Juan Gris y María Blanchard: Una emancipación cubista

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
#classical art#art#art conservation#What Is Art Conservation #Arts
Cubismo en color, Los bodegones de Juan Gris,
is the proposal of the Museum of Dallas,
in alliance with the Museum of Baltimore,
for the 2021 season.
It is a brave and risky proposal.
The pandemic has changed our lives.
Many artistic projects have been left in the dark
and we will never know if it will be possible to recover them
or make them again.
The encounter with Juan Gris is an encounter
that is inscribed in a long tradition of recovering
the life of the Spanish cubist painter
by North American museums.
Since Gertrude Stein claimed the figure of Juan Gris
as an authentic cubist,
Juan Gris has always been an object of attention
by collectors, art critics
and by North American museums,
making his figure still alive,
as this new project demonstrates this year.
I want to thank Stacy Lizotte and Nicole Mayers
for inviting me to participate
in the educational and academic program
that goes hand in hand with the exhibition.
In it, I have been required for a special topic,
special in the life of Juan Gris
and special for myself as a researcher,
the relationship between Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard.
My name is Eugenio Carmona,
I am a history teacher at the University of Malaga
and I have dedicated a large part of my life
as a researcher and academic
to the study of cubism
and the study of the works of Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard.
I want to remember now the project that, in 2017,
I carried out together with Lourdes Moreno
at the Museo Carmen Thyssen in Malaga,
the moment when, for the first time,
the works of Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard
appeared together
in a project that aimed to make
a visualisation as complete as possible
of the cubist space in the years
of the First World War.
I also want to remember the attempt
and the achievement of the Fundación Telefónica
in bringing together a cubist collection
around Juan Gris,
which is now on display in the galleries
of the Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía.
Today I speak to you from the technological centre
of the image of the University of Malaga.
I want to thank Vicente Martínez,
and Mario Ferrer.
Juan Gris said that cubism was a mental state,
a state of the spirit, we could say.
Jack Lipchitz said that cubism
was a powerful moment of aesthetic emancipation.
The word emancipation now has
a special meaning for us.
We speak of Juan Gris' cubism,
of Maria Blanchard as historical emancipation,
of the aesthetic values,
but we also speak, when speaking of Maria Blanchard,
of another type of emancipation,
that of the female artists
who decide to place themselves
in the scene of creation
in a full and uncut way.
To begin with, we have a photo.
We don't know who took this photograph,
but we do know that it was probably taken
at the beginning of the autumn of 1918.
It was taken in Bolliers-Prelors,
a town in the centre of France,
near the valley of the Loire.
The First World War was still going on.
The German army was threatening Paris.
The Great Bertha was shooting
at the Parisian citizens.
Many decided to take refuge elsewhere.
Juan Gris and his wife Josette
found in this town a refuge
to which they invited their friends.
With them were, as we see in the photograph,
the Chilean poet Vicente Huidobro
and the sculptor Jacques Lipchitz.
But other people are missing in this photograph.
It is worth mentioning the presence of Josette Gris,
of Bert Lipchitz and of Huidobro's wife,
but the real absent ones are
Jean Mestandier and, above all, Maria Blanchard.
We have a few photographs of Maria Blanchard,
some caricatures,
and it is difficult to know
the aspect of her physiognomy.
Whenever we talk about Maria Blanchard,
the artist's physiognomy
appears in the foreground as something
that must be commented on.
Perhaps if Maria Blanchard
had been a male artist,
this would not be the subject of comment.
Maria Blanchard had a birth problem
that made her be worth
the use of the word deformed.
However, this did not prevent her
from developing her life
with absolute interest
and with an enormous dedication to her work.
But the meeting of all these artists in Bolière
meant two things.
First, that between Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard
there was a special relationship,
and we know this from Gris's letters
and from another statement of Blanchard's
that they had been together for many months
and worked together.
We also know this because we can deduce
that this meeting in Bolière
was either the manifestation
or the meeting point
of something that had been taking place
since approximately the end of 1915
or the beginning of 1916.
The existence of a second cubism.
A second cubism that had Juan Gris,
Lipchitz, Blanchard and James Angier
as the main protagonists,
although not the only ones.
A second cubism that differentiated
the first part,
and we will return to this a little later,
by the search for the meeting
between abstraction and figuration
and by the structuring of the works
around dynamic sensations
of movement and diversity.
Maria Blanchard, in this context,
used her own poetry
and her own path
to reach this cubism.
Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard
had a different history
in the cubist movement.
Juan Gris is one of the founders,
one of the four essential cubists.
Juan Gris knew cubism
from its initial development
by Picasso and Braque in the Bateau-Lavoir.
Then he related to the Salon cubists,
to the group of Piteaux
and to the Dor section.
Maria Blanchard, however,
started later.
