Khủng hoảng nợ công châu Âu, vì sao Đức phải ‘nghiến răng’ cứu Hy Lạp?

Ôn Cố Tri Tân - Góc Nhìn
250 người theo dõi
52 Lượt xem video·29 thg 5, 2024
☘️ Mục lục:
00:00 Giới thiệu
01:25 Lịch sử hình thành Liên minh châu Âu và Khu vực đồng euro
04:21 Vì sao cần đồng tiền chung châu Âu - euro?
10:05 Nguyên nhân khủng hoảng nợ công châu Âu: Áp tín dụng ‘một cho tất cả’
18:06 Vì sao Đức phải ‘nghiến răng’ cứu Hy Lạp?
☘️ Đăng ký kênh Youtube Ôn cố tri tân - Góc nhìn: https://bit.ly/481WrA1
☘️ Kênh Ôn Cố Tri Tân trên nền tảng Ganjing World:
https://www.ganjing.com/channel/1fk15t0au3k3L47HGBt16Yojh1mm0c
☘️ Kênh Ôn Cố Tri Tân - Góc nhìn trên nền tảng Ganjing World: https://www.ganjingworld.com/channel/1ge5ul8vf355QTd3VFRspskdr1ip0c
☘️ Ủng hộ chúng tôi tại: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/OnCoTriTan
In 20 years of economic development, there are 11 countries with more than 100% income.
Income is a headache for many countries.
Because the more debt the government has, the more unprofitable it is.
The government has to deal with high interest rates.
Other rates are also high.
Some economists believe that the current increase in gold prices
is related to the expansion of government income.
The European debt crisis from mid-2009 to 2022 has destroyed Europe.
Strong member states in the Eastern European region, also known as Eurozone,
have to work hard to save Greece.
It is estimated that by 2060, Greece will return to normal.
During the European debt crisis, there have been 5 countries in debt,
also known as a group of 5 friendly countries,
including Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Spain, and Spain.
So what is this?
But before going into the comments,
I invite you to like, subscribe to the channel,
ring the bell to update the most unique analysis.
The history of the formation of the European Union and the Eurozone region.
From 1500 years ago, about 476 years after the foundation,
the West German Empire collapsed.
Europe, which is not a very large land area,
has been constantly at war.
Countries in this area, war lasted until World War II.
After World War II, these countries were really tired of war.
At the same time, they saw the rise of the United States and the Soviet Union.
European countries have sent their representatives to sit down to discuss.
After heated discussions, they came up with an idea.
That is, if we don't fight anymore,
why don't we join our economic activities?
The closer we get, the less war there is.
Some even suggested that
why not unite into one country?
In fact, in 1946,
the former British Prime Minister Churchill
proposed the idea of establishing the European-Chinese Union,
which sounds like the US-Chinese Union, USA.
But it was clear that Churchill's proposal was not successful.
However, everyone hoped for a closer link.
So in 1957,
the United States, France, Italy, Luxembourg,
the Netherlands and West Germany
signed the Economic Community Agreement
and the Nuclear Energy Community in Rome.
Later, this agreement was called the Rome Agreement.
The European Economic Community was established.
This is also the predecessor of the European Union.
The main reason for establishing the European Economic Community at that time
was that they did not want war.
In addition to not wanting war,
they also needed to develop the economy together.
In fact, as long as taxes, goods, money,
labor and services
can be freely circulated in this area
without being obstructed.
After World War II,
when the economy of European countries began to recover,
external competition pressure from the US and the Soviet Union also increased.
So more and more European countries
gradually joined the European Economic Community.
In 1973, there were Denmark, Ireland, England.
In 1981, there was Greece.
In 1986, there was Spain, Portugal.
In 1990, the Berlin Wall collapsed,
the iron curtain also collapsed,
Germany unified,
European countries can finally cooperate with each other.
By 1992,
the leaders of the countries in the European Economic Community
signed a treaty called the Maastricht Treaty,
mainly to amend the previous Roman Treaty.
This is a sign of the establishment of the European Union.
Why do we need the European Common Fund?
When Europe has established an economic community,
there are other relevant issues.
For example,
if our Triton oil team wants to make milk tea,
we can freely buy raw milk.
