斯賓諾莎:人為何造神來奴役自己?一出版就被禁,震撼全歐洲的政治哲學!一本來自地獄的書,揭露奴役的心理機制,統治階級如何操控群眾? 哲學爽歪歪EP11 斯賓諾莎《神學政治論》

超級歪 SuperY
23粉絲
#造神的心理學 #自由的政治哲學
📣留言加分享本貼文就有機會抽《不馴的異端》一本
📅參加抽獎活動時間為期一週:2024.5.10 - 2024.5.17
👍 感謝 麥田出版 的熱情贈書
「我努力不嘲笑人類的行為,不為它們哭泣,也不憎恨它們,而是理解它們。不要笑,不要哭,不要恨,而要理解。國家的目的其實就是自由。」― 斯賓諾莎《神學政治論》
“I have striven not to laugh at human actions, not to weep at them, nor to hate them, but to understand them.” ― Baruch Spinoza, Tractatus Theologico-Politicus
Philosophy is a blast making you
feel great Each episode introduces you
to a philosopher In the previous video we introduced Spinoza's Ethics
In this video we will introduce Spinoza's political
philosophy which is the book "Theological-Political
Treatise " exploring how people can break free from social constraints to achieve true freedom
The book "Theological-Political Treatise" was published in 1670 Spinoza said the purpose of
this book was to defend freedom of thought Humans
have an innate desire for freedom of employment
But this freedom was often violated At
that time Amsterdam was the most tolerant
city in Europe The Dutch constitution
established that everyone has religious freedom
You will not be harassed on the issue of worshiping a deity
This national commitment states that you have the freedom to practice your religion
but you do not have the freedom not to believe
Spinoza was persecuted for being considered an atheist
The Dutch government even imposed a regulation
The religious power was too great hindering the freedom of philosophers' thinking
Therefore Spinoza wrote this book
in an attempt to expose the facade of religious authority and the government
Hope to invite intellectuals to dispel superstition and lead society towards enlightenment
This book was so shocking in content
The publisher decided to publish it under a pseudonym
As a result it shocked all of Europe upon publication
The book criticized as a decadent work a book from hell
was declared an illegal publication by the high court the following year
among the intellectuals of that time
Only Leibniz wrote to Spinoza expressing admiration
most others accused Spinoza of being an atheist
Saying his existence would threaten the Dutch Republic
This made Spinoza somewhat like Socrates
Socrates was also accused by the elite class
His statements threaten the city-state and he must be executed
Let's now discuss
how Spinoza's "Theological-Political Treatise" defends philosophical freedom
Spinoza's political philosophy
The fundamental purpose is to make people more free beings
That requires asking
What makes people unfree in society
Who controls public opinion and monopolizes the right to interpret truth
In today's world it could be political parties or online armies
but in 17th century Europe it was religious groups
Because there has always been a struggle between royal power
and religious authority in European history the king would use the church's power
to more easily rule the people but the problem is that giving too much power to religious organizations
People would rather obey the church than the king As a
result the church ended up ruling the country instead
of the country ruling the church The issue of religion interfering in politics still exists to this day
In some U S states official regulations require
teaching Darwin's theory of evolution which
leads religious conservatives to protest
claiming it infringes on their religious freedom
When the authority of the monarchy and the church clash who has the final say
The British philosopher Hobbes mentioned this in his "Leviathan "
The king governs the government of the counties and cities the church governs the government of the afterlife
But there can only be one legitimate authority that is the king
Otherwise the people would be confused
What about the clergy
They are nothing but a league of frauds
Spinoza also had similar views that religion uses emotion to
control people's thoughts and ultimately aims to seize
state power Therefore criticizing
religion is not just about opposing
superstition but to enable people's intellectual liberatio
It allows for more freedom to explore philosophical truths
Therefore Spinoza begins his religious critique
First by using a psychology to explain the origin of religion
In human life good and bad luck often occur
this kind of fortune challenges a person 's
sense of control if someone always has good luck they will not seek an explanation
It might be seen as a result of one's own effort and deserved
but if a person works very hard yet keeps having bad luck
at this point people start to think
why am I so unlucky
Is there some external force interfering with my life
When people are filled with fear they imagine an external force that doesn't exist
like evil spirits gods or karmic debts from past lives
There must be an entity behind every bad action
because once a person imagines the existence of an external force
they can further imagine that
they can control this external force with certain methods
So humans invented the ritual of sacrifice to calm the gods' anger
In this way the master-servant relationship was reversed
Originally my life was controlled by bad luck
Now I am the one in control
People regain a sense of control in life
Therefore religion actually originates from a psychology of control
People use religion to regain lost control
This leads to an interesting conclusion
Does that mean people don't need faith once life improves
Marx and Nietzsche actually held this view
We don't need to waste time criticizing religious beliefs
When people regain control of their lives they no
longer need to seek solace in religion but if that were
