agents that were marketing buyer's agency as it doesn't cost the
buyer anything. And, oh, you can, you know, call me to look at this house. It doesn't cost you
anything to work with me. And that just never really sat right with me because I looked at it
and went, if it doesn't cost them anything, that means that the seller is paying both agents. And
now why is it, why is a seller having to pay an agent whose only job is to negotiate against them?
I mean, that's their one, their one consideration in putting that deal together is to try and get
as much money from the seller as possible. And the seller has to pay them, you know,
a certain percentage of that. So we wanted to kind of separate agency from the compensation.
And, uh, and this was kind of the model that we said, uh, thought maybe would be the way to do
that. Man, was it, how scary was it to actually, cause, cause I'm sure you thought of this like
jogging or, you know, like taking a walk or, you know, riding a bike or whatever you do when you
come up with these great ideas. Cause like, I, I see even though, you know, we were getting close
to Cesar Burnett, right? I still see the move you made as a visionary type of move. Cause honestly,
back then before Cesar Burnett, like it was literally like most everybody, like there were
some people that were saying it's going to change, but most everybody was, was saying how everything's
just going to keep going and be the same, but, but you months and months ahead of the trial.
So, but when you thought of this and then you actually took the physical
steps to actually start implementing it, right. How scary was that? Cause at the point, like,
like, like, you know, you see the comments on my Instagram, like, you know, agents don't like this
kind of stuff. Right. Um, how scary was that? And what was the, what was the pushback you got from
your local agents when they saw a listing was zero being offered to the buyer agent?
Yeah, it, uh, it definitely was scary. Um, you know, we looked at it as an opportunity to really
appeal to sellers. So we felt like there's still going to be transactions. It's not, it's not like
we're just going out and doing something that there's just, we're gonna have to work really
hard to get this business up and running because we definitely have a, uh, um, uh, proposition to
offer to our clients. So from that standpoint, we weren't really concerned, but yeah, the feedback,
uh, reactions that we were going to get from agents was definitely something that was,
um, a concern. Um, and I would say really the feedback that we got was kind of, uh,
um, a mixed bag, um, all the way across the board. I've had agents that have called me up. And
as soon as I answered my phone, just started screaming at me about, uh, um, what we're doing
and how, how dare we do, do things this way and not offer a compensation. And, um, I had, uh,
I had one agent that, uh, so when we initially started, there was a little bit of gray area
on whether we had to offer something. And so our first initial, um, listings, we only offered like
a hundred dollars. Right. And so I had one agent that called and she had said, um, is your
compensation really only a hundred dollars? And I said, yeah, it is. And I explained for probably
three minutes, explain how we can structure this so that she could still get paid. And I got done
talking and she goes, well, I can't work for a hundred dollars. So I suppose I just need to send,
send him to you and you can show the house. And I went, you're right. That's exactly what you
should do. I have no problem with that at all. Give me a call and I'm happy to happy to go show
it. Right. And then what did you give her a referral or something? No, because there's no,
there was no buy side at that point. I didn't have a relationship. I didn't have any money to give
to a buy side agent. No, but no, no, not a buy side. Like she referred the guy to you though,
right? She, well, she, she just said, Hey, I can't, I can't do this for a hundred dollars.
And so you need to call the listing agent. Right. And so we, we call it a referral though,
but she didn't ask for it. She didn't ask for a referral, I guess. And you weren't offering.
And we weren't offering a referral. I mean, truth, truthfully, I mean, we're working with,
if we're working with buyers, we're having the same conversations that every other agent is about.
These are the services that we're providing and this is what the costs of those services are.
