The Social and Psychosocial Determinants of Cardiovascular Health

Johns Hopkins Medicine
6 followers
9 Video Views·Jul 14, 2024
Welcome to Better Edge, a Northwestern Medicine podcast for physicians. I'm Melanie Cole and
joining me today is Dr. Neelay Shah. He's an assistant professor of medicine in cardiology
and preventive medicine at Northwestern Medicine and he's here to highlight the social and
psychosocial determinants of cardiovascular health. Dr. Shah, I'm so glad you were joining
us. As we set off the air, this is a very important topic and it's such an important
aspect of the communities that we live in. As we start, can you please tell us a little bit about
the social determinants of health in urban areas we've recognized over the years, food deserts,
accessibility. Can you outline for us the social determinants of health in the various populations
and how it's been suggested that there are these important factors, whether they are upstream or
downstream, and how those factors contribute to cardiovascular risk? Yes. Good morning and
thank you for the opportunity to share about our work and talk about this very important topic.
So, social determinants of health can be best considered the underlying factors that contribute
to health and disease. Some people refer to them as the factors that are associated with where we
live, learn, work, and play. These are factors that influence our behaviors and our health in
many different ways and examples of them include things like socioeconomic status and position,
things like income, employment, and education, food security, and access to healthful foods.
Our social communities and the context of the social relationships we have with other people,
our ability to access health care, including things like health insurance and care that's
culturally concordant and linguistically matching as well. Factors related to culture and place of
birth as well as psychosocial factors, things like the role of anxiety and depression. All of these
are highly influential in our everyday lives and are a part of the environment in which all of us
and play a significant role in determining our health and our risk for disease. So,
these are factors that do occur upstream on the continuum of health and modifying these factors,
although it's not easy, are likely to have a fairly significant impact in an individual's
risk of disease and also a population's risk of disease. And beyond social determinants,
even more upstream, there are structural determinants. And so, I think it is becoming
increasingly clear that there are factors built into the systems that we as a society have built,
things like our access to housing and our justice system that include factors like discrimination
and racism that underlie even social determinants. And all of these factors exist along the continuum
of health. Social and structural determinants do occur upstream and are likely fundamental causes
of health and health disparities.
This is such a complex issue. For you to tackle this in research studies is really quite something
because as you say, it can spread out not only for individual factors, but also then, you know,
the wider community and then the particular state and then really all over the country.
And some of these upstreams when we look at sidewalks, parks, public pools, gym and recess,
I mean, it really gets so complex that these each little individual areas are just very,
very hard to target. So, this amazes me that you did this. Now, can you tell us a little bit about
your research study? How did you get involved in something like this? And summarize what we know
now. Yes. And thank you for that very important point because I think it's important for all of
us to realize that these factors that influence our health, they are related to each other. It's
not really accurate to try to target or identify each one individually because as I think we all
understand, so many of these social determinants are related to each other. Our socioeconomic
position is related to our ability to access healthcare, is related to our access to healthful
foods. The communities in which we live and our social networks and the social support we have
are related to our ability to maintain health and engage in healthful behaviors. The environments
and neighborhoods in which we live, like you referred to, the built environment, influences our
ability to engage in healthful behaviors like physical activity but also the access that people
have to transportation to even make it to their doctor's offices. And so, I think it's important
to understand that we start with understanding that each of these factors are related to each
other. And the motivation for this research study was primarily recognizing that we as a collective
have spent a lot of time describing disparities, meaning we know that they exist. There are
considerable and substantial disparities that exist between groups in the United States,
but we haven't really started to understand why these disparities exist and even more specifically
to what degree each of these social factors explain the disparities. Because there's a lot
of evidence that indicates that these social factors like socioeconomic position and good and
safe neighborhood environments and food security influence health. But the question we wanted to
ask was, how do each of these factors contribute to the disparities that exist? So, for example,
we know that populations who identify as Black or Hispanic or Asian experience disparities in
cardiovascular health. When I talk about cardiovascular health, I'm talking about
traditional cardiovascular risk factors like smoking and hypertension, cholesterol and diabetes.