the case religious organizations would lose a large
number of followers therefore to maintain their power
Religious organizations have developed various laws rituals and theologies to control the masses
ensuring that people continue to believe even when
they don't encounter any obstacles in their lives
For example ancient Rome had fixed festivals held to entertain the gods
These religious festivals could play an important political role
When the Roman emperors did something wrong
When problems arise in society people do not blame
the ruler for not knowing how to govern instead
they blame themselves for neglecting religious rituals
they must not have been devout enough to the gods
It is this that leads to poor national fortune and continuous misfortune
In this way political figures can form alliances with religious groups to consolidate their power
People will not realize that the problem lies not with themselves
Instead they would want to contribute more to the country to maintain a sense of control
Therefore Spinoza's political philosophy fundamentally aims to address this issue
Why do people stubbornly defend the power that
enslaves them as if it were their salvation
Then Spinoza further used psychology to criticize
the belief in personal gods in many religions
Gods of Judaism and Christianity are just like humans with emotions
Gods in Chinese tradition are also human-like
and even some humans became gods
Spinoza explains why gods in many religions are like humans
The psychology behind this is
people feel that the most powerful person in society is the king
A king can issue orders as he pleases and
launch wars to invade other countries and
a nation can be destroyed Similarly when earthquakes and natural disasters occur
That power was like a king destroying a country
That would mean there is a sovereign entity behind the natural disaster like a king
Therefore God must be a personal god like a king
The concept of the Japanese emperor's unbroken lineage is similar to this
The psychology behind idolization
is that humans project their imagined
state of perfection onto the
outside Therefore Spinoza said if a triangle could
speak it would say that God is a perfect triangle
After criticizing the personal god Spinoza then criticized
the prophets in religion because the origins of many
religions are traced back to a group of ancient prophets
and Moses is said to have communicated directly with God
The Word became flesh in Jesus
Muhammad received revelation from the archangel Gabriel
These prophets claimed to bring God's law to the world
Teach people how to live a good life because the knowledge that God
gives to humans is certainly better
than what philosophers can offer
In this way theology monopolized the definition of what is
true and what is good which is exactly what Spinoza was against
So he argues that the prophets could not monopolize the
truth The wisdom of the prophets lies not in speaking
the words of God but in speaking what the people
wanted to hear and what the people were afraid to hear
Because they understood crowd
psychology knew what the
crowd desired and feared and could explain things in a
way that ordinary people could understand for example
Moses told the Israelites that God is a consuming fire
In Hebrew the word for
fire also means anger
which is a metaphorical
way of depicting angry God
In other words the prophet's advantage over the philosopher lies in the prophet's willingness to condescend
to the audience's level of understanding whereas the
philosopher doesn't care whether people understand or not
Next philosophy loses to theology because
philosophers do not have the same rich imagination as
prophets Spinoza believed that prophets were actually
people who were very good at filling in the blanks
Your imagination is too strong able to transform
prophecies into images symbols and dreams then
tell vid stories which makes it more down-to-
earth than the abstract arguments of philosophers
So people go to church to hear the preacher'
s sermons but few go to university to listen
to philosophers lecture in other words the
founders of religious organizations are very smar
They know that the general public's level of
knowledge is low so they need to awaken people 's
sense of morality using fictional stories is
more effective than philosophical arguments
Because even if a person does good deeds after
hearing a false story this person is still doing good
But Spinoza strongly opposed this view If
you don't do bad things because someone told
you that you will go to hell after death
then you are actually being threatened by fear
It's not because you truly know what is good and evil it's your emotions that determine
your actions not your reason you are essentially a
person being extorted by emotions not truly free
Spinoza believed this actually hindered the development of human reason
You lack knowledge of good and evil
and simply act on instinct driven by emotions
like an adult deceiving a child
Bad things will make the police take you away
In fact we can use rational arguments
to tell people why doing good is good
and why you should love your spirit
It is not because God says so but rather arguments
should be presented so that
people act in accordance with
obedience and reason which Spinoza called true religion
but the view of Jewish law is exactly the opposite
If people do good deeds because of reason
rather than faith they will not receive
God's blessing Oh no Therefore Spinoza actually praises Paul in the New Testament
Because when Paul was preaching his speech
