Have you ever been told by your coach to swing low to high - to impart topspin or to lift the ball higher above the net?
If you were and you found that instruction not very effective you're not the only one.
"Swing low to high" is one of those tennis tips that seems very logical at first glance but it in fact creates more problems than it solves.
In the video above you'll learn 3 reasons why "swing low to high" is not a good advice and two tennis tips that work much better.
Besides my explanations and demonstrations of how I suggest you go about swinging towards the ball and hitting you'll also see player that has a problem in his stroke and how I helped him correct it in a matter of minutes.
This topic should also very interesting to coaches who have tried the "swing low-to-high" advice and haven't really found it effective and would like to know what works better.
Hi, Tomas from Field Tennis. Have you ever heard the instruction of
swinging low to high, that you should swing low to high
to either impart topspin or to lift the ball
higher above the net? If you've been trying to use the low to high idea
or you're a coach and you're using it with your players and it doesn't work
really well, I want to show you today why it doesn't
work, how the players usually misinterpret the
instruction of swinging low to high and I want to
give you two ideas, two tips that work much better than the
instruction of swinging low to high. When we tell
players to swing low to high, they imagine something like this, that
this is the starting point that they need to be
under the ball and that they need to swing
up on the ball to lift it and to hit with topspin.
Now what happens is that when they start their swing
like this on the forehand side or like this on the backhand side
and they have this picture of swinging low to high,
they are going to try to find this starting position.
So they're going to do a swing, then they're going to try and find this
starting position of this instruction, swing low to high and then they're going
to go up and in the process what will happen is
that they will lose the momentum of the swing.
So their swing will not be continuous or smooth
and they will lose all the momentum that we create by lifting the racket head up.
The reason why we lift the racket head up is so that gravity can help us
accelerate the racket so that can be on the forehand side
or on the backhand side and so when we give the players the instruction swing
low to high, they're going to go like this.
They're going to stop the racket here because they have this picture in their
mind what low to high means. They know okay
this is the starting point, this is the finishing point
and they're going to break the fluidity of their stroke
and they will feel no power because no energy will come
to the ball and because they will feel no power
they're going to make a very jerky movement
here to accelerate the racket and that again will not produce very good results.
The second reason why the idea of swinging low to high doesn't work really
well is because players imagine a swing path
that is very steep. They imagine almost a vertical swing path
because they're imagining like in an exaggerated way they're
imagining low to high and so this swing path is way
too steep for what really happens in reality
because in reality the swing path is something like this
and so yes there is a low to high swing but it's very shallow
so players usually go way too steep when they
are instructed to swing low to high because they they are too conscious of
it but in reality the the low to high swing
is maybe at this angle is is this shallow
we are hitting the ball at this angle if we swing at this angle that would be a
lob so for the backhand again i'm not
swinging low to high like this this is my normal swing path so you can
see what is the angle of the swing so yes it
is slightly low to high but again the swing path is quite shallow maybe
it's about 20 30 degrees and when players think about
swing low to high they're going to swing maybe at 60 or 70 degrees upwards
and so again they will not hit the ball well and they will not hit with good
power the third reason why the swinging low
to high idea is not very good is because players focus on their body
they're thinking about their arm and how they're going to move it
and while the ball is coming to them they are focusing
let's say with 50 percent of their brain on the instruction and 50 percent
of their brain or their attention to the ball
and that's not enough because they don't pay full attention to the ball
they're going to position poorly to the ball they will not time it well
and again they will not hit a good ball so this is normal every time we give an
instruction about something about the body think about
your body rotate your hips or rotate your shoulders or whatever we
say about the body we have to know that there will be less
attention on the ball and that's why oftentimes we coaches we
throw the ball with hands or we feed very nice balls
because we don't want to trouble the player's mind with ball judgment because
the player's mind is on the body and not on the ball
but there is a way to bring the player's mind
to the ball and at the same time have them hit the ball with topspin and
lift it over the net and so the first idea that is
better than the instruction of swinging low to high
is to imagine that you're hitting the ball below the center
or below the equator if you imagine a planet earth and here's the equator
right here and i know that most players when the ball is coming to them they
just want to hit it straight at the back
into the equator of the ball but that's not a good idea that's not a
good mental image you should imagine that you're hitting
