Lecture 10 : Reflections on Sustainability II

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 9, 2024
[Music]
hello everyone this is rajes Gupta and
we are here in the week four or the
final installment of our discussions on
textiles and Allied practices threads of
visual exploration so we have already
been started talking about the issues on
sustainability its relationship ship to
industrialization and colonization so we
will look into some of the important
Concepts which also make us think about
sustainability in a more expansive way
so perhaps I'd start talking about some
of this important aspects such as U
carbon footprint so we hear this idea of
carbon footprint quite a bit and in the
recent times and then in terms of if we
think about what it its relationship to
textile making perhaps in one cent I can
summarize by saying that I mean the
greenhouse gas that is emitted from the
product's life cycle is something that
we understand as carbon footprint and
this idea that it is not just about we
are talking about the making of the
product but then the product's life
cycle so that means that when we are
producing a product and then the entire
time period for in which we are using it
and whatever kind of using of this
product can go on and then what kind of
energy is required for U sustaining it
maintaining it and then once the product
is discarded then what happens to it
does that go back to Nature and how long
does it take to uh sort of disintegrate
and and and it can be used again in uh
it it reaches that state so um this is
the entire life cycle we talk about so
uh sort of like I mean starting from
nature and going back to it so this is
this is something we can think in terms
of what is understood as carbon
footprint that the greenhouse gas
emission from the life cycle of a
particular product can be understood as
carbon footprint of um that particular
product and here we are talking
primarily about
textiles now the other idea is that also
equally important here and that is
perhaps the ecological footprint and
ecological footprint is something in
which we find that the land or water
area that is required for producing
nutrition nutrition for sustaining human
lives energy energy for both production
of objects production of uh different
kind of amenities but also in terms of
supporting the societies and then also
the waste treatment so um ecological
footprint can be summarized as um um we
can think about the mass of land or
water that is required for uh producing
nutrition so when we talk about
producing nutrition we say that that is
perhaps uh that includes Agriculture and
and and um of course like I mean animal
grazing and everything else which which
uh provide nutrition to the human bodies
and that is how we survive and then of
course when we talk about energy then we
talk about both renewable and non
renewable sources of energy and how
those can be used for supporting the
societies and and then also we think
about the waste management and waste
management definitely includes that when
we are discording certain kind of
objects and products what kind of state
they are in are they ready to be thrown
out in the nature or are they require
certain kind of processing and then it
can be sort of you know sent back to the
nature so this are this are some of the
concerns that we find and all those
things can be um considered under this
uh concept of ecological footprint now
uh with that we also find that uh the
ecological footprint is something in
which um the water different kind of
energy sources and different modes of
resources all of those things are used
in different aspects of textile making
so if we think about the production of
textile if I take plant-based fibers for
example cotton so we can think about the
amount of water sunlight then perhaps um
some kind of fertilizer and and
everything else those are required
simultaneously with the human
involvement the human labor for for um
production or cultivation of cotton and
then after the cotton is collected then
it is U gent and then spun and then it
is made into yarn and then all those
things they require a lot of human labor
but also at the same time it might also
require Machinery involvement because um
in a lot of places we do find that how
um even in the handmade textile sectors
spinning and jinning this processes are
um a lot of times they are done by um a
simple uh Machinery setup and and that
that s reduces the um uh human labor in
the process but I mean of course I mean
it it requires um continuous supervision
so so this is this is something we find
that how different
pre-production processes that they
require different kind of energy and and
all of them they certainly go back to
this idea of ecological footprint and
then once the textile is made and if we
are thinking in terms of diet textile
broade whatever it is then different
kinds of energy those will be required
in some textile production for example
diet textile making we see extensive use
of water sunlight those are required and
then also if it requires boiling then we
need firewood or different kind of fuel
for boiling them Etc so this these are
different kinds of energy sources we
certainly require for um um making the
textiles and then when we think about
the textiles when they are used so uh
when using of the textile it certainly
we can we can think about using normal
water but also if you're putting them in
the washing machine then what kind of
energy that that that requires for um
maintaining the textiles for the period
of time when we need it after the
textiles are used when we are discarding
them a lot of times they are also used
as landfills and and um with the with
the growth of urbanization we find that
the landfill is something that has been
evidenced across the globe and and um
