What works for mens mental health in the workplace?

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Right, I think we will start. I'm sure people will continue to join. We are recording this
and this will be sent through to you afterwards. But look, a very warm welcome and thank you for
joining what I believe is a very important topic around workplace mental health. This one focusing
on men. MQ Mental Health Research has joined together with the University of York to look at
workplace mental health generally and there are going to be a series and I'll mention those
towards the end. But over the course of the next hour, we are going to look at men's health in
particular in the workplace. So just before introducing the two guest panelists, just to
introduce myself quickly. So my name is Chris Parsons. I have been a lawyer for the last 40
years. But during that time, I have struggled with my own mental health issues. And I went public
with that in 2015. And I have to say it was transformational for me,
because I was in a position where I trust my organisation that I was able to talk about my
struggles. And in particular, my struggles were around stress, anxiety, and depression,
very serious depression, where I ended up on a number of occasions off work, under the duvet,
crying. And I guess really wishing that I could go to sleep and not wake up again.
Life was too difficult, too painful. And the reason that MQ have asked me to do this is that
I used to sit on the board of MQ for six years, I stepped down last year. So I've got an interest,
not only in the sort of lived experience, but also in the research that goes to support things
that we might be able to do to help ourselves and to help organisations. So our two panellists,
first, we've got Paul Galdas, and Paul is going to speak first. Paul is the Professor of Nursing
and Men's Health at the University of York. And then separately, we've got Geoff Watts.
Geoff is Operations Manager at Cadent Gas. And he has been very active within Cadent Gas
around the subject of men's mental health. And you'll hear from both of them
in a lot more detail as we go through. Just in terms of housekeeping, I mentioned at the
for those that have joined since, the session is being recorded, and it will be sent through to
you and your organisation. So people will be able to watch it afterwards. And to remind all of you,
please, to set out your questions. There'll be 15 minutes of Q&A, I hope, towards the end of
this session. So please set out your questions in the Q&A chat section. Unless you want me to,
I won't mention your name. So if there are questions you want to ask, and you want to
remain anonymous, that's absolutely fine. And I understand it in the context of this topic.
So please do, I would encourage you to ask any questions that you want to.
And with that, I am going to hand over to Paul. And I'm going to let Paul introduce himself and to
share a short presentation that he's got for us.
It's great. Thanks very much, Chris. Good afternoon, everybody. Hello from quite cloudy
and somewhat chilly York. I'll just share my slides. But before I get into,
are they coming through? Okay, Chris, can you see them fine?
All good, Paul. Perfect. Thank you.
So before I get into a slide deck, I'm going to speak, I'm going to speak for about 15 minutes.
But I just wanted to share a few personal reflections. Because when I do these presentations,
I often think about how best to start it. And I've been mulling over a few things that relate
to my own personal experience recently, over the last six months or so. I've had a few male
friends and colleagues who have been struggling with their mental health. And I think, despite
been doing working in this field for almost 20 years, I find it very difficult still to know
how best to respond sometimes when those people close to me are struggling. Because a lot of men,
and you may know this from your own personal experiences or from those men that you know and
love, do find it very difficult to talk or disclose challenges. And it can be very challenging
when that happens to know how best to provide support, whether that's in your personal life,
or whether that's in the workplace. And I was discussing this with my wife recently. And she
said in a throwaway comment that sometimes men don't help themselves in not being able to open
up. And I think that's a big part of the challenge, is to not look at these challenges as being an
individual men's responsibility always. Obviously, men do have responsibility for taking ownership
around managing some of the challenges that they experience. But really, this is best understood
as being a reflection of how we've socialised men in our society to be self-sufficient, to be
problem solving, to be emotionally walled off. The messages that a lot of boys and young men and
older men still receive are that those are the things that are valued within society. And they
are rewarded in society as well, and often rewarded in workplaces. And so these ideals
have been internalised by a lot of men. And when I say internalised, I don't necessarily mean that
people are always within themselves thinking about how they should best react. It's just part of who
they are. And so a lot of men don't necessarily have the tools or are familiar in a manner that
would enable them to perhaps open up. And sometimes, rushing men to do that can be
counterproductive. And hopefully, as my presentation, I'll show you this afternoon,
that there are other solutions that we need to think about. And it is a bit more complex than
just asking men to open up. And these are some of the things that we often see in men's mental
health. This is topical in terms of it's football related at the moment. I won't go into the
football. But this is Vinnie Jones in a recent campaign in association with Chelsea Football
Club, encouraging men to talk more about mental health, and more than just football women together.
