Should You Ever Do Pre-Tax Contributions?

Retire Rich
11 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 14, 2024
With the clear benefits of the Roth,
should you even bother contributing pre-tax to your 401k
or to the traditional IRA?
Well, I'll tell you when that more, coming up.
My name's Mike Bernard.
I'm the host of the Wise Money Show.
I'm also one of the certified financial planners
right here at Core Horn Financial Group.
Make sure you hit that subscribe button,
turn on notifications and smash that thumbs up button.
Early in my career, first year, first few months,
I had an opportunity to sit in and observe a client meeting
from Kevin Core Horn,
the founder of Core Horn Financial Group.
And even though I wasn't an advisor
and I was fresh out of school,
finance degree from Michigan State University
and sort of working behind the scenes,
doing customer service and doing analysis and doing prep.
Oftentimes, as often as I could,
I would sit in on meetings to learn how Kevin taught
and also learn from Kevin as well.
And this was early in my career,
like first couple of months.
I started after I graduated in May
and I distinctly remember this being late summer,
early fall.
So I didn't know anything, okay?
Well, with this client,
he was teaching the different tax shelters.
He was teaching how the Roth IRA worked.
And this was, the Roth came out in mid 90s
and it wasn't starting to being used until the late 90s.
And this probably would have been 2003, maybe 2004.
So the Roth wasn't popular.
It wasn't clear how it worked.
And Kevin was teaching it.
And I remember I'm just sitting there taking notes,
silent, not talking at all.
And I just remember thinking,
oh my goodness, this is awful.
There's no way, he must be teaching this wrong.
There's no way that's how this thing works.
And it wasn't this curiosity.
I remember this panic feeling like,
Kevin, you're teaching it wrong.
That's not right.
That can't be how this thing works.
That's how good the Roth IRA is.
This idea, the Roth 401k now,
this idea that, yeah,
you don't get a tax deduction on your contributions.
You put after-tax money in the Roth,
but then all that activity,
all the dividends and capital gains,
it's all sheltered from tax.
But then all of the growth would come out tax-free
as long as you've met the five-year rule
and are age 59 and a half.
And I remember the couple that he was teaching this to,
they were young, they were in their 30s.
And I was thinking, oh my goodness,
that can't be true.
They're gonna avoid tax.
All the growth for the next 30 years,
40 years until retirement,
this money is not gonna be taxed.
And Kevin was right.
And I remember now, fast forward a couple of years,
and I would teach the Roth IRA
and I would get a similar response from clients.
One in particular, a young entrepreneur,
I was teaching the Roth IRA
and this was an option
and this is a way for you to shelter some money
and avoid paying tax on these dollars forever.
And he said, yeah, that's too good to be true.
The tax laws will change.
This thing won't stick around.
I'm not doing it.
And guys, not only has it stuck around,
but they have been making a lot more rules
to encourage more Roth,
sort of the Rothification,
if you've heard us talk about that before.
And so, like I said,
Roth 401ks are available in almost all 401ks now,
many 403Bs.
They've expanded the contributions.
They've lifted the ceiling
on being able to do Roth conversions.
Used to be if your income was above a certain level,
you couldn't even do a Roth conversion.
They've removed that.
Simple IRAs now are coming out
where they can be Roth.
SEP IRAs are able to be Roth now as well.
They're even allowing soon your company match
to go into the Roth side of your 401k.
And then we all know about the new rule
where you can shift $529, college dollars,
over to a Roth IRA.
Lots of stipulations with that as well.
But guys, they are making it easier and easier
and pushing more and more to the Roth,
this thing that is almost too good to be true.
They could change the laws at any time,
but all the laws, the momentum right now
is making the Roth more attractive or more available.
And the deal that you're making is clear.
The IRS says, we've got a lot of debt.
We've got a big deficit.
We need your tax dollars.
So therefore, contribute to the Roth
instead of pre-tax so that we can tax you on that money.
And you think, and you believe,
hey, because of this mountain of debt as a country,
tax rates are probably gonna be higher in the future.
Seems like a win-win.
That's the deal you're making.
So with that being so crystal clear,
should you even bother contributing pre-tax anymore
to your 401k or to the traditional IRA?
Well, this is a quintessential financial planning decision.
Most people set it and forget it.
