Elon Musk revealed Why SpaceX CUT Starship B13's Raptor Nozzle? Here’s what happened… === 00:00: Intro 00:40: Why did SpaceX cut the engine nozzle? 06:49: Long-term impacts 08:30: Potential solutions === #greatspacex#elonmusk#spacex#nasa == Advertisers who want to place ads on our channel, please contact the email manager: [email protected] === SpaceX Starship SN Be the first to sponsor us Thank you. https://www.patreon.com/GreatspaceX?fan_landing=true === Elon Musk revealed Why SpaceX CUT Starship B13's Raptor Nozzle? Here’s what happened… Booster 13’s aft section has returned to Starbase, bringing with it a key discovery. Though it may seem minor, this component has yielded crucial insights. Notably, one of the outer Raptor engine nozzles appears to have been intentionally cut—an action tied to persistent design challenges. This finding highlights ongoing issues with Raptor engines that have surfaced across multiple tests. Why was the nozzle cut? What caused the issue? And how will SpaceX respond? We break it all down in today’s episode of Great SpaceX. Elon Musk revealed Why SpaceX CUT Starship B13's Raptor Nozzle? Here’s what happened… It is clear that SpaceX is continuing its work to recover and analyze Starship hardware, with the most recent effort focused on the aft section of Booster 13. After being retrieved, this segment was transported to the port and later moved to the Massey Test Site for further inspection and analysis. This development is significant because the aft section houses many critical systems, especially those related to the propulsion structure. Throughout the recovery and transportation process, the engines were kept under a blue protective covering. However, prior to this, it had already been observed that some of the engine nozzles appeared to be visibly warped. Additionally, certain protective panels located in the upper areas of the aft section were missing entirely. Elon Musk revealed Why SpaceX CUT Starship B13's Raptor Nozzle? Here’s what happened… Initially, it was reasonable to assume that these damages had resulted from the stresses of flight, along with the corrosive effects of prolonged exposure to seawater. However, a more recent observation has uncovered a very specific and unusual detail that has since sparked new discussions regarding this booster’s condition. One of the nozzles from an outer ring engine had clearly been cut. This particular engine was located near several other engines with visibly distorted nozzles, which suggests that it may have suffered similar damage. Based on the current set of images taken of this section, it is not entirely clear when this nozzle was cut. What we do know is that by the time it was covered with the blue cloth, the cut had already been made. My personal assessment is that the cut was performed at the same time that crews removed other significantly damaged parts from the upper side of the aft section.
Booster 13's a section has returned to
Starbase, bringing with it a key
discovery. Though it may seem minor,
this component has yielded crucial
insights. Notably, one of the outer
Raptor engine nozzles appears to have
been intentionally cut, an action tied
to persistent design challenges. This
finding highlights ongoing issues with
Raptor engines that have surfaced across
multiple tests. Why was the nozzle cut?
What caused the issue? And how will
SpaceX respond? We break it all down in
today's episode of Great SpaceX. It is
clear that SpaceX is continuing its work
to recover and analyze Starship hardware
with the most recent effort focused on
the aft section of B13. After being
retrieved, this segment was transported
to the port and later moved to the
Massie test site for further inspection
and analysis. This development is
significant because the aft section
houses many critical systems, especially
those related to the propulsion
structure. Throughout the recovery and
transportation process, the engines were
kept under a blue protective covering.
However, prior to this, it had already
been observed that some of the engine
nozzles appeared to be visibly warped.
Additionally, certain protective panels
located in the upper areas of the A
section were missing entirely.
Initially, it was reasonable to assume
that these damages had resulted from the
stresses of flight along with the
corrosive effects of prolonged exposure
to seawater. However, a more recent
observation has uncovered a very
specific and unusual detail that has
since sparked new discussions regarding
this booster's condition. One of the
nozzles from an outer ring engine had
clearly been cut. This particular engine
was located near several other engines
with visibly distorted nozzles, which
suggests that it may have suffered
similar damage. Based on the current set
of images taken from this section, it is
not entirely clear when this nozzle was
cut. What we do know is that by the time
it was covered with the blue cloth, the
cut had already been made. My personal
assessment is that the cut was performed
at the same time that crews removed
other significantly damaged parts from
the upper side of the aft section.
Putting the timeline aside, a more
important question needs to be
addressed. Why did SpaceX cut off the
nozzle of this engine? One likely
explanation is that the nozzle was so
badly damaged that it could no longer
provide meaningful data for analysis.
