Rep. Nadler opening statement, markup of HR 2595, the Forfeiture Funds Expenditure Transparency Act

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
1 Video View·Feb 29, 2024
Mr Chairman, H. R. 2595. The forfeiture funds expended to Transparency
Act importer reporting requirement into an asset forfeiture system
that is in desperately need desperate need of overhaul. There is
universal agreement on this committee that the asset forfeiture system
requires major reform. That is why in June of last year we voted
unanimously to favorably report. HR 1525. The Fifth Amendment Integrity
Restoration Act. That bipartisan bill would eliminate the system
of administrative asset forfeiture. Which allows the federal government
to cease and retain property that it believes was connected to a
federal crime. Regardless of whether the commission of the crime
is improving in court. As I explained during the markup of HR 1525,
there is no judicial oversight of administrative forfeiture proceedings
at all. The system lacks protection of Fifth Amendment to process
rights, and it creates perverse incentives for federal agencies to
pursue civil forfeiture in cases where it is unwarranted. Many state
and local law enforcement agencies have similar asset forfeiture
procedures. Moreover, the value for forfeited property is often less
than the quest to retain legal counsel. Leaving lower income people
whose property is seized for forfeiture with no ability to fairly
contest the seizure. This is particularly troubling in light of several
studies that have shown civil forfeiture disproportionately impacts
working people in communities of color. These already problematic
features of our asset forfeiture system are compounded. By the equitable
sharing program between federal and state law enforcement, which
allows authorities even in the states that have eliminated or reformed
their own forfeiture laws to receive a percentage of forfeited funds
referred to the federal government for seizure. The Fair Act would
begin to remedy the problems with our asset forfeiture system. It
would eliminate the administrative process so that only an article
three judge could order of forfeiture. It would raise the legal standard
for forfeiture from the preparedness of the evidence to clear and
convincing evidence it would provide access to counsel for indigent
persons seeking the return of the property. And critically, the Fair
Act would abolish the equitable sharing program between federal and
state law enforcement agencies. These reforms enjoy support, not
just from a broad bipartisan coalition of advocacy organizations.
But also from the members of this committee on both sides of the
aisle. If the majority is truly concerned about the state's use of
federally seized assets through equitable sharing. The clear solution
is to bring the fair Act the floor. Great months, The bill has been
ready for a floor vote. Instead, we're inexplicably marking up a
bill that would make no effort to reform the federal asset forfeiture
system and instead would merely wreak would merely requires state
and local law enforcement agencies. Report every six months about
the use of funds that they obtained through the equitable sharing
program. Not only are there already extensive reporting requirements
in the ankle sharing program that we're under this bill, largely
duplicative But the new reporting, But this new reporting requirement
would be entirely unnecessary under the Fair Act. Because that bill
would eliminate the equitable sharing program altogether. Ultimately,
this legislation represents a step back on the road to reform legitimizing
a program that each of us has voted to eliminate, while making no
effort is serious reform. This committee has already voted in favor
of significant reforms to our federal forfeit your system. Rather
than advancing this competing and practically meaningless legislation.
I would ask my colleagues to instead use the power of this committee
to bring the for the Fair Act, which we've already reported to the
floor to the floor. I would proudly join you in working to enact
a fair act into law. But until that happens, almost vote no on HR
2595. I urge my colleagues to do the same, and I yield
