Explained: Tactics - Operations - Strategy

Army Analysis
8 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 13, 2024
So what is the diffence between tactics, operations and strategy? How do tactics, operations and strategy relate to each other? How do relate battles, campaigns and wars to tactics, operations and strategy? What unit (sizes) are involved with operations and which are involved with tactcs?
What are the differences between tactics, operations, and strategy?
Big thank you here to everyone who voted on this topic on my Patreon page.
Now let's start off quite abstract here.
So basically, if you look at this situation,
Gerhard Gross, the military historian, points out,
you need to look at space, time, and force.
So we have basically three dimensions.
And we also initially focus mainly on land warfare.
So you have space of where the fight is going.
You have time and you have the force.
The bigger it goes, the more it gets closer to strategy.
Smaller it is, the closer it is to tactics.
So you have basically tactics on the small level,
operations on the middle level,
and strategy at the high level or higher numbers.
But there's actually a caveat to it.
Gross argues that space and time are so closely linked
that it's actually only two-dimensional.
And this is why it's important with land warfare.
So because in land warfare,
you can't increase the space too much without increasing the time.
In air warfare, it's quite different.
And it's something I'll discuss in the end.
So you have basically these two dimensions.
And if they go up, you're getting closer to strategy.
And this is also a good framework because it's relative.
So for instance, what in an operational level,
in the Second World War,
it's different from an operational level nowadays
because we have small armies usually.
At the same time, they're usually faster.
And another way to see this is
the more direct and immediate something is,
the closer it is to tactics.
And the more indirect, it's closer to strategy.
So basically, tactics is about battles.
Operations is about campaigns.
And strategy is about war.
And very important, strategy is usually determined in different ways.
There's, we're talking mainly about military strategy.
There's also national or grand strategy,
which also has economic strategy,
information strategy, and other aspects sub-mounted on it.
So these are the basic differentiation.
So now, at first, let's look at tactics and strategy.
And then let's look at operations.
Because operations is the link between the two
and also the youngest of the terminology.
And tactics and strategy are usually quite often used
outside of military aspects.
Whereas operations is usually,
even for the history buffers,
the operational level is sometimes,
okay, what is this?
It's the thing in between.
And it's also even in, for not laymen,
it's sometimes a quite fuzzy term.
So let's begin with tactics.
It's come from Greek, from taktos,
which means ordered or arranged.
So this comes back to formations, fighting in formations.
It was originally a military term.
And nowadays you can hear it all the time,
also in civilian charm,
tactics for business or something else.
And basically you could say it's the art of fighting battles.
And it's all the means that are available to commander
to achieve his goal to overcome the enemy with force.
So it's all around combat usually.
Tactics in military is all about combat.
Or in other way, to solve battlefield problems.
And it's usually very specific time and place.
Again, space, time.
So it's very specific time and place.
It's tactical.
About firepower and maneuver.
Tactics are usually very dependent or closely related.
Technology.
Because technology can make a major impact.
A mortar allows you to bring forward
direct infantry support with indirect fire.
For instance, with artillery, you usually had to call it in.
But you have a mortar now.
And you can bring the mortar, because it's rather light.
It's still heavy if you have to carry it.
But in relative terms, it's rather light.
You can bring it to you and bring it forward.
This immediately changes your tactics,
how you can go forward with this.
Where strategy and other aspects, again,
are less immediate, less direct.
So it's influenced in a different way.
So it's about defeating the enemy force.
And the main focus is the battle.
And for the size, for the second Volvo,
basically tactics go from the squad with 10 men
up to core level.
A small core with 40,000 men.
So nowadays, it's a bit smaller usually.
But in this instance, you can talk about
from 10 men to 40,000 men.
If that's an engagement, it's usually a battle.
It's more on the tactical level.
You're not on the operational,
and you're definitely not on strategic level at this point.
Of course, for another period and another time
where way less forces were involved,
40,000 men could be the whole army,
could be the whole force of one nation
or even the whole population.
So again, very important to see in a relative context
with space-time force.
Now, next strategy, which is the highest
or the biggest one, and it's also in Greek.
Strategia, the art of leadership.
Again, it's a military term.
Originally, it was a military term.
Now, it's commonly used in business and everywhere.
So I have a content strategy, I have this.
Then, and if you look at it,
it's about planning and implementation.
So you have two aspects of strategy.
It's a product, and it's also a process.
So for instance, your plan is the product,
but to implement the plan, it's a process.
So we're adapting it to the environment.
We're adapting it to the changes
that happen on the battlefield
or in the campaign and everywhere else.
So strategy has this two-kind approach.
Then again, mentioned before,
we talk about military strategy.
There's national strategy or grand strategy,
which encompasses military strategy,
economic strategy, and many other aspects.
Now, how do you define it?
One way to define it is to reduce
the enemy's capacity to fight
and to reduce his willingness to fight.
So basically, his physical and his psychological needs.
Another definition more closely
to the US Marine Corps is
the art of science of used armed forces
to secure objectives of national policy
by force or threat.
This is very important, force or threat.
So you have war and you have peace.
You usually don't have tactics in peace
because tactics is about combat.
Tactics is about fighting.
So if you take the verb for tactics,
it would be fighting.
And the verb for strategy, I think,
would be planning or implementing.
So as you can see, combat tactics
is closer to the force,
whereas you could say strategy
is closer to the cerebral,
to the intellectual part,
which doesn't mean that tactics
are not quite intensive
on the mental aspects, of course.
