Books That Talk About Depression and Grief ¦ Book Club Session

The Book Club
24 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 30, 2024
Books That Talk About Suicide and Grief | Book Club Session
Follow my book recommendations
Goodreads : https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/75664668-helly
Instagram : https://www.instagram.com/thehellyblog/
Alright, hello everyone and welcome to a book club session. Today's topic is a little
different and a little difficult to tackle as well because we'll be discussing suicide in
literature, not depression or mental illness, very specifically suicide. I have a very particular
reason I picked out this topic for today's session but if this is your first session
within Heli's book club because I know that a few of you have joined just recently. Hello,
I am Heli, I love reading books and this book club is basically my accountability project to
read more. So as much as I want you to enjoy reading with all of us, it's more of a thing
that I do to keep myself sane because I have a very ambitious career but if I don't read I feel
like I'm not in my body, I'm not in my soul, I feel very disconnected from myself when I don't
read and lately I think I have done a bunch of reading which discuss the themes of suicide. Very
strangely this was a book that I picked up on my birthday from a bookstore physically just by
reading the last page. Then I realised it is actually long-listed for the international
booker prize this year. I don't think it was selected and then I realised it's a book which
deals with the suicide of a twin. It's a very specific topic but also something that I would
have never thought about before, never thought about reading before. My voice is properly audible,
let me know if my audio is not clear by any chance. I also got this book which is,
this is not a suicide note, it's actually notes on suicide which is just a detached commentary on
the act of suicide and it's not something very depressing. So a lot of times when people
come over to my place and they see all these books, they feel like something's wrong with me
but I'm just trying to have an understanding of this through literature and I think this
book club session is so that I can actually do it collectively with all of you and get your
opinions as well. And yes, now going to the personal, why did I choose this topic very
particularly this month? A very close friend of mine from school, he was a pretty nice guy,
I had known him in school, of course we were not very connected after school, just as it happens.
He had gotten married in February of this year, I think that must be like four months ago,
and I went to a cafe in June and the barista at that cafe is one of my school friends
and we always say hello, I specifically choose that cafe to go to because the barista is my
school friend and she told me, you know, you remember this guy? I said, yeah of course I
remember him, we're friends. He said, you know, he committed suicide and my jaw just dropped
because we were very close in school, he was definitely one of my closest friends in school.
He had just gotten married and of course, I'm 25 so not a lot of our friends are married,
so we of course knew he's married. He also married his school love of 12 years, okay, something that
very few people are able to do. They were in a relationship for maybe more than 10 years
and this is within four months of a marriage. Now, what drove him to this is not my concern
to discuss here, not of my business, but it definitely triggered a lot of feelings in me,
right, and I think at that point I went through a lot of emotions, right, there was one phase where
could he have reached out to me? Probably not, we were not in touch for a very long time, okay,
were there other people? Yes, of course, he had just gotten married for ****'s sake,
just gotten married. I'm sure he had a wife, he actually had everything from what it looked like,
right, he was finally at a stage of his life that he would be happy but still this and
it triggered a lot of feelings, okay, triggered a lot of feelings and I don't think any book could
capture my feelings more than this one because it's again essays on the subject.
Suicide then finds us both strangely reticent and unusually loquacious,
lost for words and full of them. I don't think any sentence or any words can capture the feelings
you feel when you hear that somebody has done this, okay. Has this happened to any of you,
okay, any close acquaintance, anyone you knew and you would hear something like this and you
just go into an utter state of shock, of course, you want to understand but then you also know
it's not your place to understand and then you have so many questions but you also have no one
to ask and if it's someone close, God forbid, because it's happened to me during COVID,
somebody was really close to committing suicide and it definitely affected me in a very,
very negative way. I had to take therapy for a year. Yeah, absolutely, that happens and even
I started in a very good college and the girl who was the general secretary in my year of college,
she also committed suicide just a couple of years back, so what, 23 maybe, right, and a lot of times
I'm very thankful for you if you've not felt it before because it's extremely painful and
the closer you are, the more painful it is and it's something that you'll never move on from
entirely and that's something that you have to accept, which is a book, which is what a book like
Norwegian Wood deals with, okay, so I think I'd like to start the session now by asking a question
that a lot of people ask me when I tell them that I'm reading a book and it's about suicide, okay,
does literature encourage suicide? Does literature encourage you to do this? Absolutely not, okay,
now it totally depends on the reader, okay, depends on the reader's state of mind but I
don't think that there's any book that actively encourages someone to kill themselves, okay,
if anything, the reason I read these books is to confront the feelings that I do not have words
for yet, is to confront the lies that I will never live and to have a deeper understanding
