Warren Smith, profesorul din videoclipul viral despre J.K. Rowling, despre puterea gândirii critice

Renaștere culturală
65 followers
Sursa: https://www.theepochtimes.com/epochtv/warren-smith-teacher-in-viral-video-on-j-k-rowling-on-the-power-of-critical-thinking-5682339?utm_source=Goodevening&src_src=Goodevening&utm_campaign=gv-2024-07-11&src_cmp=gv-2024-07-11&utm_medium=email&est=AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAbeMndB4D6czNorABs9Eo4XAF1DejV2ydtqEeDIc%3D?utm_source=ref_share&utm_campaign=copy?utm_source=ref_share&utm_campaign=copy
#BunătateaEsteExtraordinară
I think the Socratic method is within us.
If you kind of have the right intention, the right goal, it often just happens.
I don't think Socrates invented the Socratic method.
I think he discovered something that was already there.
Back in February, high school teacher Warren Smith posted a routine video of an exchange
he had with a student, an exercise in Socratic dialogue and critical thinking.
Within a short time, the video went viral.
Four months later, his life is dramatically changed.
I never in a thousand years would have guessed that that would have gone viral, and to me,
that's indicative of a larger problem.
The fact that there's that much hunger for logic and critical thinking and seeing a transformation
occur, that is what went viral?
Really?
This is American Thought Leaders, and I'm Jan Jekielek.
Warren Smith, such a pleasure to have you on American Thought Leaders.
Thank you for having me.
Appreciate it.
Probably many of the people watching this show now will have seen your famous video
of helping someone change their mind.
That's what I remember, helping someone change their mind from a position they hadn't thought
out very much but seemed to hold quite strongly.
I remember seeing that and feeling empowered and inspired.
The thing that sticks with me is your demeanor more than the content.
You were truly open to this person.
Tell me a little bit about what you were up to here.
Well, I wasn't really thinking about what I was doing in that video, so I have since
thought about it.
I'm like, okay, well, why did that have the effect it had?
But as far as the demeanor thing, that just comes from, it's not a conscious thing, it's
just my personality.
But I think it's from growing up, I never knew anyone that really thought differently
about politics or anything.
I wouldn't consider myself political.
I think things have shifted a lot since 2016.
After 2016, then trying to have conversations with your family, with people that you love
or close friends and you're not just, you learn to navigate it delicately and everyone
seems to disagree with you on certain topics.
That's where that comes from, I think.
Also just as a teacher, it's useful in the classroom.
There's something more there.
You're actually employing a way of thinking, right?
You're playing the Socratic method.
Tell me what you're doing, and this isn't even what you teach.
You teach filmmaking, right?
At high school level, I teach multimedia, video editing, podcasts.
It is the Socratic method, and I can't argue with that.
I wasn't consciously doing it, though.
Oh, I see.
So that's what's interesting, is that I think the Socratic method is something, like many
things that are highly effective, it's within us.
If you have the right intention, the right goal, it often just happens.
I don't think Socrates invented the Socratic method.
I think he discovered something that was already there.
So imagine the ocean, and we have boats floating on the ocean.
The boats are the words.
Beneath the surface is subtext.
That's the relation between words and subtext, but also beneath the surface is the elusive
and tangible, everything that we're trying to articulate with our words.
The boats are just tools.
Words are just tools.
They're not the end-all, be-all, and people put so much stock in terminology, but they're
just what we're trying.
We're bumbling our way through, like me right now speaking to you.
There's something deeper, subconscious, that I'm trying to communicate through you, through
these tools, as they pop in my mind.
So those patterns are what interest me.
That's what I think the Socratic method is all about, is identifying what's beneath the
surface, what's underneath assumptions.
That's really critical thinking.
It's beyond just the Socratic method.
It's looking at what is actually happening, and why is it happening, so then I can understand
how to navigate it and learn from it.
So you were just genuinely trying to figure out where this guy was coming from?
I was intrigued, genuinely, yeah.
It had been a story in the news, accusations towards J.K.
Rowling, so I think that's part of the reason he brought it up.
I had a feeling, because that's usually how those certain conversations that are built
upon presuppositions often stick to a pattern.
That's why they're presuppositions.
Again, that's beneath the surface, those patterns, the elusive and tangible.
You can kind of see it coming.
But yeah, that's what I was kind of thinking.