She met cubism through Diego Rivera
and, however, soon,
in the years of the First World War,
as I said before,
around 1915 or 1916,
she contacted Juan Gris,
probably in 1916,
and she enrolled and participated
in this new way of understanding cubism.
A brief comment
on a work
of Maria Blanchard's first moment
in this new situation of cubism
can help us to know
the foundation of her poetry.
The representation has been catalogued
as Juana de Arco,
perhaps because of the cap
that the figure has on its head.
However, we clearly see
that it is a girl
who is playing with a hoop
and who has in her hand
a toothpick
with which to move the hoop.
Maria Blanchard
structures the composition
by abstract planes
that, separated from each other,
would not have any figurative capacity,
but that, together and contrasted,
appear, showing us
the figure we comment on.
But it also gives us
a sense of ambience
in a clear way.
She places something similar
to scraps of paper
painted on the walls
so that we know
that we are inside
a bourgeois house.
Therefore, Maria Blanchard
unites the abstract sense of cubism
with the survival
or re-reading of collage,
with which we could call
a post-collage situation
in the cubist experience.
To this she adds
the presence of some letters,
as was done in the first
visual verbal cubism,
but with a clear message
Portate bien
would be the translation
into Spanish
of this message.
Maria Blanchard,
through a work
in which form is valued above all
and in which she recalls
the plastic use of collage,
is evoking her own childhood
and is evoking
the advice of her parents.
Portate bien
In other words,
cubism for her
is a double experience.
She searches for the pure form
and, at the same time,
evokes her personal biography
in a certain social
and cultural context.
For Maria Blanchard
the presence of Gino Severini
and André Lot
were also important.
With them she also maintained
a privileged relationship of treatment
and much of what we know
of them is thanks to
what Severini and Lot
commented on in their writings.
This cubism
to which we are referring
is a cubism that articulates
in a diverse,
peculiar way
and that finds in Picasso,
effectively, as always,
a first point of realization.
But, as we see,
in the face of the formalist emphasis
of the three artists
that interest us,
Gris, Lipschitz and Blanchard,
Picasso,
in this figure of Arlequin
that, for him,
is a premonitory
of a new situation,
introduces factors
like this smile
or like this profile
that ceases to exist
in the canvas in white,
introduces factors,
as I said,
of a psychological nature
that moves away
his search
of what these painters
of the second cubism
will want to decipher.
Therefore,
it will be in them
where the possibilities
of cubism survive,
especially
in the work of Juan Gris,
who, as we see,
makes compositions
in which the abstract emphasis
is powerful
and in which the memory
of the painted wood
acts as a plastic component
and not so much
as a disruption
of the surface of the canvas.
This Juan Gris,
who has sometimes been treated
as a classic painter,
especially by Daniela Rikanweiler,
the theoretical merchant of cubism,
was a different Juan Gris,
but we see
that the foundation
of his position in these years
is found in works like this
and that it is the same foundation
that we have specified before
for Maria Blanchard.
A cubism
based on the abstract form
is a painting that wants
to maintain the figurative reference
and that knows
about the existence of collage
and that begins
a post-collage recovery
imbricating the new sense
of artisticity
that collage has meant
in a new type of painting.
This is why,
being aware
that we are facing
a new type of painting,
I want to talk
about cubism
as emancipation
in the work
of Juan Gris and Maria Blanchard.
But to talk about it,
first we have to ask ourselves
why the figure of Juan Gris
and not the figure
of Maria Blanchard.
What is the factor
that has intervened
in this dissociation of paths
that, nevertheless,
were so united
from the first moment?
There are many historical reasons
that we know
that existed
around female segregation,
but there is another reason
that I would like to comment on now.
I believe that the process
of idealisation
of the figure
and the work of Juan Gris
that Daniel-Henri Campbailer
was not favourable
to Maria Blanchard,
but quite the opposite.
Daniel-Henri Campbailer
is a central figure
of modern art.
He is an admirable figure.
Not only was he able
to change the meaning
of the artistic market,
the task of the merchant,
but he was also
a lucid theorist
and he was able to place
the artistic development
in a plane
that until then
no other merchant
or any other art theorist
knew how to place.
But he was also,
let's call it that way,
a paternal figure.
And as such a paternal figure
that founds a world,
gives a name
and creates a narrative
in which not everyone
receives a denomination
and a narrative
in which not everyone fits.
Daniel-Henri Campbailer,
in 1946,
just after the end
of the Second World War,
appeared with an extensive,
prolific monograph
extraordinarily well-written
and well-documented
about Juan Gris.
In a world that was rebuilt
after the Second World War,
Campbailer placed Juan Gris
as a reference painter.
And not only that,
but his monograph
on Juan Gris
served to study,
from then on,
Cubism and its trajectory.