this this is this is a way in which we
find that the items and the garbage and
and um of course like I mean all of them
are discarded items the ones which
cannot be processed and and um they are
usually used as this landfill but then
what kind of impact does it make and
then how long does it take for U them to
be integrated reintegrated into um uh
the soil so those are some of the
questions we might think about that when
we talk about ecological footprint so
there are many ways in which we have to
consider that what is the relationship
between textile making so the
pre-production
post-production usage and then after we
discard them so the entire process the
entire life cycle it has a huge impact
um and and we can think about how um the
ecological footprint can be
useful uh concept to think about its
impact in our
lives now with those things we find that
uh designer and Scholar Rebecca Rubin uh
she had uh spoken about this idea of
holistic sustainability and holistic
sustainability is something in which we
be more aware of what kind of
sustainable practices we need to embrace
and and what kind of sustainable
practices perhaps can prioritize for the
growth of our societies so in this case
in terms of the holistic approach for
sustainability reaba Rubens um uh
suggest that I mean we think about
sustainability in much more expansive
terms where ecological and environmental
concerns need to be um
simultaneously considered with
sociocultural aspects as well as
economic sustainability so uh when we
think about this this this idea of
holistic sustainability we be aware that
this is not just about our environment
but there are many different ways of Our
Lives which are all equally affected by
um sustainable or non-sustainable
practices so for example if we think
about some of the materials that we use
for textile making or for um different
kinds of practices we which may include
craft practices and the other prac IES
which result into objects of our daily
usage so if there are renewable um uh
sources for example the ones that come
from biosphere that means like cotton
different kind of plant-based sources
they are the ones which are easy to be U
um um sort of disintegrated and and and
and uh those those are the ones we find
them that I mean they are much more
sustainable compared to the ones which
we extract as like I mean in in form of
mineral resources Etc so for example
what we understand as renewable sources
that I mean something that we use it
goes back to the nature and perhaps like
I mean similar kind of um U things can
come up again and it is renewed over
time it is not something that it is not
irreversible but the ways in which we
perhaps see the use of fuel the use of
coal Etc this this mineral sources and
and those are the ones we find that once
it is used it cannot be generated in um
in the next 500 years or in the next few
thousand years so this is this is
something that we understand as
nonrenewable sources so in holistic uh
sustainability um in in the model of
holistic sustainability we do think
about um this this environmental
concerns the ecological concerns but
also think about a lot of other issues
which are prevalent in our societies so
for example in the craft sector we find
that there are certain aspects about the
mass migration of U um Artisans from one
sector to another perhaps in a lot of
times we find that with the loss of jobs
with the loss of patronage and
opportunities a lot of Artisans they
move from um the artisanal Works to
something that is perhaps uh something
that that that can support their lives
but but then like I mean their skills do
not sustain so for example during my
field work in in Mash patnam in in uh
Coastal Andra Pradesh I have learned
that how the master block makers they
teach block making to um a lot of
youngsters but then a lot of them they
cannot really sustain in the field and
then they eventually go and work as
helpers in SAR Shops and and um in
different kinds of shops and jokingly
the the block makers would say that I
mean that would enable them to sit in an
AC shop or in an AC room for the entire
day but then perhaps like I mean what
all that in the entire day all they can
do is to uh fold and unfold SES or
fabrics and show it to the customers
they can have conversations but there is
nothing they can do with their hands in
terms of when a block maker makes a
block um the kind of Engagement that uh
it requires with the tools and also with
their eyes with their brain so all those
engagement gets completely lost in this
process so if we think about that if the
if someone who's trained in a particular
uh um sector and then the sector sort of
shifts the their workplace
shifts then what are the kind of things
we can consider in that case that if the
person is making more uh economic
capital with that or not that is
something is always a concern for
sustaining lives but also at the same
time perhaps once we think about this
idea of holistic sustainability we can
consider that sustainability is not just
about sustaining Our Lives meeting the
basic or the bare minimum but it is also
about sustaining and nurturing our skill
set sustaining and nurturing our ability
to think to do and to take actions so
those kind of issues are also very much
part of sustaining certain kind of
practices and this is something we need
to always consider that uh in our
discussions about sustainability it is
not just ecology and environment but
then sociocultural sustainability is
highly significant in those terms
now I guess one of the issues that also
comes up for the Crafts People it is
about the unfamiliarity with the global
markets and um this is this is something
that had come up again and again and in
multiple conversations that I had during
my field works with uh printers with
Weavers and different other textile
