The Early Reception of Juan Gris in America

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
#classical art#art#art conservation#What Is Art Conservation #Arts
Juan Gris's achievements and contributions to the advancement of modern art were extraordinary.
Over the course of a short career in France spanning about 17 years,
he went from being an ardent admirer of Paul Cézanne's work to becoming a cubist innovator,
with significant changes to his style every year or two. Unlike his contemporaries Pablo Picasso,
Georges Braque, and Fernand Léger, Gris is not well known in the United States today,
despite his many accomplishments. His works are well represented in American museums,
but monographic exhibitions of his paintings and collages are few and far between.
Why are some artists considered essential to tell the story of art in the early 20th century
and others less so? As with many other European modernists, Gris's work was embraced early on by
a small but dedicated group of individuals. His early reception in America is the story of
supportive galleries and dedicated collectors. When surveying the list of Gris paintings that
are owned by American museums today, the majority were donated by private collectors,
with institutions making purchases on very rare occasions.
This unusual fact prompts the following inquiry into Gris's early reception in America.
In order to learn more about how the arts community would have first discovered him,
how they would have known about him at all, and start to appreciate his many contributions to art
making in the first half of the 20th century. My talk today will focus on early gallery and
museum exhibitions, important art dealers, and key American collectors of Gris's work,
who generously shared their collections with the wider public during this early period.
The writer and collector Gertrude Stein was one of Gris's first American patrons,
although she lived most of her adult life in Paris. They first met in 1910, and four years later she
began to buy examples of his work from the dealer Daniel Henry Kahnweiler, with whom she shared an
affinity for the Spanish artist. The Gris holdings would have been on view in her Paris apartment,
where she hosted frequent gatherings for writers, artists, and other culturally interested guests.
So they would have been seen by many Americans and Europeans.
For example, the beautiful collage that we see there on the right, Flowers of 1914.
The friendship between Stein and Gris grew closer in the 1920s. She wrote a word poem about him in
1924, in which she described him as a perfect painter, and she was devastated by his death.
Gris's first monographic exhibition was held in Paris in 1919. It was the first of several
one-person gallery shows of his work held in the French capital during those early years.
His work began to appear in galleries in New York in the teens as well,
with early mentions of his inclusion at the Modern Gallery in 1916 and 1918,
and in the first annual exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists in New York in 1917.
Despite the fact that Gris was first on Picasso's list of suggested European artists
to be included in the famous Armory Show of 1913,
the exhibition which introduced audiences in New York, Boston, and Chicago to contemporary art,
the organizers did not choose him, and he did not show his work in New York until later in the
decade. This may not have been a terrible thing, because he was therefore not a victim of the
overwhelmingly negative response to cubism in that show from the critics and the general public
after the show and its immediate aftermath. Gris began to receive mentions in American art
magazines in the late teens, magazines we may have not heard of today, such as Arts and Decoration
and The Soil. In 1921, he was included in a group show of living artists in New York at
Wanamaker's department store, along with other post-Impressionist cubist and futurist artists.
Gris's first American solo gallery exhibition was held in New York in November of 1930.
Two years later, the Marie Harriman Gallery in New York hosted a one-man show, and we have the
brochure for it on the left of the screen, which featured over 20 oil paintings and 11 watercolors
and drawings, all from American collectors. Only one work at that point was in the Columbus Gallery
of Fine Arts, and we see a beautiful work from their collection there on the right from 1913.
That was the only museum work in the show. In his review for The New York Times, Edward Allen
Jewell was mainly positive about Gris, although he spent a major part of his review trying to
decipher how to define his artistic output. As time passed after Gris's death in 1927,
his importance as a pioneering modernist was seen in museums throughout the United States.
In the 1930s, his work was included in group exhibitions in both large city institutions
and college galleries in Chicago, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Hartford, Cambridge, Bennington,
Vermont, Toledo, and Poughkeepsie, among others. Gris's debut at the Museum of Modern Art
took place in 1933 in what was known as the Summer Show, which I think was often when
private collectors went out of town, they would lend things to the museum
to have things for people to see while they were in the city.
That exhibition was made up mostly of works from those kinds of private collections.
