Which Diet is Best for Insulin Resistance and Longevity | Paleo vs Mediterranean vs Fasting

Health Longevity
19 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 6, 2024
I've noticed with this ancestral movement towards nutrition
that paleo is making a little bit of a comeback,
but it's not really called paleo anymore,
it's a little bit more just ancestral,
which really is kind of what paleo
was after in the first place.
Now, this entire video is based upon one particular study
that compared paleo to fasting to a Mediterranean diet.
And it only covered one real sliver
of things that we need to talk about.
So from that study,
we'll be able to branch out a little bit more
and understand which philosophy
makes the most sense for you,
which one is best,
although I don't know if there is a best diet,
but let's break it down.
Now, this study was published
in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
and it had subjects follow
a traditional sort of fasting approach,
where in this particular case,
they were kind of intermittent fasting.
And they had another group
follow a more strict Mediterranean approach.
In this case, it was actually
a pretty low-protein Mediterranean diet,
moderate fat, decent amount of carbohydrates
coming from lentils and grains
and the usual kind of Mediterranean stuff,
not as much from, say, fruit, as I would have liked.
And then there was a paleo-style diet.
Now, I'm gonna pause for one second
and describe a little bit about paleo.
Now, I'm not a paleo expert, okay,
but I know enough about it.
The idea behind paleo was to live
sort of as close to the earth as possible
in a way that our ancestors would, right?
So you're eating all cuts of meat.
It's like you're eating saturated fat.
You're probably even getting some gristle,
things like that.
You're leaning into the fruits.
You're getting rid of anything refined or artificial.
So you could eat some vegetables,
although most of the vegetables
that you would probably eat
would probably be like tubers,
maybe some sweet potatoes, maybe things like that.
Now, nuts, these were all realistic as well.
However, there's some holes that we could poke in this
because I think in a real paleolithic sense,
although nuts and seeds were probably consumed,
they were probably consumed in very small amounts.
And most of the people that I know that have done paleo
were getting a large majority of their calories
from nuts and seeds,
which again, I have no problem with nuts and seeds,
but I don't think it's historically accurate
to be eating that much
because it's a process
to actually get a nut and a seed out.
So maybe you would be eating them in a small amount
that you could harvest, right?
That's my opinion, doesn't really matter.
This study was interesting
because they were looking specifically at HbA1c.
Now, HbA1c is a tremendous marker to look at
when you're looking at metabolic health.
Now, as of 2018, by the way,
93% of Americans were considered metabolically unhealthy.
That doesn't mean that they were obese.
That doesn't mean that they had
all kinds of comorbidities.
It just means that at a mitochondrial level,
at various metabolic levels,
they were considered metabolically unhealthy.
Hopefully things are improving
because we're learning more there.
The reason that I mentioned this
is that at the very core of metabolic health
is our ability to use substrates,
fuel, glucose, fats,
the ability to switch between the two, right?
How is our glucose tolerance?
When we consume sugar,
can we actually utilize it
or does it spike our glucose high
because we have an inability to process it right, right?
That all matters.
So when you look at HbA1c,
you look at the 90-day sort of indicator
of how much glucose has been circulating
and impacting cells and tissues,
and in this case, glycolated hemoglobin.
How is it actually affecting the hemoglobin?
What they found is that after one full year
of fairly strict adherence to these diets,
fasting reduced HbA1c by 0.2%.
That's not bad,
but the fasting group was really able
to kind of eat whatever they wanted to, right?
The Mediterranean group had a 0.8% reduction in HbA1c.
That's actually quite good.
The paleo group also had a 0.2%.
So paleo and fasting ended up around the same amount.
Now, again, there is definitely some scrutiny
that can be had there.
We could like dial into those more.
The Mediterranean seemed to fare the best.
Now, I'm kind of curious as to why this is
because if you analyze the diets
and you look at other studies that look at Mediterranean,
you find that Mediterranean does do really, really well
when it comes down to glucose modulation,
but it seems to do so by working upon a different axis
than say fasting or paleo would, right?
Fasting probably reduces glucose simply by abstinence.
Like you're abstaining from food.
So putting yourself in a severe calorically restricted state
you're going to what's called phosphorylate AMPK.
So basically you're turning on a signal
that it says we're in a caloric deficit
that's pretty extreme.
So you need to like mobilize tissues,
you need to mobilize lipids and fats and whatever.
And that is going to trigger a series of different cascades
that happen as a result, okay?
With a Mediterranean diet,
it's much more about the addition of things.
Whereas fasting is more about the removal of things.
With the Mediterranean, you're usually adding things in.
You're adding the monounsaturated fats
that have a tremendous impact.
You're adding the lean proteins, which have an impact.
You're adding polyphenols, which have a tremendous impact.
You're adding fiber.
So one of the things that Mediterranean offers
that maybe paleo is not so much
is a higher fiber content, right?
Because even a well-crafted paleo diet
might not have a whole lot of say the resistant starches
that are going to come from sweet potatoes,
even though they're allowed, right?
Whereas a Mediterranean diet,
you find a lot of those kinds of foods.
Now, it makes you wonder, okay,
is the gut microbiome at play here?
Why did Mediterranean fare so well?
I'm inclined to think it does have to do with our gut health.
So much of things stem from the gut, right?
And polyphenols, which are going to be in the fruits
that we consume, in the vegetables that we consume,
these are considered fibers in and of themselves.
They are fibers that fuel the microbiome
and allow them to proliferate
and allow those particular bacteria
and those strains of bacteria to grow.
