Expert: Hong Kong exhausted all its resources: the right time, the right place, the right people

Spotlight on China
2K followers
38 Video Views·May 16, 2024
Ngan Chun Gou, a senior media personality, has expressed concerns about the current state of Hong Kong. He has observed that the city has lost its advantageous position, talented individuals and depleted its resources. Hong Kong has faced significant challenges in recent years, with the firm control of the Chinese Communist Party impacting its freedom, rule of law, and economy. Stephen Roach, an American economist, has similarly expressed his worries about the fate of Hong Kong, stating that "Hong Kong is finished." He emphasized that local politics, China's economy, and Sino-US relations have had a detrimental effect on the city.
Ng Chun-go, a senior media personality, has expressed concerns about the current state of
Hong Kong. He has observed that the city has lost its advantageous position, talented individuals,
and also depleted its resources. Hong Kong has faced significant challenges in recent years,
with the firm control of the Chinese Communist Party impacting its freedom, rule of law,
and economy. Stephen Roach, an American economist, has similarly expressed his
worries about the fate of Hong Kong, stating that Hong Kong is finished. He emphasized that
local politics, China's economy, and Sino-US relations have all had a detrimental effect
on the city. The anti-extradition movement in 2019 made the situation in Hong Kong worse.
The movement was against the Chinese Communist Party's pressure on the city's democracy,
freedom, and legal system. As a result, many Hong Kong residents chose to leave.
In 2022, Roach looked back at the significant changes that have happened in Hong Kong.
He vowed never to return and adopted a more cautious approach toward mainland China.
After Roach stated that Hong Kong is over, the public took notice.
Shan Weidian, CEO and Chairman of the Hong Kong Private Equity Fund PAG Group,
challenged Roach's viewpoint. Shan emphasized Hong Kong's unique institutional characteristics,
such as openness, freedom, judicial independence,
capital mobility, and currency convertibility, which still attract international capital.
In response, Yan Chun-go, another senior media figure, criticized Shan's perspective in a
Facebook post, questioning why the Hong Kong government would resort to night markets to
stimulate the economy if conditions were as favorable as Shan claimed. Chun-go's article
suggests that Hong Kong has lost its previous momentum and is now in a state of inevitable
decline. The city's economic growth in the 1960s and 70s was fueled by its unique position as a
British colony, which adopted a market-oriented approach, followed the rule of law, and had a
globally-minded population. During China's reform and opening up in the 1990s, Hong Kong businesses
then played a crucial role in supporting shipping, trade, and finance in the Pearl River Delta.
However, the favorable circumstances that once propelled the city's growth have now faded.
Mainland ports in Shenzhen, Ningbo, and Shanghai now rival or exceed Hong Kong's throughput,
posing a significant challenge to the city's shipping, trade, and finance sectors.
Yan Chun-go pointed out that Hong Kong's strategic location, alongside mainland China,
allows for easy travel and fosters a cooperative relationship with mainland manufacturers.
Even after the 1997 handover, Hong Kong had benefited from the
One-Country, Two-Systems framework, which compensates for the mainland's limitations
and provides flexibility. The One-Country, Two-Systems principle, which used to be the
backbone of Hong Kong's institutional advantages, has been gradually eroded due to the anti-extradition
protests and the Chinese Communist Party's conflicts with Western nations. These have
caused the industrial chain to shift away from Hong Kong, making its previous strengths
into disadvantages. As a result, the city has found itself in a difficult position,
losing its geographical convenience. Yan Chun-go has noted that since Xi Jinping
became the leader of the Communist Party of China, conflicts with advanced Western nations
have increased, and the actions of the CCP have been criticized. The independent tariff status
of Hong Kong has now been questioned, and some prominent Hong Kong figures, including Li Jiaqiao
and Zhang Chuneng, have faced sanctions from the US. The relocation of multinational companies'
headquarters to Singapore, the rise in vacancy rates in the city's central district office
buildings, and the departure of foreign bank executives have all had a further impact on
the city's economy. Additionally, concerns about safety have arisen for foreigners visiting Hong
Kong. Moreover, many middle-class families in the city have made the decision to emigrate,
which has resulted in the departure of around 160,000 individuals to the United Kingdom.
Additionally, some people have relocated to the United States, Canada, Macau, and Taiwan.
These individuals were the intellectual elites and leaders in various industries,
and their contribution to Hong Kong's economic growth was significant. Their departure has
created a complex void that now needs to be filled. Yan Chun-go emphasized that Hong Kong's
loss of timing, position, and talented individuals can all be attributed to the
policies and actions of Xi Jinping. These policies have led to regression instead of progress.
The implementation of the national security law and the talks surrounding Article 23
have further deteriorated Hong Kong's situation and weakened its power.