In 1936, the Museum of Modern Art organized Cubism in Abstract Art, the first major museum
exhibition in the United States that included Gris. It was a massive show which was comprised
of about 386 works and included examples of many schools of contemporary art all at one time.
It presented four paintings, one collage, and one sculpture by Gris. By comparison,
there were 29 works by Picasso, but only nine by Braque and five by Leger. And on the right,
we have the wonderful painting currently in the Dallas Museum of Art's collection,
Guitar and Pipe of 1913, one of the seminal works to really inspire this exhibition.
The extensive catalog for the Museum of Modern Art's show
included a very positive description of Gris's collages and canvases.
For example, the catalog wrote, during the early years of synthetic Cubism,
Gris held his own even against Picasso and Braque, achieving a series of collages and painted
compositions unsurpassed in precision and refinement. Although the more conservative
art critics did not wildly praise the show, it did make a major statement about the future of
European modernism in the United States. Two more monographic exhibitions and galleries were held
in the 40s in New York, including two important ones at the Buchholz Gallery, which was headed
by Kurt Valentin, one of Gris's great admirers and promoters. Valentin played a major role in
placing works by the Spanish Cubist artists in private collections throughout the United States
in the 1940s and early 50s. Valentin first showed his work in a group show in 1940, but the first
monographic show was in 44, where he borrowed works from private collectors and art dealers.
And a couple of things from museums, the Albright Art Gallery, now known as the Albright Knox Art
Gallery, as did MoMA and the Smith College Museum of Art in Northampton, Massachusetts.
And we see the brochure for the catalog on the left from 1944, as well as one of the works from
the Smith College collection. The Buchholz Gallery organized two more Gris exhibitions,
one in 1947, the next in 1950. In the catalog for the 1947 show, Valentin stated that most of
the paintings in the show had not been seen in the United States before, and that MoMA and the Smith
College Museum were the only museum lenders. Thanks to Valentin's determination and support,
the Buchholz Gallery played a prominent part in furthering Gris's reputation in both the United
States and America. Now, back to Smith. It's a very interesting thing. The first works by Gris to
enter a museum collection were five early still lives donated to the Smith College Museum of Art
in 1921 and 1923 by the art dealer Joseph Brummer. We don't know why he chose Smith.
We have looked into it, and there was no relationship between Brummer and the college
that we're aware of. But it would have been considered a very unusual gift to a college
museum at a time when modern art was not widely appreciated or understood. These works ended up
being important for shows for decades. People always would go to them to borrow them, which
was wonderful. For example, the museum borrowed them in the 30s. The Buchholz Gallery borrowed
them as we discussed earlier, and it was really so rare and they were so accessible that it really
allowed a lot of people to be introduced to his work in this unusual way. The many private
collectors that were buying works at his time, many of them were buying them in Paris. When they
would go for their jaunts over there, they would be introduced to them, although once World War II,
people stopped traveling so much, and so New York galleries started to show and have his works
for sale as well. Although he chose not to donate many of his more than 25,000 works of art to a
museum, the American collector John Quinn purchased at least six works by Gris of the highest quality
during these early years, including the one that we see on the left, Ace of Clubs and Four Diamonds,
now owned by the National Gallery of Art. The same way, the Pittsburgh collector G. David Thompson
also had a remarkable modern art collection, including 12 works by Gris. Thompson had very
much wanted to create a museum in his hometown of Pittsburgh dedicated to his collection,
but it was clear that people in town were not interested in supporting modern art at that time,
so he ended up selling most of his collection, but Mandolin and Fruit Dish that we see here on
the right, now in the Museum of Fine Arts Boston, had once been owned by him. Another important
person was Albert Eugene Gallatin. He played an essential role in furthering Gris's reputation in
the United States as both a major collector and the director of the first public institution of
modern art in New York, which opened in 1927. He was in a unique position to promote and provide
access to artists that weren't available anywhere else, and provided also an opportunity for local
artists to see works by Cubists and other modern painters close to home, and they even offered
classes. This desire to educate the public prompted the gallery to open, which was originally known as
the Gallery of Living Art, opened in 1927 at New York University, where Gallatin was a trustee,
and he took over some extra space and started to install his own collection, and it ended up
becoming a very major place to see things. He published a lot, published a lot of catalogs,
and wrote a lot about the artists that he liked so much. In 1936, after having lots of positive
response, he changed the name of the institution from the Gallery of Living Art to the Museum
of Living Art, and pointed out how Gris, in particular, and Spanish artists more broadly
were men of burning genius that really needed to be appreciated. And here we see a beautiful
collage from the Gallatin collection on the left, as well as its installation in one of the Gallery
of Living Art exhibitions at NYU back in the 30s. He continued to support Cubism even up until
the 40s and was really very interested in showing their work and introducing them to a larger public
as more and more people came to his gallery. However, in 1942, the university informed Gallatin
that they needed the space where the museum was housed for their library, and he was forced to
leave and close the museum. After much consideration, Gallatin decided to loan his collection of about
170 works to the Philadelphia Museum of Art just down south, with the understanding that if the
holdings were still on loan upon his death, they would be acquired by the PMA where they are today.
