It's Over! ULA is in BIG TROUBLE With Pentagon Contract... SpaceX Win

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
Jun 1, 2024
game over perhaps nobody will say I'm
too hasty in declaring this when talking
about the competition between Ula and
SpaceX we've never seen UA in such a bad
situation as they are now they're even
failing in the most humiliating way when
facing Financial penalties in the area
they've always been proud of launching
the government's payload Ula would be
dead as a door nail so why is ula in
this particular predicament and what
exactly happened let's delve into these
questions on today's episode of great
SpaceX a strong new competitor or a
dominance breaker those are the
beautiful words many people use to
describe Ula and Vulcan after the
Rocket's successful debut earlier this
year we were all hoping for the most
dramatic Space Race in recent years but
now Ula seems to be falling back in into
the deep hole of delay they had just
escaped from unable to launch their
second flight day by day the market they
have always been proud of which involves
launching government payloads is
gradually being lost to SpaceX and
everything got even worse when Ula was
hit with a heavy penalty by the Pentagon
specifically in a statement in miday the
US space force declared the government
is holding Ula accountable for delays in
accordance with the terms to date the
Pentagon has not announced the specific
fine they will impose this decision
comes as Ula has continued to delay two
missions under the National Security
space launch contract a mission to
launch a navigation satellite in January
was delayed to October while a mission
to launch the gps3 satellite was pushed
from June to early 2025 in fact this is
not the first time ula's Vulcan has
caused delays previously Ula was
assigned two missions ussf 51 and 106 in
2022 but vulcan's delay forced the 51
mission to be transferred to Atlas 5
this flight is currently scheduled for
June of 2024 while the 106 Mission
remains unscheduled consequently Ula
Vulcan currently has up to 25 backlog
missions under the National Security
space launch Phase 2 contract regarding
the nssl phase 2 contract it was awarded
by the ussf to Ula and SpaceX in 2020
after the two companies surpassed other
competitors The Phase 2 contract is
worth 3.5 billion us with the two
companies initially assigned to launch
34 missions within 5 Years From 2022 to
2026 the number of Ula and SpaceX
missions was divided 640 the ussf then
increased the mission count to 48
adjusting the ratio to
5446 in 2024 the ussf will assign 21
missions with Ula carrying out 11 and
SpaceX handling 10 no need to look at
previous years just consider the number
of missions this year to see that Vulcan
is completely unable to complete them
and Vulcan also has no support now the
Delta 4 heavy was retired after the
April 9th mission Atlas 5 is still
active but all its remaining 17 missions
have been assigned in addition to the
ussf 51 Mission we mentioned the
remaining Atlas 5 missions are for
launching the Starliner spacecraft Kyper
satellites and Viet satellites Ula
cannot cancel any of those missions to
share the workload with Vulcan in other
words the entire task of launching
government payloads now falls on Vulcan
but look at vulcan's situation right now
it's quite the Dilemma to begin
launching official missions Vulcan needs
to complete one more mission to receive
National Security launch certification
Vulcan sir 2 was scheduled to launch
Dreamchaser however due to delays in
testing Dreamchaser the mission was
pushed back to the third quarter of this
year the government agreed to let Vulcan
launched the CER 2 mission carrying a
dummy payload to complete the
certification process soon this sounds
quite reasonable but in reality it has
many problems you know Vulcan is not a
rocket that can be produced quickly in
addition to manufacturing Hardware it
also depends heavily on Blue Origins be4
engines which are notorious for slow
production if the Prototype prepared for
the Dreamchaser launch is used to launch
the payop required by the Pentagon
Vulcan may not be able to to produce the
rocket in time to launch Dreamchaser
even if they solve this problem remember
that we're almost halfway through 2024
and Vulcan still hasn't met the
licensing requirements what Miracle can
help them solve the required 11 tasks
this year as for the entire Phase 2
besides one Mission carried out by Delta
4 heavy Vulcan still has a backlog of up
to 25 missions as I've said before faced
with that situation Ula still said we