In the absence of support that would enable them to do that, and an environment that would enable
to do that, it really is unlikely to work, the evidence will show. And it really is a significant
problem that we're facing, because a lot of men do experience challenges with their mental health
over the course of their lifetime. If we look at official statistics, that suggests that about
14% of men compared to 19% of women will experience mental health problems over the
course of their lifetime. But surveys consistently show that this is underreported. A more accurate
figure would be around three quarters of the male population experiencing symptoms of anxiety,
stress or depression at some point in their life. It is a common, common problem for men.
But one of the big problems that we face in addressing men's mental health, both in general
population, but also in the workplace, is that many men don't speak out or don't talk about this
or feel unable to disclose their mental health challenges. And a key reason that we see a lower
reported figure in terms of the official incidence of mental health in men is because of
the underreporting of it. And this statistic, I think, really brings that home that 40% of men
have never spoken to anybody about their mental health. And that doesn't just mean professional
health, health professional services, that means anybody, friends, family members, health professionals,
nobody. 40% of men have reported that they've never spoken to anybody about their mental health.
One of the reasons for this is down to mental health literacy, i.e. helping men connect how
they are feeling with something that might be associated with a mental health problem that
they might benefit from getting help for. And there's a significant and growing evidence base
that the symptoms of mental health manifests differently in many men. And often men and those
around them, and including professionals, can sometimes fail to recognise or not appropriately
diagnose some of the symptoms around depression and anxiety. So men, the evidence would suggest,
are more likely to experience anger and frustration, irritability, withdrawal,
distractions, and more likely to engage in some unhelpful coping mechanisms when they are
experiencing mental health challenges. Perhaps unsurprisingly then, if we look at the data,
men are very much underrepresented when it comes to referral to NHS talking therapies,
only around a third of referrals to NHS talking therapies are for men. And the evidence also
shows that even when we get men through the door to access talking therapies, they are more likely
to drop out early. Again, it's a big challenge that we're facing and I think we look at the
further research around access to mental health support, we see that for many men there has to
be an incredibly high threshold for them to feel like they are able or willing to seek professional
health. 40% of men have said they take thoughts of suicide but to compel them to get professional
help. And that leads me to perhaps one of the starkest challenges that we face in this country
in relation to men's mental health generally, is that suicide is a leading cause of death in men
under 50 years old. And I've presented this statistic on so many different occasions and
every time I present it, it always gives me a shudder that suicide is the leading cause of
death for men under the age of 50. Around three quarters of all registered suicides in this
country are male. It peaks between the ages of 45 and 54 and over the last 10 years, the number of
men who experience suicidal thoughts has doubled to around 10%. So the picture is actually much
more complicated though than perhaps what I've presented it. It's not just a simple fact that men
are failing to engage or not willing to engage with mental health services and that's leading
to suicide. We look at the evidence and this recent study from the University of Manchester
shows it quite clearly, is that men who died from suicide in 2017 when the study was done,
91% of them had been in contact with at least one service or agency, one professional service
or agency and of those professional services and agencies, 50% of them were mental health services.
So men are engaging, men are going and accessing services but what we can read into it and from
the broader research underpinning this particular statistic is that services are perhaps not meeting
the needs of men in the way that they would prefer and so if we can summarise the problems
around men's mental health, it's at two different ends. It's first that men often don't feel able
to disclose their mental health problems and challenges and then secondly that current
services are not very well matched to be responsive to men's needs and to address
the challenges of mental health in men, we need to tackle these challenges at both ends
and at both ends, gender norms and masculine norms are at the root of problems but also
how we can find appropriate solutions. So when we talk about gender norms, we talk about
masculinities, what we're referring to is the social norms that define what is acceptable and
appropriate for both men and women in any group or any given society and there are particular
norms that are associated with health, mental health and health-related behaviour. So if we
think of things like dietary consumption, alcohol, exercise, body image, men and women grow up and
learn what is appropriate and what is normal within a given culture or a given setting
for men and women and we receive feedback on what is valued and how we should behave
and the workplace is a setting in which these gender norms and social norms can play out.
So for boys, for young men, the norms around male appropriate behaviour commonly
position men in order to be strong, the opposite of weak, to be competitive and not be passive,
to be in control and to not need help and to be practical and action-orientated and not be
emotionally driven. Now we don't behave like this all of the time and many men won't always
subscribe, maybe not even at all, to a lot of these ideals but what's present within society,
these are the ideals that are upheld as the most valued and as I mentioned, the workplace
is a setting which can act for the policing and the reproduction of these norms. So we get things
like contest culture, hierarchies, a need for control and self-sufficiency, a need to be
assertive, make decisions, how much he appeared, the level of remuneration and these things can
be played out in different workplace cultures but are particularly pronounced in male-dominated
industries which have been shown to have a much higher rate of mental health problems and suicide.