makers we find them that I mean they
have always spoken about there is a lack
of communication and how if they speak
in the regional languages the languages
which are prevalent in particular
regions but then not knowing English or
not knowing the Norms in which the the
Urban Market or the the multinational
this this um Ecommerce uh platforms they
function so that certainly uh leaves
them out of the opportunities which can
be useful for sustaining their craft
practices also supporting their families
and communities in a better way so this
is something we can also consider that
sustainability should not just include
uh being ecologically environmentally uh
aware it's not also just about thinking
that how um our skills can be used and
not but this is also it puts a
tremendous amount of uh stress on um
certain kind of skill development
certain kind of communication between uh
people perhaps um the ones who are more
aware of the market systems and then the
ones who are perhaps more um sort of um
involved in in the Hands-On artisanal
production so the ways in which we see
that the Traders and and the producers
they have survived in the pre-industrial
Paradigm is something we have to think
about that how this uh communication the
exchanges between communities skill
sharing this kind of activities need to
be more and more prioritized in which uh
perhaps one can learn something from the
other and that is how U the
sustainability of a craft or a practice
can go on further so these are this are
perhaps um there are also um Scopes in
which we can think about that how um the
designer's role can be and we will come
to the role of the designer perhaps in
later in our discussion but but uh this
is this is also something for us to
think about that how um sustainability
or holistic sustainability it is not
just something we we can consider about
being aware of the materials we are
using what kind of energy sources we are
exhausting when we are producing certain
things but it is also in terms of
thinking about the conditions of life
and livelihood of the communities who
produce the communities who get engaged
enged in um circulating product
circulating knowledge and all of us how
we are connected to them so holistic
sustainability must include all these
different kinds of concerns now as I
have mentioned that how uh this this
notion of sustainability that certainly
sort of um takes our um um attention to
a much more expansive platform where we
talk about ecological sustainability in
relation to social cultural and economic
sustainability so we will come to
discuss all those aspects one after
another now uh perhaps another thing we
have to think about when we talk about
uh sustainability in textile practices
and then also its impact on our lives we
cannot ignore the aspect of fashion and
fashion we see that I mean uh this is
this is this is a very interesting
concept which has
uh which has featured in the scholarly
discussions in many different ways so um
in in the in in the much more sort of in
the scholarly way of describing what
fashion is we find that it is usually
been considered as a way of
communication and um it is a way of
communication of our cultural need or
sorry our individual vision and and um
to the society so it is a kind kind of
way in which we can think that I mean
how our individual Vision our aims our
aspirations can be communicated to the
society and it is also a culturally
rooted system or a culturally rooted way
of sort of um communicating this ideas
to to the society so it can operate um
as a as an individual but it can also
operate as something as a as a
collective way of operating now the
thing is that I mean but then when we
hear the word fashion we usually think
about something which is quite the
opposite of this this line of thought so
when we talk about fashion a lot of
times we do think that I mean how
something that is transient which is
very much on time which is very much in
Trend and that is something we find I
mean that is which takes us to the
present moment but then this present is
not something that has always been
consciously connected to the past and
the future even though a lot of times um
the the textile historians the fashion
historians have shown and and have have
established it that how fashion always
returns after a particular point in time
but even after that we find that fashion
is usually something that is understood
as very much being on Trend and being
very much present at this particular
point in time and it is also something
that is understood as
transient that we see so for example we
when we think about of fashion and we
also think and and fashion in relation
to textile making and Manufacturing we
see this idea of the seasonal
connections the the spring collection
Autumn collection etc etc and in which
we find that there are particular kinds
of clothes which are produced clothes
and other textiles which are which are
used by US uh in the interior setup so
uh this this kind of fabrics which are
produced the fabrics and the clothes uh
they are very much in tune with a
particular season they are very much in
tune with something of a very short
period of time and the short period of
time is very important for the
manufacturing um um um the organizations
and that's because that I mean if we
consider something that can be used
again and again for years then there is
not really much scope of producing more
there is not really much scope of mass
production but then uh for for um the
seasonal collection the issue that that
is sort of emphasized is that I mean
particular kind of clothes are required
in particular seasons and that to not
Seasons every year but like I mean in a
season in one particular year so this is
this is something that I mean it's a
kind of a given precondition in which we