So when we were talking earlier, first of all, you said that it's not your favorite
thing to have everyone always talk to you about this, but it resonated with people,
right?
I think people find themselves in situations like this all the time, where someone confronts
with something and they know that the core assumption is wrong.
Maybe they don't even know how wrong or what it is, but they know there's something
wrong with that, and they don't know where to start.
How do I respond to this, right?
And challenging it might cause confrontation.
Yeah, it goes back to the analogy with the boats and cutting through, not putting all
the stock on the words, the boats floating on the surface, being able to realize that
those are just tools, being able to parse the waters, kind of like, move these boats
aside and just focus on, okay, he's saying that the tweets, okay, block everything.
Okay, what tweets?
Okay, block everything aside.
Now you have the next thing.
That's the layer-by-layer, peeling back of the onion, Socratic method.
But it's just, yes, words are tools, and a lot of them aren't really even necessary.
And be able to recognize which ones are actually necessary to what the person is saying.
What's actually meaningful here?
I think that I would argue a part of it as well was just, I think, the person realizing
that you cared about them, which goes to the, yeah, I mean, and again, that's subtext though.
The idea that most communication is nonverbal.
So if you care, then the person will sense that.
So I just want to wrap this idea up with the boats, because when we're teaching now, we're
teaching it to potential directing students, the screenwriters, because they're going to
be working with actors.
And what does an actor care about?
Nonverbal communication.
They don't really care about the words in the scene.
But what do I want in the scene?
That's what's going to dictate my behavior as the actor.
The words, I can memorize that.
But that's not acting.
It's everything else.
So when I'm interacting with that student, there is this nonverbal communication between
us all the time, every day.
Actually, if you don't like a co-worker, you're not going to say, hey, I don't like you.
It might become more apparent through your interactions in other ways that are nonverbal.
And that's another indication of critical thinking, be able to pick up on those patterns.
So how did it end up online, the video?
I uploaded it to my online teaching portfolio on YouTube, where I'd been uploading lectures
I'd recorded in the past several years, and some narrative filmmaking, and things like
that.
And I didn't have that many people watching.
I had created my ex-platform when I taught my first year of teaching at a public high
school.
But I hadn't used it in four years.
Someone, I guess, found the video and posted it on X.
Once it got big and everything, I found out.
I was trying to log into X.
I couldn't remember my password.
My brother, he's like, Elon Musk just tweeted this video of you.
Like, you should recover your password so you can get on there and you can try and make
something of this.
Well, yeah.
So that's interesting.
So this moment of fame happens, and now you're some months into the aftermath.
You've started something called the Secret Scholar Society.
Yeah, we had started this a few weeks, maybe a few months ago.
A team reached out to me, and they programmed this app that was being used for homeschooling,
mostly.
They were interested in partnering.
So I spent some time developing the Secret Scholars Academy that would allow me to offer
critical thinking classes or just spaces where we could explore these concepts like we're
doing right now.
And also a social media aspect to it.
If there's a community aspect.
We've been trying to find our direction with it.
And then ever since recent events where I did lose my job, I have now been kind of doubling
down on that, trying to, because it allows me to monetize in a way that I can't on YouTube.
We don't make too much on YouTube.
But it has potential.
There's an educational summit occurring today that the team is at right now as we speak,
and I hope that we see some growth.
I see charter schools trying to offer an alternative to students in impoverished communities,
and the parents get so excited.
And there are so many in so few spaces.
They have these raffles with the balls bouncing, and then the number comes out like bingo,
and then they call out the number, and the parents just explode with joy.
I thought, wow, that's powerful.
But then what was more powerful to me was the look on the faces of the people that didn't
get it.
It just seems wrong that that's the thing, whether you get your number called.
It's that important to them, their kids' education.
That they're that crestfallen.
It's like this is their only shot.
And I don't think it's just about college.
Yes, at that charter school, the college rate is super high.
But I think it's more, this is their only shot as teenagers to gain knowledge.
Maybe we can use this platform to help with that.
I don't know how.
Well, there's, I think, a generally understood kind of crisis in the educational system.
And perhaps this is one of the reasons why there's such an interest in these charter
schools, which perform very well.
I think any foray into helping resolve that is a very noble route.
Well, it's just an idea that hit me last night.
We have a lot.
And I texted the team.
And I posted that video on our forums, being like, can we help in any way?