So it's not just as simple as saying we need men to be able to talk and speak out
because if the culture in which they have been socialised or perhaps the culture in which they
are working in acts to reproduce some of these dominant ideals, it can be extremely difficult,
challenging and threatening for somebody to be able to have the bravery to disclose a mental
health problem that they may perceive as going against what is valued. And if we look at the
evidence on men when they do speak out, many men do find it challenging. So in this recent study
from November, 46% of men said that they worried about negative things being said about them behind
their back if they were to discuss mental health issues at work. 36% felt that could be held back
from promotion and 30%, almost one in three men, felt that the job could be at risk if they discussed
mental health issues. And the same study showed that two in five men who have opened up to somebody
else about their mental health regretted doing so and the reasons they regretted doing so was
they felt that either the person that they were speaking to didn't respect them,
they either didn't care about the problem or that they were not taking them seriously at all.
And this plays into one of my favourite quotes that I think sums up some of the challenges
that we have around the current talk in the public domain about men's mental health from
Brene Brown who said that men are often pressurised to open up and talk about their feelings
and criticised for being too emotionally walled off, but if they get too real, if they start
talking too much or they're too honest, it can be met with revulsion and there are real consequences
around that. So men will talk but we as workplaces, as colleagues, as friends, as family members
need to be willing to listen and be responsive in the right way. This recent quote from one of
our recent studies on men's mental health in the National Health Service I think again sums it up
quite nicely, it's quite wordy so I'll read it out and he said there isn't any support in my workplace
and quite often it's laughed at or you're made to feel like or grow up and it's a lot of these
mixed messages I think, there's a lot of oh we need to open up more and then when we do it's like
oh you big babies. I think men in general are in kind of in a weird place where we don't really
know what kind of role we're meant to do. If you do get help and it's in your record like oh it's
you were a bit depressed six years ago and does that mean that I can't do my job now? Am I going
to be judged? You want me to open up? And you can see from this quote that he was in a really
difficult situation and how am I going to, the things that people are saying about how I should
behave might not translate into how people react. Again this is made much more pronounced
in male-dominated industries that this particular quote from a recent study on men working in
male-dominated professions shows that. He said you're not manly if you have mental illness you're
not strong. We're the hunters, we're the gatherers you know. There's a lot riding on your shoulders
to be this strong man and if everything else is a sign of weakness right, it's like a sick animal.
The wolves go after the sick one, just like that at work. Your co-workers, the wolves, are going to go
after that lame deer. So going back to our challenges, if we frame this in the context of
workplaces we can say that we need to tackle these challenges at both ends, that workplace
cultures are not always supportive of men seeking help or disclosing mental health challenges
and if they do then some of the current support services are not always well matched to their
needs. So our solutions need to be around workplace values and culture and in developing support
services that reflect men's needs and preferences. So for the last couple of slides I'm going to
provide some examples and some of the evidence around what works in both of these areas.
Culture and stigma, workplace culture and stigma, is perhaps one of the most challenging things to
address. Stigma is a really complex phenomenon and it encompasses very deeply ingrained beliefs
that are likely to require much more than short-term intervention in order to bring about
meaningful change and there's not a great deal of evidence on what works in this area, but what we
do know are that authenticity is really important in an organisation. Genuine managerial commitment
and buy-in is required in order to promote a culture whereby colleagues and male employees
feel that this is taken seriously. Use of language in order to reduce stigma is also really important
and that's something that's been consistently shown across a range of different studies
involving men and their mental health. So normalising things, talking about staying well,
managing stress, talking about mental fitness rather than mental health, being proactive and
really leveraging and working with many of the positive attributes that many men have in relation
to their masculine identities. So the desire and willingness to provide support to colleagues,
camaraderie, using humour, drawing on often men's willingness around loyalty to their colleagues
and being action-orientated and problem-solving, all of those things can be leveraged in a positive
way in order to promote a culture that is supportive of mental health. In terms of
individualised support or support services, gender is not often thought about in the design of
workplace mental health interventions or very much evident in the standards that guide the
design of workplace mental health supports. So a key recommendation for employers on the
say is to seek evidence if you haven't already on what men are currently accessing in your
organisation. Most organisations invest an incredible amount of money into mental health
support services but knowing which ones men are less willing to access and take up is key
information in order to think about how to overcome some of the challenges because we know that men
will disclose difficulties and we know that they will seek help if there is a safe environment and
therapeutic setting to do so. And men's emotional disclosures are very much impacted by the ability
of others to recognise and respond in a way that's consistent with their ideals and preferences.