I can import milk from the Netherlands,
import fresh milk from Italy,
buy machines from Luxembourg,
hire workers in Spain,
produce in Germany,
and finally sell to France.
The establishment of the European Union
has brought the level of European economic activity to a new high.
Everyone has seen the benefits,
but there is still one problem.
That is, although I can import goods and produce without any obstacles,
I have to use Dutch Guider coins to buy milk,
use Italian Lira to buy fresh water,
use Luxembourg francs to buy machines,
pay wages to Spanish workers with Pesta,
pay rents to factories in Germany with German Marks,
and finally sell and recover French francs.
This is a bit complicated.
Member states of the European Union
have certainly realized this inconvenience.
Therefore, on January 1, 1999,
a common currency for Europe was the Euro.
This means that Europe not only cooperates,
but also uses a common currency.
Some people think that
using a common currency is nothing new,
because now many countries also use US dollars.
But these two things are completely different.
Why?
Because of the issuance of US dollars,
including the export of US dollars,
these currency policies
have nothing to do with countries using US dollars.
Only the US Federal Reserve can decide everything,
can print money,
other countries can only stand and watch.
But the Euro is issued jointly,
not issued by any country,
but by an organization founded by those countries,
called the Central Bank of Europe.
Everyone decides together how much money will be printed,
how much is the profit,
many people exchange to issue a coin,
decide how much money to print,
whether this can be successful or not, etc.
There are many complicated issues.
In fact,
since the Central Bank of Europe was founded,
there have been many disputes between countries.
For example, who will be the president of the Central Bank of Europe?
Germany and France are both very strong,
they both want their people to come to power.
Germany wants its people,
but France does not agree.
The headquarters is in Frankfurt, Germany,
so France thinks the president must be French, etc.
A lot of things need to be discussed.
But no matter how they dispute,
from the point of view of outsiders like us,
we see the Central Bank of Europe as a unified entity.
Since then, the main framework of the European Union has been formed.
Each European country has its own government,
they establish a fiscal policy and a national policy.
The European Commission discusses the economic policy together,
the Central Bank of Europe decides the monetary policy.
Here, we need to clearly distinguish
the Eurozone area and the European Union.
The EU is a political and economic alliance
established by European countries.
The Eurozone area is the area where countries use the Euro as their financial currency.
Therefore, the Eurozone area is the core of the European Union.
Currently, the European Union has 27 countries,
but only 19 countries belong to the Eurozone area.
To join the EU, if you live in Europe,
you only need to sign an agreement to enter.
But to join the Eurozone area is not that easy,
because you have to meet very strict requirements.
One of the main goals of the Eurozone area is to ensure price stability.
When entering the Eurozone area,
all use the Euro as their financial currency.
Therefore, they set strict requirements for the rate of production
and cost of labor of the member states.
It is not just a strong economy or high GDP to enter,
but to maintain a stable price,
the government is not borrowed too much and wasteful spending.
Initially, when the Eurozone area was established in 1999,
there were only 11 countries.
When lost, because at that time there were not enough conditions,
they had to rely on Goldman Sachs to fake books to pass the test,
then join the Eurozone area in 2001.
Joining the Eurozone area brings many benefits for member states.
The first is efficiency.
You can join a larger market,
where goods, capital and services flow faster.
It will definitely be more effective.
The second is stability.
For example, some small countries such as Luxembourg or Malta.
Malta is where the two meetings are held between Foreign Minister Wang Yi
and White House National Security Advisor Jack Sullivan.
Countries like Luxembourg or Malta have a population of only about 4,000 to 50,000 people.
If they use their own money, it is certainly very volatile.
But if they use Euro, it will be much more stable.
In addition to efficiency and stability,
there is also an unofficial, but also very important, benefit.
This is what the officials in the Forum revealed,
called the trust-free trust.
In other words, there is no need for trust.
In other words, it is the baseless belief of the market
in countries and governments in the Eurozone.
The reason for the European debt crisis,
the trust app is one for all.
Although there are no agreements or agreements on the market,
but when people see countries in the Eurozone
all use the same amount of money,
they see these countries as a family.
Once you are a brother,
if a country goes bankrupt and can't pay its debt,
other countries can't ignore it.
So, the nature of these countries is basically the same.
But after looking back, this is really a big mistake.
But at that time, the market thought so.
What does the market think?