We know that populations, for example, who identify as Black or Hispanic tend to have
worse cardiovascular health compared with populations in the U.S. who identify as white.
And although we would hypothesize that social determinants would contribute to these differences,
the purpose of this study and the motivation of the study was to better understand to what degree
these social determinants actually explain the differences in cardiovascular health among racial
ethnic groups in the United States. And the idea is that if we can identify which factors have
outsized influence, our ability to reduce disparities ought to focus on those factors.
So, we used data from about 16,000 participants of NHANES, which is a nationally representative
study in the United States, to evaluate the contribution of a range of social determinants
to differences in cardiovascular health in Black, Hispanic, Asian and white adults in the U.S.
And we looked at social determinants that included education, income, food security,
someone's social networks, including their marital status, health insurance and access to care,
their place of birth, whether they were born in the United States versus outside the United States,
and depression as a measure of psychosocial health. And our investigation was intended
to help us understand what to focus on in order to reduce disparities.
Wow, that is so interesting. You picked some areas that are just, you know, some of them are
pretty glaring in the health disparities. We can see the mental health and lack of experts in
different populations. We can see that access to care, all of these things. So, were you surprised
by any of the results of your study? And if not, I mean, I feel like if I was reading your study
directly, some of it would probably surprise me and some wouldn't. And that's exactly the reaction
and response that I had once we took a look at the data and matched it against our hypothesis. So,
although all of these findings are important and help us understand how to address health
disparities, some were less surprising and others were more surprising. So, for example,
we found that among men, education was the factor that contributed the most to differences between
racial and ethnic groups. The magnitude of the contribution that education had to explaining
the difference in cardiovascular health between Black adults, Hispanic adults, Asian adults, and
white adults was particularly large. And I think this was less surprising because we've long known
that educational attainment contributes to health outcomes because of all of the factors that are
associated with educational attainment. In part, higher educational attainment is associated with
higher literacy and health literacy. So, people are better able to understand and adhere to the
directions, for example, that their physician may give. But higher educational attainment is also
linked to more successful employment with higher incomes that facilitate access to healthcare
because of health insurance. So, there's a lot related to education that can be unpacked, but
education itself was identified as one of the strongest contributors to disparities in
cardiovascular health that were observed. On the other hand, a more surprising finding was that
among women, place of birth, meaning specifically being born in the U.S. versus being born outside
the U.S., was the factor that contributed most to the differences in cardiovascular health between
groups, particularly for Hispanic and Asian women. So, in the NHANES study, women participants who
identified as Hispanic or Asian, a large proportion of them were actually born outside the United
States compared with being born inside the United States. And there's several implications from this,
both in terms of how to interpret the data, but also what the next steps are from this research.
So, when I see this finding that place of birth contributes significantly, and in particular that
the proportion of women who were born outside the United States was higher than the proportion of
women who were born inside the United States, and the evidence suggests that the place of birth being
born outside the United States may actually be protective, it tells me that there are factors
related to childhood environments and immigration that are contributing to the differences in
cardiovascular health between groups. One of the surprising findings is that we showed that women
who identified as Asian and women who identified as Hispanic actually had better cardiovascular
health compared with women who identified as white in this data set. It was surprising, but then when
you dig into it, there are several potential explanations, one of which is this idea of the
healthy immigrant effect, which is to say the individuals who are able to immigrate to the
United States through our usual immigration processes tend to be people who are of higher
socioeconomic position because they completed an education in the countries from which they came
and have economic opportunities, such as moving to the U.S. for a job that led to their immigration.