So some of the things that we know work in terms of providing a support service that is aligned
with those things is co-producing with the men who are going to receive the intervention. So if
you haven't already and Geoff will speak about some of the work that he's done at Cadent Gas around
this is what the men in your organisation want, what would be accessible for them, how should
services be designed. We know that proactive early intervention is really important as well, not
waiting until men are really struggling. Again some of the evidence that I presented earlier on
speaks to that. Confidentiality and anonymity is again another consistent thing that's shown
across mental health services for men has been incredibly important and providing support such
that men don't fear that they will be threatened or there'll be significant impacts on their
employment should they wish to seek out and get help. A normalising language, practical skills
based approaches are highly valued by a lot of men and those have been framed often in contrast
to those interventions that are seen as just being about talking. And my final slide provides an
example of the workplace support package that we've just developed in partnership with men
working in frontline NHS roles. Well we took a lot of these ideas, developed them into an action
orientated proactive early mental health intervention and men really valued a lot of
the key aspects that I've spoken about this afternoon and were willing to access the service
and found it beneficial. So there are real ways that we can design services such that men will
access them and key to those is speaking with men within your organisation about them. Thank you.
Great, thank you very much Paul. I guess just one specific observation for me at this stage is
you referenced you know how people cope with issues around mental ill health whether stress,
anxiety, depression etc and you know part of my story which I didn't mention earlier was that I
self-medicated for decades with alcohol and I became an alcoholic. I am an alcoholic and
luckily in remission at the moment but you know it was the one thing that you know
sort of kept me alive I guess for a long time. The problem of course is that I ended up with two
problems and not with one so it wasn't ultimately the solution but it worked for a time. So thank
you Paul. Right we're going to move on to Geoff. Geoff I'm really going to just hand over to you
and to let you talk a little bit about you know Caden Gas, your role and in particular your role
within supporting men within the organisation. Yeah thanks Chris and yeah brilliant Paul. That
was really insightful and useful actually and yeah quite thought-provoking. Yeah so I work for
Caden Gas. We are one of the largest pipeline operators in the UK at present. My role is I'm
operations manager and I'm also the chair of an employee community called the Men's Engagement
Network. Caden Gas is made up of around 9,000 employees and around 78-79% of them are male
the rest being female and in our field force that is actually made up of 99.6% of our field force
being male. Now a lot of them are lone workers or working twos and 64% of that is also the
staff as well so it's a very male dominated sort of industry and company. We're making great strides
in to sort of change the balance but as it stands they're the figures we're working with.
And yeah so I've been working for Caden now for about 11 years. My own journey has been a turbulent
one and for the most part of that I've been working here and you know I was a lone working
engineer around seven years ago. I went through various sort of mental health struggles, a family
breakdown and sort of I guess everything led up to that moment that I'd gone through in my life,
my childhood etc. I'd led up to a sort of a pinnacle moment and it ended up with me being
off work for around a year and it all sort of started with a simple question you know very
much like the previous slide said you know I felt as though I had to sort of portray a certain
character, a certain persona. I hid a lot of my emotions, a lot of my struggles, I kept them to
myself. I didn't speak to anybody in fear of you know being viewed as you know unstable,
bit of a mess, a lot going on and again didn't want to sort of put any blockers or you know any
barriers in for me to sort of climb the ladder so to speak and advance my career within the company
and you know in hindsight that that wasn't the answer but I thought I was doing the right thing
and yeah I sort of like I said suffered with a sort of a history of mental health, you know
had quite a turbulent childhood and with the breakdown everything and you know it was just
one day, a normal working day really for me and I was in my van, I'd just been into a job and
I had an unannounced visit from sort of my director and one of the stewards, the union
stewards, just doing a random safety visit and they sort of turned up and my van was always quite
you know very well organized and tidy and on this occasion it wasn't and that was sort of a reflection
of how I was feeling internally I guess at the time and you know when they opened the side of
my van just to have a little look and chat with me you know they was quite shocked at what they
saw and they sort of looked at each other and looked at me and they you know it all started
with the one question was are you okay and at that moment sort of everything come crashing down and
I had a breakdown there on the side of the road and yeah it's all right like I said I end up having
a year off work and during that year that there was a suicide attempt that I did try but
you know thankfully by the grace of god I guess that didn't work and here I am today and
you know the last sort of I guess seven years from that moment has not been a linear path and
it's been a you know a very turbulent you know a lot of pigs and troughs I guess
to where to get where I am now and that's what led me up to getting involved with
one of our employee communities the men's engagement network we've got seven
employee communities within our company that are brilliant offer sort of a safe space for
you know everybody very inclusive environments very supportive environments and two years ago
we'd noticed that we we didn't have a employee community for for the men that there's a brilliant
community for the women that work within our industry which are that is run by an amazing
