“The content in this video is accurate as of the posting date. Some of the offers may no longer be available.”
Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post. The content of this video is accurate as of the posting date. Some of the offers mentioned may no longer be available.
Advertiser Disclosure: This site is part of an affiliate sales network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites, such as CreditCards.com. This compensation may impact how and where links appear on this site. This site does not include all financial companies or all available financial offers.
Hey, credit warriors, welcome to the show.
And this is a bit of a reaction video for you today, because a couple of weeks ago,
this video came out from The Wall Street Journal entitled Why Banks Bet on Big,
Risky Credit Card Partnerships.
And it is talking about co-branded credit cards, of which there are many on the
market, such as the Bilt credit card, the Apple credit card, and many that aren't
around anymore, as you're going to see later in this video.
So I thought I'd do a little bit of a reaction to that video.
So let's get right into it.
As much as $10 million.
That's how much Wells Fargo is losing every month thanks to this credit card.
So that is talking about the Bilt credit card, which if you don't know, it is a
credit card that allows you to earn Bilt points, paying rent to any landlord.
OK, you can already see that's probably costing banks money.
The $10 million, it comes from a Wall Street Journal article.
That figure comes from their article, which was one of those articles with people
with knowledge of the situation.
OK, according to those people, Bilt has lost as much as $10 million.
Not necessarily every month $10 million, but that's probably their worst month,
my understanding.
Despite high profile failures, these types of credit card partnerships make up 62
percent of the portfolios of the largest issuers in the U.S.
So it is true.
Maybe not for people watching this channel, because I know a lot of our viewers,
they like those credit cards with transferable points, OK, like J.
Sapphire Preferred or whatever.
But the sort of normal consumers in the U.S., a lot of people do have, for
example, the Costco credit card, the Amazon credit card, Walmart credit cards,
et cetera. And that's just because when they're shopping, they get off of the
credit cards and they sign up.
All right. I remember trying to sign up for the Macy's credit card back in the
day and my credit score was so low I got denied.
Brands that have credit card partnerships run the gamut from airlines to
retailers. Yeah, that's right.
And, you know, so they mentioned retailers, but also airlines.
That is such a huge sector of the market, OK, because whenever you go on a flight
these days, they often offer you a credit card and they also offer you a credit
card. If you sign up on the plane, there's normally a better sign up bonus than
you would get on the ground.
OK, it's kind of a sneaky little thing.
And they got you there. You're on the plane.
You got nothing to do.
You might as well sign up for the credit card.
Some of the biggest ones would be, well, obviously the three major carriers, OK,
American Airlines, Delta and United.
You know, American Airlines is with partnered with Citi and they have a credit
card with Barclays. Actually, they have a whole series of cards with both banks.
United is with Chase and Delta is with Amex.
Those two are huge partnerships.
Customers earn rewards, anything from discounts to a free hotel night.
And the banks that team up with brands to issue the cards are looking to cash in
on that loyalty. Right.
So the banks who are issuing like, let's say, Chase issuing the United cards, they
actually have to buy the rewards from United.
OK, so it actually costs them money to do this.
But like it said, in return, they're looking to upsell you to other things.
So if you get a United card through Chase, well, you're in their system then.
OK, they've got your information.
You're using a Chase login to the Chase website to access your card account.
And within that whole process, they can sell you on other things.
Amazon is the brand in the partnership.
Visa is the card network and Chase is the issuing bank.
OK, so that's giving you another explanation of it pretty clearly, actually.
Amazon is the brand.
Visa is the network.
OK, they make money when you actually swipe the card merchant fees.
OK. And then Chase is the car, the bank that actually issues the card.
Whatever revenue is generated from these cards, that is money that's all up for
grabs between the bank and their partner, and they determine how they're going to
split that. That's right.
So in the contracts for these cards, they have to determine what the split is.
And it's not always going to be the same.
And as you're going to see later on in the video, the bigger the brand the bank
partners with, the more demands they're going to have.
OK, it's going to be like, well, you want to partner with us, but yeah, you have to
give us this percentage of the merchant fees or you're not allowed to charge a fee
for this or et cetera, et cetera.
