Building Wealth Through Commercial Real Estate with Stewart Heath
2 Video Views·May 30, 2024
Stewart Heath, CPA and CEO of Harvard Grace Capital, shares insights from his 20+ years as a real estate investor. Discover how you can build wealth through commercial real estate, including retail, self-storage, and medical offices, in any market. Learn from an expert eager to guide you on your investment journey.
Welcome to the Freedom Founder Podcast. I'm your host, Zach Duggar. Now my guest today,
Stuart Health, joins me and he will be talking a little bit to us about his own experience in
business and in life. So Stuart, thank you for joining me today. Thank you for having me. It's
quite the honor. And I may have said Stuart Health because I just popped in my head, but Stuart
It happens all the time.
Yeah, I get a lot of variety in my own pronunciation. But that said,
I'd love to talk with you a little bit about your experience in the entrepreneurial space.
That's what this podcast is all about. It's just sharing the journey, sharing the experience,
so we can learn from each other, be inspired by one another, and be motivated to get to our own
life and business, whatever it is that we are doing. So let's start with what are you doing
today? Let's start being present, and then we'll go a little bit retroactive after that.
Yeah. Mainly what I'm doing today is real estate investing through our arm, Harvard Grace Capital.
And I've always kind of loved real estate, came to it really from the other end of the spectrum.
I'm a CPA, and I had my own practice for a number of years. And I watched how many of my clients
grew wealth slowly through real estate. And it does sort of feed my desire for creativity and
my need for independence and growing wealth. And me and real estate fit each other very well.
But I had spent most of my career doing entrepreneurial things. I think my first
venture was an employee leasing company, and then there've been many others along the way.
Real estate's my love. Yeah, the passion that you found and continue to enjoy. Now,
let's go back to that beginning. You said that you had an employee leasing company.
How did you get into that? What got you into employee leasing? And
for those that don't know, what is that? What does that mean?
Yeah. Employee leasing is essentially a way for smaller companies to aggregate
things such as health benefits and workers' comp costs. And the employee leasing company
will have a much bigger pool and get much better deals on benefits and work costs and payroll
administration and things like that. And then the client ends up just paying the employee
leasing company much like you would any other vendor. And it can be a good deal for a lot of
service-type businesses. It may not be a great deal. Usually for heavy labor-type industries
where your workers' comp costs might be challenged or out of control, usually you'll get
some benefits by aggregating that with other people, especially in the construction industries
or anything where labor is intensive and where you might have not a high rate, but a moderate rate
of workplace accidents and things of that nature. That's the general idea behind it. These days,
almost all the big payroll companies, paychecks, insperity, and things like that, they all have
an employee leasing option. And so it was kind of new and novel back in the 1990s. And I was
always trying it. And of course, I completely misestimated the number of headcount that I would
need for that to break even. And we did that for about a year and then gave it up. Still like the
model, I've had a lot of clients and I have used it over the years. And it's the perfect fit in the
right situation. Okay. Yeah. Well, that makes sense. And I think it is important that when you have
an opportunity to explore opportunities, and sometimes you learn in that process,
underestimate certain aspects of that new venture, but it always brings you to that next step in your
journey. So tell us about that next step for you. Where did life take you from there when
you no longer were running that business? Well, and all the while, I was doing a CPA practice
along the way. Yep. And always trying different things. At the end of the day,
I didn't ever really intend to practice as a CPA forever. I was always trying to get into
something else. I like to say I had started dozens of businesses, and a few of them are still in
business. Wow. You know, so there is a lot of the trial and error. I think the most notable thing
after that one, after the employee leasing was, I was a partner for several years in a physician's
billing company back in the late 90s. And it wasn't something that I knew a lot about. I came
in as CFO and a partner, and then learned a great deal about. I had some partners who'd been doing
healthcare billing. It's very, very, very specialized type business. And if you've ever
been to the doctor and gotten one of those, what they call a super bill, where they have, you know,
300 things on a page, and then they check off what they did for you. And then that equates to
a bill that they end up billing your insurance company or Medicare or whatnot. Yeah. We provided
a service that submitted those bills and tracked those bills and handled any questions about the
bills, and all for a percentage of the collections. Okay. And we were pretty good, because we would
come in and take over a physician's billing. Maybe they got behind, maybe there are other
people that hadn't done it, and we could collect a lot of old stuff for them. And then
you keep it clean. And we would usually do it a little cheaper than everybody else. And
I left that business selling out to the other partners. The pool just didn't, it was very
competitive, very cutthroat. And, you know, two or three times we had gone into doctor's practices
that, where we collected several hundred thousand dollars of back billings for them, and they were
great. And then they would throw us aside for somebody else who would do it for half a percent
cheaper than who were doing it. And that's very typical in the medical world. I just, you know,
I don't deal well with industries without a lot of loyalty to them.