of people because what is humanity if not the attempt to understand and love each other, okay,
so in this entire session that I'm going to host, please do not take anything that I'm saying as an
encouragement of the act, not at all, we're just trying to understand things, understand
the books that have been written but if anybody is in the session today who is going through a
hard time, please see a professional, I can assure you, you are going to, life transforms, right, and
I think that's one of the best things about the book Veronica Decides to Die but we'll talk about
the books in order eventually but I think I have also felt a lot of dark feelings at one point,
very specifically somewhere around last year where I was extremely isolated, living alone
and I also had a leg injury because of which I could not really move around much, so my life
went from traveling a lot, taking flights, going out there to work, networking physically to not
even being able to go to the washroom on my own and that was extremely, extremely depressing, I
cannot emphasize on the feelings that I felt in those days and I was prescribed some antidepressants
but within two weeks I stopped taking them because it was not working out well for me, I felt like
I'll get worse, eventually I did get better and I'm happiest right now, right, there's nothing
I'm chasing anymore but it's definitely a feeling that is very hard to deal with and people who have
not felt it can never relate to it, okay, and have you guys read Virginia Woolf's works or
Virginia Woolf's letters, has anyone here already read Virginia Woolf's works or Virginia Woolf's
letters, very specifically her Suicide Note, absolutely, so when I was in college, right,
let's start the session by, since literature also includes Virginia Woolf's Suicide Note,
okay, I'll share my screen with you guys, this was Virginia Woolf's Suicide Note, okay, and if you can
read it sometime, that would be great, okay, and when I was in college, I had still,
no, I was still happy in life, I had still not known excruciating pain yet, I was in my first
year of college, okay, there was a teacher who introduced us to this letter, okay, of course,
we are literature students and we had to read some Virginia Woolf's works and in this letter,
she wrote, she told us how Virginia Woolf wrote that although she's very happy with her husband
and her husband couldn't have done better, she cannot keep going on like this and she doesn't
want to spoil his life anymore and I really like the last sentence, I don't think two people could
have been happier than we have been, okay, and at that point, our professor said something that
didn't make sense to me on that very day, she said, what do people think, is that all we need,
a good husband, a good career, because Virginia Woolf was very successful in her career as well,
a good network of friends, family and we don't have any reason to feel sad or depressed and I
was like, yes, of course, that's all you need, okay, I was very young, I had not felt the
huge of emotions that I have felt and I'm pretty sure everyone can relate, right, when you are
young, you cannot really understand all of this, you cannot really understand why would possibly
anyone do anything like this when there's so much ice cream and the joys of our life are so
simple, okay, this is so easy, life feels so easy, just as you grow older, you understand a lot more
things but as I grew older, there was one day in my life when everything in this letter made so
much sense to me, it ******* felt like I could have written it myself and it would make total
sense, am I at that stage now, no, not, not at all but that's what literature does, it gives you a
sense of understanding when no one else does, okay, case in point, let's talk about the bell jar,
okay, let's get into the very first book we're going to talk about today, the bell jar, bell jar
is a book by Sylvia Plath, it's not too big, so even if you're a beginner to reading, you will
probably still enjoy reading the bell jar, Sylvia Plath, shortly after the publication of the bell
jar actually put her head in a, in an oven and killed herself and shockingly Nicholas who was
her son, who was with her at that time, he was very young, when he grew older, he also killed himself
the same way and that's something really morbid to get to know about but even at that, if you see
any reviews of the bell jar online or there's a very good YouTube video on bell jar by TED education,
you'd see that a lot of people say that this book saved me, okay, so nowhere in these books is the
agenda to encourage people to follow the footsteps of the right and not at all, give people a sense
of understanding that we constantly feel that we lack, okay, in all the books we'll discuss, in all
the literature about suicide in general, you'd see six very common themes, mental illness and
despair obviously, okay, but the second one is isolation and alienation, that feeling that
no one understands me, no one gets what it is to be me and after one point, you just don't want to
explain yourself to anyone, you don't want the arguments, you don't want the fights, you don't
want the conflict, you just want to quietly leave, okay, in literature especially bell jar, a lot of
people have found solace and comfort that, okay, finally the things I'm feeling, somebody has
written about it, so maybe I'm not alone, okay, so in this book, there's the main character whose
name is Esther which is basically like Sylvia Plath writing about herself, okay, now, what is
the bell jar? Bell jar is actually a metaphorical symbol, okay, like she feels that depression is
like a bell jar and she feels trapped under it, okay, so the imagery of the bell jar means that,
that feeling of being isolated in your suffering and there's no way out of it, okay, it starts
exactly how Sylvia Plath's life was at that point, okay, if the knight says that while talking about
suicide, the language we use is very different, act to be committed, okay, illegal, died by suicide,
okay, that's something interesting, thank you, thank you very much, I'll try to change that,