So the bigger brands generally are going to be more demanding and they're going to
have less advantages for the bank.
And that's why partly why it's so risky, especially when you partner with big
brands. In 2022, banks paid merchants an average of 279 dollars for every open
account. Right. So you can see from that, you know, if it's a credit card that
charges a 95 dollar annual fee, but they're paying an average of 279 to the
brand. All right. Let's say the Delta card, they've already you know, they can
have to make up an extra like pretty much 200 dollars on top of charging that
annual fee. Where's that going to come from?
Well, it could come from interest payments paid to the bank.
If people have, you know, balances on their cards or it could come from merchant
fees or other fees such as late fees.
If someone happens to pay late.
Delta made nearly seven billion dollars from its Amex credit card partnership in
2023. And you can see it's very lucrative for the brand.
OK. Delta, in that example, made seven billion dollars from its partnership with
Amex. I'm not sure what Amex made.
I assume they are making money on their Delta cards, but many banks actually
aren't making money on co-branded partnerships.
In the U.S., over a third of general purpose credit cards were co-branded in
2021. That's 173 million accounts in the U.S.
co-brand industry.
That is a lot. 173 million accounts, one third.
Didn't they say 60 percent earlier?
Or was it 60 percent of major banks portfolio?
So I guess including smaller banks.
OK, so it's one third. So it really is a massive, still a massive portion of the
market. Some partnerships carry immense risk.
Wells Fargo launched its splashy partnership with Bilt, a fintech startup, in
2022. All right.
So they're getting into how these partnerships are risky.
And they're already talking about the Bilt card, which is, I guess, sort of the
crown jewel of their reporting, OK, because they had insider insider information on
that. And they came out with an article a couple of months ago about that.
But let's let's see what they have to say.
They started going through this sort of rationale of, well, look, we're going to
get access to a lot of young adults.
You've got tons of cardholders in a short amount of time.
Yeah. So from that, it's it sort of sounds like Bilt actually got a really good
deal. I don't think they would have got that good of a deal if they had done
their co-branded deal with Chase or Amex or any of the really big like the big
four credit card issuers.
But Wells Fargo, it's a little less known in the credit card space, certainly
amongst credit card enthusiasts like the people who watch this channel.
Wells Fargo doesn't really have much of a name for itself except for that card, the
autograph and the autograph journey.
Those cards are actually becoming a little bit more more and more popular now
because they're sort of entering the transferable point space.
They got a few transfer partners and stuff.
But in general, Wells Fargo is still kind of, you know, lower on the list.
And that may be why they were willing to accept terms with Bilt, which itself is
not a huge company.
OK, it's a startup.
It's still relatively small.
But why Wells was willing to accept terms with them that perhaps were not in
Wells' favour because they viewed it as a chance to get access to a sort of
millennials or young people, Gen Z or whatever, and, you know, make a lot of
upsells to other Wells Fargo accounts.
But did it work?
I'm not so sure.
The bank is paying Bilt $200 for every new account.
It's also making separate payments every time the card is used to pay rent, which is
what the program is focused on.
Right. So Wells has to pay them like a sign up fee every time a card is opened.
OK. And that's kind of similar to, you know, when an influencer like myself sells a
credit card. Like if you click the link below, there's normally a fee paid to us.
OK. Wells has to pay a fee to Bilt because Bilt's name is being used to market the
card. But then they've got other splits of income.
So, for example, Wells is picking up the bill, all those merchant fees that have to
get paid to, I think in this case, it's MasterCard and a few other companies that
deal with the actual swiping the card, the actual payment, you know, Bilt doesn't have
to pay that. Wells Fargo has to pick up the tab, like a 2% of the transaction or
something like that, and pay those merchant fees when rent is paid with the card.
And that is how Bilt is able to allow you to pay rent using that credit card without
any transaction fees.
So basically, Wells Fargo is paying that whenever you, you know, pay rent with your
Bilt card and you earn rewards.
Don't forget you're earning rewards as well.