And so there's a lot to unpack that we don't yet understand about the role of immigration and why
people immigrate, but it was surprising to see that place of birth contributed so strongly to
the differences in cardiovascular health. It tells me that in these particular populations,
in individuals who identify as Hispanic and Asian, we have quite a bit left to understand
about what it is about their environments in childhood, their environments in the countries
from which they came, and what led to their immigration that likely influences their health.
Wow. That is surprising. I mean, not really. Certainly not in the Asian populations,
because we've heard about the foods and the exercise and maybe the lower stress levels.
I've always been fascinated by smoking populations that don't have high risk of
cardiovascular and high incidence of cardiovascular disease, and yet they smoke,
but they also walk everywhere, and their food is of a different quality, their soil,
the micronutrients. I mean, we could go on and on, right?
We could. And one point that I'll just particularly highlight that you mentioned,
which I think is important, is that there is evidence even beyond this study
that people who immigrate to the United States, after immigration, they actually tend to have
worse health, because they've moved into an environment where our environments,
they don't facilitate our health. We have really ready access to low-quality food. We have less
access to healthful food, both in terms of affordability, but also just the distribution
and availability of it. Our built environments are suboptimal. In a country like the United States,
most of us are dependent on transportation by car. We're doing less physical activity,
because our public transportation and our neighborhood environments are less facilitating
of physical activity. The cultural norms of living in the United States tend to favor
bigger portion sizes and particular kinds of foods, whereas individuals who came
from other countries, these things are less prevalent. And so there is also a phenomenon
that individuals who leave their home countries or countries of origin and immigrate to the United
States tend to develop worse health after moving here. I have heard that too. And boy, oh, boy,
is this a complex situation that you have tackled. And really, there are so many areas. I mean,
we just jumped off into many different areas. Now, as we speak of that end goal, Dr. Shah,
of these types of studies and what interventions could help mitigate disparities in cardiovascular
health, some we can do stuff about, and some are bigger than you or I to even think about discussing,
because they are those upstream that we can't necessarily really affect completely. However,
can you outline some of the proposed interventions that emphasize that need for further studies?
Because I think that's how we're going to raise awareness that can then help inform
tailored effective prevention interventions. So I'd like you to identify some of the knowledge
gaps you think need to be addressed and the end goal to get more of these types of studies
so that they're out there and more people like yourself,
which are awesome, can get involved in these community health initiatives.
Thank you for that incredibly important question. And that really is what the purpose of this
research is, to build towards the interventions and actually making changes to support people's
health. And so my response to that important question is in two parts. Because as I think
we've kind of already discussed, and as I think people who see patients pretty readily understand,
there are things we're able to do when we're sitting in front of a patient, and we can
either provide counseling or try to influence factors that contribute to health that occur
outside of the clinician's office. And then there are things that we could potentially do
as they exist in the world. And as I think anybody who sees patients understands,
patients spend maybe an average of 20 or 30 minutes with us in the clinic, but otherwise
spend 24 hours a day, seven days a week living in the real world. And so our approaches to health
care and what we do with patients in the clinical setting is part of what determines health. But
it's not the only part, and I would argue it's not even the biggest part. After doing work in this
area, I'm fairly convinced that the largest outsized influence on what influences health
and determines health and disease in patients is most strongly what occurs in the environments in
which people live. And the things we try to do, medications and other interventions, are helpful,
and we know there are evidence-based interventions in the clinical setting that help. But especially
as we talk about prevention, so much of that occurs outside the clinician's office. So some
examples of individual-level potential interventions that build on or leverage social determinants
may include things like understanding somebody's social networks and their social support. So
if you're a clinician seeing patients and you're thinking about recommending behavior change,
whether it be increasing physical activity or making dietary pattern changes to support health
in a patient who has or is at risk for a cardiovascular disease or diabetes, you might
consider enlisting the help of a trusted social network member, like a spouse or a child or a
friend, for health behavior change. Because we've learned that social support and one's social
networks have a fairly significant influence on an individual person's health behaviors. So if
you're trying to encourage somebody to eat more healthfully, perhaps you might consider enlisting
the help of somebody who's important to the patient to do it together. Addressing things
like built environment, well, you know, I think it's unlikely, speaking frankly, that a clinician
is going to be able to do much about a patient's built environment. But you could work to try to
help patients identify avenues for physical activity, like local community centers or
shopping malls that they could go to and have a safe place to do physical activity, even if it's
just walking, which is great physical activity, beyond just staying in their homes. But as I think
you alluded to, the interventions that are likely to influence social determinants, these upstream
factors that influence health, are not only going to be successfully addressed at the individual
level. There are absolutely community and policy-level interventions that are needed
to support access to education and access to care, like Medicaid expansions, especially in states
that haven't yet done that, to support food security, bringing in healthful grocery stores
to eliminate food deserts in areas where access to healthful food options aren't available.
