Neuroscientist: 'Rewire Your Brain on Nofap in 30 Days' — Science-Based Techniques

🔥 Motivation Forge - Strength Through Struggle.
214 followers
I personally think that porn and the availability of porn
is a real detriment to the developing brain.
Along those lines, I've heard you say
that in order to reset the dopamine system,
essentially in order to break an addictive pattern,
to become unaddicted, 30 days of zero interaction
with that substance, that person, et cetera.
Is that correct?
Yeah, and 30 days is, in my clinical experience,
the average amount of time it takes
for the brain to reset reward pathways,
for dopamine transmission to regenerate itself.
There's also a little bit of science
that suggests that that's true.
Some imaging studies showing that our brains
are still in a dopamine deficit state two weeks
after we've been using our drug.
And then a study by Shuckett and Brown,
which took a group of depressed men
who also were addicted to alcohol,
put them in a hospital where they had received
no treatment for depression,
but they had no access to alcohol in that time.
And after four weeks, 80% of them
no longer met criteria for major depression.
So again, this idea that by depriving ourselves
of this high dopamine, high reward substance or behavior,
we allow our brains to regenerate its own dopamine
for the balance to really equilibrate.
And then we're in a place where we can
enjoy other things.
So that progressive narrowing
of what brings one pleasure eventually expands.
So I'd like to dissect out that 30 days
a little more finally.
And I also want to address
how does one stop doing something for 30 days
if the thing is a thought?
So I'll put that on the shelf for the moment.
So days one through 10,
I would imagine will be very uncomfortable.
They're going to suck basically, to be quite honest,
because the way you describe this pleasure-pain balance,
to my mind says that if you remove
what little pleasure one is getting
or a lot of pleasure from engaging in some behavior,
that's gone.
The pain system is really ramped up
and nothing is making me feel good.
I'll just use myself as an example.
I'm not in recovery,
but that 10 days is going to be miserable.
Anxiety, trouble sleeping,
physical agitation to the point where
maybe impulsive, angry.
Should one expect all of that?
Should the family members of people expect all of that?
Yeah, so what I say to patients,
and it's a really important piece of this intervention
is that you will feel worse before you feel better.
For how long?
This is probably the first question they ask, right?
And I say, usually, in my clinical experience,
you'll feel worse for two weeks.
But if you can make it through those first two weeks,
the sun will start to come out in week three.
And by week four,
most people are feeling a whole lot better than they were
before they stopped using their substance.
So yeah, you have to, it's a hard thing.
Like you have to sign up for it.
And I will say, obviously,
there are people with addictions that are so severe
that as long as they have access to their drug or behavior,
they're not able to stop themselves.
And that's why we have higher levels of care
or residential treatment.
So this is not going to be for everybody, this intervention,
but it's amazing how many people
with really severe addictions to things like heroin, cocaine,
very severe pornography addictions.
I posit this, and I do it as an experiment.
I said, let's try this experiment.
I'm always amazed, number one,
how many of them are willing,
and number two, how many of them are actually able to do it?
They are able to do it.
And so that little nudge is sort of just what they need.
And the carrot is, you know,
there's a better life out there for you,
and you'll be able to taste it in a month.
You really will be able to begin to see
that you can feel better and that there's another way.
So the way you describe it seems like it's hard,
but it's doable for most people,
not everybody.
And we'll return to that category of people
who can't do that on their own.
Well, then days 21 through 30, people are feeling better.
The sun is starting to come out, as you mentioned,
which translates in the narrative we've created here
and support biology that dopamine is starting
to be released in response to the taste
of a really good cup of coffee, for instance,
whereas before it was only to insert, you know,
addictive behavior, whichever it was.
Of course, coffee can be addictive too,
but we'll leave that aside.
Yeah, I feel like coffee has a kind
of consumption limiting mechanism built in,
where at some point you just can't ingest anymore,
but maybe that's wrong.
Sorry to give lift to the caffeine addicts out there
as I clutch my mug.
So days 21 through 30, I've seen a lot of people
go through addiction and addiction treatment.
I've spent a lot of time in those places,
actually looking at it, researching.
I've got friends in that community.
I'm close with that community.
And so what I'd like to talk about in this context
is what sorts of things help other people
that we know that are addicted?
What really helps?
Like not what could help, but what really helps
and are there certain people for whom it's hopeless?
I mean, I don't like to hold the conversation that way,
but I wouldn't be close to the real life data
if I didn't ask, is it hopeless?
Are there people who just will not be able
to quit their substance use or their addictive behavior,
despite, I have to assume, really wanting to, yeah.
Yeah, so there are people who will die
of their disease of addiction, you know,
and I think conceptualizing it as a disease
is a helpful frame.
There are other frames that we could use,
but I do think given the brain physiologic changes
that occur with sustained heavy drug use
and what we know happens to the brain,
it is really reasonable to think of it as a brain disease.
And for me, the real window of, let's say,
being able to access my compassion
around people who are repeat relapsers,
even when their life is so much better,
when they're in recovery.
Yeah, it's like a no-brainer, right?
Is to conceptualize this balance
and the dopamine deficit state
and a balance tilted to the side of pain.
And to imagine that for some people,
after a month or six months or maybe even six years,
their balance is still tipped to the side of pain,
that on some level, that balance has lost its resilience
and its ability to restore homeostasis.
It's almost like the hinge on that balance is messed up.