Sure. Yeah, you know, I can, I can understand that. Makes sense. There's certain things that
you did, and you did a great job for them, but then they can save money even a little bit by
going with somebody else. Yeah. They do that. Yeah, they do that.
Okay. Well, that's understandable. So, yeah, as you continued to be a CPA, you mentioned something
that I think is really key. You mentioned that you started, you're seeing clients who are building
their wealth slowly by investing in real estate. And I think for some, they will think about that
as, I can't even get into real estate because I don't have enough money to do so, or I'd rather
go and do this other thing because I can make more money today than I could if I had that rental
property only paying me a smaller amount every month. So tell us a little bit about what you
mean when you say building wealth slowly. Yeah. Well, I completely understand the
desire to, well, I would really rather go do this other thing because it will make more money.
And that's assuming that the business plan is executed flawlessly and everything goes according
to plan. Your other entrepreneurial plans may be more risky than a piece of real estate.
And trust me, I've done all of those before. And I'm not here to dissuade anybody against
going for their passion or dream or whatever. I finally got to the point where, and I do really
enjoy real estate. Real estate is the most stable asset class on the planet. I do laugh
and chide Wall Street people for putting real estate over as an alternative and group us over
with art and Bitcoin and other cryptos. No, we're not alternative. Real estate's the original asset
class. And it's not as though like the IRS would tell you that it's passive. If you're managing
your real estate, I can promise you it's not passive. And there are opportunities to be
entrepreneurial with it. There are all kinds of opportunities with many pieces of real estate
to add revenue streams, to reposition it to do something else, which are all very
entrepreneurial activities. So I got there and again, from watching clients and many of them
struggling. I mean, one in particular, I call her my business mom. She was an award-winning real
estate agent in Nashville. And when she became my client, she owed the IRS a couple of hundred
thousand dollars from a big mess. And that's how I got connected with her. I helped her navigate
that. We negotiated with the IRS and we did all that stuff. And we got her not only out of that,
and the whole time she's doing fix and flips and buying whole small apartment buildings and stuff
like that. And I came out of college in the late 80s and right about the time of the real estate
crash that was part and parcel to the 1986 tax act. And so I sort of came out of my infancy
of business thinking, oh, real estate's bad. And after about 10 years into this, and certainly
after I had left a big accounting firm and doing my own firm, I'm watching these people who are
making progress. And so really, I just sort of had an epiphany and this stuff works.
Yeah. And it's also the most leverageable asset on the planet.
So you don't have to have all the money, which kind of goes back to the original question,
do I take $10,000 and go buy a piece of real estate or do I take $10,000 and do a new
venture, some sort of a side one? And I can't answer that for you. Sure.
Both are valid options that each entrepreneur has to decide for themselves. The thing with
leverage is you can take that $10,000 and buy perhaps a $100,000 asset with it. And you get
the growth on $100,000 rather than the growth on $10,000. Your successful entrepreneurial venture
might be a 10 or 20X, so it might do far better. But again, real estate tends to be stable,
which is why I gravitated to that eventually. So that's really kind of how I got there
from doing other stuff. After my first duplex, I realized I really like this.
To me, being an entrepreneur, which means we're kind of abnormal in the general population anyway,
most of us have ADD of some kind or another. And when I discovered that I really liked it,
it was just Katie barred the door and I've just pursued it for 20 years.
