The Hobbit: The Desolation of Tolkien

Nerdwriter1
2 followers
Jun 10, 2024
Middle-earth's got its mojo back.
No.
A really good movie, superior to the first in that it brings its characters to rambunctious life.
No.
It's a ride well worth taking.
No.
The desolation of Smaug has been touted as a major improvement upon the first installment of the Hobbit series,
An Unexpected Journey, which was utter shit.
So, I went to go buy my tickets with moderate hopes for a good time.
What I got was a pile of poop.
I'm a bit of a Tolkien superfan, so it hurts particularly badly when someone takes millions of dollars
and makes a hollow spectacle of his work.
The Hobbit isn't the high watermark of the Tolkien oeuvre, but it is still an exciting and wonderful book.
It's also a small, self-contained book, one written without the knowledge that a vast,
important masterpiece of the fantasy genre would follow it, or even be connected to it.
The Hobbit is Tolkien flexing his muscles with fairy story.
Only later, when the Lord of the Rings began to take shape in his mind,
did he realize that it could serve as a prequel.
For a backstory of the Lord of the Rings, for a deeper taste of the Tolkien legendarium,
take a look at The Silmarillion, or The Book of Unfinished Tales.
The Hobbit is essentially a repurposed standalone novel, replete with a number of beasts and monsters
that never again make an appearance in Middle-earth.
So, why does Peter Jackson feel the need to bloat The Hobbit into seven and a half hours of extravaganza
and spot-weld it to the Lord of the Rings?
Unfortunately, I think this is because a straight telling of The Hobbit would feel anticlimactic.
Even now, all I can think of is how inconsequential The Hobbit tale is compared to what is about to follow.
So, Jackson has to inject as much epicness as he can into the story,
but when combined with the goofy, poorly acted comedy of the dwarves,
the whole thing just feels like a big mess.
Part of this is prequel blues.
I'm hard-pressed to remember any cinematic prequel that actually improves upon the story that it precedes.
If you can think of one, write it in the comments.
But most of the time, they lean on something that I call pre-weight.
Objects, or people, or event that were meant to recognize from the original story, or elsewhere in history,
and go,
Ooh! Oh my god, it's the prancing pony! I remember that from the Lord of the Rings!
Pre-weight can be used to incredible effect,
but The Hobbit uses it as a crutch, just like the Star Wars prequels did.
In the end, Jackson doesn't do himself many favors.
48 frames per second, for example, is a mistake.
The lighting looks artificial.
The costumes and facial hair are shoddily done.
There's not a single line of dialogue that isn't predictable.
Gandalf is relegated to an expositional role.
No one surprises most disappoint.
The action is silly and void of drama.
The dragon, blah, blah, blah, blah, yeah, I get it.
Evangeline Lilly sucks almost as much as the dwarf she falls in love with,
and all five hours of the first two Hobbit films can't equal the emotional content
of these two deleted minutes from The Two Towers.
Simbulmuna.
Never has it grown on the tombs of my forebears.
Now it shall cover the grave of my son.
Alas, that these evil days should be mine.
The young perish, and the old linger.
But I should live to see the last days of my house.
Saedroth's death was not of your making.
No parents should have to bury their child.
He was strong in life.
His spirit will find its way to the halls of your fathers.
Rastoran.
Prentissium.
Fens.