Now, full disclaimer,
I think there's a lot more to the microbiome
than we even begin to pretend to know.
But I do think that it plays a big part
in our glucose modulation
because the more that our bacteria are diverse,
the more short-chain fatty acids that we can produce.
Now, what that means is those are a byproduct
of the bacteria fermenting food and fibers
and whatnot in our gut.
They produce these short-chain fatty acids
that then signal for our cells to operate in certain ways.
They orchestrate a lot.
That is exactly why there's such a push
for a lot of garbage probiotics and stuff out there.
And I say that because a lot of them are.
I think it's a lot better to pay attention to fiber
and culture your own microbiome
than it is to try to just take a supplement
to counteract a bad diet.
I put a link down below for the probiotic
that I would use.
It's the only one that I literally would ever recommend.
It's called Seed.
It is a symbiotic which has a capsule inside of a capsule.
So it has a prebiotic and a probiotic.
So whatever diet you are doing,
if you are trying to contribute to a better microbiome,
I would highly, highly recommend it.
They also put their money where their mouth is with research
and that's a 25% off discount link
off that daily symbiotic.
So 25% off, you can try it out.
One thing that I've noticed with it
is that although it does improve my digestion,
that's not what I'm after with it.
I notice personally, anecdotally, improvements in my mood,
improvements in my sleep when I am consistently taking it.
Now, I noticed an improvement within a couple of days
if I hadn't been taking it
and I usually notice it pretty quickly
if I stop taking it.
So regardless of what you choose to do,
you can skip through this section or whatever
but that link is down below
in the top line of the description underneath this video.
I wanna unpack a little bit more
about fasting for a second
because fasting versus paleo itself
could be really interesting.
Arguably, one of the reasons
that paleo works so well for people
is because you're eating in a way that is so not processed
that you're allowing your satiety signals
to naturally operate the way that they should.
Now, what that means is that
you're eating close to the earth,
your body's not gonna be bombarded
with as many signals from ultra-processed food
that are encouraging you to eat more than you really need.
So in theory, if you come back down
to that kind of whole earth thing,
protein, tubers, vegetables, fruit, nuts,
it makes sense that you're not gonna be as hungry
because you're fully satiated.
So in theory, you could eat in a caloric deficit.
But there was a study that was published in Nature Medicine
that compared fasting for 20 hours, three days per week.
Okay, so three days per week,
they would eat between the hours of 8 a.m. and 12 p.m., okay?
Now, what they would do after that is fast for 20 hours,
and then a couple days later, they would do it again.
So collectively, they ended up fasting three days per week.
Okay, that's it, just three days per week for 20 hours,
and that was it.
The other group was a 30% caloric restriction diet
where every day they restricted calories by 30%.
Okay, so it was 70% of their total energy needs.
And the third group was sort of
a standardized diabetes control diet,
like to just kind of help with lower glycemic,
et cetera, et cetera.
Now, the fasting group still reduced calories.
They reduced calories by 70% on the days they fasted,
but that kind of goes without saying
because you're only eating for four hours,
so it's easy to be in a caloric deficit.
What they found with this was after two, six, and 12 months,
the fasting group was the only group
to have a significant change in their glucose levels
and their HbA1c.
So even though they were arguably eating
just as much as the caloric restriction group,
they had better improvements.
Now, if you were to say combine fasting with paleo,
that would be an even better
sort of ancestral type of diet, right?
Because it makes sense that we would go
periods of time without eating.
That makes a lot of sense.
Like, okay, we hunt, we get a kill,
and then we fast for a while until we get our next kill,
and we gather for a little bit,
and it's kind of this mix match.
So paleo and fasting go hand in hand,
but one thing that we don't seem to think about
is how we can stack the various benefits.
We're so focused on how do we get
the benefits of Mediterranean?
How do we get the benefits of fasting?
How do we get the benefits of paleo?
But we're not really thinking about
how we can apply all the benefits of each.
In essence, you could do a paleo version of Mediterranean.
You absolutely could.
You could say, okay, Mediterranean uses lean proteins,
uses olive oils, uses these things.
How do you apply that in a paleo sense?
You eat the lean meats.
Maybe you eat the whole olives.
You still eat the nuts.
You still eat the fatty fish.
You still eat the vegetables.
The only thing you're doing is
you're not eating the grains as much, right?
Paleo is not too hot on the grains.
So with Mediterranean, you'd reduce the rices.
You'd reduce the lentils.
You'd reduce these things,
and you'd replace them with, say, sweet potatoes,
or maybe with the occasional other kind of tuber,
or maybe a squash, or something like that.
If you really think about it,
overlapping paleo and Mediterranean,
and living in a Mediterranean ancestral diet,
I say that with quotes because it's kind of cheesy,
that would make a lot of sense,
and combining that with fasting could work even better.
So paleo implies that you eat
sort of these big, fatty cuts of meat all the time,
and I have some issues with that
because fattier cuts of meat
are going to be a higher level of saturated fat,
which isn't necessarily good for metabolic health.
Contrary to what a lot of people say,
the science and the literature that is out there
refutes that, and as much as I hate to say it
because I love my fatty cuts of ribeye,
I look where the science is,
and I kind of go that direction.
So leaner cuts of meat would make more sense on paleo,
which would mean you'd have to get fats
from sort of other sources,
maybe more in the way of some nuts,
in the way of some avocados, in the way of some olives,
but it's food for thought.
Instead of taking a stance with a diet tribe,
we can overlap and stack the benefits.
So as always, keep it locked in here on my channel.
I'll see you tomorrow.