It is to assess the risk of credit
by looking at the return on investment.
People with high credit,
the return on investment is low for them.
And people with low credit,
the return on investment is high for them.
For example, if you have a high salary,
a stable job,
money sent from the bank to the rich,
and good health,
the risk when you borrow money is very low.
You will definitely be able to pay the debt on time.
You will get a loan with a very low interest rate,
for example 3%.
Conversely, if you don't have much money to send to the bank,
waste money,
unstable job,
there may be very few banks that want to lend you money.
Or if you give a loan,
the interest rate will be very high,
for example 20%.
Not to mention other types of loans.
The interest rate for people with low credit
can even go up to 100%.
Therefore, 3% or 20% interest rate
is the market's assessment of your debt risk.
Governments of countries are the same.
They lend money through issuance of bonds,
and these bonds will also be traded in the market.
When trading,
these bonds will have an interest rate.
In fact, the interest rate is how the market assesses the debt risk of a country.
The lower your interest rate,
the more the market trusts you.
Of course,
it is not possible to compare the types of bonds issued by countries
with different currencies.
For example,
US dollars,
yen,
or yen.
Because the factors such as the rate of issuance of countries are different,
so it cannot be compared.
But in the European region,
all use the same currency.
Therefore,
the comparison between them
In terms of economic stability,
the core countries,
that is, the core countries of the Eastern European region,
such as Germany and France,
will definitely be stronger.
They have a higher credit rating.
Meanwhile,
foreign countries such as Italy,
Spain,
Portugal,
Greece,
should be less economically developed.
The credit rating is certainly not equal.
So,
in theory,
their interest rates should be higher.
But before the financial crisis in 2008,
the 10-year interest rate of core countries such as Germany and France,
and foreign countries such as Greece,
Italy,
Spain,
Portugal,
were almost completely the same.
What does this mean?
It means that
Greece and Germany
can issue interest rates with the same rate.
Like,
at first,
you can borrow 1 million with a 5% interest rate.
But when you join a new group,
in this group,
there is Elon Musk.
The bank will think that
if you are short of money,
Elon Musk will help you pay.
So,
the bank will let you borrow with the interest rate for Elon Musk,
for example 1%.
And you can borrow 1 billion with 1% interest rate.
Countries such as Italy and Greece,
which have very high borrowing fees,
will definitely borrow more comfortably,
even fake books to hide.
So,
what would happen
if developing countries such as Germany and France,
and underdeveloped countries such as Spain and Greece,
can borrow with the same rate?
European subcontinent countries
are not as developed and stable as domestic countries.
So,
these countries
will definitely develop faster,
have more investment opportunities,
and have a higher potential for profit.
Meanwhile,
core countries such as Germany and France,
their investment opportunities will be better,
but they will develop more,
and have a trade surplus.
They will definitely have more money than foreign countries.
This means that
the investment profits in southern countries,
that is, in foreign countries,
will be higher.
So,
money will flow from northern countries to southern countries.
This will lead to the fact that
banks,
asset management companies,
will invest in companies,
even invest in southern governments
such as Spain and Greece.
So,
core countries
will become the export countries,
that is, the debtors,
while foreign countries
are the import countries,
that is, the debtors.
But the fact that foreign countries borrow money
is just one aspect.
Only borrowing money
cannot cause such a big crisis.
It should not be said that
the interest rates of low governments
simply mean
that the government is more likely to borrow.
In fact,
in a country,
the interest rates of different economic activities
are closely related
to the interest rates of the government.
What does this mean?
If the interest rates of the government are low,
the interest rates of individuals are also low,
the interest rates of companies are also low,
the interest rates of the entire economy
of that country will also be low.
For foreign countries,
this is no different than a breath.
They can borrow money at a high interest rate
like Elon Musk.
Therefore,
there will be a lot of capital invested.
And when the capital is invested,
in the short term,
the economy of these countries
will develop rapidly.
Not only the government borrows,
but the use of the entire economy also expands.
After the creation of the euro area,
people in Germany and France see that
housing in Spain is cheaper,
the scenery is beautiful,
the climate is pleasant.
People in France and Germany
can buy a house directly with euro.
Previously,
houses in Paris were too expensive,
so they wanted to buy a small house in the south.