Can we help in any way with this?
Not that we can fix it.
But maybe we can.
So and then I, that was a bit rash of me.
I just kind of like put it.
And then I said, my classes for the summer are going to be free for any high school students.
You mentioned that you recently lost your job.
Do you think that's connected somehow with recent events?
I could only speculate.
I don't think they technically did anything that they weren't allowed to do.
I don't think they did anything illegal.
I uploaded a video that I wasn't, without checking all the, I don't know if it was a
new box introduced or not.
But I was supposed to, I did the same thing I did with that viral one.
I was supposed to check with this one supervisor.
And I didn't check with them.
And so they, immediately following that, they told me that they wanted to, they had decided
to part ways because they couldn't trust me not uploading something online or I didn't
check the box.
And I take responsibility for that.
As far as everything, anything else would just be speculation.
But you, you're continuing teaching classes at another college, as I understand it.
I still teach.
Yeah.
I've been teaching at Emerson College since grad school.
I still teach one.
As of the fall, it'll be two classes a semester.
So explain to me what you're hoping to accomplish, you know, in your journey as a teacher, as
an educator.
So I'm trying to, that's been the driving force with the academy.
I would like to grow that into something, though, we need to find direction.
And I do think that what hit me last night is, it feels right.
I would really love for that to work, to build out and to have a thriving community on there
and to continue growing the YouTube channel.
See what else happens.
I'm not sure.
Yeah.
Work on a book or something.
There's ideas that I'm kicking around.
But the big thing is, is the academy and growing the platform and trying to get to a point
where I can make a living doing this.
And when I do speak to people in a form of an interview, often I get the question, are
you worried that one political group is going to kind of bring you in and label you that?
And I just think that's all noise.
Again, it's the boats on the surface of the water.
If you care about what's beneath the surface more, things are going to go better.
And what is the alternative?
I'm going to follow the logic, point by point, wherever it takes me.
And this would be my two cents for you all is, don't worry about it.
Because what's the alternative?
You don't worry how the chips fall.
Most people will take the path of least resistance.
I mean, it's almost like a law of nature.
It's easier to be foolish than wise.
Therefore, most people you're going to meet are not going to be wise.
They're going to be foolish almost by choice.
And this occurs in the workplace, politics, family, relationships.
So what I've been going through in these last few weeks, it's
I'm hoping I can come out of the other side.
And things in the long run will be better, hopefully.
And people keep saying that.
But when you're in it, it doesn't feel like it.
It's hard and it's awful and everything, but it's sometimes it's required.
So I wouldn't worry too much about whatever picture that paints is the picture that's
painted.
Who cares what they want to call it?
It's just a boat exploding on the surface.
It's kind of like in a courtroom.
That's why they go to such great lengths to agree on what the evidence is that's presented.
What is the fair conclusion based on the evidence that has been presented?
Not what anyone's saying outside of the courtroom or on social media.
It's just what has been presented.
And so that's all I did.
I wasn't making the point at all.
And that's what happens when you follow the logic, though.
And I believe that logic is evidence.
That's how we can anticipate what hasn't happened yet.
And there's that Don Lemon interview with Elon Musk.
And he's saying, well, how do you know that?
Do you have any examples of DEI lowering standards?
Logically, it's a certainty that that's how it would have to happen.
If it were to happen, if you were going to do that, that's how it would have to happen
based on logic.
Therefore, logic is the evidence.
Fascinating.
What is the state of education around logic today?
Is it taught properly?
Well, I can only speak to myself.
I don't know what other people are teaching.
But we have two levels.
High school, yes, we've got lower beneath that.
But really, those students trying to get into college and then college.
Teachers unions.
Lack of school choice.
What do we do around school choice?
These charter schools, private schools.
And then we have the whole debacle with higher education.
I know that's a larger conversation.
What's the debacle?
The quality of the product is decreasing.
The cost is increasing.
It's a loan you don't have to qualify for.
You can't declare bankruptcy.
You're straddled for life with it.
How much does it cost for four years of college?
The school where I work, it's over $60,000.
Often it's more than that.
It can be $80,000.
You're almost $400,000.
So what are you getting in exchange for that?
The value of these degrees are not logical.
What's being taught is not logical.
Tenure is not logical in some senses.
Because it means the same.
Because what that does is it leads often to complacency.
