Republican presidential nominee and former President Donald Trump sat down with billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk on the latter’s X social media platform for a two-hour interview on Monday evening. However, technical problems delayed the start of the event for more than 40 minutes.
Joining in our panel, Andrew Sellebak, social media professor at the University of Florida
and Mark Markois, political strategist and former presidential campaign policy advisor.
Thank you very much, both of you, for joining us.
Let me start with you, Andrew.
So from a social media strategy point of view, what did you make of Trump and Musk's use
of space, X spaces, that is, to host this interview?
Well, I mean, you have to look at it from the perspective of we knew what this kind
of environment was going to look like from DeSantis having done his sort of presidential
rollout, and it was kind of the same thing.
We had technical issues.
Now, were those technical issues because the space was being attacked, there being a cyber
attack on it?
Is it that the space's area still isn't just ready for prime time?
That's unclear.
And then you have the fact that, you know, if you look at media coverage of it right
now, literally doing a Google search, it almost seems like one reporter wrote the story, the
recap on this interview, and then it was just published in every media outlet.
And it's not good.
And Bart, as well, let me get your takeaways.
What are your main takeaways from this conversation yesterday?
I think the most important thing to keep in mind is that the reason that he went on X
is that he does not feel like he can get a fair hearing in the mainstream media, and
he wants to reach out to a diverse audience.
If he goes on Fox News or Newsmax or One American News, those are channels that are traditionally
associated with Republican voters, with Trump voters.
And he'll be preaching to the choir, and nobody will know that he said it.
If he goes on traditional media outlets, the more mainstream media outlets, they will not
give him a fair chance to say what he wants to say.
Elon Musk said, this is not an interview.
It's a conversation.
We want to get an insight into you, into who you are.
And if you see the reactions to it from all around, you see efforts to curtail free speech
coming from many, many different directions.
And Andrew, let me just add to what you said earlier.
The interview was actually delayed by more than 40 minutes due to the difficulties.
Notably, X spaces previously suffered similar setbacks when it struggled to handle the volume
of users tuning in for Governor Ron DeSantis' presidential campaign.
But this time, Musk blamed a massive cyber attack.
Andrew, do you think it was a DDoS attack that caused the technical issues?
I mean, we can take Musk at his word.
We can maybe look at, again, the previous example when you had a lot of people coming
into this particular aspect of X when DeSantis made his announcement.
What I think is that Musk is obviously kind of pushing this one part of X, but I think
probably would have been more useful, more valuable, would have been a video sit down,
just have the video done.
If you look at the popularity of sort of Tucker Carlson bringing his show to X, Musk pushing
for other people in the past, like Don Lemon, to have a show on X.
Having that sort of video sit down, I think probably wouldn't have promoted this kind
of thing that's on X, but probably would have been overall something that the audience could
have watched.
They could have watched it in bits.
You could have cut it up.
And that video component, I think, would have been much more helpful for this than using
just an audio only.
So Bart, you mentioned this earlier, but let me have your comments just laid out plainly
for us.
What were the biggest differences in Trump's conversation last night compared to with
interviews with legacy media outlets?
Well, he essentially went through his campaign platform.
It was a chance for him to give a presentation, the content that's very similar to the content
he gives at rallies.
And it all traces back to the 20 points that he released during the Republican National
Convention.
Seal the border, deport criminals, deport illegal aliens, improve the economy, lower
the price of food, lower the price of energy, drill for more oil and gas, expand every possible
kind of energy production, and increase American liberty, protect freedom of speech, get men
out of women's sports and out of women's spaces.
All of the things that he talks about.
And it gave him a chance to go into that without being interrupted and confronted
and attacked throughout the conversation.
And this might be the first time that a lot of people have heard his platform and what
it is that he's trying to do.
They've heard attacks in ads and from surrogates for the campaign, for the Harris campaign
against him, attacking all kinds of straw man issues.
But when people hear him say, well, what I really want to do is put more money in your
pocket, I don't want to tax tips.
I don't want to tax tips for anybody.
I want people to be able to keep the money they earn.
And I want to make groceries less expensive.
I want to make gasoline less expensive.
I want to make us safe.
I want to stop World War III.
People will hear that and say, oh, is that what he wants?
I need to check into this and see if all of this is true.
Okay.
So, Andrew, as a social media professor, in your expertise, do you think Trump's use of
X yesterday, did that appeal to younger voters?
Well, I think, you know, you've got, again, two audiences, the people that are actually
on X and the people that are on X and will listen to these clips.
And then you have an entirely separate audience of people who aren't on X and people who won't
listen to these clips on X.
And again, if you just go to Google, and we could have an entirely different conversation
about Google and how they are impacting the election.
If you go to Google and you do a search of Trump-Musk, it is just article after article
after article that says how bad this was, how terrible it was for all different reasons.
Even Musk literally put out on X just a couple of hours ago the exact same thing of having
screenshots just showing how all the mainstream media, the sort of traditional elite mainstream
media is saying the exact same things.
And that's what you're going to get much more people who are going to actually see than
are going to listen to the clips from this audio only interview that Musk did with Trump.
And I think that's where, again, there's a lot more problem, because if you had video
clips, if you had video of this, that's much more shareable, that's more digestible.
It's much more of a way for the audience to interact and get that information.
And I think this, again, was sort of Musk pushing, again, this thing that's on X that
I would say 99.9% of X users and even a larger percentage of people across the board just
don't use and aren't necessarily interested in.
But again, whether it was with DeSantis and his announcement that he was running or, again,
this, I just don't know if this is the right platform that could have done it when video
could have been so much stronger.
All right, Bart, last question goes to you.
What are your thoughts on the Harris-Walz campaign's response to the interview with
Musk and Trump yesterday?
60 seconds.
Yeah, again, they're focusing on trying to curtail speech.
Walz has a record of having said that the First Amendment should not cover hate speech
as he defines it.
It should not cover it should not cover misinformation as he defines it.
You know, if speech is popular, it doesn't need to be protected.
You have the UAW filing a lawsuit trying to attack Trump and Musk for words, for words
that they said, trying to curtail speech.
You had a Washington Post reporter acting, you know, it's a little extreme to call him
a surrogate for the Harris campaign, but he's carrying their water for them, asking the
White House, couldn't you do something to stop this conversation between Musk and Trump?
Their whole approach has been to attack the fact that the event happened and to attack
everything that was said rather than engaging on the issues.
Even while Kamala Harris is taking Trump's issues, I've got a friend who jokes pretty
soon she's just going to save time and endorse Trump because that's that that's more efficient
than just stealing his issues one issue at a time.
All right.
Terrific insight today.
Both of you, Andrew, Bart, thank you very much.
Thank you.