group of women very brilliant and talented and and they sort of inspired us really to sort of
get going and and get cracking on with the men's engagement network and yeah and for me the
importance of you know relatability person you know having them personal relationships and
and authenticity is is you know it holds so much weight and I think in a world where we we struggle
to you know the most simplest thing to do is to be ourselves but we we as humans you know we
struggle to do that there's a lot of society societal pressures and boxes that you know
sometimes we feel that we have to fit into and for me I did that for most of my life and it
wasn't until I sort of let go of that and and you know just became myself and was happy with myself
that my life become a lot better and and I think with what we're doing within our industry
um and within our companies is exactly that is offering that safe space for for everybody for
for that work within Caden to express their emotions freely um and really sort of get to the
and you know it's a very much a very close-knit community um we're a large company but one thing
that we pride ourselves in is that we have um a very close culture um throughout our company um
and that's something that we um sort of I noticed and thought we can really capitalize on that you
know clan culture can have a negative side but um it can very also have a very positive
um ripple effect because of the way that the sort of relationships work within
the the individual networks and the men's engaging network is doing exactly that um
and yeah we've been doing some brilliant work and some brilliant stuff um and yeah I mean a lot of
where I am today um the the contributions that I've had from my peers from my from my line manager
from the support I've had with my company has been second to none I've been very fortunate um
with that um but unfortunately that isn't the case for everybody you know there's a sort of a
you know that they say it's the line line manager sort of lottery you know it very much depends on
who you have as your manager and who you have within your hierarchy would be dependent on how
your experience is within work um and how confident and how safe you feel to speak up when you are
facing an issue and I think that's something that's one of our sort of main um sort of subjects
is getting the involvement of leadership uh senior leaders senior managers and the board
to sort of encourage that um openness and and that willingness to talk and and you know even
though I disclosed my issues that I was having at the time um that didn't hinder me in my progression
and you know that you know um I was very lucky in that sense but um you know unfortunately there is
some cases where sometimes that does happen and that's something that we'd like to tackle
um sort of one of our main subjects and one of our main pillars really is is that it's
breaking that stigma down um to create that safe space great thank you Jeff um and thank you for
sharing your personal story that's you know that's a serious issue when you're so unwell that you
need to have a whole year off work um you know I I uh empathize um with with with your position there
very much can you just just sort of some practical insight you said you sort of set up the group on
the back of what the women were doing but can you give us a sense of you know how often you meet how
many people would get together and what typically you might talk about yeah of course so um we have
weekly meetings by our teams um we also have in-person meetings uh bi-monthly um we've got
sort of four four pillars that we sort of work with and they are being um physical well-being
mental well-being uh masculinity and outreach um and those four pillars anybody can choose to
um get involved with um and it is really sort of an open forum really to choose um to to sort of
come up with any ideas that we could bring to the table um each employee community has a sponsor
we're very lucky that our sponsor is our coo um harold foster who sponsors our group and he's very
supportive in everything that we want to do and achieve um you know for instance one thing that
we've been working on me myself personally is um a workshop um a sort of a day's workshop around
sort of um you know mental resilience um you know emotional well-being coping mechanisms um and it's
not a prescriptive workshop it's more of a conversation um and an open forum um we've now
done a couple of these sort of to trial um with with all genders and they went down brilliantly
well um you know one of the exercises we do is you know the mask we wear so uh we we get masks
and we sort of um we talk about how we each day we wake up we put on a mask and we will put on
this mask that we put on we'll want to sort of portray um certain characteristics and attributes
that we want the world to see but there may be things that we don't want the world to see
and it's a very thought-provoking um exercise that we do and we sit down and we sort of
do our mast and we talk about them afterwards and sort of speak about um you know what we've
written down on the mask and it was remarkable to see how many people sort of had things in
common or similar um and again it's really about you know everybody experiences life differently
you know we've all got our own frame of reference of how we walk through life and i think but the
one thing that we can do you know as humans is all relate to each other on an emotional level
you know all humans experiencing this world you know it's that like the famous quote you know
we're all simple humans but live in a complex life um and i think that is very much the case
when you sort of get down to the crux of it um and you know sharing stories and you know short
story sharing is something i think that you know we once was amazing at we'd gather around campfires
at points of interest and share knowledge and and share stories and i think you know going back to
that old very old model that's been around for civilizations and just sit around the table and
having them open all these conversations um you know it's it does a lot of good um just sharing
your story um it can inspire somebody else to maybe share theirs and and and maybe they think
themselves well actually i'm dealing with something similar i'm not alone in this situation and i
think that's you know that and that was one big thing that we took from this workshop we've sort of
