My Friend Wants To Avoid Insurance After Hitting My Car

The Ramsey Show Highlights
1.8K followers
70 Video Views·Jun 22, 2024
[Music]
brought to you by the every dooll app
start budgeting for free today I have a
dilemma um uh my coworker accidentally
backed into my car uh earlier this week
and she's wanting to not go through
insurance and just pay out of pocket um
so that she doesn't have to have our
rates go up but I'm feeling nervous
about that and I just kind of wanted to
talk it
out how well do you know this this
coworker
um pretty well like have been to her
house
and I know a bit of her financial
situation too so that's like a layer as
well do you guys like each other oh yeah
yeah I like her okay I there's a reason
I got an angle George but I'm I'm gonna
let you walk through this financially
let's do some fact finding how bad is
the
damage so I I got three different quotes
and they ranged from 1,500 to 3600 whoa
this is a pretty serious she was in a
hurry huh this is not a dent yeah yeah
it's a big dent yeah okay so let's put
it on the high end let's say it's 3600
she's saying I'd rather pay you the 3600
than go through insurance does she have
the money to pay for it up front no yeah
so no so when I came back with those um
amounts that I got for myself she said
wow that is are they trying to repair
the whole car and I was like no it's
just for the bent um and then she said I
found someone who would do it for less
than no I'm not going to let Uncle Ricky
Bobby handle this we're going to go
through a professional route yeah she
doesn't get to choose the person and she
doesn't even have the money to cover the
repair well yeah so that's like one of
the dilemas is like because I I do know
her I know her financial situation she's
a single mom and um there's just a lot
of complex things going on in her life
again because I know her but um I I
worry that like if I did let her go and
pay me on the side like what if I have
to like kind of cound her for the money
or something like that you know yeah
that's not a that's not an option you
trying to be nice is going to reain
drama on your life and that is not worth
it for you don't take on that burden
because you want to be a sweet person
which I can tell that you are because
you're calling in you're you're toiling
over this dilemma and I just think the
long-term implications of what this
could be and how it's going to hurt the
relationship is going to be worse if you
let her go through this weird process
weird question George maybe it's not a
weird question uh do you have an opinion
here or some actual knowledge on if if
if this coworker actually filed with her
insurance and said I backed into my
coworker here um it feels like whatever
bump in
Insurance could be less if she has a
good driving record I just wonder if she
doesn't oh no because you know what I
was thinking she told me oh sorry go
ahead well Kaye what I was wondering is
is is it going to be less money out of
pocket for her if even with the
insurance hit than paying you let's say
it's 3,600 bucks well let's say the bump
was 200 bucks now that's ongoing for a
while until her insurance bumps back
down after a clean driving record but I
don't think her terrible driving record
has anything to do with you you're just
not again not your fault yeah you've got
to protect yourself in the situation and
I don't think that makes you a worse
person and she doesn't have the
money yeah so that puts you in a so you
understand that puts you in a collection
350 oh sorry no go ahead her premium's
350 a month already um four grand a year
for one
yeah she's also nervous too because she
has a side job too and she has to drive
um for it and she's worried that like if
she has another mark on her record that
she might lose that side job there's
just like a lot of layers here obviously
yes I understand it's complicated and
this is going to affect her life in some
way I still would file a claim through
your insurance because it's going to be
really tough to get insurance involved
later and all you have at this point is
her word that she'll pay and we don't
even know that she'll pay cuz she's
going to say Well since this guy can do
it for 300 I'm only going to pay you 300
and it's on you if you want to go get
some get it done somewhere else I'm not
okay with that either way this
relationship is going to be strained
from here on out yeah but I'd rather you
not take on the drama just to be a sweet
person well thank you very much I that
it's yes that's kind of where my husband
and I had landed too but it stinks I
mean I I hate that but my goodness I
what I don't understand is why her side
job would be in danger I don't get that
part well maybe there's a insurance your
driving record affects these side jobs
and if you have a certain number of
dings you can't you know drive for Uber
I don't know how the back end works I
see the drive okay I got you all right
well tough situation it's kind of like
if someone committed a crime for the
fifth time and now like hey they could
have probation because of this that's
not your fault yeah they backed into you
I want you to protect your finances and
she will survive this she survived it
already with her terrible driving record
so hopefully she has uh learned a lesson
create your free every dollar budget
today the simplest way to budget for
your life
