羅家聰:西方築起「反對之牆」 歐中貿易戰要開打? #信燕訪談

《看中國》香港頻道
2696粉絲
23 次觀看·2024年5月29日
🔥請加入乾净世界 https://www.ganjing.com/zh-CN/channel/1f6j576aqao3taCY3b7gv3NXG1540c<br>🔥請加入我們的Patreon,http://www.patreon.com/visiontimesHK<br>🔥請首選Stripe捐款:https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/donate.html<br>🔥請加入榮譽會員: https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/subscribe.html<br><br>香港巨變、新聞自由日益收窄,同香港人一齊經歷過槍林彈戰嘅我哋,國安法後要面對更多嘅挑戰同打壓,加上FaceBook Youtube等嘅種種限制、黃標甚至關閉,「報導真相,揭露邪惡」變得越嚟越艱難。<br><br>不過,無論前路有幾咁艱難險阻,我哋永不忘初衷,荊棘路上繼續為大家深挖真相,還公民知情權!<br><br>感謝你哋一路以來嘅不離不棄,請繼續支持我哋,加入我哋嘅Patreon,成爲我哋嘅榮譽會員,願榮光早日歸於香港!<br><br>本視頻僅代表嘉賓或受訪者本人觀點。<br><br>聯絡我們 [email protected]
Hello everyone, welcome to the live broadcast of the Sun Yat-sen interview.
I'm Lily, Zhang Sun-Yat.
Our guest today is Dr. Law Ka-chung, a Hong Kong economist.
Hello, Dr. Law.
Hello.
Since the US has increased tariffs on Chinese products,
the EU-China trade dispute between the EU and the CCP
may lead to a full-scale trade war between the EU and China.
What do you think, Dr. Law?
Can you hear me clearly?
Yes, I can hear you.
The so-called trade war between the EU and the CCP
has to look at the relationship behind it.
The US-China relationship is already clear.
But the relationship between Europe and China
is not as bad as it seems.
In the past few years,
you can see that Europe has largely followed the US in many policies and even in political and military matters.
But in terms of trade, the relationship is still quite strong.
The proportion of Chinese exports to the US is much smaller.
But in terms of exports to Europe, it is generally stable.
Because in the current economic environment,
of course, some of the goods exported to the mainland are very low-priced.
The low-priced goods can be sold back to Asia.
But the relatively high-priced goods,
the ones that make a lot of money,
are mainly exported to the two markets in Europe and the US.
If the trade dispute is completely unresolved,
and the goods are not exported to Europe,
the goods will not be exported to the mainland.
You can't make money just by exporting to your friends.
There is a batch of high-priced goods that can be bought and used in Europe.
Secondly, if you look at Xi Jinping's recent actions,
of course, the US has no place for him.
In terms of Europe, he has been to a number of countries.
He has been to some smaller countries,
which are easier to get hold of,
especially those in Eastern Europe,
near the Middle East, Russia,
and even geographically close to China.
His so-called pro-US stance is not so strong.
In Russia, his stance is similar to that of the Communists.
But apart from these,
he may not have such a strong pro-US stance.
He has also been to Germany and France,
where he has pulled some strings.
First of all,
in terms of e-commerce,
such as electric cars and solar panels,
the European stance is a bit vague.
It's not so clear.
It's not that the whole world wants to follow the US.
The US has its own considerations.
It doesn't sell a lot of electric cars,
so it has relatively little impact on trade.
But if the whole of Europe does the same,
it will have a relatively big impact.
Of course, he has the motivation to do it.
In terms of the internal market pressure on his own cars,
he is inclined to impose some tariffs.
But will it be as good as the US?
For example, if the US says it will follow 100%,
I don't think it will.
Even if there are some tariffs in some areas,
will it become a trade war?
It's also a matter of discussion.
To be honest, it's not a comprehensive fight.
For example, if the US elects Trump,
it will be a comprehensive fight.
Will Europe follow?
Looking back at the past few years,
in fact, Europe did not follow the US as Trump did.
So I think there will be some trade friction in individual areas.
There may be tariffs,
or even some strict reviews.
But it's not a comprehensive trade war.
Judging from the current situation,
it's not too close.
The US government has increased China's electric car import tariffs
to 4 times to 100%.
This effectively prevents Chinese electric car manufacturers
from entering the US market.
The US, China and Europe are the three largest car markets in the world.
Many critics believe that
the US has increased tariffs on Chinese electric cars,
which will make the trade war between the EU and China
even more intense.
What do you think?
Going back to what I said earlier,
the US electric car market is relatively small.
