BMW S1000RR vs S1000XR on track (Why I bought S1000XR)

Motor Club
67 followers
In 2010, BMW released the S1000RR, a motorcycle which continues to this day to dominate the
sales figures for the leader sports bike categories around the world. A few years later, they
released the more road biased but equally bonkers S1000RR, and then last year in 2015,
they gave us the S1000XR. Now, we and Trooper Ted have been running an XR for the last two
months, we've clocked about 4,000km between us, and we're honestly a bit confused by the
bike. We don't know what it tries to be, and we just realised after a roundtable discussion
that it kind of does everything really, really well. This is a bike that you can commute
on, that you can tour on, but also that you can scratch on. We were genuinely left wondering,
why would you need a dedicated sports bike to go quick, when something like the XR does
just as good a job, if not better, and does it in more comfort. So, while we found the
XR a phenomenally fast road bike, we were wondering how it would compare against a dedicated
sports bike like the RR in a track environment. Now, for this, we had to get control conditions,
so we've invited along ex-BSP Supersport rider, Alan O'Connor, to be our test rider for the
day. Alan's going to do a number of laps on both machines, and we're going to see how
fast the XR is versus the RR. Now, I must point out, both bikes are on standard road
tyres, the suspension has not been tweaked or set up, it's as if you just bought this
and rolled it off the showroom floor yourself. So, we're very, very keen to see how close
can the XR get to the RR's times.
So, here we are on the S1000RR, and the first thing we need to tell you about this bike
is how viciously quick it is. The engine revs so freely, and combined with the Gear Shift
Assist Pro system, which does up and downshifts, it's not long before you feel like you're
travelling at warp speed. Up front, the Brembo calipers do a fantastic job of hauling you
up. Braking force is consistent, with no sudden leap in bite levels, which allows predictable
braking lap after lap. Combined with the rider aids like Traction Control and Stability
Control, the RR is almost begging you to go faster on each and every lap. You can pull
moves on the RR that would normally result in you cartwheeling yourself into the gravel
track. Things like cresting a hill with the throttle held wide open, which would normally
result in the bike flipping backwards, are handled with the minimum of intervention by
the onboard computer. People often complain about the level of interference from the safety
systems of modern motorbikes, and while it's true early systems were a bit crude in their
application, modern electronics packages like those on the RR are undoubtedly making
it safer for all of us to go faster than ever before.
On to the S1000 XR with its detuned RR lumping. Now, detuned isn't the right word for this
engine. Retuned would be a better description. OK, while it doesn't have the same mental
top end the RR has, and even though it's down about 40bhp, it punches harder in the
The upright seating position fools you into thinking you're not travelling that fast,
but a quick glance at the clocks tells you otherwise.
The XR is deceptively quick, and combined with the wide bars giving you so much feedback
and control from the front, you'll find yourself pushing harder and harder into corners.
The XR has the same Brembo stoppers as the RR, and despite the much longer travel in
the front suspension, the electronic suspension package makes sure you never feel like the
just diving under heavy braking.
All these things combine to produce a bike that is incredibly stable in the corners.
The standard setup inspires so much confidence.
When all the filming was done and we headed out for a final session, I actually found
myself reaching for the keys to the XR as opposed to the RR because it's just so easy
to go so quick.
So the results are in, and even we're shocked. We knew it was going to be close, we had no
idea how close. The S1000RR went around in 1 minute and 0.59 seconds, the S1000XR went
around in 1.01 and 0.59 seconds. A single second is all that separates these two bikes
around this racetrack. That is just a phenomenal testament to how good a machine BMW have built
in the XR1000.
There's not much more really we can say, the results speak for themselves. The XR,
phenomenal bike, does it all.
We really enjoyed testing both these machines, we hope you enjoyed watching it. Thanks for
joining us and see you next time on Trooper Ted.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
Revised by https://otter.ai
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