it may not be possible in today itself but that's definitely something insightful, please keep
sharing your opinions, guys, I would love to see what you have to say because we have touched upon
such a sensitive topic today, now, there's also a very popular symbol from the book, the bell jar,
which is the symbol of the fig tree and basically, the imagery means something like Esther or Sylvia
in this scenario as well, they're paralyzed by the thing that they have only one choice to make,
you can either be this or that, choose this husband or that husband, be here or there,
you know, when you have so many options and you cannot choose everything, she feels very crippled
by that, what if, what if life was like clothes, you could change your clothes and see which fits
best, what if you could choose your life like that, okay and because she's so crippled by that
feeling of not being able to decide right or make the right choice, she feels like she will be
stagnant, okay and this is the quote I'm reading out, I saw my life branching out before me like
the green fig tree in the story, from the tip of every branch like a fat purple fig, a wonderful
future beckoned and winked, one fig was a husband and a happy home and children, another fig was a
famous poet and another fig was a brilliant professor and another fig was EG, I'm not reading
everything, I saw myself sitting on the crotch of the fig, of this fig tree, starving to death
just because I couldn't make up my mind which of the figs I would choose, I wanted each and every
one of them but choosing one meant losing all the rest and as I sat there unable to decide,
the figs began to wrinkle and go black and one by one they plopped to the ground at my feet,
now that's a very depressing way to put the paradox of choices, you have so many choices in
life but you know at a given point you can only make a finite number of choices, okay,
there's another quote I really really like from the Belga, I listened to the beat of my heart,
I am, I am, I am, it's a very very popular quote from this book I think and it makes me feel very
good, okay, I quoted it from memory, I didn't write it down for some reason so if I made a
mistake in the code just rectify me but yeah Belga is definitely a book that you would really really
like to read if you have felt these feelings or you want to get an understanding of these feelings
because unless you read you would probably not know this, a lot of times what we see is that
in such books shortly after writing such very depressing books the writers die by suicide as
well, okay, I think I got you there Shilpi but when I read Notes on Suicide I really liked how
Simon Critchley writes, this book is not a suicide note, 10 days after Edward Leve handed in the
manuscript of Suicide to his publisher he hanged himself, two years after Jean Améry's On Suicide
was published the author took an overdose of sleeping pills, in 1960 some 18 years after
Albert Camus had raised and so he thought resolved the question of suicide in the myth of
Sisyphus he was killed in a car accident, let me say at the outset at the risk of disappointing
the reader I have no plans to kill myself just yet but this book is basically like a meditation
on that and not anything depressing at all so I feel like if you want to read about suicide from
an analytical point of view this is going to be a very good book, I really really enjoyed
reading this and the next book we're going to discuss is Haruki Murakami's book Norwegian
World but before we go there there's something that caught my attention in this book is how a
lot of times this act of dying by suicide comes from a place of loss of love, a lot of times
the feeling of not having anyone in this world, not having anyone for companionship, the desire
for companionship becomes so strong and again one of the oldest books on these feelings would
probably be Sorrows of Young Werther and I have not picked it up because I've not read the original
text myself but it definitely outlines the feelings of the writer feeling a lot of depressing
feelings because the person he loves just doesn't requite their feelings okay it's about unrequited
love and you're not being able to let go and there's a chapter in this book about suicide
notes and I'd like to capture this one always speaks to someone in a suicide note, suicide
notes are attempts at communication they are a last and usually a desperate attempt to communicate
final communications they are also failed attempts in the sense that the writer is communicating a
failure to communicate expressing the desire to give up in one last attempt at expression
the suicidal person doesn't want to die alone but wants to die with another or others to whom the
note is addressed and this chapter itself I think also talked about it talks about Kurt
Cohen's suicide so if anyone are familiar with that you might like this chapter very specifically
there was also another part I really liked I hope that I can find it quickly
otherwise I'll take it to the end of the session no I cannot find it I think I definitely
underlined it but basically it talked about revenge suicides like a lot of times people feel
so much pain after loss of love that they want to leave the person who has hurt them that much
with a lifelong feeling of pain that look what you did to me and yeah that was absolutely very
very disturbing to read about we I think we read a lot about it when we are young especially like
where I came from I think it was kind of now that I'm older it's kind of funny but it was quite
funny how sometimes when like these teenagers couples you know they would have these fights and
the guys would be like oh I'll die for you and even girls right they will I'll die for you if
you leave me and all those things so definitely that shakes a lot of feelings then I do not think
thankfully nothing like that happened in our school days but boy did we hear a lot about it
in those days I also feel like there's a lot of times when these are also attempts at attention
in some way not that it's a bad thing a lot of times that attention is very much needed maybe