had a logical structure unlike Moses who
merely cited God's authority and said what
you should do after
criticizing the prophets
Spinoza then proceeds to criticize the concept of the supernatural which refers to
anything beyond the scope of natural science
explanation such as miracles or divine acts
Supernatural phenomena are actually a significant metaphysical
issue in the West because natural science emphasizes that
every effect has a cause and that every phenomenon can be traced
back to a specific cause but if supernatural phenomena exist
It suggests that some external force can interfere with natural processes
Therefore many philosophers have had to provide explanations for supernatural phenomena
For example Leibniz believed that supernatural phenomena exist
It would mean the world is imperfect and needs constant maintenance which
would imply that God should not have
created such a world in the first place
So if there really are miracles they should
have been arranged by God from the beginning of
creation and the miracles that will happen in the
future were already implanted at the very start
But once miracles are allowed to exist the causal sequence of
the natural world is disrupted
Newtonian mechanics tells us tha
But if there are miracles then Newton's laws
can be violated For example when Moses led the
Israelites out of Egypt God parted the Red Sea
Should people believe the Bible or Newton's laws
Spinoza said that all supernatural phenomena
must have some natural cause it's just that
the parties involved lack the knowledge to
explain them because nature is a single entity
All things are determined by natural laws
Therefore there is no such thing as chance in the universe
People who believe in miracles and supernatural phenomena
do not represent that they are devout but that they are ignorant
Unable to understand the causal sequence of nature
For example the Bible says
After the great flood receded God placed a rainbow before Noah
But Spinoza himself was an expert in optics
He said it was nothing more than the refraction of sunlight
through water vapor It was simply that people in ancient times did not
understand it and mistakenly believed it was the power of the gods Or it could be the story of the Virgin Mary's pregnancy
Philosopher Sam Paris believes that this is an incorrect
translation of the Hebrew text which mistakenly
translated "young woman" as
"virgin " so all supernatural
phenomena can actually be reasonably explained causally
But the ruling class happens to like the ignorance of the masses so they can tell
miracles and supernatural phenomena to control
the believers because for the general public
The simplest way to prove the existence of God is to
say that miracles intervene in the workings of the world
but Spinoza instead believed that believing in
supernatural phenomena is actually a blasphemy against God
Because the physical laws of nature were originally created by God
Why would God do something that violates the laws He created
Isn't that an extremely contradictory God
The existence of miracles actually proves God's
limitations because He created an imperfect world
that He has to constantly maintain which reflects
the incompetence and irrationality of the creator
Spinoza's critique of the supernatural laid
the foundation for the rise of Western natural
science If an earthquake occurs in nature you
must seek an explanation within nature itself
Do not resort to a supernatural explanatio
After criticizing religion Spinoza now turns to
discussing law and the origin of the state as this
is also related to religion After Moses led the
Israelites out of Egypt they encountered a problem
The Israelites were a slave class in
Egypt The standards they had to follow
were clear But after their liberation
there was no law to guide their lives
They actually became a stateless people
there was no ethnic identity in order to
unify the Israelis into a single nation
Moses started from scratch to create the laws
What to wear and what to eat is what makes a person
an Israeli and distinguishes them from other nations At this
time Moses realized that if the members of the
community followed the law not
out of fear but out of loyalty
This community would become stronger So Moses
told the people that these laws were not his
own creation but were
given to him by God because
the Israelites were the people chosen by God
Some Jewish sects even believe that the souls of
Jews look different from those of other nations
which makes even the most ordinary daily actions of Israelis full of religious significance
It seems as if my actions are affirming God's law
the concept that Jewish law and the Jewish people are God's chosen
is actually a rhetorical device invented by leaders
In other words the existence of the law is not meant for individual religious salvation but for
the well-being of the nation community and society
which led Spinoza to an important conclusion
Since the Jewish law was intended for the
national interest of the Jews once the Hebrew
kingdom ended the Jewish law became unnecessary
because the Jews no longer had a country
So after the Jews were dispersed to various places
they should abide by the laws of each country
This is why Spinoza was expelled by the
Jewish community of his time He
believed that Jews considered themselves chosen by God this sense of national superiority
Instead it would tear apart their relationships with
other groups In the 17th century Europe fought 30 years
of religious wars At that time philosophers were all
thinking about one question:
How is social order possible