They don't realize that you've gotta look
at all six areas of your financial life
to see whether it makes sense for you to do pre-tax or Roth.
They also don't know, most people also overlook the fact
that this could change on a dime very quickly.
You could, it could make sense for you
to do contribute pre-tax and all of a sudden,
it now makes sense for you to do Roth and then vice versa.
Well, there are a couple of very clear times
where yes, it absolutely still makes sense
for you to contribute pre-tax to your 401k
or pre-tax to your traditional IRA.
The first is if that tax deduction
on your contribution qualifies you
for other tax credits that you wouldn't otherwise obtain.
Here's a very clear example, but there's lots of them.
If you get your health insurance through the exchange,
through healthcare.gov, then the amount that you pay
for your health insurance is dependent
upon what your income is.
And you state, when you sign up at healthcare.gov,
you state, this is what I expect my income to be
for that year.
And the monthly then, the monthly premium that you pay
for your insurance is potentially lower
because you're getting some advanced premium tax credits.
These are tax credits you get on a monthly basis
by paying a smaller amount for your health insurance,
but then it all gets trued up on your tax return.
Well, if on your tax return,
your income is a little bit higher
than what you said it would be,
then those tax credits need to be repaid.
If your income turns out to be lower
than what you said it would be,
then you get even more tax credits.
Well, during that time period
where you might just even temporarily,
because you're in between jobs
or maybe you're doing contract work
or you're trying to get a small business off the ground,
something like that,
if you're getting your health insurance
through the exchange, healthcare.gov,
then it could significantly benefit you
by having this deduction contributing pre-tax
to your 401k or pre-tax to your IRA
because that's a deduction.
Makes your income lower,
qualifies you for more of these premium tax credits.
But that's not all.
It could be the retirement saver's contribution credit
that's based on your adjusted gross income
and a deductible contribution pre-tax
to your 401k or to your IRA
brings that adjusted gross income lower
and could qualify you
for some retirement saver's tax credit,
even American Opportunity Tax Credit
for any college students
or college tuition that you're paying.
Oftentimes, tax credits that you could be eligible for
are based on your adjusted gross income
and contributing pre-tax to your 401k
or pre-tax to your IRA
reduces your adjusted gross income
and could qualify you for more tax credits.
Doing proactive tax planning allows you to see,
am I right at the threshold?
And if I am, how much do I need to contribute pre-tax
to my 401k or to my IRA
to get below that threshold?
And then I'll do Roth, everything above that.
So doing that proactive tax planning
with your certified financial planner
can help you maximize and optimize the tax credits
by doing pre-tax contributions.
And then the second, the other clear time
when it makes sense to do,
to contribute pre-tax to your 401k
or pre-tax to your IRA
is in a year where you have unusually large income.
And wouldn't we all be so lucky?
Yes, of course.
But if there's a year where you, for whatever reason,
get an abnormally large bonus from work,
maybe you were on a different project
or your commission basis,
and you had a record year that will never be matched before
or never be matched again.
And all of a sudden, you're gonna see a spike
in your income just for that one year.
If that spike pushes you into a higher tax bracket,
then even if you've been doing Roth contributions
to your 401k all the way up until then,
well, now you're in that next tax bracket.
You're in that next highest tier or higher tier.
And it may make sense for you to get the deduction
on your contribution that year
and then go back to Roth in future years.
Maybe selling a property, selling a business,
having an investment that's not in a tax shelter
that you sold, now you've got a big capital gain.
That could be a reason why
all of a sudden you're in a very,
you have your income spike in one year
or really in a concentrated time period.
And you're gonna want that deduction
on your contribution during those times.
Those are clearly not the only two time periods
when it would be better for you to contribute pre-tax
to your 401k and to your IRA.
There's many more, but you've gotta work
with your certified financial planner.
All else being equal, guys, I love the Roth,
but it's not a one size fits all.
You've gotta do that comprehensive financial planning,
doing that tax planning to see,
does it make sense for you in any given year
to be contributing pre-tax or Roth?
So work with your certified financial planner on that.
If you don't have a CFP on your team,
you can contact one on my team.
Find us online, kohorn.com.
That's Kohorn with Kay, wisemoneyshow.com.
You can find us there as well,
or send us an email, info at kohorn.com.
All right, there you have it.
Go on and take your next wise step in your financial life.