are not aware of any significant delays
regarding space Force missions a
financial penalty is truly deserved for
Ula right now do you agree let me know
with a yes or a no in the comment
section down below indeed in the current
situation Ula cannot shift
responsibility to anyone else instead
they should blame themselves for making
too many mistakes what are those
mistakes let me count the ways but
before that please leave a like share
the video and subscribe to the channel
to support our team as we delve more
deeply into this fascinating topic first
things first Ula proactively wanted to
escape dependence on Russia by stopping
the use of the Rd 180 engine like their
previous Rockets sounds quite ingenious
but their alternative the be4 was a
mistake this engine's production rate is
very slow the be4 delay was part of what
caused vulcan's original schedule for
2021 to be pushed back many years and
don't forget that blue origin doesn't
just make the be E4 for Vulcan they also
produced this engine for their new Glen
rocket if Ula had chosen another option
like spacex's Raptor their current
situation might have been much much much
different choosing to launch a difficult
Mission or a developing vehicle is ula's
other mistake the lunar lander launch
mission earlier this year was somewhat
too challenging for a new rocket and of
course it took both sides involved a lot
of time fortunately Vulcan completed
that mission which did provide a strong
first impression of the rocket however
with Dreamchaser a developmental vehicle
Ula should have anticipated the
potential delays it could cause yet they
chose this Mission and now face delays
even when their Rockets are ready in
contrast to Ula what SpaceX is doing is
simply unbeatable by miday SpaceX had
already launched 50 Falcon 9 missions
including the ussf 124 and 62 missions
on on the 14th of February and the 11th
of April respectively in the second half
of the Year SpaceX plans to accelerate
even further to achieve the Milestone of
148 launches allowing them to complete
10 nssl Phase 2 missions this year at
their current Pace I believe they will
finish the rest of their Phase 2
assignments very quickly possibly as
soon as next year to comprehend this
let's delve into the strengths of the
Falcon Rockets their design from
Hardware to engine is much Sim simpler
compared to Vulcan the key advantage
that always ensures Falcon 99's
capability is to complete missions is
its reusability falcon9 boosters and
fairings are reused extensively setting
unprecedented records after each Mission
they require only about a month for
refurbishment before being ready for the
next launch this not only significantly
reduces costs but also eliminates the
need to build new rockets for every
launch a major challenge faced by
Expendable Rockets like the Vulcan
following the success of the Falcon
Rockets spacex's capabilities will
further expand with the introduction of
Starship this colossal rocket is
currently in development and Promises to
outperform Falcon rockets in terms of
power payload capacity price reusability
and frequency of launches with Starship
in the picture it's clear that Vulcan
will face even greater disadvantages in
the competitive landscape despite facing
challenges and failing to complete Phase
2 missions Ula is still determined to
participate in nssl Phase 3 this
upcoming phase will span from 2025 to
2029 and will introduce two lanes for
competition Lane one will cater to small
launch providers handling simpler
missions while lane two will accommodate
larger service providers tasked with
more complex missions requiring
comprehensive Solutions notably Lane 2
will expand to accommodate three
companies instead of the current two the
value of phase three is expected to be
as significant as that of phase 2
promising Fierce competition and
substantial opportunities for the
participating companies Ula appears
confident in securing a spot in Phase 3
and challenging SpaceX however while
spacex's performance ensures its place
in Phase 3 recent challenges may have
made ula's position less certain even if
Ula is selected I anticipate that the
majority of missions will be assigned to
SpaceX solidifying spacex's dominance in
the Aerospace industry's next Frontier
for Ula surpassing SpaceX seems
increasingly unlikely they face
significant penalties for delays and
must swiftly address their current
issues otherwise it May indeed spell the
end for Ula well folks that's about it
for today's episode thank you so much
for tuning in and as always this has
been Kevin from great SpaceX and until
next time keep looking up