And we're going to try and work it into the deal. So no, that, that wasn't a case where we're
going, well, Hey, if you, you know, if you don't want to show it for a hundred dollars, then I'll,
I'll pay you a percentage of whatever I get out of the deal. Yeah. If you, if, if you, Mr. Agent
can't show your value to your buyer, I'm not, I'm not going to pick it up and then turn around
and hand it to you. Yeah. So did you have agents that steered at, steered their clients away from
your listings? You feel it's, it's hard to say. That's one of those things where you just never,
you never know what those conversations are looking like on the other side. I don't know
that it was I don't know that we've lost traction on showings because of it. I do know that there
were a couple of conversations that after I explained what our business model was that the
agent said, well, then, you know, I'm just going to really struggle to show, to show your house if
we're not getting compensated. And I would just stop them in their tracks and be like, Hey,
I think you need to go and talk to your broker because I think you're starting to, you might
start to say things that you're really not gonna like that are really going to be a problem for
you down the road. And so we really, really made a point to try and curb those conversations
because that's, that's not a conversation I wanted to hear them say either. Oh, I'm, you know,
I'm not getting paid enough to go show your listing. I don't, that's not the route we want to
go. So it's like, what about the client? Right. Like, you know, what about the client? It's so
fascinating, man. What, what you've done here. So, so I guess you can look at data and you can
say, here's the average days on the market, um, from listing to close or listing to pending,
right? Listing to pending. You can say, here's the days on the market from listing to pending
for the rest of the market. Here's the average and here's the average listing to pending days
on the market for our company. And we don't offer buyer agent commission upfront. Yeah.
We're happy to oblige on the backside, depending on what our seller's appetite is to accommodate.
Yep. But, but have you looked at the data for contract to pending, uh, average market compared
to your listings? Is it? So for, for our first year, so like I said, June 1st was our, uh,
one year anniversary. Um, and our, our numbers are right in line with the, with the rest of the
market. And so we haven't seen a fall off of anything that way. So I have a huge team leader
here in my local market and I'm like, bro, you know, honestly, yeah, we'll still pay buyer agent
commissions, but we'll do it on the backend and the purchase agreement. If in fact that's what
the buyer wants to do and the seller's willing to take it. But as far as offering upfront,
it's just something that I don't feel like is in the best interest of the seller.
Um, and honestly, the way the rules are, you can't really average, you can like here,
you can put it on your website, right? Your personal website. Yeah. Who's looking at my
website to see if I'm offering a buyer agent commission, right? It's literally non-existent.
So you don't know. All you can really do is reach out and see,
and then whatever they say doesn't matter because you were going to put it in the contract anyway.
Yeah. And there's no need in offering three or two because you don't know if they're even going
to offer anything. They may have a deal worked out with the buyer, right? They may have swung a deal
when they listed their property to represent them for like a flat fee or something on the backend
or the buy side. You don't know what the deal is. They worked out. So why even offer anything
if they're going to put whatever they want in the offer and then you can negotiate it from there.
And he's like, I'm not really there yet. As far as, you know, uh, realizing that people aren't
going to look at properties if they're not. And I'm like, the clients don't care what the
commission is. They like the house. Only the, only the agent cares. And the agent doesn't have any
control over what their client sees because their client sees it online. They're going to go see it
regardless of what the commission is. Well, what if they agree to pay whatever the seller doesn't,
doesn't, um, uh, doesn't, you know, cover in terms of the buyer agency agreement.
In my opinion, in that case, those buyers are going to go directly to the listing agent.
So are you finding a lot of that with your model? I mean, we're not there yet where the market's
saturated with sellers that aren't offering a buyer agent commission, but, but for the year
that you've been doing this, have you seen buyers coming directly to you as a result?
Not yet, because I still think that the, I think the buyers are still uneducated in that. They
don't see the differences yet. And so I think that that's coming and that to your earlier point,
I think that's really something that, uh, um, could be a, uh, one of those factors that, um,
decreases the amount of buyers agents in the marketplace. Um, but also the amount of money
that a buyer's agent is able to, um, collect because educated buyers will understand how
things are, um, how commissions are, are based and then start to weigh their options a little
bit more. And so, um, so yeah, it's not something that we're seeing quite yet.
