Lecture 46 : Euler Lagrange Equation, Cyclic Coordinates and Other Properties

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 15, 2024
Hello and welcome to another lecture of Classical Motion of a Single Particle. So, finally,
we derived the Euler Lagrange equation or the Lagrange's equation of second kind and
we have actually derived this using the D'Alembert's principle which actually is one of the possible
methods by which you can derive the Euler Lagrange equation.
And we found that if we use this method this is very specific to classical mechanical systems
and we found that Lagrangian of a particle is actually given by T minus V ok, but of
course, you know that whenever this definition is meaningful, but in order to make this definition
meaningful I have to assure that the particle is actually moving in a conservative force
field where you actually have a meaningful potential.
Now, you can actually tell me that this is a little bit confusing because you said that
Lagrange's equations or Euler Lagrange equation should not use any concept of force while
deriving I agree. So, what we actually will do because we know that V is associated with
conservative force fields that is why I said that, but the proper way of putting this will
be that I have to make sure in order to have a meaningful Lagrangian I have to make sure
that the Lagrangian is associated or the motion of the particle is associated to some scalar
potential function ok. I am not that is in that way I am not associating this to a conservative
force field. Now, if Lagrangian is given as T minus V ok
then actually you can show that finally, you can derive all the equations of mechanics
without any problem for example, here for this course for a single particle and as I
just mentioned last week that this Lagrangian can be also used for any number of particles
for a system with many particles for a system with even where you do not have classical
mechanical particles either you can have different type of systems for example, I said in economics
in epidemiology in biology you can have different type of systems where Lagrangian can be of
importance, but this form you have to then understand that this form T minus V may not
be kept intact for those systems ok. So, this T minus V is the form of a Lagrangian
for a mechanical system mechanical system for our course this is much more even specific
even for us a single particle mechanical system whose motion is associated with a scalar potential
V if you remember we also used some other things. So, first we said that the V should
be existing, but V also should be a function of x y and z that we used for our derivation
ok. So, now the question is if V is a function
of velocity let us say velocity dependent potential if we have a system like that can
we also have a meaningful Lagrangian I will come to that point at the very end of this
that let me just tell you once again this is the kinetic energy. So, this is the potential
energy and we just said that this is the information we know. So, someone said that this is a system
whose Lagrangian for example, is given by half m x dot square minus some V of x for
example, ok. This is the information I start with now how to find the equations of dynamics
for that I know that the Lagrange's equation is finally, given by d d t of del L del q
i minus sorry del q i dot minus del q del L del q i is equal to 0 for all i running
from 1 to n where n is the number of the generalized coordinates.
So, this equation is not just the one single equation this is true for every generalized
coordinate and that is the symmetrical that is a symmetric victory of this formulation
over normal Newtonian formulation. So, for example, if you just start writing Newton's
second law what in general you get you get that M r double dot is equal to F. Now if
you say that I want to decompose the whole thing in Cartesian systems then you have
M x double dot is equal to F x, M y double dot is equal to F y and M z double dot is
equal to F z. Can you do the same business r theta phi can you write M r double dot is
equal to F r, M theta double dot is equal to F theta and M phi double dot is equal to
F phi the answer is a big no and you actually know that in the radial direction actually
just in 2 D just in 2 D the force expression is M times r double dot minus r theta dot
square and in 3 D it will be actually much complicated you can find it out ok by yourself.
So, you see that this symmetry does not get propagated to this system this coordinate
system although the particle or the system under investigation is the same. So, it is
a more like it is a symmetry I mean coordinate system specific symmetry and this is only
possible for Cartesian system, but as I said that for many problems the symmetry the coordinate
system of symmetry is a different system than a Cartesian one then what to do of course,
you can say that I should be happy with this type of forms that is true.
But here the main advantages is that let us say if your generalized coordinates are now
theta and phi without thinking anything just blindly and bluntly you can write d d t for
minus del L del theta will be 0 and d d t del L del phi dot minus del L del phi will
be 0 given you have correctly found the Lagrangian. So, this is a very important step forward
for us for having a symmetric analytical formulation of mechanics ok.
So, now, coming back to this point that if my L is given like this what I have to do.
