GMBN Duotone Long Sleeve Jersey | Official GMBN Merch Store XS Out of stock shop.gmbn.com/products/gmbn-duotone-long-sleeve-jersey?variant=45675069604115¤cy=GBP&utm_medium=product_sync&utm_source=google&utm_content=sag_organic&utm_campaign=sag_organic&srsltid=AfmBOorJZXuDaHBplkMSlL2upmPHcojteZtImiuXutEyvCAWhXMeUYOSXIM What's better, a 29er or a mixed wheel bike? Owen Coutts aka Owen The Bike Nerd goes for a ride on a full 29" bike and a mixed wheel size of 29" front and 27.5" rear to ask the question which one is better?
MX or mixed wheel sizes is where you've got business up front and party in the back,
and they're becoming more and more popular. Why would you run different size wheels on your bike?
Will it be faster? Will it mess up my geometry? Let's find out if the hype matches reality.
We're going to try and sort fact from fiction and explain everything that you need to know
about running a mixed wheel size setup on your bike if it's even possible. Before we dive into
the tech, I've got a favor to ask, and that's if you can like and subscribe to the channel
and to this video. It really helps us make really good content. Thank you.
Mixed wheel size is new and exciting. Well, it might be exciting, but it's not new. Cannondale
since the 80s ran mixed wheel size bikes. One of their classics, the Beast of the East,
ran a 24-inch rear wheel and a 26-inch front. Specialized in the 2000s had a model called the
Big Hit, a really long travel freeride bike that had a 24-inch back wheel and a 26-inch front wheel.
You can see there's a bit of a theme here. Some say that Specialized was modified because the
head angle was a bit too steep. Another range of bikes that came out in a similar time frame
was Trek's 69er range. These were 29er front wheels and 26-inch rear wheels, hence the name.
There was a whole range of them, but they didn't really, well, get any traction and take off.
On the racing, it's been a while since we've had mixed wheel size, and that's because there was
UCI laws about running mixed wheels, but Danny Hart was probably one of the first that we saw
racing it in around 2019. Are mixed wheels any faster? We're going to do a little experiment
to try and find out. We've got this propane tie, which we can change, thanks to a flip chip,
to run either 29-29 or 29-650. We've got matching wheels. We've got these Reynolds carbon wheels,
and we've got a matching 650B rear version as well, so same width. We're trying to minimize
anything that might be different. Likewise, we're going to run the same rear tire, same width,
same carcass, same model. Obviously, it will be a different diameter because the back wheel will be
different. We've got a track that's got a good variety of steep sections, rocky square edges,
and a really fun variety of enjoyable, engaging trails, just to see what the different ride feel
is. 29-29, run one, here goes. That's 29-29 now. It feels fast, but in a slow, controlled,
slightly muted way. On the steeper sections, yes, I did have interaction. I did have tire buzz,
and it was a bit off-putting, I've got to say, but I've got short legs,
so I think if you've got longer legs, you'd probably not notice. Maybe my body position
wasn't perfect. Maybe I was getting too far back. Maybe I wasn't centered in the bike enough.
Okay, run two, now we've got the 650B rear wheel, the mixed wheel size. Let's see how it goes.
Well, that was really interesting. I didn't think, because we hadn't got much geometry change,
and effectively, on paper, it feels like there's not that much change, but on the bike,
on the hill, there's so much change. There's more ability for me to actually push in. I've
got lots more confidence, even though it felt like the ride is a lot more dynamic, a lot more
poppy, for want of a better word. I guess also I noticed on the braking, it felt,
yes, dynamic is the best word, but I could feel the back wheel braking a lot more,
but it felt like I was still in control of it a little bit more than the 29er rear. Interesting.
I guess you want to know what the times are. Well, before we find out the times,
we've just got to do a bit of nerding. When 29ers first appeared on the scene,
there was lots of arguments and, well, lots of statements from brands saying that they were
faster because of, well, different things with the wheels, and one of them is impedance losses,
and that's because the angle of attack of the wheel, because of the different diameter,
means it can roll over objects better. The other thing is that because of that different diameter,
it has a different contact patch, and because of that, A, it can grip better, but also there
might be less hysteresis. Now, 10, 15, 20 years on from those early 29ers, the science is there.
