Should You Really Take Antibiotics for Your Sore Throat? - CENTOR criteria - Dr Gill
Dr James Gill
407 followers
38 Video Views·Sep 16, 2024
hello and welcome back to the channel
you've joined myself Dr James Gill for
another clinical skills adjacent video
as you can see once again I'm on
Expedition and bizarrely I found a video
topic that covers out here but also back
at home so often people come in and they
Grump that different doctor and things
hasn't given them antibiotics for their
sore throat and they ask me for another
prescription and that's always a very
difficult discussion because we have to
address whether on antibiotics work or
not with a sore throat and actually the
same thing has been happening whilst I'm
on Expedition there's been a a bug doing
the rounds with the team out here and
I've had lots of people come up directly
to ask me for antibiotics and it takes
some time to be able to explain whether
or not that patient needs antibiotics or
not so I thought it might be worthwhile
explaining the process that we use to go
through it and so that you guys can see
it's not just us protect in the
antibiotics although we do have a duty
of stewardship to them but it's that we
want to make sure that we're actually
helping you and not potentially causing
side effects from an antibiotic won't do
you any good so why won't your doctor
give you antibiotics for your sore
throat well let's start off with an easy
one as a rule of thumb and rules of
thumb are always slightly tricky a sore
throat which has caused a change to the
voice is probably a viral issue not a
bacterial issue now it's important we
highlight that's a rule of thumb so
we're definitely going to go further in
this and give you some tools that give
you numbers that's something to first
off put in your head now we say that as
a rule of thumb a sore throat is
probably due to a virus we're talking
about that acute sore throat because a
sore throat could be due to a virus
which won't respond to antibiotics it
could be due to bacteria where we might
need to consider antibiotics but there
are in rare cases other things that
could be causing a sore throat and we
still want to make sure that you know
all patients with a sore throat who are
concerned come and have a chat to us
because if you've had a sore throat for
a long time and you've noticed changes
to your voice that might actually be
something quite nasty potentially a
cancer there so we want to make sure
that we're looking at all options but
the vast majority of sore throats are
going to be viral or bacterial so you
come into the GP surgery and you say
you've got a sore throat I need to try
and determine what type of sore throat
it is I.E viral or bacterial but it's
not just about giving you antibiotics to
make you feel better because actually
they probably won't all the evidence
suggests that when we give antibiotics
for a sore throat even when they're
clinically indicated it probably improve
symptoms by about 12 hours so it's not
going to do a huge amount the other
thing with giving antibiotics is it's
not necessarily about you now but maybe
you later but hopefully a later that
never arrives with they bacterial sore
throat we worry about group a strep to
caucus which I'm sure lots of people saw
in the news last year because there was
quite an outbreak in the UK If we get a
group a strep to caucus sore throat that
could cause something called rheumatic
fever which at the end game could
potentially damage the heart bacterial
sore throats can also lead to another
complication called quines where the
tonsil swells full of pus in an abscess
and actually can olude the airway now
both of those are very very it's
important to highlight to the degree
that we don't really consider that we
have rheumatic fever anymore because
we've got easy access to antibiotics but
that's why we give the antibiotics
because we can make sure those
complications are pretty much taken away
from a patient so you come in you've got
a sore throat you're feeling really
rough how can I try to determine what's
going on and that that's the crucial
word how can I try because none of this
is absolute well we use something called
the centor criteria which has five
points that help us determine what's
going on is there a cough are there any
white spots is there any exate do you
have any nodes painful lymph nodes in
the body particularly in the anterior
cervical chain have you had a
temperature and oh for old age I.E are
you under 15 or over 55 but how do those
fit into having antibiotics or not well
if you've got a cough you actually don't
score a point so there's another rule of
thumb for you if your sore throat has a
cough it's more likely to be uh due to a
virus rather than a bacteria it's not
absolute that's why there's five other
points but definitely something to think
about so if you've got a cough you don't
have a point which often surprises
patients we then want to talk about
exudates if you've got a big sore
