獨家
為什麼誤解共產主義的本質會將西方引向毀滅?|鐵拳老鄧 Counterpunch

新唐人精選
5371粉絲
4609 次觀看·2025年11月18日
西方對馬克思主義和共產主義本質的誤解正把我們引向毀滅之路。
俄羅斯威脅東歐,中國威脅印度和台灣,伊朗威脅中東,紅潮正在席捲拉丁美洲。世界的力量平衡正在改變,這源於重大的歷史誤解。
特雷弗·勞登揭露了西方是如何被引向毀滅之路。
Hi, welcome to another episode of counterpunch with Trevor Loudon.
Please like the show, share the show and above all subscribe on Epoch TV.
Now today I'm going to talk about some misunderstandings on Marxism and communism
and how they're dramatically affecting the future of the world.
How we may lose the planet because of these misunderstandings.
Now you have a situation out there now where Russia and China are both
arming. Russia's threatening Eastern Europe, China is threatening India, the Far East, Taiwan
and Iran is threatening the Middle East and we have a red tide sweeping through Latin America.
Venezuela's communist, Nicaragua's communist, Chile has just elected a far leftist,
Peru's gone the same way, so has Honduras.
The balance of power in the world is changing and the West is in a perilous state
and they got there through a massive misunderstanding or a series of misunderstandings.
Some of them deliberately fostered.
Now I'd like to clear up the first one which I think is very important.
Now back in the 70s Kissinger and Nixon sold America on the idea that China could be wooed
away from the Soviet Union.
There had allegedly been a split between China, communist China and the Soviet Union
and America could get in there and give them trading rights and develop business and China
would become democratic and more Western and it could be wooed out of the communist bloc.
Lots and lots of money was put into this and American foreign policy was worked around this
concept because especially after Deng Xiaoping came to power in 1976 and started to open up
the economy, you started to see businesses spring forward.
All the big commentators thought well yes this is China's going off the communist road.
China is seeing the advantages of capitalism.
China is moving into our camp and all we have to do is keep giving them money,
build factories on their territory, open up everything we can,
the World Trade Organization etc and everybody would live happily ever after.
When the Soviet Union collapsed in the early 90s that philosophy went on steroids.
Let's make money with China.
Let's bring China into the Western fold.
Both President Bush's talked incessantly about how they wanted a strong China as a
partner in the world.
Well there's a big problem with that.
China never went off the communist road.
Once it went on it has never come off.
People have a massive misunderstanding about what communism is.
Now you can read this in the Vietnamese literature and the Chinese literature.
Vietnam and China have both adopted free market policies
and according to Westerners that means they are no longer communist.
Okay.
They've adopted capitalist policies so they can't be communist.
Well that's because these people don't understand what communism is.
Now Marx, who knew a thing or two about communism,
was really the founder of the modern communist movement.
Not the first communist but the most influential.
Marx posited five stages of human development.
The first stage, primitive communism.
You're a tribe.
You live in a cave.
You go out and kill a mammoth.
You cut the meat up.
You share it amongst yourselves.
That's primitive communism where everybody shares the wealth of the tribe.
That gave way to agriculture and with agriculture people started to develop plots of land
and they had private land.
You know they were not going to give up their produce to someone who didn't work.
They were going to have private land and it was the beginnings of a sort of
private ownership of property type of system.
But this developed into what they call feudalism.
These private landowners needed protection from people who would steal their produce
or invade their land.
So you had the feudal system where warlords would reign over a certain area.
You would pay tribute to the warlord in grain or taxes or sons or daughters
and the warlord would protect your farm, protect your property.
That's the feudal system.
That's the second stage of human development.
Then came capitalism.
Private property started to be much more pervasive.
We had legal systems coming into being.
Private contracts.
We had the birth of the industrial age.
People could use the surplus that they had created with their businesses
and their factories and their farms and invest.
Invest money in new businesses.
Make a return.
You could patent your inventions.
Private property went into a newer level and human wealth exploded.
Absolutely exploded.
After the industrial revolution, especially in Europe and in the United States.
Back in China and Russia, they were still largely living under the feudal system
where warlords or barons would basically protect areas of land and you pay tribute.
That was the system in most of the world until the industrial revolution
ushered in what the communists call capitalism.
I don't use that word capitalism.
It's a Marxist term.
I use the word the free market.
The American free enterprise system.
That's small business.
That's mom and pop.