But you get the aspect.
Less physically is on the strategic side
and more physically is on the tactics side.
Now, very important,
strategy involves all fields of war
and all military forces.
So now we have tactics
and we have strategy.
Now comes operations,
which is sometimes called
the intermediate level
or the link and the connection.
Now, in this case,
it comes from Latin, from operatio,
basically means to work.
And it's the youngest term
and it actually comes
from the civilian area in this case.
And this is operations serves as
the link, the connection
between tactics and strategy,
because it is about coordinating
the several tactical actions
to make a sum
that is bigger than its parts.
And if you look, for instance,
from the German perspective,
there's a lot of movement involved.
So as said before,
tactics, you're fighting,
strategy, you're planning
and for operations,
to a certain degree,
you could say it's coordinating.
And in some cases,
it's about moving, marching.
So the march aspect, it's different.
For instance, if you look
at the US Marine Corps definition,
they say it's about deploying,
committing and withdrawing units
and the sequence of tactical actions.
Again, deploying, committing
and withdrawal,
you could summarize this.
OK, it's about moving,
moving your units into position
to strike at the enemy,
to encircle it, to flank it.
So this is also very related
to by the Germans,
the operational art of war
is also called sometimes
Bewegungskrieg, war of movement.
Another view from the US Marine Corps
is adding a strategic dimension
to tactics
or the commander must
look beyond the battle.
Again, this is about movement,
about the dimension going on.
And the US Marine Corps
has three main ones.
One is tactics, one is strategy
and the one for operations
is actually called campaigning.
This is why I said
you have the battle tactics,
strategy, you have the war
and for operations,
you have to campaign
to focus on this.
So this is also why it's called
the operational level of war.
Now, to give you some relation
to the numbers,
as mentioned before,
in tactics about 10 men
to 40,000 men.
For World War II on the German side,
usually conducting operations
was an army,
which was about 60 to 250,000 men,
according to Steyr.
And in some cases,
you also use the corps,
which was about 40 to 70,000 men.
This was more exceptional,
this was usually a panzer corps.
And nowadays,
you basically go one level less.
So you would say,
corps is doing this
and sometimes even a division
would do operations.
But again,
we have different force numbers nowadays.
Now, initially, I said
this is mainly focused
at land warfare
and there is a very good point for this
because one air force general,
basically criticized this terminology,
at least for air forces,
very strongly.
Because he said,
it doesn't really make sense.
And I read this quote now.
And he notes,
to an airman,
this is meaningless.
My tactical fighter,
in parenthesis tactical,
flying to Baghdad,
in parenthesis operational,
kills Saddam Hussein,
in parenthesis strategic.
So finally,
in talking about airplanes
and air operations,
I keep as far from these words
as I can.
Airpower is essentially very simple.
Aircraft can range very quickly
over very wide areas
and accurately hit targets
very close to home
or very far away.
Nothing more,
nothing less.
And this is the aspect,
as we said,
time and space,
as Gerhard Gross points out,
is very closely linked,
at least in land warfare.
But as Horner points out,
well,
in air warfare,
actually not.
Because the speed of modern airplanes
is way faster,
the range is higher
and everything else.
So a very different situation there.
And I guess
there could be some argument made
that it also makes sense
for air warfare.
I don't know.
I never thought about this.
Maybe Bismarck can make a comment there
because it would be very interesting.
Now to summarize,
to differentiate tactics,
operations and strategy
on a proper framework,
you need to take a look at
time, space and force.
The higher it goes up,
the closer is your strategy
and the lower,
the closer is your tactics.
And I think you can use this
in your daily life
because you have some decisions
that don't affect,
that have usually a direct effect,
but a very minor one.
This is a tactical decision.
So for instance,
tactical decision would be,
do I go for lunch first
or do I finish this video first?
Yet a strategic decision would be,
do I put out two videos a week
or two videos a month?
Not a direct impact immediately
on my daily life,
but in the long run,
a very different one.
So strategy.
Again, differentiation,
direct, indirect,
immediate, immediate.
Look at these
and the closer you are to direct,
to force and everything,
you're closer to tactics.
The further you are away from this,
you're closer to strategy.
Of course, strategy is both
a product and a process.
So just thinking about stuff
and not doing anything
and implementing none is not strategy.
It's just procrastination.
So very important to
not just daydreaming is not strategy.
Now it's also relative to force size.
Very important.
This also could say usually
when one guy is involved,
usually on tactical level.
Now, and if I look at the different verbs
to break it really down and simplify,
it would be,
tactics is about fighting,
operations is about coordinating,
and strategy is about planning.
One could argue,
OK, operation is about moving,
but I think it's more moving,
coordinating,
it's something both.
And in the end,
I think coordination captures more
than just moving.
And of course,
since operations is quite
a fuzzy term and everything,
you often see tactical operational
and operational strategic as term.
To this expresses why there's this fluidity
and it's still not cut in stone.
Of course, also,
since the force structure
changes all the time,
it's also more difficult.
Now to all my patrons
who voted on this topic,
thank you very much.
Also, big thank you here to Christian,
who sent me the book
Operation Thinking in the German Army,
Phil who sent me
Blitzkrieg the Desert Storm,
and Jack for sending me
Blitzkrieg Legion
and many other books,
which I could put to good use
in this video.
So I hope you enjoyed this one.
Thank you for watching
and see you next time.