created um so that's one of the things we've done and a lot of charity work and a lot of
active stuff as well um you know we're doing the free peaks in june we've just done um the
edale scroll on circular there was 30 of us have done that in the free peaks in june there's around
60 of us um and so it's a very sort of we've got a lot of arms that are doing various different
things and at the minute there's around 300 of us um within within the community and there's around
10 board members um but it grows every day um like i said there's a big company and field force is
sort of one of our target audiences because of the nature of their work being lone workers
and and you know and what they experience and what they see they uh work in um line with the
fire brigade the police the ambulance services we get called out to um you know we are the emergency
gas service where we have to get to a job within half an hour to an hour and we see some horrible
things and experience some quite traumatic cases sometimes and these guys are very hard to engage
with and you know that is for us is our main target audience because they are the ones that
are quietly quietly suffering like myself um and like we sort of have discovered uh through our
sort of um you know going up and down the country visiting various depots and speaking to different
people you know there's a lot of that going on and we really do want to try and engage with them
to sort of you know because we feel that they probably could benefit the most as well from
what we're doing thank you jeff and um you talked about masks there i think that there's a really
big issue in in this area around masks i know all about masks i wore a mask for far too many years
and um it was only really when i opened up and told people about the real chris parsons that
actually i suddenly could relax and you know breathe a sigh of relief and and and for people
to see that it was all right to be you know worried in meetings or concerned about um how i was
performing and things and um the the the great danger of course in this area is that we we sort
of assume everyone else is all right and we're not all right and um and because we assume everyone
else is all right we then sort of um think we need to continue in that way and i don't know about
you it sounded a little bit like me that almost my bed my body made the decision for me i wasn't brave
enough to put my hand up and say i'm struggling but i you know i went down to the gym one evening
after work and and collapsed and was rushed to hospital and um i had every single test imaginable
done and at the end the consultant said to me um mr parsons i've got excellent news for you
uh there's nothing wrong with you and and of course that was the last thing i wanted to hear
i wanted to hear that i had something rare and exotic that would explain how um dreadful i was
feeling with there being nothing physically wrong of course there was just a mental health issue
um paul just just um bringing you in here do you have a sense of you know if an organization is
really um in the early stages of trying to grapple with this stuff do you have a sense of some some
initial um actions that they might think about putting in place that that that can make um you
know a reasonably decent impact yeah i think as i've mentioned in my in my presentation that
the first step to addressing the need perceived unmet need is to um start speaking to those who
need to use the service um and so putting together a group of individuals who can help advise
on um what what they would prefer what works what doesn't work um if an organization's currently
just providing um a minimal level of of mental health support or like i say they're attempting
to enhance that level of support um is what's currently being offered uh seen as appropriate
or accessible or or is it something that that people are really reluctant to use and um and
what what would be attractive um i think those are the important things we know some of the key
hallmarks and elements of of what works but there is no one size fits all mental health service
provision that is like the magic bullet for for men's mental health if there was we would have
i would have been a multimillionaire probably um so and i think that the i use the analogy of
you know physical health if we if we were encouraged we're encouraging people for
example to lose weight we don't just offer subsidized gym membership we might also
make sure that healthy food's provided within the canteen we might also speak to people about what
type of food they might find attractive to eat because if the vegetables is going to go and eat
you know there's no point me choosing what's going to be what's going to be cooked cycle to
work schemes my you know a range of different options with the acknowledgement that actually
different things will work for different people and they'll have different preferences and the
same certainly is relevant for mental health and it's not just about talking that is one thing i
say is that some men very much value and and want to open up in a group setting but others don't
feel ready to do that or don't currently have the perhaps the skills the tools the ability to do
that so i think we we mustn't go down a route thinking you know a group talking based um
intervention our program is kind of the be all and end all it's it's not um it's important absolutely
is it it's important um and like jeff's group that that can be a great forum for developing ideas
and it's like i think what jeff said about identifying those that are quietly suffering
like it's great to hear that because there's it's always the people who are not coming that
you that are the ones that are of concern so how do you reach out to those who perhaps
not the proactive help seekers not those who are willing to step forward and from an organization's
perspective i think that's important to consider as well informing a group of people to help advise
not just those who are already enthusiastic but can you get people in who perhaps more reluctant
and that can help to to to identify those like i said more quietly having a difficult time
yeah thank you paul um part of the challenge that i've sort of witnessed in this area is that
organizations are being sent endless different suggestions as to how to address
mental health in the workplace and there are you know literally hundreds of apps and things on the