So, I can write. So, once again L is half m x dot square minus v of x ok. So, this is
the scalar function of x only then del L del x dot will simply be equal to m x dot
and del L del x will be equal to minus del v del x.
Now, if you just write this equation d d t del L del x dot minus del L del x will be
0 then this actually gives us m x dot d d t will be equal to del L del x which is minus
del v del x and this is m x double dot is equal to minus del v del x and this is nothing
but your famous Newton's second law for a particle moving in a conservative field. I
am just saying that according to your knowledge this is the Newton's second law for a particle
moving in a conservative field having potential v.
So, this is the power of this formulation that finally, you are actually finding this
of motion. Sometimes now here there is a point that you can actually think that may be for
every for I mean may be corresponding to every generalized coordinate I will actually have
a new or a separate equation of motion. Sometime this is not also the point that and because
you think that because in your mind setting this is somehow implanted that an equation
of motion is always F is equal to m. In this framework we can also generalize the situation
and actually an equation of motion is any correct equation of motion any any necessary
information regarding the motion. I am coming to that point now.
So, let us say I am saying a particle is moving a particle is moving along some trajectory
in 2 D plane. I do not know what is the nature of the force, but the potential and the potential
associated is a function of r only. So, right from the beginning I said that for the particle
the potential energy will be equal to some v of r and what will be the kinetic energy?
This is 2 D. So, I right from the beginning I choose my coordinate system of convenience
that is half that that is the polar plane polar coordinate system where kinetic energy
is half m r dot square plus r square theta dot square. You know this and if you write
this thing now then your Lagrangian will be. So, this is your T this is your v Lagrangian
will be half m r dot square plus r square theta dot square minus v of r and your Euler
Lagrange equation will simply be given by d d t. So, how many equations do you have?
We have 2 Euler Lagrange equations one related to r another related to theta. So, the first
one will be d d t del L del r dot minus del L del r is equal to 0 and d d t del L del
theta dot minus del L del theta will be equal to 0. I can directly find from this equation
you just change the color what is del L del r dot that is again m r dot. What is del L
del r once again that is. So, del L del r is nothing, but minus del v del r, but is
this all no now you say we are overlooking something this and this one is actually will
give you a non zero contribution for del L del r which is minus. So, you will have m
r square. So, theta dot square sorry. So, this will be del L del r. So, del v del r
plus. So, that will be half m theta dot square times 2 r. So, which will be 2 r. So, it will
be minus del v del r plus m r theta dot square you combine this 2 this 2 what you will have.
So, you should finally, you should have this equation. So, d d t of m r dot will be will
be equal to del L del r which is minus del v del r plus m r theta dot square and this
is nothing, but m r double dot. So, I can take this to this side and you will have m
r double dot minus r theta dot square is equal to minus del v del r. So, you see here the
biggest thing is that you are actually recovering the same thing as you recover in the case
of Newton's law, but now you are coming from a form where you do not have to think that
you are writing for r or theta the form is. So, symmetric what happens for theta. So,
before just I can actually do here. So, what happens for theta I can take del L del theta
dot to be equal to m r square theta dot and what is del L del theta you see surprisingly
although r and r dot both are present in the expression of Lagrangian theta dot is present,
but theta is not present. So, that is why del L del theta is 0 and I have finally, m
r square theta dot will be equal to I mean will be equal to. So, I just write the properly.
So, that this is the first time you are doing. So, it is good. So, Euler Lagrange equation
d dt of m r square theta dot will be equal to 0. So, m r square theta dot is equal to
constant, you can call that L. So, you see that this is a point where you may stuck a
little bit tell me honestly what did you think you thought just like you found this equation
for r you could actually found the other equation along the theta cap direction for Newton's
second law if I do this thing Euler Lagrange equation with respect to theta, but that you
are not finding, but you are what you are finding is actually something is also true
you know for a 2 D motion that is the angular momentum vector has a constant magnitude here
that we have used actually for such type of motions and one such. So, which is this motion
finally, if you remember this is a possible Lagrangian for a particle which is moving
under a central force and for that the angular momentum is a constant vector. So, just like
the direction its magnitude is also conserved and here this equation is actually is not
giving a F is equal to m a, but this is just giving that something is conserved.