The nation and the church claimed to bring peace and happiness why then
did they bring war and casualties
Therefore the philosophers of that time
For example Hobbes said we can imagine how
humans would interact in a state of anarchy Hobbes believed that everyone would pursue
their own interests and
expand their own rights
Because at this time there was no government to
decide what was right or wrong in terms of law so using
violence to fight for resources was not considered
illegal The result is that the
strong will dominate others
But the weak can also unite
to dominate the strong
become stronger than him in a state of nature everyone fears each other
fights each other and this
nation might soon perish unable to protect itself
So rational people will find that peace is
actually more beneficial for everyone There must be
an impartial arbitrator to
end this state of anarchy
Therefore the warring parties signed a treaty
Granting a supreme authority capable of enforcing peace
This is the origin of the state
Spinoza partially agrees with this view
That's right human nature is always pursuing self-preservation
But Hobbes supported monarchy meaning
sovereignty belongs to a single
individual a king Spinoza believed
monarchy was an
infringement on freedom
Because rulers do not necessarily act in the people's interest
Democracy can achieve the country's common good
Because in a democratic assembly
it is unlikely that the majority would simultaneously allow foolish actions to happen
Democracy can allow for the existence of irrational
individuals as long as they don't become the majority because
rational people can still block unreasonable legislative
proposals if the law is approved with the people's consent
People obeying the law is actually obeying
their own will This idea was very important
to Spinoza Being a law-abiding citizen is not because I am a slave to the law
But because I believe the law is reasonable and is affirmed by my will
What if the state passes an unreasonable bill even turning into a tyranny
At this point people become slaves to the law
That the people have the right to resist the
state's abuse of power and to reclaim the rights they originally granted to the state
Spinoza believed
the purpose of the state is to allow citizens to freely develop
here freedom means being able to use reason without restrictions
Free from the constraints of emotional fear
For example people who break the law will be punished by the state
but if citizens can understand why the law has these regulations
what is the reasoning behind them
Citizens do not refrain from doing bad things because
of fear but because of reason and therefore become more
free people In order to allow
citizens to grow freely the
state should also guarantee citizens' freedom of speech
Spinoza's friend Colbrog was
imprisoned for publicly opposing the
church and died in prison an event
that had a great impact on him
Spinoza's argument in defense of freedom of speech has three levels First if one day the law
prohibits certain statements from being made citizens
will still continue to express what they believe
It's just about expressing it privately and keeping it hidden from others
This is similar to how many countries ban marijuana
This does not make the desire for marijuana disappear
It just turns into buying marijuana privately
So Spinoza said that what
cannot be forbidden should
necessarily be allowed even if it is accompanied
by harm The current Dutch attitude towards marijuana
is actually like that Then comes the emotional level
Suppressing freedom of speech leads to feelings of resentment among the people
people end up hating each other
society becomes less united
ultimately this is detrimental to efficiency
Freedom of speech helps increase human knowledge and creativity Like
the Netherlands in the 17th century
which experienced high development in
economy art and culture By contrast look at today's China where many literary and artistic creations
are subject to official censorship
Many Hollywood movies cannot be shown in
China which prevents society from releasing
cultural creativity but Spinoza has a line when it comes to freedom of speech
If it's incendiary speech that could overthrow
the state the government should censor
it other things like jokes that discriminate against merchants should be tolerated
Today's video we introduced Spinoza's "Theological -Political Treatise" to defend the freedom
of philosophy from infringement Spinoza
proposed a psychology of the origin of religio
Exclude the possibility of miracles
Expose the prophet's discriminatory abilities
Finally deny the legitimacy of religious law
Defend the freedom of speech guaranteed by the state
This earned Spinoza the title of Father of Modernity
Pioneer of the Enlightenment
Revolutionary movements in Britain France and the United States
A secular government was established after the revolution
free from the intervention of religious forces
If ethics is about liberating the individual
then theological politics is about liberating the citizen
To criticize the forces in
society that superficially
appear as salvation but actually bring about
bondage and to achieve true freedom one must expose the psychological mechanisms behind this bondage
Let the public know how they are being manipulated by emotions
We can also think about
which voices in today 's
society are disguised as salvation but
actually bring bondage and why people
stubbornly defend the forces that enslave them
It seemed like their redemption
Hong Kong Daily Ming Pao Canada Hong Kong Daily Ming Pao Toronto