Most people think of capitalism as big corporations ripping you off.
As big techs stealing your data.
They see it as a negative phenomenon.
I'm talking about the industrial revolution brought us small businesses.
It brought us patents.
It brought us legal structures to protect people's earnings.
It set people free.
It set people on a path to wealth and prosperity.
So that's the third stage of human development.
And the communists will tell you this is a great stage.
This is necessary because capitalism will produce the wealth.
And then the socialists, because what capitalism will do, they say,
is increase the inequalities.
The rich will get richer and the poor will get poorer.
Eventually the contradictions will be so strong
that the poor will overthrow the rich and expropriate the wealth.
Socialism.
The government will take the wealth off the rich landowners and the rich capitalists
and redistribute it to the poorer classes.
Socialism.
So socialism is the fourth stage of human development.
But note, you cannot go to socialism until you've been through capitalism
because capitalism is essential to produce the wealth.
And of course it's based on, the communist theory is based on a lie.
Because a real free market system,
I'm not talking about the corporate system we have today
where big government works with big business.
I'm talking small government, individual liberty, small businesses, mom and pop.
You rise or fall as far as your abilities take you.
None of this corporate handouts or corporate welfare.
None of that.
Just a plain free market operating.
That does not increase inequality.
It brings everybody up.
It means the rich can only stay rich as long as they're still producing.
They're actually offering a value to people.
It's the most democratic, the most just system that's ever been.
But the communist smear it as capitalism.
They talk about big business, crony capitalism.
They call that capitalism.
That is not what we mean and it's not the word that we should use
because it's so tainted and so dirty now.
So after you have socialism, this comes the mythical fifth stage communism.
The state will wither away.
Everybody will be equal.
Everybody will have an equal share of wealth
from each according to his ability to each according to his need.
That's the communist doctrine.
That will never happen.
There's never been a time in history when the state has taken over wealth
and the power and production of a nation then voluntarily given it up.
It doesn't happen.
It won't happen.
It will never happen.
That's why there will never be true communism on this planet.
There will only be a dictatorial top-down socialism
a la North Korea planet wide.
That's the best we can hope for in a communist.
If the communists dominate this planet,
it'll be worldwide North Korea with American technology.
Think about that.
Western accommodators thought,
wow, look, the Chinese have gone back to capitalism.
They tried to implement socialism.
They've gone back to capitalism.
To some degree, the Russians have done the same thing.
Also, Vietnam is another example.
Mozambique.
Oh, they've adopted free market policies.
They've given up on communism.
We can train them.
It's very simple.
The Vietnamese, the Chinese admit they made a massive mistake.
They ignored Marx.
They tried to go straight from feudalism to socialism
and missed the capitalist stage.
What we've seen in China and what we've seen in Vietnam
and Russia and Mozambique and Nicaragua
and several other countries around the world
is not a retreat from communism.
It is a return to classic Marxism.
We made a big mistake.
We tried to rush too far too fast.
We've got to go back to a capitalist market type of system.
We build up our wealth.
We build up our military.
And then we go back on the socialist road
and onwards to communism.
That's where the Communist Party of China is right now.
That's where the Communist Party of Vietnam is.
And that's where Russia's going as well.
They have experimented.
They've gone back to capitalism.
They've built up their wealth.
The Russians and Chinese have hugely built up their militaries.
And now they're ready to go on to socialism
and destroy any vestige of capitalism left on the planet.
This is completely counter to the narrative that we hear.
You know, Western foreign policy on for decades.
That China and Vietnam could be wooed out of the communist bloc.
That Russia could become a democratic nation.
None of that can happen unless the communist parties
are removed root and branch from those countries.
When America defeated Nazi Germany in World War II,
they denazified the country.
Anybody who'd been a Nazi could not hold public office.
They never decommunized Russia.
They never decommunized China.
They never decommunized any of these so-called former communist countries
with the possible exception of Poland and to a degree the Ukraine.
But mostly they have still got the same communist elites in power.
Russia is still run by the KGB.
I believe it's still run secretly by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
And they are ready now that their military and economies are stronger
in many ways than the West.
They're ready to go back on the march.
They're ready for war.
Now there's another aspect to this.
And this is also a very contentious area
and a big misunderstanding amongst Western policymakers.
I refer to the writings of a man called Anatoly Golitsyn.
Golitsyn was a KGB defector.