market um i don't know whether you have a particular view about any of those apps things
like calm and mindfulness and and that sort of stuff any thoughts on that yeah it's a crowded
space it's what i would say it's a crowded space and there are a lot of technology-based
programs and apps that haven't got a great evidence base underpinning them in terms of
working what we do know is that a lot a lot of people download those but then don't use them
um so again there are some that that will definitely resonate with people and mindfulness
based programs one good example that are very very popular but they might not necessarily
be appealing to to others and also um they all occur at different element parts of the spectrum
and so and then and that's another key issue in those seeking to enhance
the mental health support provision within an organization um is that you know we need to think
beyond just when you get to a very difficult point having a having a support service they're
available are there proactive early intervention things that we can do more upstream you know to
support people to develop healthy habits in the same way that we do with our physical health
healthy preventive habits we don't start doing those necessarily when we become poorly we know
that it's good for our physical health to take those actions and so there are there are all
different types of solutions that are currently on the market and available that will enable
points of intervention at different points along the mental health spectrum
um so but i think overall i would say tread carefully into that space around around technology
and apps because there's a few there seems to be a new one almost every day and not necessarily
entirely backed by science great thank you paul um we'll move to q a in a second um
my own experience has been that having senior people share their stories within the organization
was a real catalyst for change so it and i was i was very struck jeff when you mentioned about
your coo being the sponsor of that organization have you just just out of interest jeff had
senior people within your organization standing up and willing to tell their story in a way that
that you just have yeah um we we definitely have um i mean even as of as of recently um
we have a conference every year called the safe and well conference um it's just sort of the whole
uh day's agenda um around sort of 600 people senior leaders uh middle management come together
and we sort of discuss um things that are going on within the company and um i had the privilege
of speaking at that event and and before me um our actual owner um sir adrian monague he actually
spoke on stage and he's in his sort of mid 70s late 70s and he actually spoke about his own
experience uh of dealing with grief and how that affected him and actually cried on stage um
and to be honest before he spoke um i was going around all day in my head you know you know
because i'm an emotional person when i'm talking about something i'm passionate about naturally
you know emotions flow and and i wanted to make remain composed and after seeing him and how he
was and how vulnerable he was with with the man you know who basically owns the company um to say
that was inspiring and sort of then then led me to you know feel more comfortable in my own in my
speech so yeah it's something that's happening more more and more now um and i think you know
as you mentioned it does help it has a domino effect um but that you know as paul obviously
also mentioned it you know not everybody feels comfortable or has the confidence to speak out and
and from what i can see the the tried and tested method for me and and which is is labor is the
grassroots approach is is getting out there and seeing individuals and and being within the
networks having a presence um you know not just over text or phone or email or apps it's being
there in person i think that's our biggest um battle because you know of how big our company
is but yeah they definitely are and it does definitely help and the tides are changing
um but it's still a lot of work to do yeah thank you jeff that's certainly my experience that
being seen to be vulnerable uh and and therefore um encouraging um through their
own vulnerability other people sharing their stories and things and unless you've got the
senior people within an organization willing to make the place safe then it's very difficult for
people to open up i completely agree with that okay we're going to just turn to the q a now i'm
conscious of the time um so the first question was just around employees versus non-employees
so employees there are things clearly offered um and and there are therefore um far less offered
to people who are not employees um any particular thoughts on on that distinction and and how one
group might be able to help um oh yeah i think that's a relevant point that the workplace has
been identified as a key environment to support men's mental health absolutely no question and
but obviously where all efforts and interventions and they've delivered within the context of the
workplace and that will naturally exclude a range of individuals who are not currently in work
or importantly actually when we think about the workplace environment we need to we need to
to think more constructively about those who are working remotely as well and how the workplace
has changed um and how can we best intervene and support individuals when when they're not
physically in a work environment in the traditional sense um so there are there are a range of different
considerations that need to be taken in the design of mental health interventions so they're
accessible to people right across society and as i sort of emphasized there is no one size fits all
we need to do much much better at delivering mental health support for all of all of our
population right now and make them more accessible uh not not just place but the workplace is key
absolutely key for for as a point of intervention for men we know that
thank you paul um but part of the the challenge that i've noticed within within our organization
is that i rang up just to sort of test because i'm interested to test what it would be like to
to call up as as a user to say look i'm and i and i explained to them what i was doing so i wasn't
i wasn't fooling them in that sense and you know and i said look you know if i was struggling with