The US does not mind fighting.
The US has its own reasons.
Because Trump likes to wage trade wars.
If Biden's election strategy is to wage a trade war,
and Biden is completely neutral,
it will be very difficult in terms of the election process.
But if you really choose to fight,
if you choose the electric car industry,
if the impact is not so big,
it will be more practical for the US.
And this kind of more practical attitude
is actually seen all over the world.
Of course, it is also seen in Europe.
Whether or not Europe will wage this trade war
is actually very dependent on the actual situation.
If you do this, the mainland will be in a large scale.
Will it really have such a big impact on the European car market?
This is a consideration.
In fact, Europe has always paid a lot of attention to environmental protection.
The demand for so-called environmental protection cars is great.
But of course, as I said,
electric cars are now said to be less environmentally friendly.
Especially in terms of batteries and equipment.
Is it really that clean?
There are more such statements.
But you can see that the environmental market itself
has a certain demand for this.
If you really fight,
I think it's like what I just said,
if you go to a certain point
and say that Europe does not buy cars from the mainland,
in general,
first of all, can the production handle it?
Is there enough production in Europe?
This is a problem.
Second, the price issue.
Even if you can do it all yourself,
there are some estimates in the room
that it may be 50% less cost.
If you don't buy electric cars from the mainland,
you end up using your own car,
the cost will be one time more expensive.
If it is one time more expensive,
it may cause pressure on inflation.
With these considerations,
it may be a middle ground.
It's a fight or no fight.
If, as I just said,
there is tariff, will it follow the United States?
It doesn't seem to be.
There are some suggestions in the room,
for example, you are not 100% tariff,
50%,
if you compare with European cars,
everyone is close in cost,
you may have this approach,
then you will become relatively less
than those imported from the mainland.
Your cost is not all-time rising,
it is rising to some extent.
This is the biggest chance.
If you fight like this,
how will the mainland respond?
The mainland may respond
by imposing sanctions in other areas.
As you can see,
there have been some recent sanctions.
The result is that
everyone is increasing the overall price.
It also needs to consider inflation.
If the European trade war
is fierce,
the tariff will be heavy,
or when the lockdown
is tight,
will it trigger a chain reaction?
You can see that
the attitude of Europe
is very hostile.
The attitude of the EU is relatively positive,
but when Xi Jinping
goes to each country,
each country's individual
expression is not so positive.
Relatively speaking,
it seems that
everyone is doing something on the surface,
but at least
they don't want the atmosphere
to be too bad.
It makes the other party
have a big reaction.
As you can see,
the motivation to
intensify the fight is not very strong.
So the possibility is not too high.
Although the EU
is not willing to mention the trade war,
it is only willing to use
risk-avoidance to describe
the trade conflict
between the EU and the CCP.
However, analysts believe
that the EU and the CCP
are already conducting
a low-level trade war.
I would like to ask
what is a low-level
trade war?
What effect will it have?
A low-level trade war
is like what Zheng said,
if you fight, it's like you didn't fight.
In fact, everyone knows
that the mainland
is a producer,
and the EU and the US
are a consumer.
A producer, a consumer,
a worker, a player.
In fact, this chain
can only be broken
if everyone works together.
Even if the US fights
the trade war,
it will still use risk-avoidance
It doesn't want to fight the trade war with you.
You don't have to care
whether it is true or not.
But the one behind,
the one I just mentioned,
you are on one side,
he is on the other side.
This relationship is still there.
If you really have
some people
who don't want to play,
in fact, you yourself
must be very hurt.
The way to be hurt is
that he can't sell
to you, of course he has no business.
But when you can't buy,
you have to do it all yourself.
It's not that you can't do it,
but the cost is much higher.
Then the inflation pressure will come back.
Inflation pressure may increase
and then decline.
The problem is that
everyone has their own consequences.
If you use this effect,
for example,
you make the mainland
completely unable to sell,
the economy will decline.
Now the consideration
is whether to do this
or not.
If the mainland
has reached a very arrogant level,
then it will be necessary
to press it all over.
But if you press it all over,
you can do it from many angles,
such as politics, military,
and many other areas.
The problem is whether
trade should be done in this area.
If trade is done in this area,
you will be in trouble.
If you are in trouble,
this year is the election year.
If you do this in the election year,
you may not immediately
see that the economic data
will be a big problem.
If you immediately lower the tariffs,
the export trade may be relatively weak.
If the export trade is relatively weak,
it may not immediately affect the local economy.
But at least there is a proportion
of producers
that the entire
logistics will be affected.