find that fashion usually operates in a
Social Circle and um in that sense we
also find that if like the scholarly
definition sort of comes to uh suggest
that fashion is a way of communicating
our individual needs or individual
Visions to the society
but then uh in this case our individual
Visions are actually governed by
particular organizations if um an
organization suggests that this is a
spring summer collection and if we do
not subscribe to that then we fall
behind so this is a kind of idea that we
do not really see all the time that our
individual vision is communicated by
what we prefer but it is also a way in
which we can see that how we can be
aligned with particular Visions which
are already been there in the society so
um this this idea of individuality that
becomes kind of really complicated that
finding individuality by uh aligning
ourselves with um particular
organizations or Brands and which
already have Global repute so this is
this is a way in which we find that
there are inherent contradictions in
this a term fashion perhaps in the ways
in which we see that how it has its
scholarly context but also then how we
see that this this idea of fashion sort
of uh translates into the practices that
that that are um uh prevalent in our
societies so with that I'd also like to
sort of bring our attention back to this
idea of sustainability now when we talk
about sustainability and the definition
that we have looked at so far uh in that
definition we have looked into
sustainability as a way of communicating
between past present and future or being
in the present and then also drawing
from the past and then uh being mindful
about future so in a way we see this
temporal system kind of comes alive when
we think about this holistic
sustainability model but then when we
talk about the season seasons in fashion
a season being a shortlived transient
moment in a particular point in time
which is very trendy but then it might
not return so if this is something that
we find as the seasons in fashion that
is just one temporal moment we are
talking about
so speaking through this this Concepts
we find that the idea of sustainability
and the idea of this U the seasons in
fashion they're quite the opposite in
which we can see it so uh and this is
this is also something we find that u in
in some of the recent scholarship people
have uh uh reached out to different
group of people the scholars have
reached out to different groups of
people and have asked that what kind of
um uh views they have views they hold
for understanding fashion understanding
this idea of seasons and also
understanding this idea of stainable
practices so a lot of times people um
depending on like I mean their um um
background we find that the answers have
also changed in one of the recent um
works we have seen that how um
Scandinavian regions um when the craft
teachers the um uh and of course that um
the the art students when they are asked
about uh what can be their preferences
so people have that that commented upon
um how sustainable practices or perhaps
like I mean the kind of clothes which
can be worn for um an extended period of
time as opposed to the ones which are
just suitable for one season can be
useful but then with the group of people
when when this particular setup changes
then we have also seen that how U the
seasonal collections they get much more
priority so it also says something about
that the consumers are not really
homogeneous across the globe which is a
given fact but then we think that I mean
how our preferences they might also
change with our inclination uh and
Alignment also awareness of particular
kind of design Paradigm and at the same
time that how we are aware of certain
kind of systems of operation so these
are some of the issues we can think
about that how the idea of temporality
is ingrained in the idea of both
sustainability and fashion now thinking
about the different kinds of
sustainability uh first I'd like to
address this idea of ecological
parameters and sustainability that I
mean what is ecological sustainability
how do we think about that so definitely
we do see that I mean ecological
parameters or the ecology and
environment these two terms being almost
interchangeable we find that I mean they
play a big role in terms of
understanding as I have already
mentioned that pre-production of
textiles lifespan of textile at the same
time the afterlife of textiles when they
are discarded and what happens with that
so the ecological parameters they play a
huge role and then how that also impacts
upon sustainability we find that there
are different kind of ecological
condition those are created and those
eological conditions also make a huge
deal of impact on the ways in which
textiles are produced so uh perhaps this
is something we can think about that uh
this when in our discussion we see that
ecological uh um conditions or eological
sustainability and how how that operates
in the field of textile making instead
of giving all of you the different
tables or the account in which like I
mean it affects or not perhaps I will be
taking a different approach I will be
going through certain narratives and and
also give us some of the examples from
the history as well as from the um the
recent past or the Contemporary period
uh to to make us understand about the
relationship between ecology and and and
also textile making some of this aspects
are perhaps already been addressed in
the earlier lecture and the discussions
as well but in this case what we will do
is we will look into them exclusively
from the perspective of um ecology and
and environment so those are the things
we will start discussing and we will
continue the discussion perhaps in the
next lecture thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