Um, but there's definitely in the same school of thought, um, when you start to talk about
agencies that are brokerages that are still collecting compensation and offering out co-op
to me, I feel like there, there's a potential for liability there because now they don't have a one,
a one place to put that offer so that you can't put it in the MLS anywhere. So now they have to,
to make sure that they are not hurting their seller by not communicating this offer to every
single agent that calls. I feel like that's opening them up to liability. So for an example,
if you've, if you've taken a listing and you're offering a co-op compensation, but we don't know
where necessarily where that is. I call you, I say, you know, I call you because I've got an
agent that are a buyer that wants to write on it, but you don't answer my call. I'm still writing
the offer. Well, now there's an unknown there. And now I may be going, okay, they're not offering
anything. I have to go off the assumption that you're not offering anything. So now I'm counseling
my buyer in that same way. Well, now my buyer is writing an offer that's lower because they're
going off the assumption that there's not a co-op compensation offered. Well, now just because you,
Mr. Listing Agent didn't answer your phone, have you hurt your, your seller's, uh,
your seller's bottom line? Because now the offer that they're getting is lower simply because you
did not have a way to communicate what that compensation was. Right. Right. There's so much.
It's so fascinating. Like the world that we're in now. It is. Um, going back to that team leader,
he was saying he's not quite there yet on not on, on, on not offering it won't reduce showings.
And I said, I used to believe that, but I quit believing that a while back that offering the
buyer agent commission actually increases or decreases activity. Yeah. Um, I believed it for
a while because we've all been programmed. We've all been programmed to believe certain things. Um,
but it's, it's fascinating to, to, to hear your, hear your, that your days on the market from
listing to pending lines up with, with the rest of the market. Yeah. Yeah. It has not to us. It
has not seemed like that's a, a factor now, now, now. Okay. So, so, so, so what, what does it look
on the backend? Like you, you get offers with compensation. Is it 3%, um, you know, what's the
standard, uh, deal that you normally do, right? Are these sellers listing for 3%, but then ending
up paying five or six on the backend? Like what? So that's what I love. That is what I have loved
the absolute most about all of this is that no single deal has been the same. Like every single
offer that we get is, has some component that's a little bit different and gets to be negotiated
out. Whether it be the, the rate that the buyer is willing to pay their agent or how much they're
asking, or maybe how much they're not asking. Um, I think that has been the greatest thing about it
is it just leaves so much more, um, ability for the seller to negotiate on the table, um, and
have more opportunities to come out ahead. And so that's what I love most about it. But a very
interesting, um, component to this is that, um, we are seeing buyers agents that are getting
typically more. If I was, if I was following our industry, our local, our local markets, um,
kind of history of what they are offering in their compensation, buyers agents that purchase our
listings and are negotiating their compensation into the, uh, into the transaction, they're
actually getting paid more than they would have had. They went and bought one that was offering
a co-op compensation because they have the ability to negotiate their fee with their buyer and figure
out what their buyer is willing to pay them for a, for a compensation, and then turn around and
include it in their offer. As opposed to just settling for whatever amount I decided that I
wanted to offer them in compensation. So, so you, like I say, I, I, I consider you somewhat
of a visionary with this, right? I appreciate that. Took this and like created a business model
and went out there when you did it. Obviously I would think that your business had a spike
up because you're offering 3% commissions. You're, it's a different model. So did your business,
you know? Yeah, we, we definitely pick up a lot of phone calls of people that are just going,
Hey, I drove by and I saw this list list for three, you know, sign what, what is that about?
And we explain how we do things and how we do things differently. And a lot of people go,
that makes a lot of sense. Now we don't, we, we've lost out on, on listings as well
that people look, you know, Hey, I, you know, I want to go with the more traditional route and
that's perfectly fine. Yeah. But yeah, it definitely has spurred a lot of a lot of
conversations. And that was one of the reasons, I mean, why we, why we created the company,
the way that we did was I wanted to anybody who has ever driven by and seen one of my signs or
seen an ad and seen our company name before they're sitting down and writing, signing a
listing contract for, you know, 5%, 6%, 7%, whatever it is that they're looking at it and
going, well, what about that other 3% company? What does that, maybe I need to explore that
option before doing this. And we've had a lot of conversations that way.
Right. Right. So, so with you, you know, obviously you have some, some kind of gift
of being able to kind of see ahead a little bit and, and take actions to take advantage of
situations. What's your take on where we kind of go from here? Do you consider the current market
where the sellers are willing to pay the buyer agent fees in the offers? Like you've seen in
some of your offers, because that's kind of been like the traditional, as you say, route.