Manufacturing,
importing,
logistics will all be affected.
These are all votes.
If these people
suddenly mess up your business,
the reaction
will be relatively large.
This phenomenon actually
appeared in the era of Trump.
He did strange things
You don't know what he did.
Often these tricks are suddenly used.
When you use it,
the whole industry
may be messed up.
The whole industry
may feed a certain number of people.
Suddenly,
the entire business
or the entire production
or sales department
is messed up.
This is a big problem.
In addition to these,
I think the overall economic considerations
are important.
It's the other way around.
Do you want to have
a relatively high inflation
Because if you suddenly have
some tariffs,
the immediate import of tariffs
will be more expensive.
Even if you go to the bank,
you have to do your own part.
In fact, the production cost
will soon fall
to the level of
consumer prices.
In Europe,
in comparison,
the inflation is not very low.
Especially in recent years,
you can see that
the current government has
relatively low public opinion.
The reason is that the inflation
in the past two years is quite high.
If the inflation does not need to go back,
the level at that time was still high.
As long as there are signs of going back,
there is now.
The inflation of 4%
seems to not fall.
Then you have some
artificial, especially obvious
government-made
inflation effects.
This matter will definitely
be used by your opponents
to make a big deal.
In the election year,
they won't do such a stupid thing.
So I guess
they will ban the mainland to some extent.
But there are many ways to ban the mainland.
It is not necessary to use
all means of trade.
In fact, the motivation to fight
the trade war is not very strong.
At the same time,
the United States is also
pressuring the European Union
and other friends
to reduce their dependence
on China's trade
and jointly respond to
China's problems.
Last week,
U.S. Secretary of State
Yellen said that
he hopes that
Western countries will
raise the wall of opposition
to the industrial policy
The purpose is to protect
the domestic free market.
This is a key issue
at the Group of Seven meeting.
What do you think of this situation?
First, look at
Trump's means of
fighting the trade war.
At that time,
it was called a one-on-one fight.
The U.S. even turned against
to fight the trade war.
The effect of that era
is that
the U.S. has made
a lot of trade sanctions
and tariffs against China.
But in fact, the effect is very low.
You can see that
the overall export of the mainland
and the U.S.
have not been reduced much.
It may be through the third party.
Many times,
the suspicion of trade
is that
you are not the only buyer,
and you are not the only producer.
As long as you are
the only buyer,
it is useful to fight like this.
If you are not the only buyer
and the other is not the only producer,
you can definitely
fight the trade war
through the third party.
Although the U.S. has
reduced the trade war,
it is the same as
the trade war in Mexico.
How many countries in the world
have been closed?
Every time you
build a trade barrier
there is a price to pay.
For example, if you say anti-China,
you clearly have a trade war with China.
But if you want to
fight the third party
the political price is quite high.
So you may not want to do this.
If you don't want to do this,
then you have to
do it together.
If you don't have
a common
consensus
to do this,
it is very difficult to achieve.
But now,
according to the principle of
if you join hands
to do something,
to some extent,
it is a joint action.
In theory,
it is a joint action
because you can file a complaint.
Is there enough motivation
This is also a problem.
If everyone
goes to buy
something at a cheap price,
everyone has to buy expensive things.
When everyone is buying expensive things,
there is a price to pay.
What is the benefit of
You have to convince
so many countries
not only to convince the leaders,
but also to convince
the trade unions
to do this together.
That's how it works.
It doesn't look easy.
For so many years,
there have been many
trade wars.
Many times,
individual countries have fought.
It is rare to work together.
In the past few years,
have you said that the mainland has not been negotiated?
No.
Have you said that the relationship with the mainland is good?
No.
Is there enough motivation
for them to work together?
It's not easy to see.
Each country has
its own economic problems.
So if you
say this slogan,
in theory,
everyone has to do it together.
But to some extent,
it feels like pushing the ball
to others.
Everyone has to do it together.
How many things
have you done?
If you want to fight
a trade war,
do you fight it all?
The problem is that you have chosen a few things.
Even if other countries want to fight a trade war,
they may not want to choose a few things.
In the middle,
there may be a lot of
quarrels.
This is the reason
why the whole thing
is not so easy.
So I think
after the meeting,
there will be more rhetoric
than actually.
In fact, there may not be
a lot of trade wars.
After the meeting,
the chairman of G7
issued a joint statement
on the 13th of March.
The main content is the problem of China's
production capacity,
and worries that the CCP's non-market policy
may destroy the economic prosperity
of other countries.
That's all for today's live broadcast.
Thank you.
See you next time.