You're earning one Bilt point per dollar on your rent payment.
So you should be thanking Wells Fargo for that.
The internal projections that Wells Fargo made as to how consumers would use this
card turned out to be wrong.
That's right. So Wells Fargo at the beginning, they projected that people would pay
their rent with the card, but then they would actually carry a balance and way less
people. I'll put the stats on screen.
We can find it in the article, but way less people carried a balance on the card than
Wells Fargo had projected.
OK, because I think most people, you know, they may carry a balance if it's for sort
of luxury items that they buy one month and they pay it off over a few months.
But rent payments tend to be something that people really build into their budget,
whether it's rent or mortgage.
I know for me, that's kind of like the base transaction each month in my budget.
OK, rent payment, car payment.
Those are the things that I cannot, you know, borrow to pay.
All right. They're like built into the budget each month.
I mean, I advocate paying off credit cards every month anyway so that you don't pay
any interest at all.
But even more so with like rent and mortgage, it's the one kind of set in stone
thing that you pay it with, you know, say you're using the built card, you pay your
rent with it. Boom.
You transfer money from your bank to pay that off.
It's like very, very clear.
And I think Wells Fargo didn't anticipate that people would be so disciplined with
that. And then also you do have to use the built card five times a month to earn any
rewards at all. So I'm sure people are using it five times a month to get the rewards.
But those are probably small purchases with many people.
They're probably mainly using it for rent, using it for you, you know, for dining
purposes, dining purchases on rent day because it's double points on the first of
every month, maybe a few other purchases to get the five and then maybe they're putting
it away for the rest of the month.
So it was not what Wells Fargo anticipated.
And now the Wall Street Journal goes into a few other examples.
Let's check it out. Apple and Goldman Sachs announced the Apple credit card in 2019 to
great fanfare. Balances on the card grew to over eight billion dollars.
So that one, I mean, that's actually promising.
Eight billion dollars in balances on the cards, which means that presumably interest
was being collected by their banking partner, which was Goldman Sachs.
Goldman Sachs accepted unusual terms from Apple.
One of the risks here is when it's the big companies, you know, you want to partner
with me and you have to deal with my terms.
Yeah, that's right. That's what we said, isn't it?
Partnering with the really big companies, OK, the Apples, etc.
They make you agree to certain terms and some of the terms with the Apple card
partnership, from my point of view as a credit card YouTuber, credit card reporter,
were pretty ridiculous.
Agreeing to Apple's terms, like not charging late fees or selling customer data, meant
losing valuable income streams.
So, yeah, with that, I mean, not charging late fees.
A late fee is standard.
I've never paid a late fee because I always pay on time.
But if you do pay late, I mean, it's your fault.
You paid late. Why?
Why is not charging a late fee a selling point for a card?
Right. You're not. It's not a good habit to pay late.
It's to be honest, it's good if there's some kind of forfeit, some kind of fee for
it. So I don't really rate Apple's not charging late fees as a selling point of the
card at all. And obviously it eliminates a revenue stream for Goldman Sachs.
You know, another risk is when you have a merchant partner that is insisting on most
of the cardholders getting approved.
Then we have what she was saying about Apple insisting that most cardholders should get
approved, which led to the Apple card actually approving people with subprime credit
scores. And that's definitely an issue for Goldman Sachs because those people are way
more likely to default and actually not pay it back at all.
And it goes to collections. And, you know, Goldman tries to recoup some money by
selling it to collection agencies for pennies on the dollar, but it's really a fraction
of the money they borrowed. And then, you know, those people just don't pay it back.
So the Apple card is another one that could be at risk.
You know, Goldman doesn't want to renew their partnership.
They actually want to get out of the consumer lending space.
So that's another one, you know, like the Wells Fargo built card.
That's another one that might not be around in a few years time or it could switch to a
different issuer. In May, Walmart and Capital One ended their exclusive credit card
partnership several years before the contract was slated to end.
Yeah, so that's an example of one that actually has already ended.
The Capital One Walmart partnership.
The decision came after Walmart sued Capital One in 2023, alleging that the bank
didn't meet certain terms of the contract.
