Nadler opening statement for markup of H.R. 354, the LEOSA Reform Act

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
1 Video View·May 9, 2024
Markup of Markup of H.R. 743, the Protect and Serve Act of 2023; and H.R. 354, the LEOSA Reform Act
Mr Chairman, the Ileos Reform Act would remove critical gun safety
protections from the Law Enforcement Officer Safety Act, or Lisa.
Which became law in 2004 to understand just how problematic this
bill is. It is helpful to revisit a little bit of history from the
committee's past. Under Republican majority. The committee report
on the Osa began by explaining that quote a state has traditionally
in the exercise of its sovereignty controlled who, within its borders
may carry concealed weapons. And when law enforcement officers may
carry firearms, close quote, the report explained that Lisa would
override virtually all state laws on concealed carry. It was supplant
the judgment of the states about the appropriate use of firearms
by off duty and retired law enforcement, both through their own agencies
and The law enforcement agencies of every other state and would four
states to allow these individuals to carry concealed firearms within
their borders. The Republican chairman of the committee. At the time,
Jim Sensenbrenner, began the markup of the bill by saying, quote.
It is no secret that I am opposed to this legislation. I believe
it violates the principles of federalism and undermines the authorities
of the states. This legislation would disregard the judgment of state
authorities on what many believe is an important public safety issue.
Close quote. I agreed with those sentiments and we both opposed the
legislation. I also explained that the bill created the problem by
allowing nationwide concealed, carry by off duty and retired law
enforcement without any national standard for training.
New York City could require one level of training. Well, a small
rural city with a very different needs, and a very different approach
to policing could require a very different level of training. And
yet each would be forced to allow the others off duty and retired
officers to carry concealed firearms within their community and potentially
even in interactions with their own on duty law enforcement.
International Association of Chiefs of Police or I AC. P opposed
this legislation, too, because they were concerned about how it could
endanger law enforcement and could lead to situation situations in
which officers from one jurisdiction are killed or injured by local
police, who cannot distinguish between a criminal and a retired officer
using a firearm. The police Executive Research Forum, or PERF, opposed
the bill because it could put police agencies at risk for liability
for an officer who misuses a weapon in another state and because
the required and because the requirements for retired officers were
insufficient. For all of these reasons, I joined former chairman
Sensenbrenner and other members from both sides of the aisle in opposing
Lisa. Unfortunately, it became law despite our objections.
Importantly, the law included exceptions for special places like
government buildings, gun free school zones and private property.
These exceptions have been in place for 20 years and have served
as important protections. But this bill tosses those exceptions out
the window. This bill eviscerates the rights of states to control
the concealed carrying of weapons, even in places where a state has
a special interest in retaining control of its gun safety laws and
where Congress is protected that interest for 20 years
It Forces states to allow off duty and retired officers to carry
firearms and playgrounds, government buildings and on buses, trains,
subways and boats. It reduces the rights of private property owners,
including individuals and organizations, who may not want concealed
weapons on their property. It undermines state laws limiting magazine
capacity by allowing some people to carry large capacity magazines
even when a state has prohibited them. It relaxes training standards
so that some people will be able to carry a concealed firearm even
though it has been three years since their last firearms training
certification. Not only does this bill infringe on the rights of
states and private property owners, but it also unravels federal
laws that have kept firearms out of federal facilities. It does this
for federal facilities that are open to the public in quotes and
that are classified as quote facility security level one or two close
quote. This definition will create significant confusion for those
trying to abide by it. And for those tests, we're enforcing it. If
a federal facility is open is only partially open to the public or
only open to the public during certain hours. Does it fall within
the buildings that within the bill's definition, we don't know.
What about a facility that is open to the public so long as they
are not carrying firearms. The bill does not say and as the bill
itself states the facility security levels are determined on a facility
by facility basis and may not be publicly posted, so it is virtually
impossible to know what federal facilities are included in this definition.
We looked for a listing of federal facilities that are classified
in these security levels, and we could not find one. Memories may
even have offices in federal facilities that will suddenly be forced
to allow concealed firearms in their doors as a result of this legislation.
I was proud to join my Republican colleague, former chairman Sensenbrenner
in opposing the original Lisa. He recognized that it undermined state
careful determinations on how best to protect their citizens from
gun violence. This bill is an even further intrusion on their ability
to make their own judgments about public safety, concealed firearms
and the regulation of their own law enforcement. For all these reasons,
I urge my colleagues to join me in opposing this misguided and poorly
crafted legislation and I yield back Balance of my time