Yeah, absolutely. Can you give us an example of kind of what kind of returns? And I know this
would be very hypothetical, but maybe even in your own experience, something that you
had occur, whether it's that duplex or something else that, because somebody might think, well,
$10,000 and I have this $100,000 house, but what can I get from that? How does this increase still
and how does it increase my net worth? Well, rule number one is all real estate's
local. So your returns are going to be primarily based upon your local market. Now that doesn't
mean you have to buy locally, but where you do buy is going to be determined by the local market
where that piece of real estate lives. Now that said, that doesn't mean that you can't
make your property better and be more attractive in the local market.
So there's all kinds of things that can be done in that regard. So as an example,
back three years ago when office and retail had been declared dead by the financial media,
we bought an office building that had been full. I had managed it for one of my clients for several
years. I knew the market. I knew the building. I knew the tenants. It just didn't get any better
than that. And we bought that building without any trepidation whatsoever, even though the world was
telling us office is dead. Nobody's ever going back to their office again. Well, you're in
Michigan. I'm in the South. We kind of pretended like there was no pandemic from about June of
2020 on. And nobody was staying home for any reason, much less to go to the office. So we
bought it. And while I was managing it, I couldn't do things that I wanted to do
because somebody else owned it. So in the last two years, we've been able to
work with the tenants. We've actually added some space. Internally, we took away some
internal storage space and have converted that to rental space. We've been able to move some people
around and take advantage of the increase of rental rates. So we bought it for 3.8.
And really, two and a half years later, that building's worth $6 million today.
We just had it rephrased. And so it doesn't always have to be
slow jumps like that. And we're not likely to sell, but we did just pull out some cash
on a tax-free basis. So now, technically, we have zero dollars in it. We still have a full building
and we still get quarterly cash distributions. And now that we've repositioned that building,
which I'll say was fun and creative and really got the entrepreneurial juices flowing.
But now that we've got it, we think of it as a basis of $6 million. We expect it to grow
about 10% year over year for the next five to six years, at which point in time we may
sell it then. But we were able to reconvert many leases to much more long-term leases.
And it gives some people like dentists more space that they wanted and who always write nice,
really long-term leases and things of that nature. So that's one example.
So if somebody is not as business savvy and they don't know how that might
impact the value of it, can you kind of give a brief overview of how getting those longer-term
leases, some of those rental rates going up a little bit, how that impacts value of that
property as well? Absolutely. That's a great question. So the value of a piece of investment
property is directly related to the bottom line, which real estate would generally call the net
operating income. That's basically your rent less all your operating expenses. In business,
we would call that EBITDA, earnings before interest taxes, depreciation and amortization.
So your operating income. And some multiple of that,
you know, a multiple, just say, you're going to go buy a liquor store, it's worth
40x of the bottom line. So that's the multiple that we're talking about. And in real estate,
we actually invert that and call it a cap rate, but it's the same concept exactly. So that's what
your properties worth is some multiple and that also goes up and down with the market and with
interest rates. So as interest rates have risen over the last few years, multiples have actually
come down or in our case, real estate world, cap rates have gone up. A cap rate is nothing more
than what amount of return you expect to make off of that investment. So cap rates have gone from
4% in some cases to now 8.5% or 9% on commercial properties.
Where you get into a little bit of gray area is perhaps a rental house, where your house has a
market of people who might want to buy it and live in it, or to other people, buy it and rent it. So
you get into a bit of a gray area as to what the house is worth. And in many times, and probably in
most markets around the country, where real estate markets are strong, your house probably
has a higher value to the general for sale market than it does to the investment community market,
once it needs a lot of work or something like that. But in general, your property is worth
how much money it will generate. And that's true for any business, frankly, each property is a
business in and of its own, and it's worth the amount of money that it can generate. Now, in the
case of properties such as office or retail, where you have long term leases, and not multifamily,
where the leases tend to be month to month, I mean, year to year, forget, when you can book a
long term contract, that's essentially, you can then market that property and sell it on future
cash flow, rather than on what you're doing right now. So and then that just becomes the
negotiation between you and the buyer. But it depending upon the credit quality of the tenants,
then you're dealing with what's the reality that those people will actually stick around,
stay in business and pay the rents. Yeah. Sorry, if I got too far in the weeds on that.
