Transmission of the Plato Atlantis Myth from Solon | Randall Carlson - Kosmographia Clips 004.3

Solon of Athens
1 follower
Others who do not consider Plato's narration to be an invention
persevere in trying to interpret it in a way which would make it possible
to link it with the already explored archaeological sites.
Thus some of them contend that none other than the island of Crete
is Plato's Atlantis, claiming also that Greeks used the name
of the Pillars of Hercules mentioned by Plato, not for what is now called the
Strait of Gibraltar, but for some rocks which were situated
on the way from Athens to Crete. And I think that's where we ended it last week.
So then, because that's probably the most popular
of the ideas now, that if Plato had any literal idea in mind,
or if there was a literal or actual history to Atlantis,
or the idea of Atlantis, it was really the destruction of Minoan Crete.
Or a variant on that, the destruction of the island of Terra
by the eruption of Santorini. Are they on the island of Santorini?
The volcano Terra. So then he goes on to say that given such
an interpretation it becomes imperative for them to bring the
date of the vanishing Atlantis given by Plato
in line with the time of the decline of the Minoan civilization
established by archaeologists and link it to the explosion of Terra on Santorini.
Hence is given rise, rise is given to the hypothesis,
that the span of time between the vanishing of Atlantis
and the conversation between Solon and the priest is actually
10 times shorter, and that the mistake was made either when Egyptian priests
were copying the sacred records, or because Plato himself, like all his
contemporaries, had little sense of time and dating.
I don't know, I find that to be a bit condescending.
Yeah, a bit condescending and a very questionable
assumption. A bunch of savages don't know how to count time.
Yeah, that savage Plato doesn't know how to count time, right.
Even though, he goes on to, this author goes on to say, and obviously lower sea
level is taken, it can be seen that in the area of the
present Azores and Canaries, which are most often pointed to as the
remains of the sunken Atlantis, there had been no size of a land.
So what he's doing here is he's echoing
the book Atlantis Factor Fiction and the few other
articles and papers that came out purporting to
to say that there was no geological basis for any sunken landmass in the
mid-Atlantic Ocean. So my point last week was that, and just
like he's making here, if coming up to those late 60s and 70s in
this shift when oceanography and marine
geology really became a thing, this is when you saw this shift where
previous to that most of the stories, books,
and things about Atlantis put it in the mid-Atlantic,
obviously and naturally because it's so clear that that's where Plato was
pointing, right? Post, say 1978, after Atlantis Factor
Fiction, that's when you see the Atlantis
researchers going all over the world, picking out this place or that place
that in one detail or another does not conform to Plato's
narrative, and so they have to make these assumptions that, well, no, he really meant
this when he said that kind of thing. Whereas I say, no, let's just go back to
the original, but here this Russian
author does make an excellent point here. He says, and this was the word that
was used in Plato's accounts, the word nasos.
Nasos probably would be
none, epsilon, sigma, omicron, sigma, as I'm guessing would be the spelling of it.
I have the Greek back there on my shelf and I could look
it up, but the point is, any SOS,
yes, in the Greek, so in the original it would have been none,
it would either have been an epsilon or an eta in the second place,
sigma, omicron, sigma. The Greek word nasos,
or nasos, used by Plato, quite unambiguously is translated as
island, and I have no reason whatsoever to assume that once upon a time it could
have had another meaning as well. In the same vein, the Latin word insula
does not seem to allow other interpretations.
So is it possible to equate that area of land in the west of Europe with Plato's
Atlantis? I believe it is, and there are two possible
explanations of why the word, which means island,
is used for something that actually was not one.
So here he is, he's admitting that Plato used the word for island,
he's then putting Atlantis in northwestern Europe,
and comes up with his explanation for why
the word nasos, which means island, which was used by Plato,
was actually meant something else. Okay, so what I'm saying here, my point being,
is we could go through all of these various accounts,
right, that deviate in one detail or another, or multiple details from
Plato's account. Now, the question I would ask is, how far
can we deviate from it where we should even be
thinking, why are we calling this Atlantis?
Right, they're doing mental gymnastics to try to get some other place because
this other book, the Fact or Fiction, and this geologist basically said it's
geologically impossible for it to be in the Atlantic, and
so everybody starts doing backflips and cartwheels trying to put it somewhere
else, right? Exactly, backflips and cartwheels,
that's what we've been seeing ever since the 70s, basically.
But yet, here is the opening
quote from Timaeus, and this is Critias talking now because he's the one who's
relating the tale to the Socratic Forum there in
Athens. Then listen, Socrates, to a strange tale
which is, however, certainly true. So right there, right at
the outset, we're standing, this is a true story,
as Solon, who was the wisest of the seven sages, declared.
So he was a relative and a great friend of my grandfather
Dropidas, as he himself says in several of his poems, and Dropidas told Critias,
my grandfather, that would have been Critias,
Critias the elder, who then told it to his grandson,
Critias the younger, who is now presenting the tale. So that's the
sequence there from Solon to Dropidas to Critias the elder to
Critias the younger. Now this is being told in the Socratic
Forum. That's where Plato hears it and writes it down.
And so for those people, all of those people were very,
they had high standing, it's like citing scientists.
Yes, yes. So these days they can be like, well, those guys are just
Greek philosophers or whatever, but back then they're like, no, these are the most
respected. Yes. Yeah, okay. That's where I crossed it.
Those guys were highly respected in their time and that's why citing them is
a big deal and saying this is a true story.
