Spice Cake | Chicken Salad | Recreating Recipes From The 1920s

Food and Nutrition
578 followers
Hi my friends and welcome back to the 52 Sunday Dinners Project where we are taking all of the
menus out of this cookbook, the 52 Sunday Dinners Cookbook from Women's World Magazine in 1924
and we're going week by week and recreating each of the menus that are in here. Now for this week
this is the 25th Sunday Dinner and here's what's on the menu today. We're starting off with a cream
of potato soup and then for our main course we're going in with a chicken salad. On the side of that
we'll have boiled buttered rice and scalloped tomatoes to serve on top of it. For our salad
course we have cucumber salad and for dessert we have two options including spice cake which is
served with an orange icing on top and then we're also going to have apple amber and as we said last
week normally this is the part where I say of course we're having coffee but we're not. We're
going in with a much cooler drink this time and we're going to go with iced tea. For our tartar
dressing I assume that I'm pronouncing that correctly. I'm thinking about steak tartare and
this is certainly our tuna tartare. This is definitely not the same thing. I have our mayonnaise
and our mustard mixed up in here and then onion, our sweet pickle which I detest. I know some of
you like sweet pickles. I love sour dill pickles but sweet pickles I do not like but maybe it'll be
good in this and then our capers. Capers are already pretty small I think so chopping them up
was interesting and a little difficult but we got it there and there we are done. Something that I
find a little bit odd about this recipe is okay we're using the warmed molasses. Great. Is the
butter that we're using supposed to be melted? Is it supposed to be just regular? Is it supposed
to go in I mean I cut it in pieces because that's what makes the most sense but the way it seems to
be in here it it feels like it should already be melted but it doesn't say that so does it melt
in this um molasses foaming molasses mixture? I don't know but it I don't know very very interesting
um we'll go ahead and get everything added and hopefully the way that we're adding it is correct.
There is no way this is right but we've already committed to it and done it but there's just
there is no way that's right. I wonder if we were supposed to cream the sugar and butter together
separately and then add these that's not at all what the recipe says but there's just no way that
this is correct. So before we add the eggs we're actually supposed to cool this so I'm really
guessing this was supposed to be not warmed molasses but hot molasses. I'm wondering if I
should just pop this into the oven for like one minute to heat up and get this butter melted down
kind of for it and then let it cool after because that's the only way this makes sense.
All right this seems more correct now let's let this cool for a while before we add these eggs.
I think we're cool enough I can touch this bowl now so I'd say we're probably plenty cool enough.
We'll add our eggs we have three yolks and one white in here we'll add our
yolks one by one and we are just mixing we are not beating in this one. We have our flour
this one is gluten-free so I can actually try this cake this week and we're just gonna mix this in
oh I forgot about the sour milk I have regular milk and I've just added a little bit of vinegar
to it to make it kind of like a buttermilk I suppose you can see the little chunks in there
you know we talk about this pretty often I am relatively sure that all of this is not going
to fit into here but maybe it will we may need a second cake pan though oh maybe not maybe all
this will fit yeah it definitely will my my eyes have no concept of actual size underneath of all
there you can see we have our onion there's celery tops everywhere and let's get this all boiled up
in our two cups of water you know I'm pretty sure if I'm remembering that correctly several of you
at least one of you but I think several of you have talked about instead of running things through
the strainer that we've been using the different mesh strainers why not run it through the ricer so
we have our potato soup here I think that's a great idea particularly for the potatoes
we use the ricer on the potatoes often why not for this so we're going to go ahead and try that
I'm not sure how the onion will move through the ricer but we're going to try it out
it's nice and steamy
all right at first this just feels like mashed potatoes just keep adding all of the milk
I'm not sure if this is going to thicken when it's not on a double boiler but
I guess we'll just mix this up a little bit and then we'll get it on the double boiler
doing a little bit different of a double boiler today normally we have the two glass pyrex but
I didn't think that was going to be big enough so we're doing it the old-fashioned way we talk
about this many times that likely the desserts are a choice they give us several options for
desserts and you're supposed to probably just pick one of them but of course we pick both or