stress anxiety and depression you know how would it all work and things and actually it was an
amazing service and i was put through to people and i was handled you know carefully and gently
and thoughtfully and all these sorts of things and then separately decided to ask our hr how
what percentage of our of our workforce has has called this in the last year it's four percent
so so you know i think that really goes to your point as well paul is is you know what would
people find helpful you know we we think we've got this amazing service and we pay a lot of money for
it and there are all kinds of experts there at the end of a line who who can help and support us but
if people aren't you know don't feel comfortable with picking up the phone to that sort of
organization then it's hopeless isn't it yeah yeah absolutely right and i think yeah as i've
mentioned getting information and data like that on who is accessing it and how does it how does
that square with the things that we're seeing in relations to things like sickness absence
um and is there a disconnect between people's needs and what's currently being provided because
there are a range of options there that we that we've talked about different types of support
interventions different things that can be done from a grassroots perspective like that jess spoken
about thank you paul there's there's one not surprisingly from somebody anonymous um saying
that you know many companies have a sort of culture of um just you know almost the survival of the
fittest it's almost darwinian um so so the individuals within those organization there
may well be um keen not to share knowledge or to cooperate or help others because if you're doing
that then then somebody else is going to be promoted and not you um just any thoughts about
you know really tough work cultures where it is sort of you know dog eat dog yeah jeff i wanted
to chip in but i think my initial thought to that is it sort of speaks to a criticism around the
development of mental health support in the workplace that's focused on the individual
which which have been criticized for not not focusing on the real problem which is at an
organizational level and things need to change at an organizational level to provide a healthy
workplace uh the nhs has been uh in if you look at the literature on mental health support for
people working in the nhs has been very much criticized for that in so much as um the working
in by individual mental health support has been orientated around developing resilience in
individuals but then the criticism has been we need to create a system that doesn't require people
to be so resilient in order to be able to flourish there um and you know other evidence
shows that well-being is correlated with increased productivity and job satisfaction so it makes no
sense to create an organizational culture that doesn't support that yeah thank you paul any
thoughts from you jeff on on that yeah yeah i mean it's it's something um you know we we try
to tackle within our own within our own company and i think um the trouble is sometimes uh
leadership um managers can often focus too much on the input from individuals um and not so much
on the output and i think if we look at individuals uh output their performance um and if they are
you know underperforming then we can sort of look at that and ask the question as to why and i think
again that that culture um that a lot of companies have the close-knit culture within
the smaller pockets is something that we can use to uh an advantage something and those close
relationships and i think you know the encouragement of mentorship and and and training and teaching
others um and the fulfillment you get out of that is something that we we we do quite well within
um so from my own experience you know i was mentored and i am mentored now um by by senior
leaders and they take time out their own diary in their own day to help me and guide me in anything
that i'm able to pursue and i think we can do that on every single level of the hierarchy um
and i think you know that there is that like that you know like they they rightly said around
underperformers sort of being being let go um without really focusing on you know why why are
they underperforming is there something we can do to help and nurture them so they can become
better in their role um but yeah it's definitely a difficult task to to tackle but um with the
right leadership and the right environment you know anything's possible yeah thank you jeff i
mean i certainly agree with that um look we're we're coming to an end now um the other couple
of questions one was on signposting which i think you know that that's really important that all
organizations should have clear signposting for those that are that are struggling uh so you know
where you can turn to for help and then there was another question around training and development
and treating people properly which is all around um workplace culture which which paul you you
sought to address as well and and you jeff so look i i'm going to wrap up now um so i'd like to thank
you paul and jeff very much indeed um please look out for future webinars that um mq mental
health research and the university of york will be putting on uh in terms of topics um having
looked at men's mental health there's one on loneliness one on the importance of prevention
and then the final one is is around the role of first aiders um in an organization there are
lots of ways that you can get involved with mq mental health research please do um have a look
at their website um uh and part of what they do i know because it was one thing that i used to bang
on about when i was on the board was was around workplace mental health it's something that is
very very close to my heart um they're working mq is working also um with virgin unite and 100
human at work to look at producing a leadership playbook uh on how to build um mentally healthy
organizations so please if you're interested in that then um i think there was going to be
around um where you can get details but irrespective go to the mq website and you'll
be able to find something on that so look we we haven't really scratched the surface
of what is an incredibly important topic but thank you again for joining us and do please look out
for future editions uh of what mq will be doing in conjunction with the university of york so thank
you very much indeed everyone thank you