I've had teachers that were just coasting.
Similar to teachers unions.
Though I understand the entire reason for tenure
was to allow professors to push the bounds of knowledge.
To explore new territory without fear.
But you can't do that in higher ed without potential pushback.
You were a volunteer firefighter?
I still am.
Do you get to do it very often?
Well, I can go on call whenever I'm available.
We don't get that many fires where I live.
Okay.
What's that like?
It's cool to have a team of guys and a few girls.
And to be part of something.
To feel like you're being of use to your community.
It fulfills a part of me.
Something masculine, I guess, about it.
That's criticized with toxic masculinity.
But I think it is essential and it's real.
Why did you choose to do this?
When I moved to this town, the realtor said,
they love joiners here.
What's a joiner?
What do you mean?
Join a committee.
But I was like, what committee am I going to join?
Oh, Frank up on the corner.
You should join the fire department.
He's in the volunteer fire department.
Frank's in it.
Yeah, they're like the cool guys in town.
They have the shirts and everything.
Three weeks later, there was this kind of, not a hurricane.
There was a storm, a bunch of branches down.
I was driving back from school.
And I saw them jumping in the truck and loading up to go out.
Because when there's storms, there's usually some car crashes and stuff.
And I had been thinking, I was like, that would be really cool.
And I just went and talked to them and started the process.
It took a long time, several months.
So this is you voluntarily entering the unknown.
Yes.
Yes, I didn't think about that.
I'm just alluding to this.
Yeah, to your-
It is, yeah, the voluntary aspect is key.
Well, that is an idea Jordan Peterson has talked about.
I had a short interview with Piers Morgan a few days after that viral video.
And he was like, what's the best lesson from Harry Potter?
Voluntarily enter the unknown was the summation of it.
Harry, Ron, and Hermione, almost every book, if not every book,
voluntarily go beneath the surface and face the beast.
Enter the chamber of secrets through the toilet,
or Harry voluntarily walk into the forbidden forest to his death
at the hands of Voldemort so that he can be reborn.
Yes, there's reluctant heroes.
But still, there's a voluntary aspect.
You can't force someone to go on the hero's journey.
That goes back to teaching as well.
You've got to get kids to voluntarily do it,
whether it's their homework, the assignment, or whatnot.
So if you're doing stupid things as a teacher, that's illogical.
And they're not going to listen to you because they can smell it.
They can feel it.
That's how I know that everything beneath the surface is more important, not the boats.
There's a lot of teachers that think the boats are all that matters.
And people like that will never innovate.
They shun their noses on YouTube and teachers that do things differently.
Perhaps that's one of the reasons we are in the state that we're in.
We are always going to be tribal though.
We've been tribal since the dawn of man.
That's how we survive.
And so you're not going to be able to get rid of that aspect of human nature.
But political labeling, that's ideology.
So did the J.K. Rowling's books, the Harry Potter series,
had some sort of significant impact on your life?
Yeah, they're my favorite books.
They've had the greatest impact of any book I've ever read.
I was the same age as Harry Potter.
I was 11 when the first one came out.
Why is that?
It's a masterfully created world.
It's built upon archetypes.
They incorporate things like voluntarily accepting the unknown,
recognition there's pieces of evil in you,
slaying the dragon, that masculinity is not a bad thing.
Then you can save Ginny from the beast.
They also recognize categories as well with Slytherin, Ravenclaw, Hufflepuff and all of that.
But they also show that you've got to understand when to break the rules.
You might not put your name in the goblet of fire,
but the goblet might shoot it out anyways.
And then you got to decide,
are you going to play the game to the best of your ability
and try and get that golden egg from the dragon?
And you don't know how you're even going to do it.
Like Harry, he didn't know what he was going to do until the last minute.
So I gave him a tip.
I'm just like, just think different, basically.
You're like, just a little innovation is all you need.
Oh, but you are allowed a wand.
Allow him to get his broom, boom.
He's able to use that one little bit of ingenuity to stand up to a dragon.
He loses his friends in the process though.
Right?
Ron turns his back on him, gets jealous.
Yes, you put your name in that goblet because it's coming from a place of jealousy.
I didn't put my name in there.
All his friends turn on him and everything,
but he keeps going and keeps playing the game to win,
even though he didn't sign up for it.
And in the end, you know, what does Ron say to him?
He goes, I was wrong.