He defected from the Soviet Union to Finland in 1961,
spent some time in Britain,
and then left and went to the United States.
He told a story that very few were willing to believe.
He told a story of massive communist deception
that was way over the heads of most policymakers
and most intelligence officers.
A few British intelligence officers championed him,
and good for them.
And James Angleton, the head of counterintelligence in the CIA,
also became a big champion of this man.
This started a war inside the CIA.
The traditional faction who believed that the Soviet Union
was nowhere near as powerful as we thought
and wasn't really interested into big strategic disinformation,
and the Golitsynite faction,
who believed that most of Western policy
was based on false assumptions about the Soviet Union
and the communist bloc,
and that the infiltration of Western countries
was way, way bigger than we had thought.
That it was in most political parties,
they had penetrated most intelligence agencies,
they were in the position to manipulate the West from Moscow.
This is the message of Golitsyn.
He wrote this all up in 1984,
in a book called New Lies for Old.
By that time, the CIA was done with them.
Angleton had been fired,
the unimaginative faction, I'll put it kindly, of the CIA
was back in control,
and Golitsyn was sidelined.
They ignored what he had to say.
In 1957, under Chalepin, the head of the KGB,
the communist movement did a major reorganization
and a major reassessment of its mission.
They were not doing well.
They were having trouble in their subservient states
in Eastern Europe,
their economies were a wreck,
they couldn't build up their military,
China was draining their money.
They just were not competing with the West.
They knew their communist experiment would die
if they didn't change strategies.
They were not going to defeat the West
unless they did something differently.
So this is what Golitsyn said,
and he was part of this process.
An inner KGB set up at this time in 1957 to 1960,
and they came up with a long-range strategy
that was implemented at the top reaches
of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
They drew to some degree on the split
between Tito, the communist leader of Yugoslavia,
and Stalin.
They had a genuine falling out.
Tito split from the Soviet bloc,
and American money, American aid,
poured into the country,
trying to woo Tito and Yugoslavia
out of the Soviet bloc.
Well, they eventually reconciled,
they became friends again,
and that money was very useful to Tito and his comrades.
But the Soviets learned a lesson.
Well, if we could get a lot of money by feigning weakness
and pretending we are split,
imagine if we had major splits.
Imagine if we had major retreats from communism.
Imagine how we could fool the West.
With all of our agents in the Western system,
we could feed them disinformation,
we could check that our disinformation is working.
Let's try it.
So what they did was this.
The first thing was a split
between China and Russia in 1961.
They threw a few, you know,
had a few exchanges.
They fired a few artillery shells at each other.
There were a few troops got shot.
You know, this was a big deal in the world stage.
Russia and China are splitting.
The Chinese communism is splitting
with Soviet communism.
We must exploit that.
And they did start to exploit it in the 70s
through Kissinger and Nixon.
Then they started to have other splits.
Romania became very, very troublesome
in the Soviet bloc under Ceausescu.
Poland had some difficulties with the Soviets.
They had the Prague Spring in 1968 in Czechoslovakia
when Soviet tanks had to roll in
and suppress the insurrection there,
the uprising against communism.
So the Soviet bloc looked weak.
And the Western policymakers thought,
well, we can use this.
We can play one off against the other.
We'll start sending money to Romania.
We'll help Ceausescu.
We'll help Tito.
We'll help these rebel communist organizations.
So they put a lot of money in there.
But what Galitsin said was,
the biggest split,
the biggest fake will come in the 80s.
And part of it was to do with
the new economic policy of the 1920s.
When Lenin took over the Soviet Union,
the economy collapsed.
So for a while he had to turn back the free market,
the new economic policy,
to feed the people so they didn't starve.
And that had two purposes.
It kept the people from rebelling.
And it fooled the West into thinking
the Soviets were giving up communism.
They're opening markets.
They're opening trade.
They're allowing private stores.
They must be giving up on communism.
When that had achieved its purpose,
Stalin came in and shut it all down.
And so the new economic policy was the model.
What was planned in the 1980s,
there was going to be a new leader,
a new Soviet leader.
There would be a mass opening to the West.
There would be talk of,
they would give up the word communism.
They would possibly let some of the Baltic states
and Eastern European states go.
There would be a retreat,
a massive retreat of the Soviet empire,
a collapse of communism.
And this would be designed
to get lots of Western money
and critically to get the West to disarm.
Clinton did this,
the so-called peace dividend.