No, not at all. I think that it's important for people to understand that how that value can
change. And it can change quite drastically and quickly based on some of the things that you do
creatively in the space that you have now acquired and are able to because you now own the space like
you had just mentioned. I think that was a great example. So for this period of time that you've
been in real estate, it sounds like you've done different projects and different things.
Has it primarily been individual with partners? Do you use your own capital? Do you get investors
involved? How does that work for you? Early on, I did it all by myself.
You know, probably not one of those that that learn to play well with others, as they say,
and a little bit of greed in there. But as I started to move away from residential properties,
again, do what you love. I ended up with a whole bunch of residential units that I was managing.
And I didn't like managing those units. Sure. People are crazy when it comes to their homes.
And I'm much more comfortable or adept at communicating with business people.
So I've moved into the commercial realm of offices and retail. And we do do some storage as well,
which is sort of a hybrid between crazy people and business people. But
so that's kind of where we've ended up
migrating to the commercial realm. And as I moved into that, we syndicate some equity,
we take on partners, we manage everything that we bring to the market. Usually we are the sponsor,
we are the originator of the transaction, we go out and negotiate it,
bring in partners, we guarantee the debt and do all that.
Awesome. So do you primarily focus on the market in which you
live in? Are there certain? Yeah. Okay. Yeah, we have a territory
of southern middle Tennessee and northern Alabama.
Okay. There's anything we can get to within an hour.
Yep. And it's because we are the day-to-day managers.
Yeah. If something comes up, we need to be able to get there in a reasonable period of time.
Yeah. And for those that may not have heard the term syndication, what does that mean in
basic terms? And for those that might be interested in like, how could I get involved
in something like this? Sure.
Syndication is just a big fancy word that means a group, a syndicate, you've probably heard of that.
It goes hand in hand with the regulation D or the private placement rules of raising money,
which are all about securities laws, which have been liberalized almost every year since 2012,
mainly in response to technology. I have to say that the federal government under Democrat and
Republican administrations have done a pretty good job, I think, of keeping up responsibly
with the offering of these types of securities to the public. And so a Reg D, which stands for
Regulation D, governs all the rules that come from issuing securities for opportunities privately.
And privately means you're not filing for an IPO and you're not a traded security,
either bonds or stocks. But although those two worlds are beginning to merge,
because there are different rules under Regulation D and different rules come with
different things, we typically will use a rule called 506C, which allows us to publicly
advertise our deal, as long as we say for accredited investors only.
Accredited investors is a definition by the Securities and Exchange Commission,
basically means people who are making over $200,000 a year and or have a net worth outside
their home of a million dollars. There's different rules for trusts and corporations and things like
that. But generally, that's the rule. And if you meet those rules, then you can
invest in one of these deals. And sometimes the seller of the security can take your word
for it that you meet those and others, whether you're an accredited investor,
has to be independently verified. So that's what a syndication means. And a sponsor is going out
to the world, to the market, and gathering like-minded, interested people. And then they
collect all the money and they move forward together as a syndicate to take down that piece
of property. And generally, the minimums are $25,000, $50,000. The bigger the deal, the older
the sponsor, those minimums will go up to $150,000 or even $500,000 sometime. And that has
everything to do with the sponsor's desire to limit the number of individual people he's dealing
with. Generally, ours are $50,000. And we're usually going to have 30 or 35 people invested
in any particular deal. Okay. So for you, you've gained a lot of experience,
both personally and then cooperatively with others, and then through syndications and
managing property for others. And I've also seen for, well, just even this past year,
some of the challenges that people have faced in the real estate market where they've maybe
over-leveraged themselves, or they've had themselves in a position where now the interest
rates are going to go up and they are not going to be in a position to be able to afford that debt.
And so how would you say that you protect your investors from getting into a difficult situation,
or what have you learned to help produce consistent returns, or I guess more
realizing those returns on the investment that you've not necessarily promised them,
but that you've shown them and indicated that they've received?