You know, you would have had to been barking mad to put your name in that goblet.
And Harry just says, finally caught on, have you?
So is it by coincidence that in this video we're talking about J.K. Rowling?
Yeah.
I wasn't talking about the studio broader though.
Right?
Right.
Coincidence is a remarkable thing.
I'm not sure coincidence is even the right word.
So I have toyed with the notion of God and it makes for interesting conversations.
Well, so here's another thing I think that you picked up from Jordan Peterson.
I think you said you act as if, I'm going to live as if God exists.
When I live as though God exists, I've seen remarkable differences.
When people say, do you believe in God?
What do you mean believe?
What do you mean by God too?
There are things I encounter in those conversations that I don't have words for.
Therefore, there are things that cannot be expressed logically.
Like I can't logically justify the idea of God.
But when I live as though he exists, I see results.
Feel results.
But I can't articulate it.
And your argument is that that is, in fact, that's the definition of faith.
Yeah.
I would have to play with that.
But I do think it's something like that.
I've had interesting conversations around faith.
If suddenly we had evidence that God exists tomorrow, what would happen?
Well, everyone apparently in the streets of New York City,
they would start living as though God exists.
If they have any logic, right?
We know now there's evidence on CNN, blah, blah, blah.
And your network.
But what does that mean?
We're just living up to a standard now.
Faith would cease to exist.
People say, why would God make it impossible for there to be any potential proof or logical evidence?
That's my response.
If I were going to create a system where faith is possible,
you wouldn't make it impossible for there ever to be proof.
Otherwise, faith would cease to exist.
Everyone would just be living up to a new standard.
But faith, you're saying, somehow transformed.
When you have that, suddenly things are transformed in a very positive way that you can't explain.
I think that's what I heard you say.
Something like that.
Because faith exists because of the elusive and tangible.
Because I can't formulate words.
So what's next for you?
You're working on the Secret Scholars Academy, creating education.
Trying to reach financial stability.
Grow the channel.
And people, there's so much criticism online of that.
Oh, he's a grifter.
He's a shill.
He's trying to profit off.
Yes, I'm trying to profit off this.
When I look at that video, I never in a thousand years would have guessed that that would have
gone viral.
And to me, that's indicative of a larger problem.
The fact that there's that much hunger for logic and critical thinking and seeing a transformation
occur.
There's so many presuppositions and unfair accusations.
There's such lazy thinking out there that that is what went viral.
Really?
I add one thing to that.
And I think that was the compassion and the heart and the caring.
Yeah, I think that's what made that video.
And I think that's what facilitated the transformation ultimately.
That's my read anyway.
Well, that means a lot.
Thank you.
That's a genuinely interesting read.
You're saying that people have accused you of grifting through this.
Well, it's understandable to see if someone is.
He's a teacher.
Now he's offering classes for $15 an hour or whatnot.
He's going on podcasts to talk to you.
There's people that like to try and make this political or try and pigeonhole me politically.
And if they disagree on J.K. Rowling or a number of other issues,
anyone who's publicly discussing the intellectual ideas or trying to break new ground or
articulate these things publicly, there's going to be backlash.
I think you're getting me brainwashed into finding significance in all this Harry Potter
stuff because this is really the goblet situation, isn't it?
This is like, hey, you put your name in the goblet.
And you're like, I wouldn't want to put my name in the goblet.
Right.
I mean, yeah, that when I was making that video, I was thinking about it.
Somebody made a joke and they were like, Elon, put your name in the goblet of fire.
And I was like, no, it's technically not true.
It was the guy who brought the video over from YouTube who I know his name and everything.
And he's a good guy.
He's a nice guy.
He's very supportive.
But no, Elon Musk didn't put my name in the goblet of fire.
He is the goblet of fire.
That's funny.
Someone just put the name in and who spit the name out?
And I don't think Elon Musk knows who I am or anything.
But that's a more accurate analogy.
Well, any final thoughts as we finish, Warren?
This has been very lovely.
Thank you so much for allowing me to stop and taking the time.
It's always surreal that anyone wants to talk to me.
Well, it's been a real pleasure for me.
Thank you very much.
Warren Smith, it's such a pleasure to have had you on.
Thank you so much for having me.
Thank you all for joining Warren Smith and me on this episode of American Thought Leaders.
I'm your host, Jan Jekielek.
