Here's the ultimate secret of model railroading: You can do whatever you want! You make your own rules! You can model anything you want, real or imagined. Ok, that's not much of a secret, but it is my personal philosophy and I'm happy to expand and expound on it for this Workbench Wednesday.
Music: "Cowboy Sting" by Kevin MacLeod - YouTube Audio Library "Country Cue 1" courtesy of Audionautix, licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Artist: http://audionautix.com/ "Rural Stride" - YouTube Audio Library
[Music]
Howdy Folks Dave here at Thunder MAA
Studio on a workbench Wednesday yes
workbench Wednesdays are back and I want
to thank you all so much for joining me
today hope you are having a great day
wherever you are and whenever you happen
to be watching this you know lately I've
been thinking a lot about the parameters
of model railroading you know what is
and what is not a part of this wonderful
hobby of ours and I know from personal
experience that there are some in the
older guard of this hobby that can be a
little bit gatekeeping for lack of a
better word they can be a little bit
conservative about uh what is and is not
a model railroad and how you should
proceed and what your goals as a model
ra Builder should be but who really gets
to decide that it's not like there's
some overarching Authority that gets to
dictate what is and what is not a model
railroad even the nmra the national
model railroad Association doesn't have
that kind of magical power now thanks to
people like you who watch this channel
And subscribe I've been able to build up
a little bit of a platform here and I'm
often contacted by people who are
interested interested in getting into
the hobby or new to the Hobby and what
I've heard from a lot of them
particularly younger people is that that
sort of Old Guard conservative
gatekeeping can be very
discouraging so I'm going to say
something to you that I wish someone had
said to me when I was first starting out
with trains many many years ago and that
is you can do whatever you want so if
you feel like you need someone's
permission to do something wild and new
and Innovative or a little offbeat or
outside the norm you can have mine but
honestly you really don't need anyone's
permission I really only have two
criteria for what should be in a model
railroad number one trains of some kind
preferably that move and number two a
story or an idea or a point of view that
you're trying to get across everything
everything else is artistry and
engineering and you will learn those
you'll get better at those the more and
more you do them you will learn and grow
as a human no matter what you choose to
model and that is really the whole point
of this entire exercise so you can do
whatever you want and please ignore
anyone who tries to tell you that you're
doing model railroading wrong they're
out of line just for saying that in any
field of endeavor attracts its
self-appointed experts and this hobby is
certainly no exception we've got our
fair share now I believe that most of
them are actually trying to be helpful
but there are also usually a few who are
simply blo hards who want to show up how
smart they are if you present your work
in a public forum you're going to be
open to criticism especially if what you
do is novel in any way or beond on the
usual Fair my advice is take it or leave
it as it helps your process but you can
almost always ignore unsolicited
critiques that's when someone offers you
an opinion on your work that you simply
did not ask for there are people who
assume that anything that you post
online is fair game and you're asking
for their expert opinion the truth is
this goes Way Beyond modeling and making
too I think we all know somebody like
this and by the way if you don't know
somebody like this I hate to tell you
it's probably you and if it is you you
should stop you're not helping the thing
about giving unsolicited critiques to a
complete strangers labor of love is that
there is no way of doing it without
sounding like a complete jerk so as we
all hopefully learned in kindergarten if
you can't say something nice it's best
not to say anything at all that said you
should definitely seek out the opinions
of experts and fellow modelers and
makers who you know and respect that's a
great way to grow and learn and to try
new things that you may not have thought
of on your own so you can do whatever
you want you can model whatever you want
any place any time period real or imag
the point is this is a hobby it's not
rocket science we're doing do it
primarily to create enjoyment for
ourselves and if we're lucky for you
know a few select others too but you are
the primary audience you have to please
yourself first and foremost you can do
whatever you want but if you do
something that's outside of the
mainstream be prepared because somebody
will say well that's nice but that's not
model
railroading what they mean is that's not
model railroading to them but who cares
what they think if you set out in this
hobby to please the standards and
expectations of others or some other
imagined Authority that is a recipe for
disappointment and you'll probably end
up losing interest after a short period
of time and there's no doubt in my mind
that there are some experts out there
who will probably disagree with me on
all of this many of my friends in this
Hobby and you know I know some people
that follow the channel too or what are
known as freelance modelers those are
modelers who prefer to invent their own
prototype or to fictionalize an existing
prototype to tell a different kind of
story it's a Whata if sort of railroad
and Freelancers can run the gamut from