It probably wasn't working out well for Capital One, I'm guessing, although that
mentioned that it was actually Walmart that sued Capital One, but maybe they weren't
meeting terms because they weren't making enough money or something and they wanted
to get out of it. I'm not totally sure with that one, but it was ended.
The economics of these partnerships tend to favor the brands.
In all likelihood, you know, two thirds or three quarters of the total revenue that's
generated by this will go to the brand partner.
That's right. So kind of a conclusion of this video is that these partnerships generally
favor the brand. Like that guy said, two thirds to three quarters of the revenue
generated goes to the brand partner.
You've also got then the network like Visa, MasterCard, Amex, et cetera, taking a
portion and actually what's left for the issuing bank isn't as much as you would
think. So it's definitely a problem.
But, you know, are there any benefits for the bank?
It brings in customers who the bank might not otherwise have.
All of this equals what?
More customers, more purchase volume equals more revenue.
In conclusion, that is the benefit for the bank.
It's really like she said, bringing in customers they wouldn't otherwise have and
then selling them other products.
Maybe they open a checking account, maybe they open another different credit card with
the bank that's more lucrative, et cetera, et cetera.
And if that all balances out, it doesn't matter if, say, the bill card makes a loss
or the Apple credit card makes a loss, et cetera.
But with Goldman Sachs getting out of the consumer lending space altogether anyway,
they don't have anything to upsell Apple card holders, too.
So I predict that one really will end.
The Apple card will probably move to a different issuer or just get cancelled.
And, you know, we've seen this before as well.
Well, obviously, the Capital One Walmart card ended this year.
But what about the Uber credit card?
You remember that one from a few years ago?
Partnership with Barclays?
Well, that was just too good.
I'm guessing it was costing Barclays too much money.
And that is another one that just ended and doesn't exist anymore.
So I think it's probably, you know, only the really big ones are actually going
to be lucrative for the issuing banks.
Thinks Costco, think, you know, ones where they have had reasonable
negotiations on the actual terms of it.
Apple is really such an outlier.
It's not a financial company.
OK, there are probably things that they don't really understand and they don't
realize that it's not going to be a lucrative long term partnership if they
don't allow late fees, over the limit fees, et cetera.
These are all things where the issuing banks should be able to make some money
on. So I think it was a great piece of reporting by The Wall Street Journal and
certainly very interesting.
And it certainly makes you think about these partnerships.
Some of them will obviously continue, but there are always going to be
co-branded cards that just prove too expensive and are discontinued.
I think the built one, it's certainly like we've seen with them cutting
benefits. You know, rent day is now limited to 1000 extra points that you can
earn. It used to be 10,000 points with 1000 extra points.
It's almost not worth it.
You can't really get a significant number of points with the built card anymore.
But obviously, if you are a renter, it is really still worth it for you.
So the credit card industry, from our point of view, it's always changing.
There's always sweet spots.
And if you're a renter, you might as well have, you know, capitalized on those
sweet spots with built.
And now maybe the card is being devalued.
It's not as good anymore.
We're going to move on to the next thing.
And normally when cards are first launched, that's when they are at their best.
OK. And then as the years go on, the banks want to make money from them.
So they have to cut benefits and then we move on to another card.
Maybe we'll still keep those cards, use them sometimes for certain things.
But our new, you know, one that's earning us loads of points and rewards for free
travel is going to be a different one.
Anyway, guys, let me know what you think.
Leave your comments below.
Also, if you are interested in any of the credit cards I recommend on my show, there
are currently some cards out there that have great welcome bonuses.
For example, the Chase Inc.
Business Preferred, 120,000 points, OK, worth $1,500 in free travel at least.
Then you got the IHG Rewards Premier card.
They're currently offering five free nights at IHG hotels as their welcome bonus as
well. I will put links to both of those cards and a few others below for you to learn
more about. If you want to support our show, using links to learn more about these
cards is a great way to support us at no additional cost to yourself.
Please subscribe to the channel if you knew.
We'll see you next time. Bye bye.