the ball first below the center so in a similar way as
we explain a topspin serve where we say you should spin the ball from seven to
one so we imagine like this we say okay start
here at seven o'clock and go up across the ball that's how we imagine
we explain the topspin serve in a similar way we can imagine how we hit a
topspin forehand or a topspin backhand except that we
don't say at seven o'clock but maybe more at six o'clock
and not completely at the bottom of the ball because we are not
under the ball but we are more behind the ball
so you should imagine that you're hitting the ball at roughly 45 degrees
angle below the center like this that should be your first contact with the
ball and then you go over the equator and
leave the ball above the equator so you should imagine
when you're hitting the ball quite a long interaction between the
strings and the ball it should not be a short interaction
where you just tap the ball it should be a longer interaction where
you roll the ball i don't like too much the the word
brushing the ball because then players they just go up like this
and they don't really hit the ball so i prefer to
to tell the players that they roll the ball or they press into the ball and
roll it and you imagine that you first make
contact below the ball now what's important to
understand here is that this is just a mental image it's it's not what really
happens maybe it happens on some balls but what
it helps us is that we create the right swing where
the racket comes a bit under the ball so when i'm about to hit the ball i'm
not thinking about hitting the ball at the back at the equator but a little
bit below the center and rolling it so i'm
playing more like this here's one more as i mentioned before
the second problem of the instruction of swinging
low to high is that players slow down or actually
like almost stop the racket and then they go up because they have
this picture in their mind where is the starting point and where
is the finishing point of this instruction of this picture
swing low to high and so instead of telling players swing low to high
you can do exactly the opposite you can ask the players to swing
down first here's an example of a player that has a very nice technique but he
has a little pause in that lower part that i marked with
the yellow line so this is where he's slowing down his racket too much
because i believe he's thinking too much about low to high
so as you will see right now i'll just go right
to him and push his arm down so i'm pushing his arm down
down to give him this feeling of swing down first and even though it's very
strange for the player to do that he does it and then he is very surprised
with the with the speed and the results of the
ball so again you don't see any pause now and
his backhand goes much faster and he has much more topspin on the ball
even though he is not thinking about up he's thinking about down
because up automatically happens so try this idea imagine swinging down
first and see what happens try to feel that
you feel the momentum building up you feel the speed building up
and you realize oh my arm actually swings up automatically so the same on
the backhand you can imagine first swinging down
and realizing that's how you generate momentum
and how your arm will automatically swing up
so i show first one on the backhand so i imagine from here
i imagine swinging down i swing down and i let go and it works out just fine
and i can of course do the same on the forehand so i lift the racket i try to
feel a downward swing first it's a downward
swing i feel how the speed builds up and how
my arm automatically goes up so if i hit the
ball in the right contact point well in front when my arm is already
going up then it will just work out fine so i'm
trying to feel how i swing down i'm approaching the ball from below and
then i just finish my stroke so in the end if you've tried the idea
of swinging low to high and it didn't really work for you
i really recommend that you try the idea of the mental image of hitting the ball
below the center because not only will that create the
right swing but you will also pay attention to the ball
as i mentioned before when we think about our body and we think what we have
to do with our body then we really don't pay good attention
to the ball and then we miss time the ball and we
don't position well and so on so we have a lot of problems with the ball
but when we imagine hitting the ball a bit under the center
then our whole attention is on the ball because this is our target this is our
moving target so when the ball is coming toward us our
full attention is on the ball we are positioning to the ball
and we are imagining where we're going to hit it
so it's a much better method because all our attention is on the ball and not on
the body and the second idea of swinging down
also works quite well especially if you have someone that can
push your arm a bit down that you feel this build-up of momentum
and that you realize that even when you swing down your arm will
automatically swing up which is a similar idea
when we serve because when we serve we say that we have to hit up
yes we hit up we accelerate the arm up and even when we accelerate the arm up at
some point it will start to go down so we don't really
have to worry about swinging down because the arm has nowhere else to go
it's attached in the shoulder so if we accelerate the arm upwards it
will go downwards and for more on this i will give you a
link to the full explanation of how we serve up
and similar here it's a similar idea we have to swing down first and the
upward swing will automatically happen so if you like this video please
subscribe and like it and thanks for watching i'll see you
next time