just slightly off prototype to complete
and utter fantasy it just all depends on
the kind of modeling they want to do and
the kind of story they want to tell and
I can't stress enough it's all valid we
can quibble about skill level technique
and execution but you really can't argue
with anyone's idea or basic premise and
this goes the other way too sadly I've
heard more than a couple of Freelancers
say that uh strict prototype modelers
so-called rivet counters just don't get
it and they're not having any fun that's
ridiculous of course they're having fun
they're getting the enjoyment out of it
that they want otherwise they wouldn't
be putting so much time into it
different people enjoy different things
let them some people really enjoy
operations While others couldn't care
less and just want to make models some
want to recreate a place and time and
history as accurately as possible While
others enjoy trains going around castles
and mermaid lagoons the point is if
there's a train in it and you're making
models it's model railroading everyone's
enjoyment is equally valid if you follow
this Channel and thank you so much if
you do you've seen the kind of modeling
that I prefer uh welld detailed
story-based layouts that pack a lot into
a small area I love structures and
scenery first and foremost but those are
just my personal preferences others
might prefer a big HO scale Empire in a
basement or an attic transition era you
know Pennsylvania Railroad Santa Fe
Union Pacific something like that that
packs in tons of operational
possibilities that's great cool it's all
cool I like the old west the desert
Southwest Victorian architecture the
colorful locomotives Narrow Gauge a
certain humor and caricature and Disney
esque quality to the modeling those are
my personal preferences that's what
makes me happy as a model
maker other builders other makers of
model railroads are going to have
different opinions and different
preferences and it's all good it is
completely unnecessary to choose sides
you know we're not making up teams for
softball and you know none of this is
new what got me thinking about all of
this again was remembering back to a
thread I had been following many years
ago in one of the old model railroading
forums sorry I can't remember which site
it was um off the top of my head but I
was lurking in this thread where a very
heated discussion was going on about
what was and what was not to be
considered legitimate model
railroading and one poster in particular
got my attention because he brought up
Malcolm
Furlow and he said that while Malcolm's
work was very
artistic it wasn't real model
railroading in his opinion and several
other people on there agreed with them
and I found all of this to be completely
absurd Malcolm furo was one of the most
influential model railroaders of the 70s
and 80s and probably inspired more
people of my generation to get into the
hobby than all of those transplanter and
Gatekeepers
combined and you know I made a conscious
decision then to never be like that to
never mistake my preferences and my
opinions for the gospel truth to never
try to tell people how to enjoy their
hobby I mean come on it's up to you
enjoy it any way you like in the
beginning I started this channel just as
a way to share what I was doing a side
effect of that I could never have
foreseen was that what I was doing would
have influence on you know other
modelers when I began the Thunder Mesa
layout I gave myself permission to do
exactly what I wanted it was not a
layout designed to please the
sensibilities of traditional model
railroading I had tried and failed to do
that in the past mostly because my heart
wasn't in it so I set out to do exactly
what I wanted and in so doing you know
I've gained a a small and dedicated but
growing audience and for that I am
eternally grateful over time my goals
for this platform have shifted a little
bit from just showing what I'm doing to
helping other hobbyists do what they
want to do sharing ideas and materials
and techniques to help everyone move
forward you see we all influence and
Inspire each other either directly or
indirectly and I think that's a great
thing the most rewarding thing I ever
hear from doing this is When someone
tells me that they got into the hobby or
back into the hobby after a long absence
from watching my videos that's
incredibly humbling and you know it
means the world to
me I think maybe they were looking for
someone to give them permission to do
something different something a little
non-traditional well you have it you
have that permission but it doesn't come
from me it comes from the fact that
freedom of expression is required in any
creative
Endeavor so you know Express Yourself
model trains may be seen as trivial or
folkart at best and let's face it we're
not curing diseases here but we are
bringing a smile and the world
desperately needs that too now before we
wrap this up today I want you to think
of your best idea for a model railroad
that you're willing to share and put it
in the comments down below it can be
based on a real world prototype you know
like the Denver realr Western the Santa
Fe the penzy whatever something you want
to model as accurately as possible down
to the smallest detail or it can be
something completely wild and outlandish
like say a a mining company on mars or a
train that goes to
Neverland this hobby is your canvas and
you really can do whatever you want the
only limit is a in ination now I want to
thank you all so much for watching today
and a huge thank you as usual to our
channel members for helping to make
these videos possible keep moving
forward my
friends adios for now
[Music]