Therefore,
capital is not only used
to buy government bonds,
but also into the real estate market
of foreign countries.
This leads to the boom of real estate
in countries like Spain, Ireland.
Capital flows into foreign countries
in different ways,
such as through government bonds,
through finance or real estate.
But in nature,
it's all because the interest rates
in these foreign countries are too low.
Put simply,
At first,
when the capital was still rich,
everything was fine.
Foreign countries
can borrow new debts to pay old debts.
But when the global financial crisis
broke out in 2008,
the capital line began to tighten.
Rich families like Elon Musk
are not left with anything.
At the moment,
government bonds and real estate
of southern countries
are beginning to be sold out.
Selling out will make the bonds cheap,
and cheap bonds
will make the government bonds
of foreign countries increase.
When credit is tight,
foreign countries can't borrow money.
At the same time,
the economy is declining,
the government can't get a tax,
the problem of debt appears immediately.
When the crisis broke out,
the boom of real estate
in countries like Spain and Ireland
began to break,
leading to banks in the country
having to pay a lot of bad debts.
What does the government have to do?
If the government doesn't try,
banks will go bankrupt,
causing a big crisis.
The government has only one way to save the banks,
but they can't borrow money
because they use European currency.
They don't have money either.
Therefore,
the tight use of real estate
has caused foreign countries
around Europe
to face serious debt issues.
Why does Germany have to
save Greece?
After the financial crisis in 2008,
foreign countries
faced serious debt issues.
In 2009,
the Greek government revealed that
their GDP debt
had exceeded 110%,
much higher than
Eurozone's 60% limit.
In January 2010,
the European Union found
that Greece had embezzled funds.
According to the Greek government's
it was not 3.7% of the GDP
as announced,
but 15.4%.
The market began to panic.
At this time,
Greece insisted that
they did not need help,
but the market did not believe it.
Greece's government spending
began to increase by 10%
and the market was worried
that Greece would pull out of Europe
and reduce the Eurozone.
So now,
what will the Eurozone do?
Specifically,
what will Germany do?
Why?
Because Germany
is the owner of Eurozone.
When using real estate,
the capital will definitely
go to safer places.
So now,
Germany is definitely the strongest.
If we analyze from Germany's point of view,
should we save Greece or not?
If we don't save Greece,
in this situation,
Greece will definitely go bankrupt.
What if Greece goes bankrupt?
If Greece continues to stay in Eurozone,
the market will see that
even if it goes bankrupt,
a country like Greece
will still stay in Eurozone.
This will significantly reduce
the market's belief in Eurozone.
If Greece is pulled out of Eurozone,
the situation will be quite different.
In the beginning,
it was all brothers.
Now Greece is still there.
Eurozone did not save,
but still pulled Greece out.
So today Greece is pulled,
tomorrow Italy is pulled,
Spain is pulled,
Portugal is pulled.
By that time,
Eurozone will go bankrupt.
So,
if we don't save,
but let Greece
fall into a difficult situation.
At the moment,
both Germany and Eurozone
have no choice.
They only have to save Greece.
There is another reason.
As I said before,
most of Greece's debtors
are stable countries
like Germany and France.
If Greece is in debt,
both Germany and France
will not be able to recover money.
This will also affect Germany and France.
Therefore,
Germany saving Greece
is also saving itself.
Previously,
Greece did not listen,
did not comply with financial standards,
even hired Goldman Sachs
to make a fake book
to get into Eurozone.
But now,
Germany has no choice but to save Greece.
So how to save Greece?
At that time,
the global economy was declining.
Eurozone is not like USD.
Fed can manage money
and print money to stimulate the economy.
Because Eurozone is a community,
not only to stimulate the Greek economy,
but also to make Eurozone affected.
Therefore,
Eurozone cannot print money.
At the moment,
Germany only has a way
to collect money by itself.
Although Germany is very angry,
but there is no other way.
They still have to collect money
to save Greece.
In May 2010,
the EU and the IMF
passed a package of aid
of 110 billion euros for Greece.
Of course,
everyone is in trouble.
And Germany has to pay for itself.
Germany forces Greece
to cut back on spending,
according to the style of the Germans.
Germany believes that
spending money like this
will solve the problem.
But in fact,
the nightmare has just begun.
Ireland has a problem,
not a real estate problem,
but a debt problem.