they're not feeling hurt they're not feeling seen it reminds me of the time when I was in school
and there was this particular classmate we had who was quite suicidal in her outlook it was
extremely scary sometimes to be around her and I'm hoping she got the help that she needed she's
doing well in life she's studying law as far as I know but she would often sit alone in the class
and she would you know do I'm not sure if I'll be able to put this up on YouTube but she would
put glass panels from the windows to her wrists and we would get extremely scared I remember this
one time we had to call a teacher because we were extremely scared what she's up to and a lot of
times the narrative that becomes in the in that teenage group is okay this person is very attention
seeking okay this person is very I remember the narrative around that person was definitely not
a positive one and definitely not a sympathetic one because teenagers can be extremely cruel to
each other I think anyone who has been in school can feel that please let me know if you can relate
but teenagers can be extremely cruel to each other I don't think there's a there's any other
age group that's worse and this is a feeling that that is echoed in the virgin suicides when
the main there's five sisters in virgin suicides actually let's go to virgin suicides first
there's five sisters the Lisbon sisters in virgin suicide by Geoffrey Eugenides okay and basically
the book is about the collective suicide of five sisters this is the novel okay and
in this story the story begins with the youngest Lisbon sister Cecilia who is only 13 years old
her attempt at suicide is basically what begins the book okay and she tells the doctor obviously
doctor you've never been a 13 year old girl okay so I'm not sure what kind of pain or what kind
of something she's going through in this novel but definitely teenage is a very very difficult
period I think another very good book that captures these feelings is 13 reasons why
by Jay Asher I couldn't read this book I knew that that's a book I should avoid because I knew
it will not affect me uh in a good way for sure because it was extremely disturbing to read the
phase of life that I was in I did not feel comfortable finishing it at all I didn't I'm
happy about that but definitely the teenagers are very very brutal period okay and I think
there's always this thing that adults really trivialize the pain of youngsters what could you
know about pain because of course adults have seen much more what in their vocabulary would be serious
worries or serious problems but at the point at that outlook I think everything is very magnified
to teenagers and I feel like teenagers a space where we need to extend so much understanding
to uh the children right my sister is a teenager right now my cousin sister I'm very close to her
and I have always told her that no matter what happens I am going to be there for you and you
have to know and also teenagers overthink a lot okay they overthink everything I think with my
sister I gave her a course and she didn't finish the course okay that's all now she stopped talking
to me entirely and I was very puzzled why is she not speaking to me lately and she messaged me one
day that I think you absolutely hate me and you never want to see me again because you paid money
for a course that I didn't do I said not at all I love you forever but I don't know what must have
gone on in her head that I would hate her for something so trivial okay I would rather she
did it okay I that course would have benefited her but it's fine but her message seeked of so
much self-loathing and that also brings me to the question that there's a lot of self-loathing that
develops in people over years okay and it doesn't develop in one day of course it's
uh some things you hear from from parents probably something you hear from your teachers
something you hear from your friends something you hear from romantic partners or rejection
from hopeful romantic partners and uh yeah it's it's it definitely disturbs someone a lot on
the base level right and yeah I just hope that all of you who have teenagers in your family are
able to extend that uh love for them we were talking about uh virgin suicides and
in virgin suicides I think the best uh way to put virgin suicides is like it there's a
certain sort of voyeurism to this act there's a certain because the book is written from the
point of view from few boys who are enchanted by these girls because they're very beautiful girls
who have been close to death who are almost romanticizing death okay um and there's a lot
of alienation in this book okay the parents of this these five girls are very very harsh on them
which might be one of the reasons why they feel so repressed throughout this book okay um one
book that I loved a lot and I will recommend you guys highly is Veronica Decides to Die
contrary to the title it's actually a much more hopeful book okay in this book uh there's a
central character Veronica of course she is a young Slovenian girl and she has everything in
her life right but she decides she's going to kill herself okay she and she the way she
logics her life is so nice the way she logics why she's doing certain things she's gonna do
is amazing okay and I'll read one passage out from it which is gonna be a little long
but I really wanna uh and basically she doesn't like herself anymore she's not inspired by herself
anymore she's just tired of sticking to societal norms she doesn't want to go on anymore she
thinks that life is just a repetitive routine you have to do the same things again and again and again
exactly and uh yeah that's why she decides she's going to uh end this okay but her attempt fails
and she wakes up at uh at an institution called Villette and the doctor tells her that she only
has a few days to live okay she that she he tells her that she's gonna die but she's gonna die in a
few days okay now this altered reality knowing that you're gonna die right now and knowing that
you're gonna die in five days in these five days she develops a lot of appreciation for life okay
by the way she's not gonna die in five days spoiler alert okay but this entire book is so