Gallatin also played a major role in suggesting that wonderful works by Gris and others owned
by Walter and Louise Ahrensberg also come to the PMA, to the Philadelphia Museum of Art,
where the two collections could come together to create an unrivaled view of modern art.
The Ahrensbergs had begun collecting modern art after seeing the Armory Show in 1913,
became friends and patrons with some of the most important artists of the day, and in 1938,
they bought five wonderful works by Gris, and three of them are in the exhibition on Gris
that we are celebrating today. In the 40s, the Ahrensbergs started to look for a museum that
would take their work, and after seeing the reception to the Gallatin collection with his
suggestion, they decided to give their collection to the PMA in Philadelphia in 1950. And in 1954,
a suite of galleries dedicated to Gallatin's collection opened, followed by another suite
of galleries to the Ahrensberg collection later that year in October, and within those two
collections combined, the PMA has become a center for modern art with one of the strongest and
largest, most comprehensive collections of Gris's work in the United States.
Duncan Phillips, who had founded the Phillips Memorial Art Gallery, today known as the Phillips
Collection, in 1921 in Washington, D.C., which was the first museum of modern art, bought his first
work by Gris that we see here on the left, Abstraction from 1915 in 1930, which was a very
small but colorful and beautiful work that really shows his interest in abstraction and synthesis.
About 20 years later, he bought Still Life with Newspaper that we see here on the right,
from a very different period of his career when he was looking back to old master paintings and
artists that he knew from his time in Madrid. That painting on the right had been seen early
on in the 1930s in a big exhibition at the Brooklyn Museum, so it really does a great
job in showing his career with these two works. The Museum of Modern Art began acquiring works by
Gris in the 30s and 40s. The work here on the right is Guitar and Pipe that I mentioned before
from the Dallas Museum of Art. It had originally been owned by the Museum of Modern Art
and had been sold in the 60s. Luckily for all of us, it was soon acquired by Eugene
and Margaret McDermott, wonderful collectors of Impressionist and modern art, who donated it
to the DMA in 1998. Guggenheim also, in the 40s, started to collect works by Gris.
So in the 40s, things really started to pick up with museum collections, as well as the National
Gallery of Art opened in 1941, and a major gift of modernism, including Gris' work, was given to
Yale University also that same year. So into the 40s, Gris' reputation really started to grow in
the United States, at least in museum collections. Both the Sidney Art Museum of St. Louis,
today known as the St. Louis Art Museum, and the Washington University Museum in St. Louis,
now known as the Mildred Lane Kemper Art Museum, both purchased works by Gris in the 40s,
which was very unusual. At that time, most museums were only acquiring works by him as gifts,
and these two purchases made some important statements about the institution's need,
interest in modern art and our wonderful works by him and wonderful additions to the show.
Sadie Adler May, a collector born in Baltimore, purchased two important works by Gris,
one in 1938 and one in 1940. Unlike the better-known Baltimore collectors and sisters,
Claribel and Etta Cohn, who favored works by Henri Matisse and Pablo Picasso and displayed
their holdings in their Baltimore apartments, Sadie May saw her role as one who's an advocate
for the Baltimore Museum of Art, often sending her acquisitions directly to the museum
after purchase, directly from the galleries. May really wanted to make sure that the BMA's
collection wasn't so heavily focused on Matisse and Picasso, so she started to look for artists
like Gris, like Mondrian, artists that were more interested in abstraction to really round out the
collection of the BMA, as well as being really interested in surrealism. And then these two
works on the left, Bottle and Glass from 1918, is a prime example of Gris in his mid-career,
just as his interest in little dots of paint and pointillism had started to fade,
and he started to become fascinated with interlocking planes and a more muted palette.