These are things that admittedly are far more challenging for individual clinicians to do,
but your advocacy matters. And so if you have the opportunity to speak with your local
representative and try to get involved to advocate for some of these things, it's certainly
one direction that I'm planning to do with the results of this study. And as far as next steps
in the research go, it really is what you mentioned, which is our data so far are observational.
And HANES is an observational study. These participants do not undergo any intervention.
So now that we've identified what factors may most strongly influence health disparities,
I think the next step is to try to intervene on those factors and see if they lead to reductions
in disparities. And that's certainly easier said than done. You know, place of birth is not an
intervenable factor. But the next steps in the research in that aspect, I think, is to better
understand what it is about being an immigrant or coming from a different culture that influences
health and changes when somebody immigrates so that a community health worker or a clinician
can be aware of those factors that influence health and try to mitigate the influence of them.
Wow. That was beautifully put. And I've even seen Dr. Shah, cardiologists get involved in
community walks and, you know, meet me at the park kind of walk and reaching out to that broader
community. And as we said, this is just such a complex issue. You and I could talk for a long
time about this. As we wrap up, I'd like you to speak to other physicians involved in cardiology,
what you'd like them to keep in mind based on the findings of these studies and what you would like
the key message to be from this very important discussion you and I had today.
So I would recommend that clinicians in cardiology, at minimum, just think more broadly about what is
We see a lot of patients who have cardiovascular diseases or are trying to prevent cardiovascular
diseases. And we are trained to think about some of the behavior changes and even more heavily,
some of the medications that may be used. And these absolutely have a role. But in my experience
working with communities and in research about health disparities, I again have concluded that
health and disease is actually largely determined by what happens outside the physician's office.
So the influence of social determinants on health status and outcomes is incredibly important. And I
would encourage clinicians to make sure they are asking questions of their patients to better
understand their social determinants. For example, can your patient afford their medication? Does
your patient have access to transportation to come to appointments? Does your patient have
the ability to access healthy foods or are they even getting enough food at all? Do your patients
have support from others to maintain their health or are they influenced by people in their social
networks to take up unhealthy behaviors? These kind of things have a huge influence on health.
And the first step that I think will help clinicians take care of patients and understand
their social determinants is just to ask about them. I think many of us would be surprised just
how challenging it is for our patients to surmount the social determinants that exist in their lives
and environments. And even if we're not able to fully address them within the scope of our practice,
it will absolutely help us better understand why a patient, for example, may not be responding to
the recommendations that we give them for medications or behavior change or otherwise.
Well, Dr. Shah, thank you so much. And I hope and invite you to come back on as often as you would
like to update us as you learn more. And yes, you said these are observational, but your advice to
other physicians and clinicians is spot on that these are the ways that they can help these
communities and help individual families by looking at the support system and offering resources. And
what a great episode this was. Thank you so much for joining us. To refer your patient or for more
information, please visit our website at breakthroughsforphysicians.nm.org slash
cardiovascular to get connected with one of our providers. That wraps up this episode of Better
Edge, a Northwestern Medicine podcast for physicians. I'm Melanie Cole.