However,
in a certain chapter
of this book,
when Campbailer
talks about the years
that interest us
and the years
in which Juan Gris
and Maria Blanchard
were in a relationship,
some of his comments
Campbailer says
that in August 1914,
Picasso,
when he went to say goodbye
to Braque and Derain
to the train,
because they were both
going to war,
separated from them
and never saw them again
and that the paths
of each one
were divided.
Each one followed
its own trajectory.
But a new
cubist medium was created
and around Juan Gris
were grouped
Gertrude Stein,
Maudit and Reinald,
Pierre Reverdy,
Lipschitz
and the Chilean poet
Vicente Huidobro.
That is,
Campbailer makes it clear
that Gris is the leader
of a new moment
of cubism.
But he adds
This was not the opinion
that Juan Gris had
of Maria Blanchard.
It is Campbailer's opinion,
the opinion that remained
in the artistic literature.
If we review Gris's letters
and his writings,
we realize that,
for him,
Maria Blanchard
was always a close
and collaborative figure.
Even in some of his letters,
Gris accepts,
because Blanchard
is his friend
and admires her,
the return of Maria Blanchard
to figurative painting
of a realistic nature.
But no derogatory comment
about her,
no moment Gris says
that Maria Blanchard
is around him
as an imitator.
He always treats her
as equals,
as probably happened
in the historical moment
that interests us.
The idealization
that Campbailer made
of Juan Gris
comes from the years
of the First World War.
We have to jump back now.
Campbailer had,
during the years
of the First World War,
to exile in Switzerland.
He lost his gallery,
he lost his works,
but as soon as the First World War
he tried to recover.
Before, during the years
of the First World War,
he had seen an exhibition
of cubist painters
organized by Léon Rosenberg
and there he had realized
that Gris's art,
which he had not taken into account
until then,
had made a great evolution.
And in his letters
to Karl Einstein,
he writes,
clearly,
tentatively,
When I left,
I left a painter
I was interested in.
When I returned,
I met a master.
From here,
he begins to reflect
on Gris's work.
And not only that,
in his letters to Einstein
we see that Campbailer
begins to think
all cubism
according to Gris.
He writes in 1922
that Gris's art
is an art of qualified forms,
which is part of the abstraction
to find qualified forms
through which
the figuration is recovered.
And he writes that he thinks
that in Gris's art,
with 1917 as a date of change,
there are two ways
to understand cubism.
One is called analytical cubism
and the other is called
synthetic cubism.
In his monograph
of 1929 on Gris,
Campbailer insists on his theses
on Gris and the history of cubism.
An articulation of the history of cubism
that will be collected and consecrated
by Alfred Barr
in his first great exhibition
at the MoMA
and that from then on
will be used to speak of cubism,
although Barr did not lend
a special interest
to Gris's work in his proposal.
But for Campbailer,
Gris had been
the most tender man
and the noblest artist
that had ever existed on earth.
And based on this,
he decided on a sublimation
that made him the protagonist
of an entire aesthetic experience.
Campbailer forgot much
of the context in which Gris moved.
In his book,
he talks about what he calls
the Juan Gris method,
which consists,
as we have already indicated
and can be seen well
in this work
by the Rena Sofía Museum,
which here he names The Violin,
in which the artist
paints this part of abstract forms
on canvas,
which he qualifies
until he finds
a final figurative form.
We usually think
that it is the opposite.
We usually think
that the cubist painter
breaks down the figures
and articulates them on the fabric.
And yet it is not like that.
Campbailer explains to us
that Gris starts from abstract equations
that become recognizable forms.
What Campbailer forgot,
which says that this Gris method
was produced in March 1920
and that he commented on it
in a conversation
he wrote on March 13,
but what I say
that Campbailer forgot
is that Jacques Lipchitz
had developed
exactly the same method.
In the magazine L'Esprit Nouveau
or in the magazine Action,
in his statements
to Blaisendrart or Paul Dermé,
Lipchitz says that his sculpture
comes from the same way
that Gris's painting
came from.
Lipchitz says
that he elaborates abstract volumes
that he modifies
towards an encounter
with abstraction.
Lipchitz's poetry
and Gris's poetry, therefore,
would be the same.
While Campbailer affirms
that the whole second cubism
was made around Gris,
Lipchitz affirms
that it was a collective experience.
And in that collective experience
Lipchitz always remembers
the determining role
of Maria Blanchard.
A determining role
that is also remembered
by Gino Severini
in his memoirs.
When Gino Severini
recalls the moment
of this second cubism,
he speaks of Maria Blanchard
as a demanding woman.
He tells anecdotes
such as that she lived
from meal to day
a fillet and a glass of milk
and that she had no more,
that her study was very sober,
and that, however,
in the theoretical discussions
of the group,
she always gave her opinion
and, as it is said
in common Spanish,
she sat at the head
of what the new cubism
had to be.