And right now you've got agents that are like, oh, we'll be fine. I've got buyers signing 3%
agencies and sellers are paying it on the back end. We're literally one weekend of this thing.
You know, I, I'm kind of considering this more of a, like a dead cat bounce situation where
it's kind of a false reality of kind of where we're actually going and giving
agents a false sense of security with this, in my opinion. But where, where do you see this
going? Cause you have experience here. You've dealt with sellers on listing for three and then,
and then negotiating in the commission. You've done it in the traditional world,
which was the world of yesterday. Now we're in the new world. And obviously you have some kind
of vision, vision for where this thing might go. Where do you think this is going in terms of buyer
agency sellers willing to pay, you know, X percent to the buyer's agent that's negotiating against
them? You know, buyer agency buyers pay like, like what's your, what's your thoughts? Cause I know
you've spent a lot of time thinking about this. Yeah. I think, I think from the seller side,
so the, the perspective that we have and that we share with our sellers is that instead of
focusing on the purchase price, they need to be focused on their bottom line. How much are you
walking away from the transaction with? So set aside the fact that you're paying for a buyer's
agent or, and we kind of put it, we kind of put it in the same light that we would with a buyer
that's asking a seller to pay for concessions, pay for, you know, contribute money to towards
their closing costs. We, we talked to our sellers and say, don't worry about where the
money's going. Don't worry about that. Let's focus on your bottom line. Cause that's what
matters most to you is how much money is, are you walking, how much money are you walking away from
the transaction with? And so if we, if we're negotiating from that aspect, then it allows
a seller to still keep a deal together because at the end of the day, the seller's goal is still
to sell the property. And so that's what we love about the model is that we're bringing all of
these terms to the seller so that they're able to weigh it all out at the same time and say,
Hey, yeah, look, I can get, I'm perfectly fine, you know, paying their buyer's agent because
we're, they, you know, they brought their price up to offset some of that.
So you think it's something that will continue for years and years and years to come?
I think, I think so. Now where I think things will change is on that buy side.
Because like you said, you know, we're, we're still just kind of stagnant on the buy side.
People still doing what they've always done. Charging fees that they've always charged on
the buy side. They're just negotiating that out with their, with their buyers and still working
it into the transaction. I think that there's going to be more components coming into more
competition coming into the buy side. So you're going to start to see probably just wild business
models that come into the buy side that are going to drive those costs down. And, you know, there's
going to be a fair amount of quality buyers agents, if they can share their value with their
clients. I think there's still a lot of opportunity for them to, you know, get three, 3%, or, you
know, whatever, whatever fee that they are. I think you could probably see some buyers agents that may
get more, they may be able to justify, Hey, these are all the services that we're going to provide.
And this is what the costs are. So I think it really brings more of a free market to that buy
side agency that we've never seen before. And then just like any free market, you're going to see a
lot of different factors that are going to start to weigh out where, you know, where do we end up
on a common number? Like what is the, what is the most frequent number? What's the average that
agents are getting on that buy side? So I think that's, I think the buy side is going to be really
where we see the most change, the most decrease, and the most volatility. Yeah. Do you, do you feel
like, have you looked at other countries and how they operate? Do you, do you feel like, do you
feel like we'll see a lot of unrepresented buyers? A lot of people are talking that, right?
A lot of people are putting that out there. Yep. I think the implementation of the requirement for
buyer broker agreements, I think is going to push to see, you'll see more unrepresented buyers for
a longer period of time so that I think buyers will do more shopping around going and looking
at open houses, looking at maybe doing one-time showings with the, with the listing agents.
Right. Before, just because they have a little bit of a hesitation to sign up with a buyer's
agent. And so there may be some opportunity for listing agents to put together more deals that
way. I think dual agency would be, is going to be a very interesting dynamic for things as things
continue to work themselves out. I think that we'll see dual agency become a little bit more of
a topic and a little bit more of a discussion because you're going to have more buyers that
are going to be, if they're not able to look at a house with a buyer's agent without signing a
piece of paper, I think we're going to see more buyers that are just going directly to the listing
agent. That's going to create those opportunities for that dual agency. And so I think that's where
we'll start to see maybe some issues coming out of that. But yeah, I think, I think
unrepresented buyers are definitely going to be something that we'll see, see more of,
but at the same time, is that necessarily a bad thing? If you have experience now,
unrepresented first-time home buyers, I think we can all agree that that's probably a terrible idea.