Another possibility is that its
condition posed a risk to nearby
components and it was therefore removed
to prevent further complications during
transport or testing. If either of these
is true, then the next logical question
becomes, what caused the nozzle to
become so severely affected? As
previously mentioned, the damage could
have occurred during flight, during
splashdown, or possibly during both.
However, the most probable source of the
damage appears to be linked to events
that took place during the powered
flight phase. Supporting this idea, some
users on X have circulated a still
frame, possibly extracted from the
flight live stream that shows a
concerning moment. During engine
operation, bright sparks were seen
flaring between two engines in the outer
ring. If you weren't watching closely,
this detail would be easy to miss. So,
what exactly caused this sparking? As
you may already know, the Raptor engines
operate under extreme stress throughout
flight. From liftoff all the way to the
point of shutdown, these engines deliver
tremendous thrust. On the Super Heavy
booster, the outer ring engines are
primarily used during ascent, where they
generate up to 2/3 of the total thrust.
Given this immense power, structural
wear is inevitable. Previous recovery
attempts have already shown just how
intense these burn environments can be,
especially when looking at heat and fire
damage in the engine bay. The outer ring
engines on Superheavy do not have gimbal
capability. This makes them more
vulnerable to structural impact since
they cannot move to relieve stress or
realign themselves during thrust
operations. But that is only part of the
problem. Another major factor is the way
energy moves through the engines during
operation. Thrust is not only directed
downward. Heat and pressure are also
distributed outward which creates
lateral forces. As these engines heat
up, the nozzles expand. If two
neighboring engines expand in this way,
their nozzles can make contact. Since
the outer engines are packed tightly
together, the chances of physical
interference between them becomes even
more likely. To better understand this
situation, we should take a look at the
materials used in the Raptor engine
nozzles. These nozzles are constructed
using a layered combination of
specialized materials. The inner lining
is made of copper which is an excellent
conductor of heat and helps manage the
immense thermal loads generated during
operation. Over this copper core is a
coating of nickel cobalt alloy. This
coating forms a protective barrier that
resists oxidation and corrosion in high
temperature environments. Finally,
stainless steel is used to form the
outer shell as well as the weld points
that hold the assembly together. This
steel adds strength and helps support
the integrated regenerative cooling
system. SpaceX selected these materials
for a reason. They provide a combination
of heat resistance, strength, and
reliability that is essential for the
reusability of the Starship system. The
Raptor engine must survive extreme
conditions and remain structurally sound
to allow multiple flights. However,
achieving that level of reliability is
still a work in progress. Despite their
robust design, the nozzles remain
susceptible to deformation when exposed
to intense flight heat and pressure.
After enduring the stresses of ignition
and sustained burn, the engines then
suffer another extreme shift in
environment when they hit the ocean. The
temperature drops rapidly, leading to
what is known as thermal shock. This
sudden cooling can cause metal
components to contract rapidly and
change shape. The materials become
significantly weakened as a result. Once
the temperature stabilizes, these
deformed nozzles often harden in their
new warped condition. In some cases, the
metal becomes so brittle that any
further force, such as a strong ocean
current, a wave impact, or a hit against
the sea floor, could cause breakage or
cracks. That explains why upon recovery,
we sometimes find engine nozzles that
are completely dented, shredded, or cut.
At this point, these nozzles are no
longer usable for flight. Their role is
now limited to providing engineers with
post-flight data. The engine with the
cut nozzle was most likely removed
either because the damage was too
extensive for meaningful study or
because it posed a risk to other
components during recovery. These are
the possibilities that I believe best
explain why SpaceX chose to cut off the
nozzle of that engine. Do you agree with
the analysis or do you have a different
theory about what might have happened?
Feel free to share your thoughts in the
comments. And if you found this
breakdown helpful, be sure to like the
video and subscribe to our channel to
stay uptodate on SpaceX's ongoing
progress. Of course, these issues extend
well beyond the B-13 flight. They speak
directly to the long-term viability of
Starship and Superheavy on the road map
ahead. One key consideration is SpaceX's
plan to increase the number of Raptor
engines to 35 or more. In the 35 engine
configuration, two additional engines
are placed in the inner ring of Super
Heavy. That may sound unrelated to the
outer ring issues, but in reality, it
tightens the available space in the
engine bay and significantly increases
the risk of nozzle collisions across all
rings. As the engine count rises, the
probability of interference, including
thermal and mechanical overlap also
increases. That presents a serious
engineering challenge. If SpaceX wants
to scale up the thrust, and thus the
number of engines, they will need to
adapt in one of two ways. either expand
or reconfigure the engine bay so that
the engines have more clearance or make
the engines themselves more compact.
