Jim Cramer talks lessons to be learned from Donahoe's time as Nike CEO

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
Sep 22, 2024
Mad Money' host Jim Cramer looks at the CEO switch-up at Nike.
After Nike CEO John Donahoe announced his retirement last night, the stock poured today,
and for good reason. Donahoe never made sense as the CEO of a sneaker company, let alone the
largest sneaker company in the world. But he was a longstanding board member of Nike, who I'm sure
contributed a great deal in that role. Problem is, he was a consulting guy who made the switch
to tech about 20 years ago, coming to Nike by way of ServiceNow, PayPal, eBay, and originally
You see, that's not the resume of someone who should be entrusted with one of our national
icons, Nike. As we know from ShoeDog, the terrific autobiography by Nike founder Phil Knight,
you had to be a sneakerhead or an athlete who played or both in order to run this business.
Donahoe seemed to be devoid of these characteristics. He swapped, but they would
have been better off with someone modeled off the late, great Steve Prefontaine,
the legendary distance runner who was the first athlete to sign with Nike way back in the early
70s. Here's something ironic. When Donahoe took over ServiceNow, the cloud software firm in 2017,
outgoing CEO Frank Slootman raved about him, quote, John's extensive track record of creating
value, driving innovation, and scaling a large technology organization will be critical as we
continue to move ServiceNow up the enterprise value chain, end quote. It's true, he was a great
fit at that enterprise software company, but it turned out to be a bizarre, oddly truncated
launching pad on Donahoe's way to the top job of Nike in January 2020. Donahoe from ServiceNow
to Nike? But a few months later, COVID went on to swamp Nike's operations, making the company less
beholden to mall-based retailers like the 2,500 stores controlled by Foot Locker. Nike tended to
view these stores, frankly, as too downscale. They were anxious to premiumize the brand.
So why not go all in on direct consumer? Yes, digital direct sales with a tech guy who must
know it, right? He came from ServiceNow. Unfortunately, Donahoe did it too well.
When the pandemic ended, Nike had the finest direct-to-consumer technology around,
but people didn't want it as much. Two problems. One, after we beat COVID, people would turn to
the mall in droves. Nike had gone all in on digital, though, so during that period,
Wanholding, Decker's, which is a hocus, Adidas, even Vans took critical shelf space in these
mall-based stores. You started seeing new balance everywhere. At the same time,
we started hearing that Nike's innovation pipeline, at one time the envy of the industry,
was drying up. Donahoe was adopting old models, previous incarnations that had been successful,
and somehow he actually seemed to be proud of that. To which I say, what was Nike thinking?
How could they have squandered this great job on someone who understood how to improve corporate
onboarding and IT ticketing, but not how to sell brand new inventor shoes and not just the
recycled old ones? His skill sets had nothing to do with running Nike. Of course, that's the
fault of the board, not of the man. I personally wouldn't have picked someone who was so willing
to leave service now after only three years on the job. Bill McDermott placed Donahoe over there
and promptly took the stock from 240s to more than 930 today. Donahoe took over Nike and its
stock proceeded to do nothing, with his tenure seeing no increase in the stock price. That's
amazing when you remember that the S&P 500 is up over 80% during the same period. Near the end of
his tenure, he finally made amends with Footlocker and repaired a lot of the relationships he helped
destroy, but it didn't work in time. Nike's rivals may have caught up to it and in many cases
surpassed it. I think there's a real cautionary tale here. Luxman Narasimhan, late of Starbucks,
had many of the characteristics of Donahoe. He was known as a management consultant, not a
coffee person. Frankly, it would have been better to bring in a good hospitality executive or
someone who could help draw a heart at the top of a cup of Joe, you know, foam cappuccino. Again,
this stock reflected that fact until he finally got ousted, which is what really matters here. Memo
to the boards of directors out there, there are grades in this business. The stock market gives
them. Donahoe got a gentleman's C, but Nike deserved an A student. Now maybe they'll get one.
My advice, go with what Starbucks did. Find the equivalent of a Brian Nichol, late of Chipotle,
someone steeped in food and marketing who knows how to make things fresh and loved by all. I like
to say there's always a bull market somewhere and I promise you I'd find it just for you right here
at Money. I'm Jim Cramer. See you next time.