so uplifting in confronting the philosophy of what it is to live and I think a lot of these books
actually deal with uh the question of what does it mean uh to live and Shubham I have literally
written in my notes Hemlock Society. Hemlock Society is an amazing Bengali movie that you
guys should watch watch I loved it which is uh similar in the topic I don't want to say more
but it's amazing uh by the way Porom Roto Chatterjee followed me on Instagram
and I'm very very excited about that so I have been lucky enough to get a like and a follow
as well because I made a piece of content that I guess he liked but yeah my family is very proud of
me yay but for those of you who don't understand Porom Roto Chatterjee is a Bengali actor and he's
a very very popular Bengali actor like a lead Bengali actor all right uh yeah of course there's
a lot of YA literature as well that deals with like they both die at the end I think all the
right places but I'm not picking them up that much because I wanted to keep the conversation
to general literary fiction and not YA very specifically also because YA focuses mostly on
youngsters um talking about youngsters in this book what I'd rather not think about which was
the last book I was reading when I decided I want to take this session is uh this book about
a couple of twins okay and the book is written from the sister's point of view
her brother decides that he wants to die at 35 and this book basically is a collection of all
the memories feelings positive negative about her brother okay and also the way it captures seeing
someone you love slip slowly away from you but not being able to do anything about it she's also
consulting a therapist in this novel and a lot of times the things that the therapist says
make so much sense right for example when she's feeling that her brother is going away from her
and I think that's a feeling a lot of siblings can relate to right there was a there's a point
in your life you realize that you and your sibling are not that close anymore and it's
definitely painful but it's definitely more painful for twins right and she's trying to
get close to him but he's like shutting down her attempts at communication okay and I think
a lot of times what happens because it definitely happened to me when this happened to a friend of
mine is my question was like why was this person not reaching out or why did I don't understand
why was I not there okay because there's always that feeling that could I have done something
okay and similarly the main character in this this is the book the main character in this
she wants to connect with him but the therapist tells her that she cannot connect with someone
beyond their will and she has to contact is not something that can be forced upon someone you have
to wait for them to accept it until then you can only grieve there's a lot of understanding that
this book deals with okay and you know one of the quotes this book I personally really liked
is I thought about all the love we have inside of us and how only a shred of that reaches the people
we actually care about another quote that was really nice would be this I'm trying to understand
him when someone says they love you but still ends up leaving I can't understand it I don't believe
in that kind of love this is such a nice way to capture the aftermath of mourning somebody's death
okay and also the it's also stages of grief right even if you've lost someone in life I think there's
a lot that you can relate to because it's not morbid to read this book is definitely not morbid
to read some some books definitely are morbid to read when it comes to such a topic okay also there
are certain there's one book that I absolutely didn't like which I will tell you to not read
because I hated it so much which is called love letters to the dead okay similar topic
about letters to people who have died by suicide but I honestly felt like that book was written
just for the shock factor of it or just to use it as an element because there was no sensitivity
there was no there's such a deep topic that people can do wonders with but that book was wow
one hell of a shitty book that I have read you know very long time so yeah not a good one okay
I also want to recommend a few books that I have not read or read very little of yet
but in my research about books and suicide literature they were like literally on the top
of my searches in Japan there's an amazing writer called Yukio Mishima I've read quite a few books
of his okay he actually died by seppuku which is a Japanese method of a self-inflicted death but
it's not because they want to they're depressed or anything they do it for their country they do
it for their they do it because they'll stand for something that they want to be remembered for
okay I'm forgetting the exact reason for Mishima but Mishima is very very very popular
in Japan he has lots of short stories and you can read them as well okay also Osamu Dazai is
no longer human where the main character feels like he's so depressed he's not even qualified
to be a human anymore okay so that's a good book and it's also a very short one okay thank you so
much for sharing the image Shujai so yeah I hope that you'll read these books what else which
book apart from these have okay Dostoevsky's characters are also a very good case study
on suicide because a lot of them are contemplating either for or against it not necessarily like
you know it's not like he condones it nor that he really advocates for it it's
interesting the way he thinks like for example in Crime and Punishment his main character is
Kolnikov even though the idea comes to his head he is absolutely repulsed by it and I think there's
a lot of religion also that comes into this because in some religions it it is absolutely
the worst thing that anyone can do to themselves okay but above all I think I forgot to touch on
Norwegian Wood which is my favorite book okay absolutely love this book okay this book
opens with three characters Toru, Naoko and Kizuki okay they are friends
Naoko is Kizuki's girlfriend in the beginning okay and Kizuki kills himself and