Both routes require substantial
engineering effort and time.
Additionally, downsizing the engine
could lead to trade-offs. Reduced
thrust, complexity, and cooling, or
higher production cost. All of this
complicates the road to increasing
engine count without sacrificing
performance. Another consequence of
nozzle deformation or damage like we saw
on B13 is the reduced potential for true
reusability. Engines that require
partial or full disassembly from the
booster are costly and timeconuming to
refurbish. Their performance may also
degrade for subsequent flights. When
operating at a high frequency with rapid
turnarounds and dozens of reuses per
year, the current Raptor design may not
scale efficiently. That raises serious
concerns about whether the current
engine architecture can meet Starship's
intended reusability goals. So, what
solutions might SpaceX pursue? Many in
the community hope for Raptor 3, a
redesigned engine version that addresses
known limitations. Introduced in last
year's company presentations, Raptor 3
is visually distinct with its black
finish and simplified upper systems.
This simplification cuts down on
complexity, volume, cost, and
importantly, turnaround time for both
production and refurbishment. But under
the hood, the engine's lower section,
especially the nozzle, likely contains
much more robust engineering. I expect
Raptor 3 to be reinforced in every
structural detail. This may include new
materials or cooling strategies to
resist high thermal stress. The nozzle
may feature alloys or geometries
specifically designed to reduce
expansion and deformation under thrust.
There may also be improved thermal
protection and insulation to reduce
incidental contact with adjacent
engines. In parallel, the engine
compartment itself, particularly on the
next generation Starship B3, is likely
to be re-imagined. During SpaceX's May
company talk, images showed that engine
bay covers were removed and replaced
with a more open structure. This
provides more clearance and reduces the
likelihood of nozzle collisions. The
engine layout appears less cramped,
giving engines greater room to expand
and tilt safely under heavy load.
Currently, this V3 variant is under
construction. Booster B18 is already
stacked in Mega Bay, awaiting V3
outfitting. If SpaceX follows typical
scheduling, Raptor 3 engines may begin
installation around the end of August or
the start of September. If integration
and testing proceed smoothly, we may see
the first V3 flight by the end of the
year. But even with major upgrades, one
factor remains critical. How the booster
lands. If Super Heavy or Starship
continued to splash down in the ocean,
many of these hardware gains might be
undone by corrosion, impact trauma, or
thermal shock. That is why landing on
the Mechazilla arms remains the optimal
recovery approach. It preserves hardware
integrity to the highest degree.
Refurbishing a fully intact engine after
a clean catch is far easier than working
on a seawater soaked or structurally
compromised one. Mechazilla's
effectiveness has already been proven.
Raptor 314, an outer ring engine, was
recovered and flown a record three
times. I expect SpaceX to leverage the
success model fully as it transitions
into Starship V3 operations. Clean
catches should dramatically reduce
engine damage and accelerate fleet
turnaround. The B-13 engine anomaly is a
textbook example. Detailed analysis of
its deformed and cut nozzle will inform
future design revisions. The data
arriving at the Massie test site will be
invaluable in refining new Raptor
variants. At the same time, keep an eye
on the upcoming flights of booster V1
and ship V2. These missions may reveal
further insights into materials aging,
thermodynamics, and stress response
under repeated cycles. The direction is
clear. Raptor 3, V3 engine bays,
mechazilla landings, and rapid feedback
loops are SpaceX's strategy for solving
these challenges. The road is long, but
each step moves Starship toward the
future Musk and SpaceX envision a fully
reusable high thrust launch system
capable of interplanetary missions. Let
me know what you think. Are you
optimistic about the shift to Raptor 3
and Mechazilla landings, or do you
foresee further structural or materials
hurdles ahead? Share your thoughts in
the comments and don't forget to like
the video and subscribe to our channel
as we continue to trace SpaceX's
evolution. This has been Kevin with
Great SpaceX. Thank you so much for
watching and always remember, curiosity,
imagination, and inspiration will follow
you so long as you keep looking up.