Schumann: Scenes from Childhood, Op.15 - 4. Pleading Child

【Classical music and nature 古典音樂小站】Robert Schumann: Scenes from Childhood, Op.15 - 4. Pleading Child. This beautiful piece was played by Chiara Bertoglio. It has Creative Commons license (CC BY 3.0 DEED Attribution 3.0 Unported) and is provided through www.musopen.org.
The Kinderszenen op. 15 are a cycle of thirteen short piano pieces written by Robert Schumann in 1838.
The scenes describe childhood, but what what childhood like in 1838?
"Although obedience out of love has the highest value, it is not always attainable and therefore a punishment is often necessary. But even with this, the child must necessarily feel the sorrow of having to punish, as well as justice. Therefore, never punish without first warning. If the child does not obey, then apply the threat, and only if this is in vain, the punishment, but immediately, as long as the child, whose memory for such things is not far-reaching, is still aware of his offence as well as of the mother's warning and patience. It does him no harm to see his mother angry or saddened; on the contrary, in a well-behaved child this pain outweighs the physical pain, and the moment after his right has been done to him by the rod, he will wrap his little arms around his mother's neck and sobbingly stammer the plea that she may be good again. Such moments are the most suitable to speak to the child's heart, so the mother must not let them be taken advantage of and must not be angry longer than the child testifies his remorse.
Even the most stubborn, obstinate child must be brought to the point where it cannot fall asleep unreconciled; here double love and patience are necessary and strictness is certainly the least effective; here the mother's pain over the naughtiness must be shown openly in order to soften the mind and encourage repentance." (Source: The Housewife's Book, ca. 1880 page 358)
I liked how forgiveness, patience, forbearance and love form the basis for a strict upbringing in this text. The strictness is good for the child, it learns to distinguish between good and bad.
In my opinion, the child must know the rules before there is any talk of threats or punishment. In particular, the mother or father should be sure that the child has done something that he knows is wrong before a threat or punishment is given.
My father, for example, was most important to him that I tell the truth and behave truthfully. He clearly showed me that if I had broken something, it wasn't a bad thing as long as I stood by the fact that it was me who had broken it. If I had lied or blamed someone else, I would have been in serious trouble. His rule was: truthfulness comes first. Always and everywhere.
What I experienced with my own children was that I had to be careful when I was under stress that I didn't discipline them for something just because they were getting on my nerves and not because they were breaking a rule. The rules for my children were very simple. For example. Don't lie, don't give back (in word or deed), don't swear. They were just basic things that I insisted on with rigour and that a child can remember well.
This also meant that I was not allowed to swear, lie or retaliate, because children learn more from our example than from our admonitions.
The video was filmed by Simone Schlegel and edited by Wenjing Ma.
#classicalmusic, #Music, #古典音樂, #klassischemusik, #GJWexclusive, #Switzerland, #Schweiz, #Natur, #Nature, #KlassischeMusikundNatur, #ClassicalMusicAndNature, #古典音樂小站,