The data proves that for cross-country riding, they are faster. If you're riding ultra-long
endeavors over rolling terrain where you're looking for efficiency and speed and comfort,
29ers are a really good option. Hyster who? Impedance what? Okay, yeah, these are kind of
slightly weird technical terms, but they are useful to describe lots of things that are going
on. Hysteresis first. Okay, this is the energy losses that happen when the tire is rolling
through its carcass. If you think of the carcass flexing down just here, it's flexing all the time,
and some of that flex is absorbing energy, and how much depends on the carcass and lots of other
stuff. The bigger wheels of 29er, because of this different contact patch, mean that they've got
less losses, and they roll more efficiently. Impedance losses. These are kind of complex,
but 29er wheels, because of their approach angle, so it's a shallower angle, so it means it can roll
over things, means that it's less likely to have impedance losses. A good example of this is a
skateboard rolling along, and the size of the bump that you need because the really small wheel
that's going to have to lift the whole skateboard up, that lifting up, that's the impedance loss.
Now, with a really big wheel, those losses are just less, so a 29er wheel can roll more efficiently.
Since those early 29ers arrived on the scene, where and how we're riding, what we're riding
regularly, has changed radically too, from traditional cross-country to, well, new school
cross-country. Riding has changed radically. We're riding really burly, really steep stuff a lot more
regularly. As 29ers developed and got longer and longer travel, it meant designers were more
challenged. Why? Well, when a bike's got 160 mil of travel, it means that, well, as you might
imagine, the rear wheel is going to move about 160 mil. To design that into a bike with reasonable
chainstay lengths and the one that you're not going to have impacts where the rear tire is
going to interface with either the seat or the seatpost is a challenge. It's not only the bike
design of packaging stuff in a long travel format that's a challenge for 29ers. No, another challenge
can be the riders. DH racers were later to adopt full 29ers, full wagon wheels. One of the reasons
is, well, it's difficult to package a really big wheel and full 200 mil travel that you get on a
downhill bike. The other reason is probably to do with tire buzz, and not tire buzz on the frame,
no, tire buzz on the person. Downhill racers need lots of weight shift to make sure that the wheels
stay on the ground and track. On really steep terrain, you need to get your weight really far
back and quite low. Those shorter stature, well, tire buzz is a real issue and a real problem.
What am I talking about? I'm talking about literally interface between my butt and this
tire. As an example, this rear tire with the tire on and with the wheel all set up is around 745
millimeters. My inside leg is only about 760 millimeters. That only gives me about 15 mil of
clearance, which is not a lot. Actually, on the bike, it will be even less. If you're a shorter
rider and you're riding the gravity side of mountain biking where you're into steep drops
and steep descents and technical stuff where you're having to do radical weight shifts on the
rear, maybe the smaller wheels will be better. Apart from greater crotch clearance, what are the
other advantages or disadvantages of running a 650B or 275 rear wheel with a 29er up front?
Well, there can be really radical geometry changes. Thankfully, this bike, Propain,
has got a flip chip here. It's been designed specifically to work with a 650B rear wheel
or a 29er. When I change this flip chip, it keeps the geometry more or less exactly the same
depending on which wheel and which configuration. If your bike isn't designed for this, you could
void your warranty. You might be able to go wild with offset bushings and maybe angle sets to
change the geometry and work around the changes that the different wheel size will have on the
bike. It's probably not recommended unless the bike is specifically designed for it, like this
one. Different diameter wheels are going to create a different footprint. Even though we've got the
same tire in the same carcass and the same width and they measure up the same, that footprint is
going to be a different shape. That means it's going to grip and roll differently. It's also
going to have a different mass as well. They're going to weigh differently and that's because,
well, the 29er is bigger. There's more carbon, there's longer spokes. That extra mass means
that there's going to be more inertia. It's going to take more energy, so probably more time,
to get up to speed. It will ride differently. Dynamic changes, sideways movements or locking
up a wheel will also feel differently because of that different weight. Purely in the lab,
29ers do roll quicker. I'm saying that because some Swiss scientists about 10 years ago did a
really detailed study for the Swiss Olympic cross-country team that proved that 29er wheels
were faster. That was for cross-country racing and that is racing uphill and downhill, not
really enjoying the downhill and just surviving the climb. It will be a little bit different.
On paper, at least, the smaller wheels, because they've got less mass, should have less inertia.
That means accelerations should be quicker with the smaller wheels. I think once you're rolling,
those differences between the different inertia fields of the different weights of wheels,
well, it doesn't really match up with the reality. Of course, if your specific trails
are really stop and go, then yes, it could make a difference, but for general rolling,
I'm not sure it's going to factor that much. Switching to a smaller, lighter 650B rear wheel
will change the balance between the sprung mass and the unsprung mass. Should you care about this?
