The US Army’s Universal Camouflage: A Terrible Mistake

Army Analysis
8 followers
5 Video Views·Sep 9, 2024
This is good camouflage. This is bad camouflage. This is great camouflage. What's that,
you don't see anything? Exactly. From 2002 to 2004, the US military invested $5 billion in
over a decade of research developing this camouflage pattern, and the design, aptly
named Universal Camouflage Pattern, quickly became iconic. Anyone who sees it can instantly recognize
it as US Army Camouflage. Which is, well, kind of the problem, because it turns out that UCP
should have stood for Useless Crappy Pattern, because while it looks great on hats and pants
and this actual Amazon listing for desert child soldiers, it wasn't particularly great at,
you know, hiding the adult soldiers from the people who wanted to kill them. According to
one Army specialist, this camouflage pattern was a quote, universal uniform that universally failed
in every environment, like the United Nations Peacekeepers in any international crisis, which
raises two questions—how did we end up with such an ineffective design, and why, exactly, doesn't
it work? For decades, all military personnel had used the standard battle dress uniform,
which looks like this. It worked fine and seemed to do the job, but when Y2K hit,
so did the peak of art-inspired military design that had been crescendoing for decades. As early
as World War II, military designers had been experimenting with optical illusions like cubism
to trick their enemies' eyes more better. The first pixelated, or square-based pattern used
in camouflage was dual-text, which used individual squares rather than blotches of colors that could
each blend into the environment at close range, known as the suit's micropattern, while also
making up a larger pattern that could blend into the background for longer distances, or the suit's
macropattern. In the late 1990s, a military officer named Timothy O'Neill, who some call
the grandfather of modern camo and others call Tim, developed camouflage on his computer using
pixels. It turns out that pixel-based designs act as white noise to the brain. Basically,
because pixel camouflage looks less like nature, the brain becomes less fixated on it and thus
ignores it as part of the background. So, when soldiers are wearing the camouflage, they're more
likely to blend in precisely because their camouflage stands out in the natural environment
like a normal person walking through a New York City subway station. After O'Neill's development,
a lot of military branches started to take notice. As with most military strategies,
the Marines were first in, last out. In 2000, they wanted to duplicate this Canadian camouflage
design known as CADPAT because of its trendy pixelation and striped lapels. But those greedy
Canadians had copyright to the pattern, so the Marine leaders had to make their own,
different-enough version that wouldn't get them sued. After making a trip to Home Depot to look
for paint swatches—that's not a joke, military officials actually went to Home Depot—they
landed on Ralph Lauren's Coyote Brown, presumably in commemoration of the skin tone of the people
they hoped to bomb. Coyote Brown became the centerpiece of two color palettes, one for
forests and one for deserts, the overarching design coined MARPAT for Marine Pattern Camouflage. The
thing is, this pattern, with four distinct colors that made up its camouflage pattern,
worked. MARPAT had undergone a plethora of different prototypes, testing, and development
to make sure that its pixelation actually did its job in a variety of environments before it
was printed on thousands of uniforms. It even became a standard part of the Marine Corps combat
utility uniform that's still in use today, along with rainbow toe socks. Meanwhile, the Army needed
a new camouflage design because they didn't have matching camouflage sets at the time,
so soldiers were basically walking targets on the battlefield—which sucks when you're trying
to avoid getting killed by people trying to kill you. The Army wanted something like the
MARPAT pattern, but because the Marines didn't want the Army stealing their hard-earned survival
rates, the Marines had copyright to their camouflage, and instead of just paying the
Marines to use it, the Army decided to take some creative liberties with their own knock-off design
known as the Universal Camouflage Pattern. But like any knock-off—Dr. Wow, Prongles,
or Ratatouille—it didn't work quite as well as the original. During the process,
they made the decision to eliminate any blacks and browns from the design, arguing that these
colors didn't exist in combat environments, and opted for Desert Tan 500 as the camouflage's
central color. While Desert Tan 500 is really good at sounding cool as hell, it turns out it
was really bad at camouflaging soldiers, especially compared to the Marine-patented Coyote Brown,
which had been the key to making MARPAT so effective. Plus, the Army's overpaid consultants
forgot to consider how shadows would factor into the pattern's design, and to top it off,
they didn't test the design before slapping it on thousands of spongy 19-year-olds and shipping
them to the desert to pay for college. The pattern, named Urban Track, was composed of tan,
gray, and sage green, and soon after it was approved in 2004, soldiers started to notice
its flaws—its macro pattern, or the collective camouflage effect of the whole uniform,
didn't work. The pixels made up distinct blobs of color meant to disguise them, but the problem was,
these blobs were actually too small, and created an effect known as isoluminance, which means the
entire uniform appeared as a visible tan mass, rather than a blitz of colors difficult to
separate from each other. This effect made the camouflage appear flat in a three-dimensional
environment, so from nearly any distance, the camouflage failed to do its job. Given how exposed
the pattern made troops in the Middle East, with its high levels of sand and similarly high levels
of people trying to kill soldiers, Army officials had to go ask Mom to borrow her uniforms—in this
case, Mom being the Marines. So, the Army had to start a new search for a pixelated camouflage
pattern from scratch by 2010, and the UCP design was soon phased out for literally any other
alternative. Since then, Congressional members have been pushing the Department of Defense to
adopt one camouflage set for all military branches, which would theoretically have the
triple effect of saving government money, not getting soldiers killed unnecessarily,
and standardizing camouflaged bikinis across all spring breaks.
And if you'd like to learn more about what it takes to coordinate the world's largest militaries,
have I got a deal for you. Joseph from RealLifeLore's Modern Conflict series details the
world's most pressing conflicts of the last century, like the war in Ukraine, the US invasion
of Afghanistan, and even the Greco-Turkish Cold War, which I bet you haven't heard of much,
and it's only possible because of Nebula. Nebula is a creator-run and creator-owned
streaming platform that we and RealLifeLore and tons of great creators are all part of,
where we can make content free of the YouTube algorithm and content guidelines. Nebula enables
us to produce content that wouldn't otherwise be viable, like our boots-on-the-ground documentaries
Alaska's Silent Summer and The Final Years of Majorao. This content lives only on Nebula,
which lucky for you is less than $15 a year with our Nebula and CuriosityStream bundle deal. By
heading to our link, curiositystream.com.hai, you can subscribe for less than you would for
Nebula by itself, which means you also get access to some of the internet's best documentaries from
the same people who created the Discovery Channel, like The Origins of Stealth, which details the
development of the F-117 Nighthawk and the machinery of war that goes into the real-life
specifics of creating today's modern military technology. All you have to do is click the
button on screen, or go to curiositystream.com.hai to subscribe to both for just $14.79 per year.