somebody said it so right that depression and this kind of a pain it never ends with anyone
it just passes on so the pain whatever Kizuki was going through it kind of transfers itself to Naoko
and a spoiler alert now ahead you can mute me for two minutes if you want if you don't want
the spoiler throughout the span of the novel Naoko goes deeper and deeper into a depressive mental
state till she also does the same thing and Toru and Naoko have formed a very strong bond
after Kizuki's death so this also affects Toru and in the end Toru receives a call and he doesn't
know what that call is now that call is such a symbolic call because it could be a call
to join Naoko in a similar state of mind and maybe Toru is headed towards the same fate or
maybe the call is a call for you know coming back to reality now it totally depends on what you
interpret the call to be as that's the end and it's absolutely beautiful there's I think the
best thing about this book was the quotes the sheer number of amazing quotes this book has
because I have so many of my personal favorites from this one like there's a scene where they
are walking through the woods like the woods are a recurrent symbol in this book which is why the
title Norwegian Wood because the woods basically signify that period in their life where they were
together and then they had this trauma and in their childhood and everything that they had
together especially Naoko and Toru Kizuki is not a very big part of the novel because he
dies in the very beginning so but it's more about Toru and the way this affects him so this was
very very nice I was reading this paper on suicide memory and trauma in Haruki Murakami's Norwegian
it's a very nice paper on research gate if you guys want to read deeply you can read it okay
I'm gonna read this from the research paper itself death is a recurring event in the novel
Norwegian Wood upon reading the novel the readers would feel that Murakami is obsessed with death
more precisely with suicide Kizuki Naoko's childhood friend and boyfriend and Toru's
only friend commits suicide at the age of 17 there's a quote by the way this I'm saying
so there's a quote by the way from this book that only the dead stay 17 forever that's a
nice sentence Kizuki's suicide for no apparent reason brings an end to the friendship triangle
among the three his death traumatizes Toru and Naoko so deeply that it changes the course of
their lives forever as Toru narrates until that time I had understood death as something entirely
separate from and independent of life the hand of death is bound to take us I had felt but until
the day it reaches out for us it leaves us alone this had seemed to me the simple logical truth
life is here death is over there I am here and I'm not over there and that's such a nice there's
one point in your life where you actually find finally understand what death really means and
one of the recurring themes in Norwegian Wood is that death does not exist opposite to life but
rather with life the image of yin and yang can be worth considerable to understand the inseparable
psychological and emotional connection between Naoko and Kizuki in yin and yang without the
white counterpart the black cannot exist similarly Naoko's existence becomes a mere living without
Kizuki so upon Kizuki's death Naoko encounters a physical psychological vacuum that impacts
her deeply this traumatic experience impacts upon her so much that she develops a psychological
condition clinically known as PTSD Kizuki and Naoko sister's suicides can be referred to here
I'm not sure if can be referred here to fill the void Toru and Naoko develop a less romantic
more habitual relationship her obsession with Kizuki and now his absence created a complex in
her and then it goes more into psychological thing but yeah basically yeah this is so relatable
Naoko feels guilty at times because she happened to be Kizuki's girlfriend at the time he committed
suicide as why he killed himself remains unknown but she feels guilty of her ignorance or concerning
his plans to kill himself it is not clear from the narrative whether Kizuki should and yes it
is not it's like he's such a small part of the novel like Kizuki is actually a very very small
part of the novel but his effect you can actually feel through the characters throughout the novel
and I think that makes so much sense because when you come across people in life there's so
many people that have impacted them and you would not really know in what way ever a book that
captures that very well is called The Details by E.R. Grenberg I read it recently it's not
a depressing book at all it's just about capturing the people in your life and the way they impact
you and I feel like lately I've really been into fiction where nothing really happens it's just
like people going about their lives and how that is how that's going for them what is happening
it's it's interesting because daily life is not that tantalizing it's much more simple okay
so yeah I hope that you like the books that I picked from for the discussion today
please let me know in the chat with your opinions I think some of you are discussing Yukio Mishima
some of you have loved Norwegian words so that's great and yeah please drop your opinions in the
chat and yeah I'll like to conclude today's session by talking about the common themes between all
these books okay the first one is 100% mental illness and despair okay every novel that I've
discussed today or all novels that usually touch upon this subject would talk about mental illness
and recently I've been reading these books I want to die but I want to eat tteokbokki and
I want to die but I still want to eat tteokbokki which is like conversations with the psychiatrist
and it actually captures a lot of feelings you might have felt about existing existentialism
in general as well so you can read this book these are very much guiding and they're not
depressing at all okay in Beljar of course Esther descends into a deep depression then
her feeling of being trapped in the Beljar okay in Norwegian would of course Naoko is in an