inflamed angry throat that is definitely
a problem and you are certainly
suffering and there's lots of things
from a symptomatic perspective we can do
paracetamol if you can take it ibuprofen
if you can have them the difflam sprays
the local anesthetic sprays and the
throat lenes but you don't get a point
for that what you do get a point for is
the exate if you got nasty white creamy
stuff sloughing off the tonsils that's
where we've got a bacterial infection
and we're seeing the effects of that
bacteria on the tonsils yes bacteria
could cause that big inflammation as
well but that's more likely due to a
virus if you've got painful lumps and
bumps in the neck that also gets you a
point now it's quite possible you could
have big lymph nose in the neck because
your body's fighting the virus but if
they're tender when we do that
examination it's more likely that it's a
bacteria Tu the next one temperature
we're taking the information largely
from you if you as a patient say that
you have a temperature at home or have
done a short while ago then you get the
point because you may have had
paracetamol or Ibuprofen recently which
has brought your temperature down so in
the GP clinic or by the Rocks when I
check your temperature it might be
normal normal because you've had an
antipyretic so very much we're listening
to what you're saying there and then
finally o for old age and say r t and
sympathy points you gain a point if your
age is under 15 and you gain a point if
your age is older than 55 because
they're the areas where again we're more
likely to be dealing with a bacterial
infection but great you've got a handful
of points how do we analyze those points
how do we use those points to determine
if antibiotics are going to be useful
for you so if you score one
realistically it's under 10% chance that
you'll need antibiotics and that is
crucial not saying it's zero there is
still a possibility that you need
antibiotics but now we really dig into
the numbers we know that about 50% of
people will be made worse by the
antibiotics and the antibiotics aren't
going to have a big impact on the
symptoms as I say it will only reduce
the symptoms by about 12 hours what it's
there for those antibiotics is to stop
those nasty complications like quiny and
rheumatic fever so if you've got one you
probably don't need them now if you're
absolutely terrified and you want to
take the potential for the side effects
I will certainly give you them but we
treat the patient not the computer so if
you're adamant then we'll have that
discussion and we'll make the uh the
choice together if you got two points
we're moving up a little bit now there's
a 15 to 20% you need antibiotics so in
my opinion we're still looking on the
probability of symptomatic treatment if
we get into three now we need to start
doing things so if you've got a score of
three I'm going to suggest that we do a
throat Swap and I'm going to suggest I
give you a delayed course of antibiotics
we send it off to the pharmacy or give
you it to hold in your hand but only
take it if this swab which we should be
able to do over 24 hours comes back
positive so we're covering you knowing
that the antibiotics aren't to treat the
symptoms they're to prevent a
complication which is more of a longterm
which is why we're going to have the
full 10-day course of antibiotics but if
it comes back negative then we don't
need to take those if we've got a score
of four I'm more likely to say take the
antibiotics if the patient in front of
me is really ill but we're still going
to do that swab but rather than send it
to the an Pharmacy I might give them
those antibiotics to say if you
deteriorate as well start to take those
because with a score of three you're
probably dealing with a 30 to 40% chance
that you need antibiotics and a score of
four there's a 40 to 50% chance you need
antibiotics so again we're getting close
to that the balance of probability a
score of five now you have 58% chance of
bacterial infection which is more than
our possibility of the antibiotics
causing your problems so I'm going to
not give you them but I'm going to
suggest strongly that you do consider
taking those medications because it's
still about the patient in run to me and
some patients might say no they don't
want to take them and they'll see how
things go in which case I'd still
probably suggest that they take the
delayed course and if they work person
so if their you know symptoms become
more severe then definitely take them
but it's all about treating the patient
so I hope there's been a useful overview
as to why your GP might not give you
antibiotics for your sore throat it's
not because we are saying no it's
because we want to make sure we treat
each of you correctly and using the
balance of probability so I hope it's
been useful and I think off the back of
this we're probably going to have to do
a video on how to properly examine the
throat so stay tuned for that and we'll
see you in the next one J
