C'est un procès qui choque la France et le monde par l'horreur des faits. À Avignon, le procès des viols de Mazan se poursuit, où Dominique Pelicot est accusé d'avoir drogué son épouse pour abuser d'elle et la faire à nouveau violer par des dizaines d'hommes. Cinquante d'entre eux sont jugés, dont 35 nient les faits. Cette semaine, la défense a pris un tour dérangeant, avec des débats malsains. « Jusqu'où peut-on aller ? Assez loin pour qu'une femme se sente accusée plutôt que victime ?», écrivait Le Parisien.
Notre invitée ce matin pour en parler est Violaine De Filippis Abate, avocate et co-fondatrice du collectif Action juridique féministe, autrice de l'ouvrage "Classées sans suites. Les femmes victimes de violence face à la justice", aux éditions Payot. #mazan#pelicot#viols
It's a trial that shocks and disturbs a whole country, France and the whole world.
Which shocks and disturbs by the horror of the facts judged, but also, no doubt, because it tempts us a mirror.
In Avignon, in the south of France, the trial of the rapes of Mazan continued this week.
That of a man, Dominique Pellicot, accused of having drugged his wife to rape her and have her raped by dozens of men.
50 of them identified appear on his side, of which 35 deny their guilt.
And this week, the court has become the theater of a defense that sometimes leads to debauchery and unhealthy debates.
« How far can we go? » wrote the Parisian on Thursday, evoking the defense of the accused.
Surely far enough for a woman to have the feeling of being accused rather than victim, continued the daily.
Our guest this morning to talk about it, Violaine de Philippis Abbatt.
Hello, and thank you for being with us on RFI.
You are a lawyer, co-founder of the feminist legal action collective.
« J'ai l'impression que la coupable, c'est moi » said Gisèle Pellicot this week,
saying she was humiliated while the defense lawyers treated her to the court of intimate photos,
questioning her unconsciousness during the facts,
questioning her about a possible tendency to exhibitionism or libertinism.
What did you feel following this trial this week?
I think it raises a lot of points.
We can already mention two that you just raised.
The first is the rights of defense.
Of course, the rights of defense must continue to exist.
It is fundamental in our state of law.
On the other hand, it raises the question of their exercise and their modality of exercise.
The second thing is that we are also witnessing today the trial of the culture of rape through Gisèle Pellicot,
since in the end we find all the stereotypes, the hondi around what should be,
I put quotation marks for those who do not see me, a real rape with quotation marks,
or a real victim with quotation marks,
with this idea that in the end we would be more raped in a street by a stranger in the evening,
while statistically it is false.
And I think we will never repeat that enough.
Women are mostly raped by a loved one,
and in most cases it is their spouse or their ex-spouse.
It is an opportunity to change minds,
to bring down the myths about the figure of the rapist
when we see the varied profiles of the co-accused,
of the normal men,
it shows us that we need to think more about rape in what it has of daily, of intimate, of ordinary, if I dare say.
Yes, and to sensitize from an early age to the question of consent.
Today, for about 20 years in France,
we are supposed to have three sessions of education on affective and sexual life
in all school establishments, from high school to high school.
So for your listeners who have children,
I think you can ask them the question,
do they have these sessions?
And you as a parent, did you get this information at the beginning of the year
during the parent-student meeting?
In most cases, the answer is no.
And this is the reason why one of the feminist associations,
the Planning Familiale,
had initiated an action against the state about two years ago.
So I can't tell you where the trial is,
but we can see that we have a problem of society on rape,
and as long as we don't talk about the consent of children,
we will continue to condition individuals,
to assault women and sometimes even rape them.
So I would like to go back to the course of the trial this week.
We were talking about the defense lawyers.
We saw some of them go very far to defend their client,
who claims for the most part that he was not aware of raping Gisele Pellicot,
that he even thought she was an accomplice to the acts of his ex-husband.
Earlier in the trial, one of his lawyers even said,
there is rape and rape.
We also saw a defense lawyer
comment often in a sarcastic way,
even move the trial on his Instagram account.
You as a lawyer, what do you want to say to your colleagues?
I don't recognize myself at all in their professional practice,
in the practice they do.
Like many lawyers,
I have the feeling that my profession sends a bad image
and that our courts do not do what is necessary.
Even if at the heart of these courts there are very good people,
it doesn't move enough.
I think that the defense,
which is developed by one of my colleagues,
who defends several accused,
the one who said there is rape and rape,
is also legally possible for the following reason.
It is that in our penal code today,
there is unfortunately no presumption of intention to rape
when a woman is unconscious.
