With consumers grappling with the burden of high prices and persistent inflation, the implications for the retail sector are becoming increasingly apparent. Barclays' Consumer Discretionary Analyst Adrienne Yih and Jonna Kim TD Cowen Analyst join Market Domination to dissect the dynamics shaping the retail sector. Yih acknowledges the evident "pullback" in consumer spending due to the ongoing impact of inflation, describing it as "a creeper effect" that is gradually affecting consumers across various income levels. She emphasizes that for retailers to maintain consumer loyalty and spending, they must offer "a trend or a brand that rises above." Yih identifies American Eagle (AEO), Gap (GPS) , and Old Navy as companies that possess this momentum. Kim, on the other hand, notes that despite the pressure on consumers, "the newness is resonating well with consumers." As more brands introduce new products and offerings, she believes this is boosting consumer sentiment within the retail sector. However, Kim notes that consumers are still prioritizing value overall.
All eyes on the consumer this week.
A slew of retailers like Abercrombie & Fitch, Costco,
Kohl's, they're all set to report their quarterly results,
providing insight on customer spending.
This coming as consumer confidence saw a rise in May,
while recession concerns still linger,
according to the conference board.
And we're looking at how to navigate the big picture
with the Yahoo Finance Playbook.
Here to discuss, Barclays consumer discretionary analyst,
Adrian Yee, along with TD Cowen analyst, Jonah Kim.
Thank you both for being here, appreciate it.
Guys, I wanna start big picture first, right?
Because we, it's a confusing time
when it comes to consumer, right?
You got consumer confidence day rebounding,
but you have a lot of the retailers
talking about a trade down effect, et cetera.
When we're talking about
these specialty retailers in particular,
the likes of an American Eagle and Abercrombie,
a Gap, for example, Adrian, I'll start with you.
Kind of, how are they sitting with the consumer?
What share of the consumer's wallet
are they getting these days?
I would say that this is an ebbing tide.
We are year to date in what I call a consumer malaise.
Clearly you're seeing a pullback.
The inflationary impact is now impacting
not only the low end 50K consumer,
but starting to have a creeper effect, right?
It's coming up to the 75K
and even to kind of the higher household incomes.
So what I would say is,
you have to have a trend or a brand that rises above.
This is the 80-20 rule, right?
80% of stocks that are in kind of this subsector,
they trade along with kind of the,
what I call the micro macro.
And you've got to find, our job is to find the 20%
that have some halo moment on them.
American Eagle, this whole silhouette shift
that I've talked to you about,
the denim bottoms and the kind of fashion change
that's gonna happen in the back to school time period.
I also think Gap is our other pick here.
We don't cover Abercrombie,
but they would fall into kind of
the companies that have momentum.
Old Navy is the key at Gap Brand.
They are the ones that are actually turning
and they are taking share in that lower
and household income in their segment.
And Jonah, I wanna bring you in here as well
and maybe start that same high level.
Jonah, just how does the consumer look to you, Jonah?
How healthy, how resilient based on your coverage numbers?
The low end is definitely pressure,
but we think the new next is resonating a lot
with consumers at Bath & Body, which is our topic.
They have a new Netflix partnership.
They're venturing into men's and laundry.
So there's a lot of new categories there.
We like the new balance that they're having in stores.
So any newness is resonating quite well.
And another differentiator is proprietary products
and HIMSS is another concept that we really like.
And that proposition is products that are affordable
and differentiated from other platforms.
So those are the key to a strong consumer sentiment
in our opinion.
And Jonah, I wanna pick up on what you were talking
about with the price point, right?
That value is also an important component of this.
And I wonder sort of how does value now
compare to value last year or two years ago?
I mean, how much are consumers prioritizing that?
Yeah, we are seeing a lot more choice for consumers.
So they're prioritizing value while also being very selective
in what they can spend.
So as I mentioned, having that newness
and differentiating factor in addition
to having strong value proposition make strong sense
for consumer at this stage, that yeah,
that's sort of how we are seeing a consumer today.
And Adrienne, and same to you,
because that is a theme we hear, Adrienne.
If you're trying to pick on kind of trends you hear,
it seems to be this consumer who is generally more cautious,
more prudent, kind of focused more, Adrienne,
right now what they need rather than what they want.
I would say that's absolutely the case.
Let's remember that compound inflation
over the past five years is up close to 20%, about 18%.
Within kind of just apparel and accessories,
once they went through the purging process on the inventory,
the average unit retails, right?
The outdoor pricing,
inclusive of prices that they took up, right?
During the 2021 time period are also up about 15 to 20%.
So people are paying significantly double digit
more than they were in 2019.
And we're starting to see the ceiling get hit
on those price points.
We're seeing a ton of promotions.
Memorial Day was about as promotional as we've seen it.
And I don't think people made plan
over this past weekend, generally.
So we saw a lot of extensions
and I think you're just gonna kind of fight through
kind of the summertime period
until we get to the back to school season.
And then we have reason and need to buy.
And reason and need to buy where is the question, Syl.
So Jonah, you talked about that BBWI
is your preferred stock right now,
but we're also getting Gap and American Eagle this week.
So just quickly tell us what your stance is
on those two going into the numbers.
Yeah, on American Eagle and Gap, we are market perform.
We see strong momentum in both brands.
Obviously Gap is having its moment
with the fashion show and others.
So we are seeing a lot of momentum there,
but we are just a little bit more cautious
on the execution and longevity of growth
at both Eagle and Gap, especially Gap Athleta
really needs to turn around.
In our opinion, Old Navy is an important concept,
but I think there's still a little bit more focus
on Gap brand at the moment.
So we're waiting to see more stability in the financials.
And also Eagle has done very well.
We do need to see a little bit more,
I think strong signs at Aerie and Offline and American Eagle
and to our point, there is a little bit
of a cautious consumer dynamics playing here.
So we remain cautious, but our pick is Bath & Body.
We like the newness and we think promotions
are well-controlled and they have 37 million loyalty members
that they can continue to leverage.
So there are a lot of new exciting initiatives
at Bath & Body Works in our opinion.
And Adrian, you gave us your thoughts on Gap.
What about American Eagle as well?
Stock has had a nice move already, Adrian.
So American Eagle, we think that they are absolutely
in the bullseye of this kind of silhouette ship
with the 40% of their sales at American Eagle
are actually in denim bottoms.
And they are kind of the lone team player
from like 10 years ago when we had Abercrombie, Eagle
and Aeropostale playing in this space.
Our promos kind of throughout the quarter
and sort of quarter to date, they've held in there, right?
So we hate to see deeper promos
and we see them hugging the promos that they did last year.
To us, that kind of says that they're on plan
and they should be okay.
No one's gonna blow away the quarter, right?
So the best you can hope for is a little bit of upside
probably driven by SG&A for the quarter,
a blessing of the Q2 guidance,
maybe a little pass through to the year
and that's all we need.
Sorry, go ahead, Adrienne.
I think we're having a little sound problem with Jonah.
Oh, no, I was just saying that a little bit of a beat,
an inline guide and a pass through to the year,
a little modest pass through, that's a heroic.
That would be a really good print for us.
All right, thanks so much guys.
Adrienne, Jonah, thank you both for joining us today.
Appreciate it.