What We Learned After Testing a Honda Civic Si Over 40,000 Miles | Car and Driver

Cars Arena
18 followers
Welcome to Car and Driver.
We've just wrapped up our long-term test
on this Honda Civic Si.
Yes, we drove it 40,000 miles across the country
on the commute and in real winters.
Not only that, we also outfit this car
for track days at Sebring International, Watkins Glen,
and Virginia International Raceways.
We'll go over how it did, what you could expect
if you were to buy one, what we like, what we didn't like,
and how it does during a track day, bro.
Let's start with how we configured this Si, which
is easy because outside of a few accessories,
your options really are the color.
In this case, blazing orange pearl, which is about $400.
And whether you want these Goodyear Eagle F1
asymmetric two summer tires or not, we did,
may cost around $200.
That brought the as-tested price of this car
to just under $29,000.
that price makes the Si very appealing.
And what's great, too, is everything inherently good
about this car comes standard.
You don't need to get an optional performance
package or anything like that to unlock the car's best features.
Those are a six-speed manual transmission
with automatic rev matching, a limited-slip differential,
and a 200-horsepower turbocharged four-cylinder.
Now, on the other hand, this car isn't exactly
what you might call quick, even compared
to the previous generation.
At our test track, we recorded 60 miles an hour in 6.6 seconds,
and the quarter mile in 14.9 seconds at 95 miles an hour.
So if you're the kind of person who really cares
about acceleration results and bragging about those results
online, this isn't the car for you.
But before you click off this video,
let me tell you that focusing on those results
misses the point of this car and why this car is so enjoyable.
When you interact with this vehicle, which
is what you do every day on the commute,
you don't notice the acceleration results.
You feel everything else about this car.
For starters, this manual transmission
is probably the best shifter this side of the Civic Type R,
and the rest of the car it's connected to
is really enjoyable to experience,
even when you're just cruising along.
The steering has lots of feedback.
It's overall superb, and the handling is excellent.
And together, this is a package that
makes even the most mundane commutes very enjoyable.
So the Si is fun to drive, but there's
another strength that emerged during our test,
and that is the Civic Si is an affordable way
to do an expensive hobby.
And by that, we mean specifically track days.
Everybody likes the idea of track days,
but few people actually think about the economics
of actually attending one.
Think about it from a cost perspective.
You have to pay a couple hundred bucks just to enter.
You've got to pay for the fuel to get there,
do your laps, drive home.
You've got to pay if you're staying at a hotel.
You've got equipment to buy.
You've got a cooler to fill their snacks.
The list goes on and on.
It can be expensive.
And that's even before you consider
how you actually get all your stuff to the racetrack.
If you're buying a Civic Si, you probably
don't have a truck and trailer to tow it with.
So you're either going to have to cut a hole in the bumper
to install a hitch and get a trailer on that way,
or do what we did and put all your stuff in the car.
And here it is, all the stuff.
We've got everything you would need to attend a track day.
Well, mostly everything.
We're missing the cooler.
But we've got tools.
We've got fluids.
We've got a jack.
We've got jack stands.
We've got an air compressor.
We've got a helmet.
We've got four mounted wheels and tires.
All of this stuff, plus the cooler, plus the driver
and passenger, fit in the Civic Si
and made a 20-hour drive from our headquarters
in Ann Arbor, Michigan to Sebring
International in Florida.
Best part is, all this got 31 MPG on the way.
Now, before we talk about how it did on track,
let's talk about how we set it up.
And that requires going back to our first time
testing this vehicle.
We noticed significant brake fade
during repeated stops from 100 miles an hour,
even so far as setting the brake warning light off on the dash.
Now, this isn't something that's going
to happen during normal driving, but it
is something we wanted to address when we were taking it
out on the track.
So for brake pads, we actually had
to turn to Carbotech, who built a custom
set of pads for our vehicle.
You can read more about that story on the site.
Interesting thing is, they actually used our car's hardware
to develop its own system for owners of 11th Gen Civic SIs.
So all you out there watching this who
own one of these cars, who plan on taking it on a track day,
you're welcome.
Now, as for the rest of it, we got from Tire Rack
a set of OZ wheels for about $1,500.
Yokohoma sent us a set of Advan Neova 80-09 track tires
for around $1,200.