That's a great question. So when we bring a deal to the market,
it's going to be a cash-flowing deal from day one. I'm not against development. I'm not against
a lot of things, but this is just what we bring to the market. We think cash-flowing assets,
whether it be a dividend-paying stock, bonds, whatever, should be the foundation of anybody's
investment portfolio. And cash-flowing real estate is sort of the best of both worlds. You get
growth in your principal as well as recurring cash flow on a regular basis. Now, you're not
going to see 60% or 100% returns on a stabilized asset of any asset class, much less real estate,
because it's already stable. But what we bring to the market is, like I say, it's a stabilized
asset. We only do fixed-rate debt, so we have no interest rate risk. We don't have any development
risk because we're not doing anything development-wise. And so the only real risk that
the investor is taking is vacancy risk, because every landlord needs to know that whatever business
your tenant is in, and that includes your rental house versus your office building, you're in that
business too. You are sending them credit based upon the likelihood they will continue to be able
to make those rent payments. And there are some tenants who've come along that we've
passed on renting or buildings that we've not purchased because we didn't like the
tenant mix and the quality. And so there's a piece of it that you put your banker hat on,
and you're like, hmm, I don't want to go do something with a brand new one-year-old restaurant
in it. As my dad, who was also a CPA, said, restaurants are the quickest way to get rich
and the quickest way to go broke. It's because that business cycle is one day to one week, and
every turn of the cycle, that's where you book your profits and your losses,
which is why restaurants go out of business so quickly. 80% of independent restaurants
go out of business in the first five years, and you can break that down by year. So
those are credit risks that we don't really buy into.
I like that. You have an asset that's actually there, so people are investing in something
real and existing, cash flowing today, and then you consider what that looks like with the
mix of tenants and whether it'd be a good fit. And that long-term experience has shown
what has been doing well and what has not done well. So I think that's a great strategy and also
just shows that you have that experience and are really thinking it through, not just in the
quick dollars now, because that's usually where people get themselves in trouble.
If you find something that's quick and fast in real estate, you should probably run.
That's wise advice, so mark that down and keep that in mind. Now, I want to ask one more question.
I always like to ask all of my guests. If you were to be handed a million dollars today,
no strings attached to that, what would you do with that money, and how would you invest that
in your current endeavor or another one, and why? That's a fun question. So I would
buy more real estate with it, frankly. So not necessarily anything I'm currently doing,
because those are already done deals, but I would definitely deploy that probably into
three different pieces of real estate, because diversification is important, even in real estate.
And I would expect from the time I completed the investment, it would probably take me
six to nine months to deploy that into three pieces of property. And in the 12 months after
I had completed that, I would expect to get about $100,000 worth of income.
10% is realistic. There are others, sometimes we'll start a deal out with 5% cash on cash,
but the bigger you go, usually those numbers go up a little bit.
Yeah, okay. Well, I like that answer, and it fits in with what you're doing now,
what you're passionate about, and what you've seen have success. So,
Stuart, if anyone wants to reach out to you, what's the best way for someone to connect with
you and find out more about you and about Harvard Grace? Easiest way to go is to harvardgrace.com.
You can find my townsley link there, and I offer to anyone and everyone who wants to book some
time with me and chat, please do so. I like to talk entrepreneurial endeavors as well as real
estate. We also have some great resources there. One of my favorites is why entrepreneurs should
be investing passively in real estate, five reasons why. There's other resources there
as well. We have a one-pager on what is a syndication, which we talked about a minute ago.
Please just go to the website and reach out and see what interests you.
Perfect. I love it. harvardgrace.com, you said, right?
Yes, sir.
So, I encourage everyone to just take a look, take a look at those resources,
reach out, schedule some time with Stuart. Like you said, if you're an entrepreneur,
maybe your passion isn't necessarily real estate, but if you can add that as an asset class,
that would be one of the best ways you can grow your wealth of any other period.
Yes.
We'll start there and we'll end there. But, Stuart, I want to thank you again for your time
today and I really appreciate the insights that you share as well as hearing a little
bit more about what you're doing. So, thank you again.
Thanks for having me, Doug. I'm Zach.
Of course. Yeah, no, I'm Zach.

