Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell said on Friday “the time has come” for the U.S. central bank to cut interest rates as increasing risks to the job market left no room for further weakness. Powell said that a slowdown in the labor market is “unmistakable,” and that “the downside risks to employment have increased.”
Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell delivered a high-profile speech this morning at an annual
conference of central bankers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. Joining us now to discuss is Jeffrey
Tucker, senior economic columnist for The Epoch Times and founder and president of the Brownstone
Institute. So, Jeffrey, from what you heard, is the U.S. Central Bank worried about the economy?
I think they're more worried than they've admitted. Jerome Powell a few months ago
hinted that there were problems in the jobs figures. But this past week, we got some
clarification on what that could mean. And we got downward revisions that amounted to 818,000
jobs that ended up being phantom jobs. They seem to be there, but weren't actually there. And when
you add those revisions to the previous revisions, we're looking at 1.2 million jobs that we thought
were there that are not actually there over the last two years. So that changes things
substantially because we've not had much in the way of output increases. And then once you fix
the inflation figures for what's really on the ground, what people are actually spending is
versus what the Bureau of Labor Statistics is reporting, you've got strong recessionary
trends that have been persistent now for years, but relatively not reported very well. So Powell
is extremely aware of this and is looking for ways to use what powers he has to bolster the
macroeconomic environment before the recession becomes unbearably obvious.
So I don't want to put words in your mouth, but are you saying the Federal Reserve believed that
the official job numbers that we're getting is actually overstating the job market?
That's for sure. And he's known this. In fact, he hinted this back in March. He's known this
for a lot longer than we've known it. I mean, actually, economists who have been looking at
the jobs numbers now for two years have noticed something has been off because there's been this
growing divergence between the establishment report and the household survey. And we've
never seen that before. So we knew that something was wrong. Powell certainly knew this. So he's
been preparing for a while. But, you know, the problem here is that the one tool he has really
remaining in the Fed's arsenal is the setting of the federal funds rate, which is the bank rate
that the Fed lends to banks. And then that influences the yield curve. The problem
with that, and yes, you can lower rates and that does spur economic activity. The problem is that
it can kick off another round of inflation. And he's profoundly aware of this. We have experienced
this back in the 1970s, where it seemed like inflation was almost entirely conquered. The
Federal Reserve lowered rates to prevent the recession and then kicked off a second wave.
So that's the great danger. So, you know, you are faced with this problem and Powell's very aware
of this, that you might have to face this trade-off. You know, you can lower interest
rates and hope to prevent an aggressive recession. On the other hand, you are pumping out more
credit to keep the casino going and risking restarting inflation again. So this is a terrible
problem for Powell. He's not unaware of this. But these kinds of trade-offs are extremely difficult
for central bankers to make this late in the game. He's got a balance sheet that he is still
worsening all the time. He's very aware of that. A lot of this started becoming a problem in 2020
and that problem has not gone away. Okay. I mean, from what you're saying,
it seems like Powell is between a rock and a hard place. So, I mean, if there's a way out,
what would that be, in your opinion? Well, I think the way out is something that in American
politics nobody really wants to talk about. I think we have to be tolerant of a period of austerity.
We're going to have to tolerate these recessionary conditions and see where that leads us. The last
time that the US economy has made, I should say, the Federal Reserve and policymakers made that
decision to be tolerant of recession was back in 1981 and 1982. And that was 40 years ago,
more than 40 years ago now. And since that time, the Fed has always said they're going to stop the
recession. But I think in this case, they're going to have to tolerate the recession or risk
firing up another round of inflation, which would be truly devastating. I don't think that people
can handle any more of this declines in the purchasing power of the dollar. It's been
devastating, far more so than the Bureau of Labor Statistics admits. And you know this,
and your listeners all know this. We're out there shopping. We've seen the prices of appliances,
and food, and insurance. And it's nothing like what the official data says. So another round
of inflation would be quite devastating and have some grave political ramifications.
If the Federal Reserve really does embark upon a rates-lowering program, I don't believe that
it could ever be enough to repair the structural problems in the manufacturing sector we're
starting to see, much less fix up the jobs markets. I don't think that it's possible
they could do it. And the problem is that in six to eight months from now, we could start seeing
a re-acceleration of inflation across the board. And that would be the worst possible outcome.
So that's the risk as far as Powell's is concerned.
Okay, so let me focus on one point here. So inflation is simply a matter of supply and
demand. We're expected to get a 25 basis point rate cut in September. You don't think that will
push up demand so much so just with one rate cut that it's going to give inflation a surge, right?
No, it's not enough to make any real difference. It will make a psychological difference.
Mainly, the effect of that will be on financial markets. But keep in mind, though, that
I think we're now probably six months old in the expectation that we're going to get a 25 basis
points cut in September. I think that's long been known and it's already priced into financials.
So I don't think by the time it actually happens, it's going to make any difference whatsoever. In
fact, it could have the opposite effect. We often see this in financials that the expected event
is a buy opportunity and the event itself becomes a sell opportunity. There's nothing
that Powell can do to stop that. But in terms of a real economy, in terms of bolstering labor
participation or stopping the bleeding of jobs in business and professional services and
manufacturing, these rate cuts are not going to do it. All right, Jeffrey, so much information
to parse through here. Thank you very much for your insight. It's my pleasure. Thank you.