extremely fragile mental state and also there's another character in this why my is her name
Mizumi the second female character can one can anyone please confirm with me what is the name
of the second girl but the girl who's full of life and much more vibrant Midori Midori sorry
Midori Midori is like if if Toru is the guy Naoko is a very very depressive and Midori is very very
full of life despite everything okay Midori also has a sad story in general but I think that
really captures that they have chosen how they want to be someone they have chosen to choose
life choose happiness choose to be happy despite everything and Midori is an absolute badass
character in the book okay I think the time that I read the book I was more sad so I liked
Naoko more but now that I have moved on from the book I 100% think Midori is the one I would
want to live like okay Midori is crazy and she wants to be crazy she wants to be madly loved
she wants to have a crazy love in her life she wants to have everything and she is she's not
shy to ask for it she asks Toru very verbally that I want this uh don't hurt don't hurt me
no matter what I've been so hurt don't hurt me um I just want to be loved I want to be so full of
love I want to be crazily loved okay there's a very nice example that she gives she wants a
shortcake and the guy she asks the shortcake from should go immediately and get it for her
and when he gets it to her she'll throw it away and and then the guy should be like oh of course
I should have known that you wouldn't like the shortcake and the guy should apologize to her
now if you take it at face value it of course does not make sense it sounds stupid but honestly it's
not about the shortcake it's about the fact that somebody being so madly in love with you that
they love you no matter how you are they love you and they listen to every whim of yours that's like
the expectation to be madly loved now whether that's realistic or not is a discussion for
another day but uh yeah but love it's such a beautiful uh allegory to what women look for
in love okay um and yeah I love Midori's character so Toru is kind of torn between Midori and Naoko
he loves them both somewhat okay now of course his past Midori's future so similarly right if
you're in a depressive state uh you you also feel both of those things it's not like you feel one
thing or the another you sometimes feel both at the same time so that's something that is very
interesting to look at second theme is isolation and alienation okay Beljarme Esther is very
disconnected from everyone she doesn't understand the society what it expects out of her okay in
Posthuma's book the what I'd rather not think about both the main characters feel very isolated
from everyone but the brother more than anyone okay um Norwegian would of course they feel very
isolated after the death of their friend Veronica decides to die uh yeah she initially does feel
that but when when she is in the asylum uh or the institution she finds people like her and
actually something I forgot to mention is that a lot of the dialogue in Veronica decides to die
is about what it means to be sane or what it means to be insane what is normal what is crazy
and when a lot of people they mention in this book a lot of people once they come into the
institution they want to stay there because they find more people who understand them because
they're all collectively called insane right and there's a lot of like philosophical questions
like in any coelho book what does it mean to be insane okay there's an example right the doctor
says that I'm wearing a tie and no just because a collective group of people have decided to call it
a tie it's called normal but if somebody comes and tells me this is a piece of clothe uh colorful
clothes tied around your neck that makes you feel choked it's still right okay but we'll call them
insane it's just a tie why can't you just call it a tie um all right uh thank you Prachi I'll send
notes don't worry um okay so definitely that is a decadent feeling that isolation and uh virgins
besides of course I think the parents of the sisters are definitely the characters driving
them to isolation but also the society right these girls are always looked at like they're
exotic being everyone is fantasizing about her or about them or sexualizing them or
the families don't want them to go out much or want to control their uh sexualities and
that definitely makes them feel very isolated and alienated despite all of them being in the
same house okay um the next one is probably societal expectations and repression of your
feelings okay and I think Veronica decides to die has definitely an NSFW chapter on this that
I don't want to talk about but uh let's just say that there's a scene that I would never be found
reading online or offline for that matter uh search for meaning search for meaning of life
that's again a very common thread in these novels all these characters in this novel
are looking for a meaning in life because they feel life is so monotonous or they want to just
stop because they are so exhausted of looking for it and one part that I particularly really really
liked was from Veronica decides to die it's the moment that Veronica realizes that her attempt at
suicide has not been successful and she has to go on living and I really like the way she thinks
okay and the entire life she has before herself it kind of spreads out before her and the way she
writes it in a matter-of-fact way I really liked it I'm alive thought Veronica everything's going
to start all over again I'll have to stay in here for a while until they realize that I'm
perfectly normal then they let me out and I'll see the streets of Yogyana again its main square the
and from work since people always tend to help others just so that they can feel they are better
than they really are they'll give me my job back at the library in time I'll start frequenting the
same bars and same nightclubs I'll talk to my friends about the injustices and problems of
the world I'll go to the movies I'll walk around the lake since I only took sleeping pills I'm not
disfigured in any way I'm still young pretty intelligent I won't have any difficulty getting