Yes. Okay. So we go back to Solon in his sojourn in Egypt, where he heard the
tale from Sonchus or Sonchus, the elderly priest,
elderly Egyptian priest, and this is generally going to be
around roughly 600 BC, right? So we can say, again, roughly
11,600 years from Solon's time to our
our own time. He goes on to say that there were of old great and
marvelous actions of the Athenians which have passed into
oblivion through time and the destruction of the
human race. And one in particular, which was the
greatest of them all, the recital of which will be a suitable
testimony of our gratitude to you and also a hymn of praise true and
worthy of the goddess which may be sung by us at the festival
in her honor. So that was one of the things that they
would have these festivals and they would
they would recite these poems and these poems would be these epic tales
that had been handed down. And again, this is the Egyptian priest speaking to
Solon? Yes, this is the Egyptian
priest speaking to Solon. Right. And people might go, well, you know,
hearsay, blah, blah, but see what people, a lot of the people who don't
understand about how knowledge was transmitted is it was
an oral tradition. Yes. And the way those oral traditions work
is you learn rote. Right. You become a storyteller. You have to
learn those stories perfectly because the idea is you don't
change a single detail. Right. Because if you change a detail
here, somebody, two or three or four hearings
subsequent, it's going to change another detail.
And then eventually, you know, what's the game we used to play when we were kids?
You'd sit in a circle and whisper in the ear.
Right. What do they call that? There's a name. That's what I thought was called.
What was it? Telephone. Telephone, whatever. Right. Right. Right.
But the point here is that, you know, you're transmitting from the
priest, right, now to Solon, that's one transition,
to Dropidas, Critias the Elder, Critias the Younger. So you're looking at
basically five transitions between presumably
highly intelligent men who would have been able to remember the details and
pass on pretty much exactly what they heard.
Right. So already trained in this idea. Yeah. In one of the quotes I read last
week, they were speculating, well, that there was a,
that the story got, you know, all blown out of proportion
in the telling from the priest to Plato. But I would say that that's highly,
highly unlikely to have happened amongst that,
you know, amongst that chain of individuals there
from Dropidas to Socrates. So then Socrates says to Critias, well, very good.
And what is this ancient famous action of which Critias spoke?
Not, again, here, not as mere legend, but as veritable action,
yeah, of the Athenian state which Solon recounted.
Then Critias replies, I will tell an old world story
which I heard from an aged man. For Critias was,
as I said at that time, nearly 90 years of age.
Now the day was that day of the Apertura,
which is called the registration of youth, at which, according to custom, our
parents give prizes for recitations. And the
poems of several poets were recited by us boys, and many of us
sang the poems of Solon, which were new at the time, see? So that was his
introduction. If Solon had only, like other poets, made
poetry the business of his life, and had
completed the tale which he brought with him from Egypt,
which he didn't do, and when people read Critias,
you'll discover that when the decision is
going to be made to destroy the world and the gods get together for their
conference, you're like, okay, now what happens? Boom,
the tale ends right there. It's a very frustrating,
yeah, it's very frustrating. So then Socrates says, tell us the whole
story, and how and from whom Solon heard this veritable
tradition. So once again, you know, veritable
meaning this true story. Yeah, so all throughout the narrative,
it's emphasizing, no, this is veritable action. It actually
happened. It's true, right? So you cannot, from the
narrative itself, say, oh, well, no, it's just meant
allegorically, and not, you know, not literally,
because, you know, the tale itself reinforces the idea that it is
literal. So yeah, so
anyways, so when Solon goes to Egypt, I'm going to jump ahead a little in the
story to get to kind of the essence of the thing here.
So thither came Solon, who was received by them, that is the
Egyptian priesthood, with great honor. And he asked the
priests who were most skillful in such matters
about antiquity, and made this discovery that neither he nor any other Helene
or Greek knew anything worth mentioning about the times of old.
On one occasion, when he was drawing them on to speak of antiquity,
he began to tell about the most ancient things in our part of the world,
about Fronius, who was called the first, so this was kind of the Greek Adam, and
about Niobe, and get this, and after the deluge to
tell of the lives of Deucalion and Pyrrha,
and he traced the genealogy of their descendants and attempted to reckon
how many years old were the events of which he was speaking,
and to give dates. Thereupon, one of the priests,
who was of a very great age, said, O Solon,
Solon, you Helenes are but children, and there is not an old man among you
who is not a Helene. Solon, hearing this, said,
what do you mean? I mean to say, the old priest replied, that in mind you are
all young. There is no old opinion handed down
among you by ancient tradition, nor any science
which is hoary with age, and I will tell you the reason for this.
There have been, and will be again, many destructions of mankind
arising out of many causes. The greatest have been brought about by the agencies
of fire and water, and other lesser ones by innumerable other causes,
which reminds me of the old English proverb
that says, fire and water have no mercy.
And this is where it really begins to get interesting now.
The old priest goes on to say, there is a story
which even you have preserved, that once upon a time
fated the son of Helios, having yoked the steeds of his father's
chariot, but because he was not able to drive
them in the path of his father, burned up all that was upon the earth,
and was himself destroyed by a thunderbolt.
Now this has the form, it has the form of a myth, but really
it signifies a declination of the bodies moving around the earth,
and a great conflagration of all things upon the earth,
recurring at long intervals of time. So he's laying it out right there, the
declination of bodies basically orbiting in space around the
earth. Yeah. So I mean he's, and by invoking the
myth of Phaeton, the myth of Phaeton is clearly
an extraterrestrial encounter.