I think it should question the legislator or the legislator,
because we often say the legislator,
but there are also women in Parliament, fortunately,
to reform the definition of rape,
to question the insertion of the notion of consent, of course,
but also to foresee a presumption of intention to rape
when a person is unconscious.
Since today, if we hear this development at the bar,
it is because there is no presumption of intentionality.
So the accused are not presumed to have known
that they were raping, which seems completely crazy.
We could still foresee in our penal code
that when rape is perpetrated by seizure,
by seizure, attention, I put it in constraint,
since there is no seizure in the penal code,
there is the word constraint.
So a rape by moral constraint,
so seizure or chemical submission,
and there we will enter the context of the surprise
or physical constraint.
The two legal elements, rape by surprise
or rape by physical constraint,
allow the chemical submission to enter,
according to the jurisprudence.
In short, we could foresee that in these cases,
the intention to rape is presumed,
since the person is unconscious.
What you are saying is that the law is not explicit enough,
that it actually foresees the definition of rape
in a case like that of Gisèle Pellicot,
but that it does not do it in a fairly precise way,
that it allows the defense lawyers
to immerse themselves in the voids.
Yes, exactly, that's exactly it.
That is to say, if it was clearer,
in the law we could not plead something
that is against the rules, that is, against the law.
As long as the law does not say anything,
we can always, I say we, of course not me,
but my defense lawyers can always, in quotation marks,
try to, and I hate this word,
but play on the voids of the law.
And there, recently, there was a stop
of the Cassation Court, very interesting,
which was published in a legal journal,
which explicitly says that
the Cassation Court considers that
when a person is unconscious,
she cannot give her consent.
And so, this stop falls, in quotation marks, well,
since it will surely influence
the court in the trial of Gisèle Pellicot,
since even if the Cassation Court
does not make the law,
it gives an interpretation of the jurisprudence
and it is she who uniforms it.
So the judges still tend to respect these positions.
Gisèle Pellicot asked that this trial
be public, so that shame
can change sides, that's what she said.
Finally, the court decided at the end of the week
that the public and the journalists
should come out during projections,
videos, rapes,
key element of the investigation,
found on the computer of Dominique Pellicot.
For you, is it a step back from the judges,
in the face of the co-accused who asked for it?
In any case, it raises real questions,
I mean, I can hear the argument
which is to say that
there must be calm in the audience room
and that it is still something
both intimate
and public.
That's the whole problem, because on the
public side, it is certain that
it would have been interesting to allow the journalists
to be able to relay precisely
the portraits of these accused men,
since it shows, as you said,
the fact that anyone, in reality,
can have assaulted a woman
or raped a woman.
It's not because we look nice,
nice, well inserted, respected,
that we have a good job,
that we are not an aggressor or a rapist.
It does not mean that anyone
would go so far as to perpetrate
collective rapes
in these conditions.
We are really on the high level
of the continuum of violence.
However, if we go down
in the gradation of the continuum of violence,
it means that yes, any man can be sexist,
at least at the level of ordinary sexism,
and that's how it starts.
It does not mean that it still climbs happily
to the fact that we are witnessing today
in the Pelico trial, but it means
that we must have an awareness of society
about the fact that ordinary sexism
is anchored in our daily lives,
and that as a man and as a woman,
we allow this sexism to exist.
Hence the importance of a public trial
that is widely documented.
I understand that the victims do not file a complaint,
said Gisèle Pelico,
when she said this week
she felt humiliated by the questions
asked to her. Is there a risk
that the turn that this trial takes
actually encourages some victims to remain silent?
Yes, because
in fact, it actually scares justice today.
The conditions in which
victims come to file a complaint
are still not good,
even if it still tends
to improve. It is true that I noticed
on the ground that there is still an improvement.
For example, ten days ago,
I accompanied a woman
in her filing of a complaint, then in her future trial,
for facts.
In fact, her ex-husband took
videos of her during their intimate relationship
to her. Well, the preliminary investigation
was launched in less than a week
by Le Parquet.
That,
apart from the media files, I had not seen it yet.
So we see that it is improving. But you are right,
there are only 6% of women who file a complaint,
and that is a statistic from the National Observatory
of Violence Against Women.
Violaine de Philippe Issabat,
thank you very much. I remind you that you are a lawyer,
co-founder of the
Feminist Juridical Action Collective,
and you are also the author of the book
Classées sans suite, les femmes victimes de violences
face à la justice. Have a very good day.
Thank you. And see you soon on RFI.
It is almost 6.30 am,
in universal time, and the info continues on Radio du Monde.