a boyfriend I never did I'll make love with them in their houses in the woods I'll feel a certain
degree of pleasure but the moment I reach orgasm the feeling of emptiness will return we won't
have much to talk about and both he and I will know it this time the time will come to make our
excuses it's late or I have to get up early tomorrow and we'll part as quickly as possible
avoiding looking each other in the eye I'll go back to my rented room in the convent I'll try
to read a book turn on the tv to see the same old programs set the alarm clock to wake up exactly at
the same time I woke up the day before and mechanically repeat all my tasks at the library
I'll eat a sandwich in the park opposite the theater sitting on the same bench along with
other people who also choose the same benches on which to sit and have their lunch people who have
all the same vacant look but pretend to be pondering extremely important matters just
the way she writes everything like if you think about things in that way actually they seem very
depressing and monotonous my mother who must be out of her mind with worry about over my suicide
attempt will recover from the shock and will keep asking me what I'm going to do with my life
why I'm not the same as everyone else things aren't really as complicated as I think they are
look at me for example I've been married to your father for years and I've tried you to
give the best possible upbringing and set you the best possible example one day I'll get tired of
hearing her constantly repeating the same things and to please her I'll marry a man whom I oblige
myself to love he and I will end up finding a way of dreaming of a future together a house in the
country children are children's future will make love often in the first year less in the second
and after the third year people perhaps think about sex only once every two weeks and transform
that thought into action only once a month even worse we'll barely talk I'll force myself to accept
the situation and I'll wonder what's wrong with me because he no longer takes any interest in me
ignores me and does nothing but talk about his friends as if they were his real world when the
marriage is just about to fall apart I'll get pregnant we'll have a child feel closer to each
other for a while and then the situation will go back to what it was I'll begin to put on weight
like the aunt the nurse that nurse was talking about yesterday or was it days ago I don't really
know and I'll start to go on diets systematically defeated each day each week by the weight that
keeps creeping regardless of the controls put on it at that point I'll take those magic pills
pills that stop you from feeling depressed I'll have few more children conceived during nights
of love that pass all too quickly I'll tell everyone that the children are my reason for
living when in reality when in reality my life is their reason for living people will always
consider us a happy couple and no one will know how much solitude bitterness and resignation
lies beneath the surface happiness until one day my husband takes a lover for the first time
and I will perhaps kick up a fuss like the nurse's aunt or think again of killing myself by then
though I'll be too old and cowardly with two or three children who need my help I'll have to bring
them up and help them find a place in the world before I can just abandon everything I won't
commit suicide I'll make a scene I'll threaten to leave and take the children with me like all men
my husband will back down he'll tell me he loves me and that it won't happen again it won't even
occur to him that if I really did decide to leave my only option would be to go back to my parents
house and stay there for the rest of my life forced to listen to my mother going on and on
all day about how I lost my one opportunity for being happy that he was a wonderful husband despite
I cannot pronounce his word that my children will be traumatized by the separation two or three
years later another woman will appear in his life I'll find out I'll find out because I saw them
or because someone told me but this time I'll pretend I don't know I used all my energy fighting
against that lover I've no energy left it's best to accept life as it really is and not as I imagined
it to be he will continue to be a considerate husband I'll continue working at the library
in the square opposite the theater reading books I never quite managed to finish
except that I'll eat my sandwiches with a sense of guilt because I'm getting fatter
I won't go to bars anymore because I have a husband expecting me to come home and look
after the children after that it's a matter of waiting for the children to go up and of
spending all day without thinking about suicide without the courage to do anything about it
one fine day I'll reach the conclusion that that's what life is like there's no point worrying about
it nothing will change and I'll accept it oh this is the beginning of the novel so of course this
outlook is very very depressing this outlook really changes at the end of this novel which
is I really liked it but the way it captured the horror horrifying thing about marriage my god it
shall made me shiver hopefully my life is not like that is it married people in the house
anyone thinking about a divorce yet hope not but okay that was a very intense para to read
and I really liked it I remember making I was cooking something while reading this
and I was like should I keep cooking because of course I was making a sandwich at that so yeah
but at the end of the day uh it's about the outlook right like I really want everyone here
to read Veronica Decides to Die if not any other book because I think this was definitely my
favorite amongst all the books I have read in this entire lot okay all the books are great in
their own ways but I think Veronica Decides to Die was my favorite I'd love to know which ones were
yours and yes thank you so much for being a part of today's session I'll stop recording but let's
keep the conversation on and yeah I'll see you guys also in the next book club session