Yes, you should. It's quite difficult to describe. Effectively, we want the forces that we want to
absorb to move the suspension system and not the main frame of the bike. Balancing our sprung mass
to our unsprung mass can help this. Otherwise, we're going to ask our suspension systems to do
a lot. The lighter rear wheel should help the suspension. Square edge bumps, 29ers are really
good at tackling these and that's because they've got a reduced approach angle, but suspension
designers and suspension designers that can play with the rear axle path of the suspension system
are really key in helping 650B bikes work almost as well as 29ers. The gearing will change. Now,
I know initially this sounds bonkers because all you're doing is changing the back wheel,
but by changing the back wheel, specifically the rolling out diameter, that's going to change
the gear ratios. It's going to change how far one pedal stroke will take you. It changes all of the
gears as well, so it makes them all slightly lower. It means that your spinny gear will be
slightly more spinny, so hopefully, you'll be able to crawl up even steeper stuff,
but it will make your big cranking out on the fire road gear a little bit less tall. You may
have to go up a chainring size to get the same ratio as you had before.
Wheel stiffness. The rim is the same diameter and these carbon ones from Reynolds should feel
very similar, but what will be different is the spoke length. Longer spokes will flex a little bit
more. Even if we play with tension, there is going to be a different dynamic ride feel.
What do we mean by that? Well, it means that the smaller wheel could be a little bit stiffer,
so it might be nicer to load in turns. It might feel better to push through.
Conversely, the 2901 might be more compliant and actually have less trail chow through. On a
suspension bike, that trail chow might not make much of a difference, but there will be a subtle
different flavor to both wheels. Okay, despite what you might think, whilst we could switch the
rear wheel, it doesn't actually change the wheel base, at least on this bike. That's because we're
using a flip chip, but the distance from the bottom bracket to the rear axle doesn't change.
The wheel base isn't going to change. However, not all brands do it like this. Some brands make
dedicated 275 or 650B rear ends. On those bikes, then there's going to be some more changes to that
dynamic ride feel. It's going to be a little bit shorter, so that might mean it's a little bit more
poppy and a bit more playful on the trail. Conversely, it's also going to be, well,
maybe a little bit less stable at speed because the overall wheel base is going to be shorter.
Like a number of brands, Reynolds allows you to buy either 29-29 wheel set, 275-275 wheel set,
or a mixed wheel size in a lot of its range, which is really nice to have.
Bottom bracket height versus bottom bracket drop. Okay, bottom bracket height is relatively easy.
That's just the height of the bottom bracket off the ground, the BB, bottom bracket, same thing.
Okay, BB drop. This is where the bottom bracket will drop down or where its situation is between
the two wheel axles. Now, on a bike like this, the bottom bracket height when we flip the flip
chip will stay pretty much the same, so the height will be the same, but the BB drop where
that bottom bracket sits between the two axles is going to change, and that will have some dynamic
ride changes. It's probably going to make it feel like it's easier to manual. It's not because we're
shortening the back end at all. It's just we're changing the ratio of where my feet are and where
the bottom bracket is to where the rear axle is, so where I'm pivoting for manuals. Yes, it's
another factor where small changes in BB height slash BB drop can make a big difference to the
ride, and that's where the 650b wheel could come through with the goods.
Okay, that was a lot of nerding. Thanks for sticking with us. You want to know the times.
I'm sure you're keen to know. Okay, well, 29.29 set up. I did a couple of runs beforehand,
so I had warmed up, but yes, 1.41, so 1 minute 41 seconds, which I was pretty pleased with it.
There weren't any major mistakes. I wasn't able to attack that much, and I think, yes, the next
time for me was very surprising, 1.38, 1 minute 38, and that was for the mixed wheel size bike,
so the 650b in the back really did change the ride a lot for me. I felt like it gave me a lot
more confidence. In terms of where I'm getting that confidence from, I'm not really sure. The
bike feels a lot more dynamic. It was easier to lift the front up, so that helped me feel a bit
more confident. I think the other thing, it was easier to manual a little bit, and again, weight
the back wheel, which is hard to describe, especially as it's smaller. You'd think it'd be
a bit more difficult. The other thing I found really interesting is in turns. The bike felt
I could set a course and change it, whereas the 29er was just set on one arc.
It was really interesting. I've got to say, I was really surprised that this bike was quicker.
I think the other factor was that on some of the rollovers, the steeper sections,
with this bike, with the mixed wheel size, I was able to commit a lot more. I was able
actually almost to pre-jump into them, which I've got to be honest, I tried on the 29er before.
You might have seen how I'd gone on the 29, 29 before in Bike Park Wales. It didn't end pretty,
and I think that really knocked my confidence. With more crotch clearance, this bike, for me,
did feel faster. What are your thoughts? Have you tried mixed wheel size? Is it better for you? Is
it quicker for you? For me, and my little legs, I'm a real fan. Right, more riding time.