President Clinton started gutting the US military
in the early 90s.
And it has been downward ever since,
with a few exceptions under President Trump, etc.
But this was the plan.
This was the plan all along.
We're going to de-emphasize communism.
We're going to let the Baltic states go.
We're going to let Eastern Europe go.
They're a burden anyway.
American money will pour in.
Western money will pour in.
We will still keep some degree of control
because we have got so many people in their military,
so many agents in their government,
so many agents in their intelligence services.
We will still have some control over these states.
The only states that probably really, really broke away,
truly, in this scenario,
I would say the Ukraine and Poland,
and maybe Georgia.
Georgia might be another example.
But by and large,
states like Bulgaria, Romania
are still very much under the same control
that they were in back in the Soviet days.
The same people are still running things.
But what's changed?
The West doesn't care about communism anymore.
The West was focusing on Islam
while the Soviet Union collapsed into Russia
and then restarted building its military.
When China built up the world's second greatest economy
and a massive military,
Western policymakers said,
well, China's not communist really.
They've got business,
so we don't have to worry about them.
Russia's still got a long way to go.
In any way, we can be their friends.
Let's just concentrate on chasing the Taliban
around Afghanistan and going into Iraq.
So what Gillitson said was this.
This was the policy.
This was the plan.
This is the biggest disinformation exercise
ever done by communism.
And remember Lenin.
He was all about one step forwards,
two steps backwards.
One step forward, two steps backwards.
You go as far as you can.
When you meet resistance, you retreat.
Your enemy gives up,
and you come back for more later.
This is where we are now.
You still have American commentators
who will seriously tell you
that Russia and China can be played against each other.
Russia and China held the world's greatest
military exercise together
outside St. Petersburg, Russia in 2018.
The biggest military exercise in world history.
They are allied in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization.
That is a military, political, economic pact
that was established in 2001
to unite Russia, to unite China,
Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan.
Iran is an observer.
India was an observer for a while.
This is the new Warsaw Pact.
But you have serious Western commentators
trying to tell you
that Russia and China are not working together.
Absolutely they are working together.
And as Gillitson said,
when the West had disarmed
and the West had invested huge amounts of money
in China and Vietnam and Russia,
when the West was pretty much exhausted of its cash,
Russia and China would join together
and with one closed fist,
destroy the United States once and for all
and become the dominant world powers
and go back onto a very rigorous,
very tyrannical form of Leninism.
That is the program, folks.
We misunderstand the nature of communism.
We think because they have some market operations,
therefore they can't be communist.
That's a fallacy.
We believe that because communism
went into major retreat in Eastern Europe,
that it is no threat,
that Russia is no threat.
Russia has nukes now
that could take out Texas with one bomb.
China can send missiles twice around the world.
Russia and China are getting ready.
Russia, China and Iran and Venezuela and Cuba
and North Korea and their allies
are getting ready for war.
The American military is getting ready for mascara.
That's the situation we are in.
Communism is on the verge of its greatest triumph,
its final triumph,
and we are living in la-la land
if we think we can play one country off against the other.
Russia and China are allies.
They're allied to Iran
and their major enemies are Israel and the United States
and their goal is to annihilate both.
So we've got to wake up, people.
We've got to get onto our leaders.
We've got to elect leaders who are Winston Churchills,
not Neville Chamberlains.
We have to wake up to the fact
that our civilization is threatened
like it's never been threatened before
and stand up.
Please, read Gillitson's book,
written in 1984,
New Lies for Old.
It will change your view of world politics.
Read his second book,
The Perestroika Deception.
Read books by Jeff Nyquist,
The Origins of the Fourth World War.
All of these books will give you a far better view
of what's going on in the world right now
than anything you'll see on the mainstream media.
So I'll repeat them.
New Lies for Old by Natalie Gillitson.
The Perestroika Deception by Natalie Gillitson.
The Origins of the Fourth World War by Jeff Nyquist.
This is what you need to understand
if we're going to survive in the West
because the hour is late.
So I hope you found this interesting,
if a little chilling.
I don't expect you to believe what I've said here.
Please do your own research.
I think if you're honest and diligent,
you'll come up with similar conclusions.
So thanks for watching, people.
I'll be expanding on these themes in later episodes.
So God bless America.
God bless every freedom-loving person in the world.
And let's save our countries,
save our civilization,
and just roll up our sleeves.
So thank you very much for watching.