Severini says
that the sessions
began in the afternoon
and at night
in some cafeterias
in Montparnasse,
but that later
the day ended
in Maria Blanchard's study
where everyone discussed
what they should do
with cubism and painting.
Therefore, for Lipschitz
and for Severini,
Maria Blanchard's role
was decisive.
And not only that,
if they accused her of anything,
it was that she was too rigorous.
It was not understood
that a woman
did not want a painting
to please the senses,
but that it had a strong
pictorial sense
that acted in the history
of modern art
with a definite
and exact precision.
The same memory
that Lipschitz and Severini
had of Maria Blanchard
had someone
very important for us,
the poet and writer
Ramón Gómez de la Serna.
Probably Ramón Gómez de la Serna
is not well known
outside the Spanish borders,
but nevertheless,
for Spanish literature
of the 20th century
he is a maximum
and indisputable reference.
Ramón Gómez de la Serna
organized in Madrid
the first exhibition
of Cubist art,
which he called
the Integral Painters' Exhibition.
Ramón Gómez de la Serna
wrote one of the first monographs
about Picasso
and in his book Ismos,
one of the first summaries
about modern art.
Preparing some elements
with which to illustrate
and improve the catalogue
of the Cubist collection
of Telefónica
when that project was produced,
Alicia Carabias and I
found some unpublished documents
of Ramón Gómez de la Serna
in the National Library of Spain.
We were surprised
that there were unpublished documents
of Ramón Gómez de la Serna,
but that's how it was,
and one of them
was especially valuable
for us to find them
and to solve the criteria
around this period
of the history of Cubism.
Ramón Gómez de la Serna,
whom you see here
painted in Cubist style
by Diego Rivera,
visited Paris
during the years
of the First World War
and when he visited Paris
in those years
he interviewed
and visited the studies
of Gris, Lipchitz and Maria Blanchard.
First of all,
Ramón Gómez de la Serna
described how
the Gris method
that Kahnweiler
had synthesized
was true.
Gómez de la Serna tells us
how Gris started
with a cartabón squad
of abstract shapes
on paper or cloth
and that later
these shapes
were derived from figurative shapes.
But second of all,
and in this of Kahnweiler's history,
Ramón Gómez de la Serna
tells us
that the whole creative process
of this Cubism
arose from the joint work
of Gris, Lipchitz and Maria Blanchard.
I think it would be necessary
to take a turn in history
based on this new knowledge.
We see that sometimes,
as in these works
of the MEDOS Museum in Dallas,
Maria Blanchard
is enormously similar
in her formal language
and in her abstract and figurative
intentions to Lipchitz's work,
although she adds a factor
that characterized this second Cubism,
the awareness
that we are in the post-Collage era.
And if we reconsider
these two works
belonging to the collection
of the Fundación Telefónica
today in the Rinasofía Museum,
we realize that Gris
and Blanchard
handle the same basic language
surrounding Cubism,
that of proposing
a new sense of pure painting,
that of proposing
a vision of Cubist painting
that is appreciated
only by the forms
and the construction of the forms,
but which must maintain
a last element
that helps the visuality
to recognize the relationship
with the world of objects
and phenomena,
but both, however,
act in different ways.
Gris always tends
to compositions
that are dominated
by a presence sense
of what is sometimes
called classical,
although there is also
a dynamic Gris,
but in which the structure
of the forms
is maintained
as a constant articulation
of elements
that function in counterweight.
Maria Blanchard,
however,
plays with the sensations
of space
and with the interrelation
between the color plane
and the silhouette of the drawing.
It is the same poetry
in two different versions.
Maria Blanchard
did not imitate Juan Gris.
Maria Blanchard
formulated solutions
for Second Cubism
and gave her
personal and unique response.
What perhaps interrupted
the passage of Second Cubism
to history
and its current understanding
was that in parallel
with the development
of Second Cubism,
the absolute abstraction
of Piet Mondrian
and other authors
For many years,
for decades perhaps,
the proposal
of absolute abstraction
as a paradigm
of modern art
has been the guide
and criterion
in the narratives
of modern art.
Today, however,
we already know
that in modern art
there is no paradigm,
but several paradigms
working at the same time.
Today, perhaps,
is the time
when we can recover
the fundamental idea,
the fundamental poetry
that Gris and Maria Blanchard
wanted to launch in unison.
An art that was appreciated
from the pure plasticity
of the surface of the fabric,
but that through
the eye re-educated
by the fabric
moved by Cubist language
to give us objects
of reality,
objects of environment
with which to reconcile ourselves.
And this possibility
of understanding this chapter
of Cubism
and of appreciating it again
is what the Dallas Museum
with its exhibition
Cubism in Color,
Los Bodegones de Juan Gris.
Thank you very much.