She purchased that in 1938, 1940 she bought the Painter's Window, one of Gris's last works,
a really wonderful work that shows all of the still-life motifs that he had used up to that
point in his career, the musical instruments, the cards, the fruit set before a window,
but one of the few to include the artist's palette to show his tools, and somehow
seems to be a reflection of his own biography in the way he's added it to this particular
painting. The Cincinnati Art Museum hosted Gris's first monographic show in 1948,
more than 20 years after his death, and here we see the brochure and a couple of
fabulous paintings that were in the exhibition. It featured 64 works,
and about a third of them were already owned by museums, and two-thirds were owned by private
collectors. In the introduction to the catalogue, even back then, there was conversation about why
Gris wasn't better known, and the author talked about perhaps it was because Gris was always used
in books to talk about the tenets of Cubism, and nobody really looked to see the wonderful
things he was making. Also, he had such a short career that perhaps his colleagues Picasso and
Braque had gone on to other styles, and it was Gris who stuck with Cubism for a long time,
and perhaps the short career and the commitment to Cubism may have made him, for some reason,
less appealing, but he certainly didn't agree. Ten years later, in 1958, the Museum of Modern Art
organized a major Wanderee retrospective, which traveled to the Minneapolis Institute of Arts,
the San Francisco Museum of Art, and the Los Angeles County Museum. It featured 63 paintings
and 27 gouaches, drawings and prints from his short career. Again, many more works in the
exhibition were owned by private collectors than by museums. In doing research, I found there was
a list, preparing for this show, of 42 collectors in the United States that owned a Gris work.
Only 13 were museums for the preparations for this show, so that gives you a sense of
how it took a long time for museums to kind of catch up and understand his brilliance.
In the catalogue, the curator discussed the originality of Gris's color, which, of course,
is what he's so well known for, and wondered if maybe some of his lack of familiarity with the
general public had to do with his reproductions were often in black and white, and, you know,
which is something that today is so funny to think about, how we're so used to seeing images in color
and quickly on our devices. Back in those days, you were really reliant on black and white imagery
to learn about new artists. The exhibition was very well received, and the New York Times
art critic wrote something that, quote, that Gris's work warrants his inclusion in the first
rank of Cubist artists. Despite this great interest in Gris during the run of the MoMA show
and the broad recognition of his importance visible in museum exhibitions and collections
around the country, it took 25 years for the next major monographic museum show to be mounted in
the United States. In 1983, the University of California Art Museum at Berkeley organized a
major retrospective, which also traveled to the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C.,
and to the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum in New York. It featured more than 90 works
and provided a fresh view of Gris, you know, as one of the most essential members of the Cubist
circle. John Russell wrote in a review, quote, in the New York Times, quote,
a great Gris stays with us forever. It stands for an imaginative energy, a multiplicity of lucid
statement, and an apparently limitless invention. It also stands for a depth and strength of
color that are, on the whole, excluded from Cubism. Where Picasso and Braque in the heroic
years worked by taking color out, Gris worked by putting it in, unquote. Unlike his colleagues,
Picasso, Braque, and Leger, Gris's work has not been explored by theme or examined in slices or
chapters of his output until now. And more recent years, his work has been enthusiastically
collected by the New York businessman and philanthropist Leonard Lauder, who has given
either his promise gifts or finished gifts to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and has created the
Leonard Lauder Research Center for Modern Art, where scholars and curators look at Gris and his
circle for exhibitions and papers. His extraordinary contribution to the recognition
understanding of Gris's achievements will continue for generations to come. As Daniel Henry Kahnweiler
wrote about his friend Juan Gris in 1948, more than 20 years after his death, quote, time will, I am
sure, increase more and more the reputation of this modest genius who received so little
encouragement during his all but too short life, but who never despaired, unquote. Thank you very much.