all of them because we like them and I am just assuming you all feel the same way that I do
because you should but if I had to have the choice between making these two desserts if
I was a busy mother in the 1920s unquestionably I would pick the apple amber because it's so
simple we're just chopping thinly some apples throwing them in a pan sprinkling some cinnamon
sugar over throwing it in the oven and calling it a day no not really any measuring not any
mixing it's just chop throw so easy now it says to sprinkle sugar between and then finish off with
the cinnamon nutmeg butter however we have cinnamon sugar right here we're gonna go ahead
and sprinkle the cinnamon sugar in between each layer instead of just sugar because I think it's
just going to be better that way and I think maybe our four mothers would have done the same thing
or maybe they wouldn't maybe cinnamon was expensive back then and if they saw this
they would be thinking what a wasteful little idiot this girl is but uh we're gonna go with it
anyway I find this icing recipe very interesting it's not a meringue but it's also not a frosting
or an icing it's like a mix between the two I'm wondering how it's gonna hold up if it sits for
more than I guess for overnight or something we have our orange zest here I'm gonna add just about
half of it and our juice of the whole orange it's a really I used caracara oranges let me show you
the color it's almost the color of an egg yolk actually it's it's beautiful we have caracara
oranges and I don't I don't know what kind of oranges they would have been using at the time
maybe not this type but this it's just beautiful it smells phenomenal in this kitchen right now
as soon as we started zesting this orange rind oh it was good I'm gonna go ahead and add of course
this confectioner's sugar we're gonna sift it in there but I don't know there's it just seems
very odd to me maybe the egg white is going to lend itself to I guess creating some air and
lightness in this but we're mixing everything in with it so I I don't know that it is going to
the amount of powdered sugar this is taking is insane I think there is already close to three
pounds a three pound bag in here I don't know if I add any more it's it's not quite spreadable I
think I mean it's spreadable but I don't know if it's thick enough but if I add any more sugar to
this I don't know that it'll be edible it'll be so sweet so I think I'm gonna stop here add the
butter and I don't know either the recipe is off or maybe the orange the amount of orange juice was
too much maybe the oranges they were using back then would have been much smaller but
it didn't seem like an overwhelming amount also there's so much of this there's no chance that
this is going to just go on the top this is definitely going to go down the sides as well
all right let's see if we can get this reasonably on here maybe it'll harden up after a little while
I don't know maybe it's only supposed to be on top because of how sweet it is because otherwise
it would be too overwhelming either way if that's the case we have enough here for like
10 cakes I baked up some chicken now it's all cut up we're gonna put our french dressing
all around it to marinate just let that sit for a while we have our scalloped tomatoes
which is actually listed as scalloped tomatoes in the menu and it says to go to page 40 which is
scalloped tomatoes and the menu next week has a recipe for scalloped tomatoes I know the way
I'm saying this probably makes no sense however this cookbook sometimes makes no sense think of
all the salad recipes so far that we've had this is the easiest most simple one all we're doing is
peeling these little it says short cucumbers I just bought mini cucumbers I don't know if that's
right or not but we're close enough and then we just have to cut them lengthwise and that's it
put them in some ice water put them on lettuce a little of the tartar dressing on top and we're
done have our little cucumbers on our lettuce leaves I have to be honest I went to get this
out of the refrigerator because that's what I'm storing it in and I saw this and I thought
how did my whipped cream get that moldy that fast I forgot that we made this
and that legit looks like whipped cream got pretty moldy in the fridge it is not it's just
the tartar there we have it for this chicken salad it says to use either celery or white
cabbage if celery is not available we do have celery available but I've never had white cabbage
before in any type of salad other than I mean I should I shouldn't say that in coleslaw and
vegetable salads but never in like a chicken or tuna or anything like that I always put celery so
I'm kind of interested to see what cabbage is going to be like so let's try that out
drain the dressing off this chicken and we'll mix it up with our cabbage and celery seed
I'll be back in a few minutes to see if every kernel stands on end all right let's see well I
don't believe it looks any different but we're going to go ahead and pour our butter over it
fluff it and we're going to get to eating now this doesn't say whether to pour it over in the
colander or to put it in a bowl so I guess we'll I think we should put it in the bowl I think the