Like that's a, that's a tough thing to get into for people to try and make it through a purchase
of a home on their own, unrepresented, I think is going to be really tough. But I just had,
we just had a listing that was a foreclosure property that the buyer that came in has bought
hundreds of houses. And I talked to him about, Hey, you know, can, if you need representation,
this is what the costs are. And he goes, I don't need representation. I've, I've got it taken care
of. Right. So, okay, cool. Go talk to, go talk to your attorney, have them draft up an offer,
or we can figure out the details and put something together and see what we can do.
And he did that, brought an offer, got it presented, got it put together. So now I'm
only representing the seller. There's no buy side commission on the buy side. He's, I mean,
cash purchase to, to get this thing done. So I think it's going to open up avenues for
experienced buyers to save on that commission side and kind of see if they're, you know, what they,
what they can do, knowing that they're comfortable doing it on their own.
So this was your listing and the buyer came to you first and you basically said, yeah,
you can work with me, but this is what I charged. So you was, you were going to charge them
outside of closing. Yeah. So we, the discussion that I had with him was so because it was my
listing I'm there in service of the seller to, to show the property. Right. So before we even
looked at the house, he's signing a notice of non-agency. And so I'm having that discussion
with him saying, Hey, I'm here representing the seller. I'm not representing you. Please don't
tell me anything about you and any, you know, any, any negotiating. And so we're just a full
disclosure of of agency at that point. And then we kind of discussed, well, if you wanted to
offer, this is what the cost would be on the, on the buy side. And he went, you know what?
I've done this a hundred times. I don't, I don't feel like I need an agent and we can,
we can do this without that cost. Yeah. Perfect. You're right. I think we can.
Yeah. Yeah. No, it's, it's, it's interesting. I think what, why do you think agents are freaking
out so much? I think it's just the unknown. I think that, well, I guess I think that's a
part of it. I think the agents that are freaking out the most are the ones who can't wrap their
head around how, how to structure deals moving forward. And if the seller isn't offering a
compensation, how do I still get paid? Okay. This, you know, you get paid from your buyer
in your agreement that you have with them. And then if your buyer needs help with that,
they can ask for help from the seller and try and work it into the, into the transaction that way.
Or they can pay you outside. So I think, I think structure is probably one of those that they just
kind of can't, can't see outside of what they've always done.
You know what I think? I think that they've been so dependent on buyer leads.
Their whole business is buyer leads that were handed to them by a big corporation or a broker
or a team leader. They have, they don't have the skills to go develop leads on their own.
And they certainly haven't been going after property owners to help them buy and sell and
which would, which would turn your business into more of a listing based business.
I mean, my answer was, I had an agent today asked me where I was on a webinar and they were like,
if I have a buyer who can barely afford the down payment, how am I supposed to explain my value
to the buyer? And I said, that's easy. Be the listing agent, right? If you've got the house
that they want to buy, there's the value in your hand, right? That's how you, that all the buyers
are going to come to you when you have listings. It like we've become, we've shifted so far,
the pendulum has swung so far this direction because of the way that it's set up. It's created
a bunch of this massive group of agents that's dependent on third parties for lead flow.
And it's like, if you shut that off or create a situation where that type of lead,
it's harder to get paid or you have to negotiate or have a harder conversation.
I think that's the real issue really at hand. And that, uh, the name of the game, right? We should
be screaming at agents. It's like buyers should be your, the bonuses of your business. The cherries
on top, not the core, not the core foundation of your business, right? The core foundation
should be listings. Yeah. Yeah. I can see, I could see a lot of, uh, brokerages looking at
buyer side agency as almost like a ancillary, uh, income and looking at that going, Hey,
you know, it's, it'd be great if we could have a lot of income from buyer agents,
but our business is listings. And that's really where this business was, was built off of real
estate is built off of selling advertising, marketing, selling real estate, not the buy side.
Yeah.