Yes, exactly.
And so, I mean, for someone
who's never experienced addiction like yourself,
maybe one way to conceptualize it is-
Well, I didn't say that.
Oh, okay.
I was not, to be clear, I was not referring to myself,
but in this example I was given,
if I were, I would come clean, I would reveal that.
But I think that, especially after hearing
some of your lectures and descriptions
of the range of things that are addictive,
I think I've been fortunate
that I don't have a propensity for drugs or alcohol.
Right, okay.
I'm lucky in that way that, frankly,
if they remove all the alcohol from the planet,
I'll just be relieved
because no one will offer it to me anymore.
Right, right.
So don't send me any alcohol, it won't go to me.
Right.
Imagine that you had an itch somewhere on your body, okay?
And it was, I mean, we've all had that,
like, you know, whatever the source.
It was super, super itchy.
You can go for, you know, if you really focus,
you could go for a pretty good amount of time
not scratching it.
But the moment you stopped focusing on not scratching it,
you would scratch it.
And maybe you would do it while you were asleep, right?
And that is what happens to people with severe addiction.
That balance is essentially broken.
Homeostasis does not get restored
despite sustained abstinence.
They're living with that constant specter of that pull.
It never goes away.
So let me say there are lots of people with addiction
for whom that does go away.
And it goes away at four weeks for many of them.
But in severe cases, that's always there and it's lingering.
And it's the moment when they're not focusing on not using,
it's like a reflex, they fall back into it.
It's not purposeful.
It's not because they wanna get high.
It's not because they value using drugs
more than they do their family.
None of that.
It's that really, they cannot not do it
when given the opportunity and that moment
when they're not thinking about it.
Does that make sense?
That's a great description.
And actually in that description,
I can feel a bit of empathy
because the way you described scratching an itch
in your sleep, you know,
I've done that with mosquito bites in summer
and scratching and you're like,
you wake up scratching that mosquito bite.
And I also have to admit that I've experienced
not feeling like I wanna pick up my phone
because it's so rewarding,
but just finding myself doing it.
Like I'm not gonna use this thing,
I'm not gonna use this thing.
And then just finding myself doing it.
Like, what am I doing here?
Sort of the, how did I get back here again?
And I know enough about brain function
to understand that we have circuits
that generate deliberate behavior.
And we have circuits that generate reflexive behavior.
And one of the goals of the nervous system
is to make the deliberate stuff reflexive
so you don't have to make the decision
because decision-making is a very costly thing to do.
Decision-making of any kind.
So that does really help.
I wanna just try and weave together this dopamine puzzle,
however, because if by week,
so first phase of this 30 or 40 day detox,
it's like a dopamine fast, right?
Okay.
First 10 days are miserable.
Middle 10 days, the clouds are out.
There may be some shards of sunlight coming through.
And then all of a sudden sun starts to come out,
it gets brighter and brighter.
Why is it then that people will relapse
not just after getting fired from a job
or their spouse leaving them,
but when things are going really well?
Is it this unconscious mechanism?
Because I've seen this before,
is they have a great win.
I have a friend who's a really impressive creative.
I don't want to reveal any more than that,
and relapsed upon getting another
really terrific opportunity to create for the entire world.
And I was like, how can that happen?
But now I'm beginning to wonder,
was it the dopamine associated with that win
that opened the spigot on this dopamine system?
Because it happened in a phase
of a really great stretch of life.
Yeah, right.
Yeah, so you raised that great point about triggers, right?
And triggers are things that make us want
to go back to using our drug.
And the key thing about triggers, whatever they are,
is they also release a little bit of dopamine, right?
So just thinking about whatever the trigger is
that we associate with drug use,
or just thinking about drug use,
can already release this anticipatory dopamine,
this little mini spike.
But here's the part that I think is really fascinating.
That mini spike is followed by a mini deficit state.
So it goes up and then it doesn't go back down the baseline,
it goes below baseline tonic levels.
And that's craving, right?
So that anticipation is immediately followed
by wanting the drug.
And it's that dopamine deficit state
that drives the motivation to go and get the drug.
So many people talk about dopamine
is not really about pleasure,
but about wanting and about motivation.
And so it is that deficit state
that then drives the locomotion to get it.
And earlier, your description of dopamine being involved
in the desire for more, giving the sense of reward,
but also movement.
Right.
I have to assume that those things
are braided together in our nervous system
for the specific intention of when you feel something good,
then you feel the pain.
Yeah.
Or maybe you don't notice it.
And then the next thing you know,
you're pursuing more of the thing that could deliver.
And I love the way you use the word braided together.
That's beautiful.
And let me also just say something
that I find also fascinating in my work with patients.
And I see this all the time.
There are people for whom bad life experiences,
loss, in any form, stress, in many different forms,
that's a trigger.
But there are absolutely people
for whom the trigger is things going well.
And the things going well can be like the reward
of the things going well,
but very often what it is,
is the removal of the hypervigilant state
that's required to keep their use in check.
So it's this sense of, I wanna celebrate, you know,
or I wanna, this reward happened,
I wanna put more reward on there.
And it's really, really fascinating
because when people come to that realization
about themselves, that they're most vulnerable
when things are going well,
that's really a valuable insight
because then they can put some, you know,
things in place or barriers in place,
or go to more meetings or whatever it is that they do,
you know, to protect themselves.