colander seems silly okay my friends let's get to trying everything we're starting off this time
we're back to a soup and you know I'm a little surprised by the choice of soup because it's more
of a heartier cream of potato soup where we have a lot of cooler kind of things I guess through the
meal through the menu our main dish is cold and we've been seeing this our our drink instead of
coffee we're having iced tea so I would think that for this meal we would have gone with something a
little more refreshing like a cold soup or some fruit or like last week we had what I assume was
a drink maybe I was wrong I don't know but we're gonna go ahead in with this heartier soup and see
how it tastes I smell the potatoes strong hmm that's not bad at all I I do feel a little bit
like I'm eating very runny mashed potatoes but not in a bad way I suppose now I didn't have any
gluten-free crackers for me to put with this and I think if I did it would be a lot tastier it it
would bring it up a level that salt on a cracker with this or crouton would really level this up
a good bit and I can see for this right here tasting it and imagining what it would have been
like with the salt salted cracker you could have that cream of potato soup as a pretty hearty meal
in the wintertime I think on its own or maybe with a little source of protein inside maybe
throw a few cubes of ham or something like if we had some of that leftover ham from last week
cubing a little bit of that up into this cream of potato soup that could be a whole meal in and of
itself but overall it's not too bad for our main course we have our chicken salad here and we have
it nicely decorated I think with our sliced stuffed olives and our hard-boiled eggs and then we have
our rice with the scallop tomatoes on top before starting into this I just have to say I find it
just a bit of an odd combination for me hot rice and cooked tomatoes and then cold chicken salad
to me these things just don't pair together and also there's a tremendous amount of dishes
in this unless I'm serving it wrong but if they want the chicken salad to be served decorated
on lettuce leaves like this my assumption is it would be on its own individual plate now maybe
they meant to make a whole tray of it or serving dish of it like this and then everybody scoops a
little bit onto their plate and the same with the the rice and the tomatoes it would be on the same
plate as this or I guess I'm just not sure and the same thing with the salad I've always served
the salad on a separate plate instead of one serving dish decorated how they suggest so I
don't know what do you guys think do you guys think this should have been all separate dishes
should have all been on one what what are your thoughts and your experiences and while you tell
me that let's try the chicken salad first when I have had chicken salad in the past again like I
before I've never had it with the cabbage and typically when I have it there's some sort of
fruit in here um nani makes a really good one with a mango chutney and I've had it with walnuts
and grapes before I enjoyed that just never had it quite like this before but we're gonna find
out how it tastes the chicken smell with the mayonnaise actually reminds me of the smell of
it tastes good it's not bad but I think it's missing a little bit of acidity it's a little
heavy in the flavor I think and it feels like it just it's kind of pulling the flavors down a
little bit on the heavier side it needs something to brighten it up let's try it with the decorative
little olives here maybe that will help the olives help a little bit but not quite enough
I think it does need a little bit of that fruit in there just to brighten it up a little bit
I would like maybe even a little bit of lemon zest in this I bet would be really good we have
that orange zest left over maybe we could have put orange zest in here it might have been pretty
tasty that way but overall not bad I think it just needs a little bit of brightness to level it up
let's try our rice and tomatoes they smell nice together it smells like it should be some sort of
a soup like a tomato and rice soup or something they taste great together the pairing of the
tomatoes and the rice and the rice has all that butter in there too so there's a nice buttery
ness and richness to the rice and then that more acidic tomato on top those pair very well
together however I don't think they pair with the chicken salad quite like maybe they should
it's it's not bad together it just to me they don't belong together so speaking of all the
different dishes we're using here is our salad course very cute very different I think than
what we are used to seeing with this usually we don't see that elongated shape with our salads
this is very fun let's try this with our dressing it smells very good it smells very fresh let's
try it out I love cucumbers and I love the way they're served here now we know that mayonnaise
isn't my favorite but it actually doesn't go too bad with this together maybe it's the addition of
those pickled items in there those more acidic items the capers the pickles and whatever I