Before 2008,
Ireland's GDP debt rate
was below 30%,
still very far
from 60% of Eurozone.
But to save its banking system,
Ireland's GDP debt
has increased to nearly 120%.
The situation of Ireland
is the same as the situation of Greece
that we have analyzed before.
The European Union also has to save.
The EU and the IMF
have to save Ireland
with 85 billion euros.
At the same time,
Ireland has to cut down on spending,
have to cut back on spending
to ensure debt repayment.
At this time,
the market is beginning to doubt
whether other countries in the Eurozone
have a problem or not.
The market is beginning to sell
Bologna's bonds.
The Bologna government says
everything is fine,
we don't need help.
Less than half a year later,
the Bologna government
began to admit that
they could no longer resist.
They began to demand money
from the European Union.
In May 2011,
the EU lent
78 billion euros to Bologna.
In July 2011,
the EU found that
Greece was short of money.
The money for Greece
was still not enough.
The EU decided
to lend another 100 billion euros to Greece.
When this money
has not yet reached Greece,
Spain and Italy's bonds
began to fall sharply.
This is a big problem.
Because
Italy is the third largest economy
in the Eurozone.
If the Italian government
also needs help,
this is a real problem.
The European Central Bank
quickly began to print money,
buy government bonds
of these two countries
to reduce production.
Spain and Italy
also quickly announced
they would back down
in their financial policy.
At this time,
Greece began to speak up,
saying that
the European Union
said it would give money.
Where is the money?
The Greek people
began to go down the road of riots.
The next day,
the Standard & Poor's organization
lowered the level of trust
of the Italian bond
from A to A.
This problem is getting bigger.
If not handled well,
it could lead to
a global economic crisis.
Britain and the United States
have also quickly
showed serious interest
in this issue
and participated in meetings.
Britain has also quickly
printed 75 billion pounds
to pump into the economy.
This is called
a vacuum.
Then,
in Greece,
everything
has become uncontrollable.
So the European Union
meets,
G20 also meets.
Finally,
the decision to cut
Greek private debt
suffered 50% damage.
The market immediately realized
that
the European Union
is not united at all.
All the bonds
of the countries
in the Eurozone
have fallen sharply.
Then,
the European Union
began to discuss
and implement
some economic stimulus measures.
But because of opposition
from Britain and Hungary,
it could not be achieved.
In 2012,
the Standard and Poor Organization
reduced the credit rating
of 9 European countries,
including France.
The market criticized
the speed of dealing
with the debt crisis
of the European Union
as too slow.
But the EU
has no other way
because to achieve
reunification
between 20 countries
is really not simple.
In March 2012,
finally,
the European Union
once again
achieved reunification
and decided
to raise
130 billion euros
for Greece.
Spain said
they could hardly
resist anymore.
Unemployment rate
rose to 20%.
So Spain
received
another 100 billion euros
in aid.
Germany
has been through
two difficult years.
On the one hand,
Germany is thinking
about solutions
to the problem.
On the other hand,
Germany has to participate
in daily discussions.
Finally,
this problem
was also solved
mainly by
Germany and the IMF
Of course,
later,
the EU
also became smarter.
They created
a debt system
on the market
instead of
spending money on themselves.
They made the market
spend money.
Finally,
in 2018,
Greece paid
the last debt.
All emergency aid
from countries
have ended.
This time,
everyone has seen
the 5 countries
with the most serious
impact,
namely
Portugal,
Spain,
Italy,
Greece,
Spain,
What
they called
this
is
Eurasian
countries,
the 7 most
important
on the
The European Central Bank is beginning to release energy to stimulate the economy, it has printed up to thousands of billions of euros
Currently, the GDP of the euro-eurozone region has not returned to the same level as more than 10 years ago
Unemployment rates in Spain and Greece are still at a high of about 15%, while in Germany and France it is 5%
This creates a clear contrast
Some economists predict that by 2060, Greece's economy will be able to fully recover
It is not clear how they calculate, but if you look at these numbers, we will know that these foreign countries really need a lot of time to recover
What do you think? Please leave a comment below
If you find this video useful, please support us by sharing this video with your friends to help us spread this content to the community
If you agree, please invite us for a cup of coffee by the link below
We sincerely thank you, see you in the next comments
