Joining us now for perspectives on
Trump's meeting with Xi is David Jang,
host of China Insider on YouTube. David,
thanks for joining us. Um, I want to get
your initial thoughts on yesterday's
meeting. There's so many different
directions to go in and overall, what
what did you think?
>> Yeah, well, I said the last time I was
on that this was uh optimistic in the
sense that both sides came with a
framework and they seem to have left
with what was agreed on in those
frameworks. Uh the key ones obviously
fentinel. Uh again, if the CCP goes
through with their promise on cracking
down on fentinel precursors, that's
going to be something to watch for in
the next uh six months. Another big one
is the rare earth export control from
the CCP. Um but if you do read the
Chinese readout that just uh published,
you see that there's an overall tone
shift in the language that was used. Uh
for example, the word security didn't
come up a single time. Compare that to
the Biden meeting last year in Peru. uh
the aggressiveness has been toned down a
little bit. So obviously I think this is
a domestic issue that there's a lot of
pressure on Xi Jinping and the overall
US China relations. Uh but on the US
side I think it is a good starting
point. 10% less tariffs dropped because
of the ter the fentinels
uh tariffs but I think that uh again a
lot of uh observations and surveillance
on those key promises from China has to
be watched out for. Yeah, you mentioned
a couple of things there, particularly
that Bessant had kind of locked this
framework before they even had the
meeting. Um, and that really just got us
back to even, right? Obviously, we're
looking for some progress on fentanyl,
but when it comes to the soybean
purchases, when it comes to the rare
earths, China basically broke previous
agreements and and now we're just kind
of back to even. So, why did they do
that? You you mentioned the domestic
elements and the Chinese readout that
most Americans won't ever see. What what
was behind getting to this meeting?
>> Yeah, I think she's um obvious stance on
trade and international diplomacy has
been what's called the wolf warrior
relationship, which is essentially you
be as aggressive as you can. This was
the case back in February when the
entire trade war started again. Uh she
allegedly didn't pick up President
Trump's call. Now what has changed so
far is that it seems to me after the
fourth plenum there was a overall
downshift in how this wolf warrior tone
appeal appears internationally. Uh one
of the the Chinese negotiator Lie Chung
Gang his uh his stance even changed from
when uh Secretary Besson called him out
on on this unhinged behavior. And what I
do think that um just based on you know
the recent talks from CCP officials is
that they want to go back to this US
China loveydvey relations. Obviously
this is again for the survival of the
regime. It is not for the sake of
actually keeping global peace. But if
you look at what the long-term
I guess agenda that we've seen is that
they tried to use the rare earth export
as sort of the the top threat right to
the United States. uh but but that has a
as has an expiration date in the sense
that the US has already inked many uh
rare earth deals with different
countries this time in the trip to Asia.
So within 5 years we could see that
threat becoming uh useless in the sense
that it no longer works because the rare
earth uh industry would have shifted. Uh
but uh so that's why I think they're
trying to buy time in the sense that
they want to find a solution to getting
a trade deal done. But the US side is
very cautious about doing something
longterm as the president said. You know
it's on a yearly review basis. A lot of
that has to do with whether or not they
keep their promise which again the track
record doesn't really show that they do.
So I think it's something that you kind
of have to consistently watch for the
development rather than it's you know
other countries it's you know sign a
deal it's done.
>> Yeah. this isn't uh our relationship
with them, not a gentleman's agreement
where you sort of self-monitor that
you're holding up your end of the
bargain. They have to watch it closely
as history has shown. Um very different
tone than any other meeting with Trump
and another world leader. There's there
I was hoping to watch like an hour of
footage and really they ex exchanged
some premeditated pleasantries in front
of each other and then the press were
let out. No questions from the press, no
mention of the Russia war, no mention of
human rights. Do you feel like in a
certain respect that um the US side
didn't get as much out of the meeting as
they had hoped besides economics and
some sort of a pledge on fentanyl, which
is sort of hard to uh police.
>> Yeah. Well, Carrie, you're right about
that. I think the meeting could have
been longer had many more topics been
included also with Taiwan, which was not
mentioned. Uh that's one of the
so-called red lines for the CCP. another
point in which you see the shift from uh
the Chinese uh but I I do think it's
correct that you know some of the key
issues like human rights violations
force organ harvesting uh even some
things to do with political stuff uh
wasn't in part of this this meeting but
you do see that this was almost felt
like a rushed uh let's meet before I
leave type of thing. It it was it it was
put out there on that this Thursday
meeting was going to be this great
thing. Even the president tweeted out
that it was going to be like the G2. Uh
but it didn't feel that way. They were
put in this, you know, much uh smaller
place venue- wise in in the airport of
Busousan. And it just felt like the two
side uh, you know, got things what they
wanted done. it felt like it was a a
through the motion uh rather than a
concrete one which I think you know we
could have a followup or a much more
detailed uh one where when Trump goes to
China uh there could be something more
in-depth talked then but so far it
doesn't seem like the two sides have
rebuilt trust in any way shape or form
other than the temporary uh trade talks
that have been going on for months.
>> Do you get any sense? You had came on
earlier this week saying how there are
the four factions in China. She has lost
power of the military and there's a lot
of um infighting. Trump almost seemed to
bolster she saying, you know, we're
going to be working together for a long
time to come. Is Trump doing that? Does
he have something to gain in trying to
help Shei remain his counterpart or how
do you understand the relationship?
The way I see it, whether Trump deals
with Xi or whoever else is in control,
it doesn't matter as long as on the
surface there is a world leader that he
from China that he can talk with. Now
having said that, she staying in
position with his titles does not equal
to shei having the power because the way
the CCP structure works is that once you
effectively lose the military power even
if you remain as uh former officials
like Huaguaong for example, he was
stripped from power while maintaining
all three titles that Xiinping currently
holds. Uh and then within the two years
time, Deng Xiaoing uh essentially
rendered him a a figurehead. So in that
sense, yes, you could still go out and
and you know, shake hands with the world
leaders, it does not mean that you have
the final say. And that's where I see
things go right now. Even though she
appears like he is the decision maker. A
lot of these shifts in in the tonality,
shifts in the substance has indicated
that he isn't the final uh person who
decides on whether these traits go. And
in terms of the faction, Carrie, you
mentioned uh right now the the the I
would say the tones show that uh the
faction that was in charge when the US
China relations was relatively more uh
not peaceful but but lovey uh back in
like 10 years ago is sort of back in
control. So that's where things are
right now. Now it could obviously shift
because Xiinping isn't going to sit
around and you know not sabotage uh some
things ahead. So, I think as long as he
remains in that position, there's still
factors that could change.
>> And David, just as we finish up, what
should we be looking for over the course
of the next year? We know that Trump
said he's going to go to China in April,
and he he's inviting Shei to come to
either Florida or DC. What What should
happen over the next year if things kind
of remain on their present course?
>> Yeah. Well, right now the CCP is putting
on a show saying that look, we're buying
the soybeans, we're buying, we're we're
cracking down on fentinel, but how long
is that going to last? That's the real
question. and is there going to be a
watchdog or a surveillance type to
specifically focus on this? Because with
everything that the CCP does, they're
very good at promising you things and
never deliver them just as they never
did in the first Trump administration.
So, I think that's going, you know, it's
something that I think the uh the White
House has to be ready for and I think
the president is ready for, which is to
go back to where things were before if
they violate those promises.
>> So much to look out for. was supposed to
be a historic meeting. It seems like,
you know, they were in the same room.
They they shook hands. Appreciate all
your insights. David Jang, host of China
Insider. Great to see you.