So, also at this point it is a very good thing to learn that whenever we say that whenever
you I mean put the Lagrangian in the Euler Lagrange equation for a system the outcome
is not always an equation of dynamics in Newton sense this is some information. Now, I have
a question for you please think otherwise I will tell you I will tell you in the next
lecture. So, this is that how actually finally, you have to find I mean how you can find in
this frame work the force equation in the theta cap direction of course, you thought
that could be done by using the Euler Lagrange equation with respect to theta, but that did
not work. So, what is the trick then I am just going a little bit with some other interesting
things about this Euler Lagrange equation. So, you see that the first thing. So, mainly
in this lecture I will try to describe some properties of Euler Lagrange equation. So,
I will continue of course, in the next lectures as well this.
So, the first important property is that d d t of del L del q i dot minus del L del q
i is equal to 0 where q i is a generalized coordinate and this is true for all generalized
coordinates equally. Now, the first point is if L does not explicitly contain any q
i let us say some q i star a specific q i it can be more than 1 or more than 1 specific
q i or a more than 1 specific q i. So, for example, let us say out of 3 q i's in a system
2 have this properties that 2 are absent from the expression of Lagrangian, but their dots
exist in the form of the Lagrangian for example, this thing half m r square minus r dot square
plus r square theta dot square minus v of r. You see that this does not contain theta,
but contains theta dot ok. This type of coordinate is known as cyclic coordinate. If a coordinate
if a generalized coordinate is a cyclic coordinate for a system then what happens that the corresponding
if for example, q i star is absent or it is a cyclic coordinate then del L del q i star
is 0 from this one and if this is 0 then I can actually say d dt of del L del q i star
dot is always 0 and del L del q i dot star is conserved.
as the conjugate momentum of the coordinate q i star. So, for any generalized coordinate
q i for q i ok conjugate momentum is given by del L del q i dot ok. So, if q i or q i
star is a cyclic coordinates is conjugate momentum is conserved. So, you see in this
problem theta is a cyclic coordinate. So, it is conjugate momentum since theta is an
angle and if you think that theta theta is a generalized coordinate then the corresponding
momentum will be angular momentum and that is exactly what we get from this one ok this
thing this thing ok. Now, you see again this d dt del L del q i
dot minus del L del q i is equal to 0. I add to this L some arbitrary constant with the
same dimension of course. So, for example, here L you can easily understand L has a dimension
of energy because this is T minus V. So, I can now add L plus some k which is a constant
ok having the dimension of energy. Is it also a valid Lagrangian for the system? Yes, because
if you see carefully this equation ok any constant if it is added or subtracted from
this original Lagrangian actually also satisfies this Euler Lagrange equation because Euler
Lagrange equation just associates the derivatives of Lagrangian.
And that is why if L is a Lagrangian then L plus minus k is also a valid Lagrangian.
And if you now take L to some beta times L where beta is a constant will that be also
a valid Lagrangian for the system? Again my answer will be anything which is for a
given system anything which is just satisfying the Euler Lagrange equations ok they are valid
Lagrangians ok. Now, for a given system where exactly we I mean put this specific specific
condition that this is for a given system in the choice of the generalized coordinates
ok. So, if L is transformed to beta L let us say 2 L, 3 L, 0.56 times L whether this
is also a valid Lagrangian? Mathematically yes, you can say yes if again if you just
multiply this beta throughout this equation ok this will not change and that is why again
you see that this is a valid Lagrangian I mean actually this one is a valid Lagrangian.
But now the point is that whether it will simply always have the simple usual meaning
of the Lagrangian that is T minus v if you now say T minus v times root over 3 by 2 what
is the meaning of that? Of course, that is a little bit difficult and that is why we
always choose a meaningful Lagrangian ok, but mathematically no one can prevent this
from being a good Lagrangian. Finally, I will I will of course, continue
discussing such properties in the next lecture as well, but I am simply just doing something
that we have already said that Lagrangian in general can be the property of ok it can
be a function of the generalized coordinates, generalized velocities and also explicitly
the time. So, if I now say Lagrangian then what is d L d t? So, d L d t is actually then
del L del t plus del L del q i q i I mean I would say d q i d t plus del L del q i dot
d q dot q i dot d t there is a summation over the. So, just for n dimensional space
let us say small n dimensional space for small n dimensional space which is usually 2, 3
for us space ok. N dimensional space simply means that n is
the number of generalized coordinates that is this is the dimension of the space with
effective number of degrees of freedom ok. So, for example, for a particle while moving
on the surface of a sphere with constant radius ok n will be equal to 2. So, you will see
that this is simply i is equal to 1 to n and i is equal to 1 to n. So, this can go up to
say that number of generalized coordinates. If this is true then I can actually write
this is equal to del L del t plus. So, summation over i 1 to n I can simply say this thing
is q i dot by definition. So, I will actually say that this is q i dot and what is this?
