Fast food discounts are a 'necessary evil' right now: Analyst

Invest Insight
9 followers
2 Video Views·Jun 1, 2024
McDonald's addresses viral social posts and media reports on the company, raising prices
significantly beyond inflationary rates.
The fast food chain defending its commitment to value and affordability, a key ingredient
other fast food companies are getting their hands on.
We're looking at how to navigate the big picture with the Yahoo Finance playbook.
Peter Saleh, BTIG Managing Director, and Andrew Charles, TD Cowan, Managing Director, join
us now to discuss.
Guys, good to have both of you on the show.
Peter, maybe I'll start with you.
We can start kind of high level, Peter, as you kind of look across your coverage universe,
the fast food chains, Peter, you know, inside and out.
How healthy, how resilient does this industry look?
So look, I think the industry is healthy, but I think they are going through a tougher
time right now.
Lots of discounting.
You're seeing it from McDonald's.
I think this is just the beginning.
I think you're seeing it from Wendy's.
You're seeing it from Jack in the Box.
You're seeing it from Burger King.
And I think this is going to continue.
And I think these discounts, as steep as they are, are going to likely hurt same store sales
in the medium term.
And I think they could hurt margins.
In our opinion, these are investments in value perceptions, given all the media backlash
against all the price increases that have been happening.
So we think this is something necessary, a necessary evil for these companies to be doing
at this point in time.
But it's going to take some time to change the perception and the narrative in the media
that these companies are more about value than they are about price hikes.
It's really interesting.
I mean, price wars we haven't seen in a while, right?
Because of this inflationary environment, Andrew, is it going to work?
You know, are consumers going to gravitate to those chains where they see promotions?
Thanks for having me.
So we're cautiously optimistic.
But I would say the last time we saw this, to your point, was in 2018, not a bad year
for McDonald's.
You know, you had same store sales of about 2.5%.
It's a little bit above the consensus right now for 2% for the year.
And during that time, traffic was negative by about 2.2%.
So the analog here is not great.
I think that the numbers are achievable, though, for McDonald's based on this strategy.
And so, you know, we're optimistic that this could be met.
But you know, McDonald's did rescind their guidance or their outlook for 3% to 4% U.S.
same store sales.
And obviously, this tactic likely wasn't contemplated at the end of the year when they issued it.
And Peter, back to you.
You know, McDonald's is big in the Lipton household, Peter.
I mean, that five-year-old, if you give her an Oreo McFlurry, she's good to go.
Let's get some of your top picks, though.
Domino's Pizza, Peter, walk me through why you think that's a buy right here.
Yeah, so Domino's is our top pick, the only QSR that we are bullish on.
And it's a self-help story.
They got several initiatives that they're working on or that are going to drive same
store sales.
And they're very company specific, first of which is the change in the rewards program,
which really happened last September of 2023.
So that gives them a benefit, really carries through the full year of 2024.
And they're already seeing increases in transactions across the board with that change.
And then when you look at the change in the Uber Eats partnership that they added at the
beginning of this year, that is starting to add some incremental sales as well.
They think they'll exit the year close to a 3 percent sales mix.
The vast majority of that is going to be incremental this year.
And then they can layer on on top of that in 2025, adding on DoorDash and other
partnerships as well.
So I think they have a lot of self-help initiatives going on that will drive that
mid-single digit same store sales growth.
And that's why we're bullish on them.
And Peter, how is pizza viewed in the sort of value chain?
Right. Like, you know, do you think consumers say, oh, am I going to go to McDonald's or
am I going to order a pizza?
And that pizza is viewed as a good value proposition?
Yes, I do think pizza is a cheaper alternative in terms of feeding a family of four, probably
like 30 bucks.
Can't do that these days at any of the other QSRs.
I don't know that pizza is necessarily taking share from these other fast food players at
this point.
I don't believe that to be the case.
I do think pizza just continues to grow at a very low single digit rate, will continue
to grow at that rate.
But I do think it's probably one of the better value propositions out there in the
quick service space.
Andrew, I'm looking across your coverage universe, a number of buys.
One hold that that sticks out to me is Wendy's.
How come you're on the sidelines there, Andrew?
And what would you need to see to get more bullish?
Yeah, we're worried about McDonald's share gains from this.
If we go back to 2018, Wendy's and Jack in the Box were two names that noticeably
McDonald's gained share from.
Taco Bell is noticeably one name that was able to gain share in the 2018 environment.
So part of it reflects that and part of it reflects the fact that they're trying to
march towards a more sustainable growth rate for the company of that two to three percent
range.
You know, we're a bit more concerned on their ability to do so given high interest
rates, given that it's been a challenging cash flow story for franchise operators
for the last several years.
Unfortunately, Wendy's, we don't think is immune from that.
And the fact they've missed their development targets in recent years as well
leads us to believe that there's better opportunities elsewhere versus Wendy's.
And Peter, back to you for a sec here, because you recently upgraded Darden.
I know not, you know, not exactly in the same category, but like talk to us about
what you're looking at in that in that situation.
Yeah, so for Darden, we view it as a best in class casual diner.
I think you've seen the same store sales trends improve as we've gone through
this year from January through February, March and into April.
We think they will benefit from that.
I do think they have levers to pull if they so choose on promotions and
advertising, given that they've reduced that level by about 200 basis points
since the pandemic.
I also think they can be a great beneficiary of the weakness over at Red
Lobster.
Red Lobster announced the bankruptcy a couple of weeks ago.
They closed about 100 stores.
Darden or Olive Garden and Red Lobster share a parking lot in about 400
locations.
There's a lot of overlap there.
We think a weaker Red Lobster is a benefit to Olive Garden, and so we went
ahead and upgraded shares of Darden.
Andrew, we were just talking about Wendy's, and of course, they made all
kinds of headlines for dynamic pricing.
I'm just curious, Andrew, that issue, dynamic pricing, is that a real
potential change you could see kind of ripple through the industry you cover?
You know, it's interesting you think about dynamic pricing.
I mean, when you look at the delivery platforms, the Uber Eats, DoorDash,
et cetera, typically you see about a 20% markup there, and so I would call
that dynamic pricing.
I think there was a PR snafu when Wendy's messaged what they were looking
to do.
It seemed like it was a bit misinterpreted, but they eventually backed
off what they planned to do.
So I think it would have to be handled delicately.
Certainly third-party delivery makes a lot of sense.
That's a convenience-based occasion, not a value-based occasion, where
restaurants can charge more.
I would be curious if we think philosophically, though, about the
industry, that restaurants in general talk about how the best prices and
deals are available through their app.
So it kind of fits your point just about the dynamic pricing, that it just
has to be done in a way with finesse.
But I think there's absolutely a way for this to be done and a way that
restaurants are looking at this.
I think the word choice will be a little bit different, though.
Well, and that sort of comes back to something you said in the beginning,
Peter, which is messaging around that dynamic pricing, around pricing
generally.
McDonald's recently pushing back against that sort of viral thing that
said that there was the $18 Big Mac or whatever.
Do you think that they've learned some lessons?
Are they doing a better job?
So for McDonald's specifically, I don't know that – they haven't taken
an outsized amount of pricing.
It's just strange as to some of the reports out there that prices were up
100 percent or more since the pandemic.
It's not true.
Most of these quick service restaurants have taken a high teens, low 20
percent increase over the past four or five years.
Pretty consistent across the industry.
So I'm not sure where those numbers are coming from.
But clearly when the discrepancy is that wide, they needed to push back
and clarify a little bit.
And I think they did a good job of doing that with the letter that they
put out.
Guys, good to see you.
Thanks a lot.
Thank you.