think there's something else we put in here but I think they pair pretty well with this cucumber
and if you're somebody who likes mayonnaise I think you would really enjoy this and
it's kind of a simple but fun different way to serve a salad so it's got my vote all right let's
see how this spice cake turned out with this the icing on top has hardened a good bit not
significantly but enough oh it is very easy to cut into whoo very easy and eager to get out I'll
show you what it looks like on the inside there we go I think that looks pretty great let's give it
a try we have our spice cake and then we also have our apple amber right there with our whipped cream
so there is a lot of spice cinnamon in both of these things I think we'll try the apple first
it is very tender and soft those apples at the top they created I had all that cinnamon sugar
on top and they kept their shape and were maybe a little bit harder or spongier they might have
like just slightly dehydrated but also cooked the ones in the bottom they're almost unrecognizable
they're just like applesauce already they're a mush I bet it's going to be delicious oh it smells
good apple and cinnamon together just an amazing smell oh yeah that's delicious together I don't
it was so easy to make but also it is so good we could repeat this multiple times and I don't
think I would get sick of it if I was making this on Sunday and I knew that it tasted like this
I might make maybe a triple batch so that we could eat it all week you could put this on oatmeal you
could eat it just like this is dessert on top of ice cream with pork oh oh this is good
well now I feel a little sad for my cake because it has to live up to this expectation it's you know
if you've ever performed or anything and you have to go up on stage after somebody who is amazing
this poor little spice cake has to go up on stage after that apple amber I'm sorry little guy you're
you're gonna have to be amazing it does smell very good it has more of a fall winter smell to me than
a nice summery smell but actually the apple cinnamon did too those are things I associate
with the fall or the winter and something that I was surprised about with this spice cake
there's no raisins or walnuts in it which I'm not complaining about I don't particularly love
raisins or walnuts in my cake but like last week we had a chocolate cake that had raisins and
walnuts but not a spice cake usually when I think of spice cake I do think of adding those raisins
or dried fruits and nuts into it but not this one this one we're leaving alone let's try it we
have the icing on there I do not smell the orange at all on this just the spice hmm that is really
good and the icing my expectation for the icing was that it would be overwhelmingly cloyingly
sweet and maybe if we ate it on its own and tasted it you know the little like dipped a spoon in
there and tasted it on its own it might be but on top of this cake I think those flavors are very
well balanced and I certainly tasted the orange once I had the whole thing in my mouth even though
I didn't smell it the flavor comes through once you start eating it but it is not overwhelmingly
sweet like what I would have expected I still think I like the apple more but this spice cake
is not too shabby at all the iced tea I think pairs very well with this meal the only thing it
maybe seemed a little bit strange eating it next to was the rice and tomatoes but not I mean not
that strange it wasn't that much off just with I think with everything else it pairs well with it
the rice and the tomatoes just I don't know overall I didn't think this menu was too bad
most of the things in it I felt needed maybe something a little different to elevate it or
change it a little bit like the potato soup and the chicken salad they they needed something just
a little bit of something but overall and you know again I also thought some of the things went well
together some of the things maybe didn't so I think overall I'd give this one a six or a seven
out of ten nutrition wise this was not a bad one again we used chicken breast for the chicken salad
and although we did add some mayonnaise on there the lean chicken breast is a very good source of
protein we had several different instances of vegetables in here and if we had chosen the
apple amber instead of the spice cake we would have had a nice healthy fruit dessert and I guess
if we would have chosen the spice cake over the apples that would have made it you know a little
bit less on the nutrient dense side however this meal overall I think I'd also give it maybe a a
six six out of ten for this one the price of this one was actually a good bit cheaper than some of
the ones we've had recently if I had to calculate for six people what this would have been it's
around probably about between 40 and 50 dollars so not too bad if you like what you saw today
please consider liking the video and subscribing to the channel so that you never miss another
sunday dinner and if you'd like to join us next week watch as we make an attempt at strawberry
ice cream and we'll try our hand at sponge cake again see you then