This one is by Euler Lagrange equation is nothing, but if you just see this equation
carefully this is nothing, but d d t of del L del q i and then plus you have summation
over i 1 to n del L del q i dot oh sorry this is del L del q i dot yeah. So, d d t of del
L del q i dot and now here you will have del L del q i dot times d d t of q i dot ok.
So, you can write again t you can take the summation out i 1 to n then d d t of q i dot
times del L del q i dot ok. Now, I say that ok I started from d L d t and I have this
expression I can actually say ok. So, this d d t and the summation can commute because
they are totally independent d d t is just the time derivative and summation is just
acting on the number of generalized coordinates. So, I can actually have d d t of I can take
this thing on one side L minus summation over i 1 to n q i dot del L del q i dot ok
is equal to del L del t. This is a fantastic results result because if if del L del t is
0 that means, if the Lagrangian does not explicitly depend on time just exactly the
Lagrangians you have seen over here or here ok they are not depending on time then what
happens that del del t del L del t is 0 and d d t of these will also be equal to 0 and
that means, L minus summation over i 1 to n q i dot del L del q i dot will be a constant.
Now I just use my definition that L is equal to t minus v ok where t is nothing, but summation
over i 1 to n half m q i dot square ok minus v I can I can write just for example, I can
write just just for just I can write this ok. So, v is a function of q i's q i means
just not one i it can be generalized it can be depending on more than one generalized
coordinates, but only coordinates not velocities ok.
If I write this then you see that what I will have. So, first I make this thing highlighted
that this will be constant ok when del L del t is 0 that means, your Lagrangian does not
explicitly contain any time, but what will be this this one ok actually then you can
actually have to calculate. So, what I will do I will not do the general calculation,
but I will do just I take a specific example I take the example of a particle single particle
moving under some potential x y function of x y z ok. So, what will be Lagrangian that
will be half m x dot square plus y dot square plus z dot square minus v of x y z.
I can see here since there is no further constraint yeah since there is no further
constraint one actually can take x y and z to be the system of generalized coordinate
that is also possible for this system the Cartesian system is the system of generalized
coordinates ok and you will have this quantity is to be determined. So, it will actually
be x dot del del del L del x dot plus y dot del L del y dot plus z dot del L del z dot.
If you properly calculate this from this Lagrangian this will be given by ok. So, m x dot square
plus y dot square plus z dot square ok and now if you just say that my L is half m by
y dot square plus z dot square minus v x y z that minus. So, then L minus this thing
which I can now call minus h I can say. So, minus h will be equal to this whole thing
minus this. So, this will be minus m by 2 x dot square plus y dot square plus z dot
square minus v and you can I think remember what this is h is equal to m by 2 x dot square
plus y dot square plus z dot square plus v. So, this function h is nothing, but the
total mechanical energy this is the kinetic energy this is the potential energy you started
with T minus v you come with a form T plus v.
So, you see this is also consistent with our conclusion that this is the motion of a particle
which is moving in 3D space under a potential because we know that potential means this
is moving under a conservative force. So, the total mechanical energy should be conserved
ok and this function ok is actually conserved. So, where this quantity which looked strange
for us now we know for a simple particle ok single particle moving in 3D space with some
associated to some potential this quantity is nothing, but just the minus of its total
mechanical energy and since the total mechanical energy is conserved this is also conserved
ok you can just try to find this function for other Lagrangians as well ok.
Remember that this form T plus v is very specific to a mechanical system ok and it may not be
the form of this function in general for other systems ok.
Thank you very much.