And we topped it all off with Castrol React SRF Racing
DOT 4 brake fluid.
With all that done, Austin Irwin made the 20-hour trek down
to Sebring for a track day.
And he reported that the brakes and tires
made this thing a great learning tool
for track etiquette and competitive driving
and how to not end up on a YouTube fails compilation.
He has said, of course, that this thing was outmatched
on the straights.
But he did get a point by from a C8 and a Supra,
which had to feel good.
After another track day at Watkins Glen,
we switched the tires to Bridgestone's new RE71RS
Extreme Performance summer tire.
Those were around $960.
And then we set off to Virginia International Raceway.
There, this car set a 3-minute and 11-second lap time.
That's obviously not going to be an official lightning lap
time around the grand course due to the modifications.
But that's not too shabby either for a 200-horsepower front
wheel drive Honda Civic.
In total, those Carbotech brake pads, the high-temperature
brake fluid, gave this thing plenty of durability
to last a few laps.
The limiting factor would likely be the single-piston calipers
sourced from the last-gen Honda Accord.
But overall, this thing did great.
Between all those track sessions and long stretches
of highway driving in between, we
didn't see a need to add any more coolant or oil
during the process.
In fact, the only thing that we noticed
was some light blowtorching on the front caliper dust boots.
But it wasn't enough that we needed to replace them.
So the Si is a potentially thrifty way
to do track days with your new vehicle.
But that affordability comes with some concessions.
For starters, we had a love-hate relationship
with this car's suspension.
We loved how it handled, but hated
how bumpy it could feel on our admittedly awful roads.
Unlike the previous generation Si,
you can't get adaptive dampers with this car.
They're saved for its mechanical twin,
the Acura Integra A-spec.
And overall, that's really unfortunate
if you're like me and getting older and slightly creakier.
Similar how Honda did away with adaptive dampers,
there's also no way to get heated seats in the Si.
That's frustrating because not only are Michigan winners
Michigan winners, but heated seats
are standard in the less expensive Civic EX.
As it comes to actually driving this car,
you still have the issue of rev hang.
We've gone over this previously where
during a full throttle upshift, the engine speed
flares up in between a shift.
That means you have to wait a long time to actually engage
the next gear in order for it to feel nice and smooth.
This really only happens, though, when you're really
trying to drive fast, and not when
you're commuting because you're shifting a bit more slowly.
Similarly, we love that this car has automatic rev
matching on downshifts.
And we like that you can turn it off and on depending
on your preference.
But what's annoying is that the only way to do it
is through this touch screen when
the car is parked with the emergency brake activated.
Fortunately, though, this is something
an owner would probably only do once or twice,
so it's not that big of an issue.
When winter came around, we put on a set
of Bridgestone Blizzac WS90 winter tires
that we sourced from Tire Rack.
And this year's winter, you may have already heard,
was pretty mild.
So there wasn't much of a challenge to this car.
The only thing that will call out, though,
is similar to the Civic Type R, the last gen one
that we ran through our long-term test.
Having a metal shift knob is just
as painful in the extreme heat of summer
as it is during the extreme cold of winter.
Wear gloves.
As for service, we had three visits
that altogether totaled $382.
The Civic uses a maintenance minder light
that determines when it's time.
And for us, it called for an oil change at roughly 12,000 miles,
but oddly, not a filter change until around 23,000 miles.
Our last service at about 35,000 miles called for both,
and a cabin and engine air filter change,
as well as a tire rotation.
As for repairs, the only thing we had to take care of
was a cracked windshield, courtesy of a rock on the road.
That took about two weeks to get due to supply chain issues,
and it cost us about $760.
The Civic Si has many increasingly rare qualities.
It's an inexpensive, fun-to-drive sedan
that sold exclusively with a manual transmission.
That combination in and of itself
is just out there in this day and age.
But the fact that it's actually good, too,
is just icing on the cake.
This car did everything that we asked of it, from the commute
to winter to track days.
And yeah, there are some downsides.
We'd like to see another 30 horsepower,
but what car wouldn't benefit from that?
We'd also like to see a couple other small issues addressed.
But on the whole, this was an economical, enjoyable,
and flexible sedan.
That, for the money, is a hard combination to beat.
